8 ms·
Apple, Goldman Sachs Debut Savings Account with 4.15% Annual Yield
- mjh2539 4y ago4.15% is still well below annual inflation.
- BugsJustFindMe 4y agoIt is, but the context is that most other savings account in the country have been giving less than 1% for years now, which is unconscionably low.
- joshuahedlund 4y agoCapital One is currently 3.5% and Barclays US is 3.8%
- WoodenChair 4y agoSo, this is significantly better.
- standardUser 4y agoIt's 0.35% to 0.65% better, until those rates inevitably change.
- standardUser 4y agoThat's because interest rates have been historically low for a generation. Now they are climbing, so yields are rising. Nothing conscionable or unconscionable about it.
- itsoktocry 4y agoInflation rates were unconscionably low. The comments seem to think Apple is doing something revolutionary here. I'm making 4% on my savings accounts now, too. Nothing special here.
- mupuff1234 4y agoBut that's for last year's inflation. This year's inflation might be below 4.15% (not sure what the projections are)
- martinky24 4y agoIs inflation the goal here, or is it comparison to other HYSAs? If no HYSAs match inflation, it's not really reasonable to compare this one to it, no?
- Zandikar 4y ago> it's not really reasonable to compare this one to it, no? Are the fees, minimums, limits and rate structures similar? If so, then the inflation thing is irrelevant. They either beat it or don't, but at the end of the day, you're still comparing who has the better APY and what not regardless of that differential on inflation. If HYSA's (which this is, by reasonable metrics and their own definition) beating Inflation is important to you, that's a separate discussion to be had first before shopping specific offerings, as that's a discussion of a systemic problem and if HYSA's are relevant to you at all in the first place. Hot tip, in high inflationary markets like today, HYSA's don't beat inflation.
- howinteresting 4y agoSeveral other financial institutions offer similar or higher yields with higher FDIC insured limits (eg Betterment's cash reserve), with the additional advantage that the account isn't locked to a particular hardware vendor.
- mikestew 4y agoYou state that as if savings accounts ever paid better than inflation. And in nearly a half-dozen decades of walking this Earth, I don't recall ever seeing that happen. Of course a savings account pays below inflation, it's about as risk-free as money storage gets. You want better returns? Go with something that carries more risk.
- Dave_TRS 4y agoThe saddest part of bank interest is that on top of it lagging inflation, but also gets taxed aggressively making it effectively lag by inflation by an even wider margin! Being a borrower is the way to go, where your interest payments are less than inflation AND you get to deduct each year on your taxes and save keep more real dollars in your bank account than you would otherwise. I just hate debt personally, part of my upbringing. But I wonder if there's some reit or low fee investment vehicle that makes it easy to take advantage of this dynamic while still being able to sleep at night. Any ideas?
- fundad 4y agoOther than a 30-year fixed mortgage?
- Dave_TRS 4y agoYes, the dynamics of a 30 years mortgage are what I'm looking for, but turn-key. Because purchasing a property and getting a mortgage is a huge hassle up front and requires tons of work for many years. Compare this to buying a publicly traded security which requires the click of a button to purchase, and retrieving the tax slip each year.
- sakopov 4y ago> Being a borrower is the way to go, where your interest payments are less than inflation AND you get to deduct each year on your taxes and save keep more real dollars in your bank account than you would otherwise. With mortgages at over 6% and personal loans at 8-9% (according to my local credit union) I'm not sure if it's that much better and if deductions would offset high interest rates, but it's definitely a nice kickback.
- standardUser 4y agoYou don't know what the inflation rate will be over the next 12 months. You do know what your savings account yield will be (well, until it changes). There's I bonds and TIPS if you want a hedge against inflation.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- philip1209 4y agoThere's an interesting YC co addressing the interest rate difference between banking + investment accounts. They basically add checking account functionality on top of auto-investing: https://nexushq.com https://nexushq.com I have no financial interests in them, but I'm a happy customer. I like using it to make float on cash in between tax payments and other obligations.
- hsjqllzlfkf 4y agoOh, only for people with iphones? And then these companies act surprised when people call for breaking them down.
- officeplant 4y agoIt's a benefit of the Apple Card within Apple's Wallet app. There is no other way to access your apple wallet other than the app. You might be able to access savings via a Mac since there is desktop access to apple wallet. I'd have to verify its possible once I get home to my machine. Now you don't need an iPhone to use and pay on an apple card[1], but currently I don't see any way of accessing the savings account on the card website. Not that you would want to use an Apple Card without an iPhone anyway because using the card gives you less money back. (1% vs 2% or 3%) [1]https://card.apple.com/ https://card.apple.com/
- massysett 4y agoEven as someone with many Apple products, this card and account have no appeal to me. I see no reason to chain my credit card together with my gadget maker. There are way too many good financial products that aren’t chained to a particular gadget maker. I’m not the target market I guess.
- shagie 4y agoThe press release from Apple: https://www.apple.com/newsroom/2023/04/apple-cards-new-high-yield-savings-account-is-now-available-offering-a-4-point-15-percent-apy/ https://www.apple.com/newsroom/2023/04/apple-cards-new-high-...
- dhaulagiri 4y agodupe https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35600882 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35600882
- calderarrow 4y agoThis is a step in the right direction, and personally I think that low-level deposit accounts are ripe for serious competition. There are thousands of banks and credit unions (~9,000 if memory serves) all offering the same risk-free product, but the rates and fees can be wildly different. The FDIC publishes some decent statistics about average yields for various deposit products.[0] As of March 2023, the national average for savings accounts was 0.37%. The largest banks (Wells, BoA, Chase, Citi) offer 0.01% interest. That's 1 penny for every $100 you loan them. That low rate made sense when the federal funds rate was low as an incentive for banks to borrow from consumers rather than the government. But now the rate is almost 20x more than it was a year ago, so there's a larger incentive for banks to borrow from consumers.[1] This should drive more competitive rates offered for consumer deposits. If you're earning less than 1% APY on your checking and savings account and have $1000 in it, spend an hour researching an alternative. Going from 0.01% to 1% alone would earn you $10 more per year on that amount. If you have $10k, that's an extra $100 for maybe an hour of your time. [0] https://www.fdic.gov/resources/bankers/national-rates https://www.fdic.gov/resources/bankers/national-rates [1] https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/fedfunds https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/fedfunds --- On a related note, I'm part of a team working on a service to monitor all the deposit rates across all financial institutions in the US in real time. If you're interested in learning more or signing up for the alpha launch (targeting Summer 2023), shoot us an email at bankrank.alpha@gmail.com
- incrudible 4y agoThere is a reason the other banks do not offer more: A great deal of that money is locked up in long term, low interest assets. What do you think will happen if people try to take their money elsewhere?
- calderarrow 4y agoIf people take their money elsewhere, the banks can borrow from the fed, just at a higher rate. So in theory, they should be willing to increase their rate up to whatever the fed-rate is, minus some margin for the risk of dealing with lower sums of deposits. There's a direct correlation between advertising spend and interest yields on deposit accounts, which is somewhat interesting. It seems like the optimal business model is to focus more on customer acquisition than customer retention, because these products are very sticky. Churn rate for deposit accounts is like 8%, which is crazy given the rate variance.
- incrudible 4y agoGreat, let us all move our cash deposits into a savings account. What could go wrong?
- websap 4y agoHow is it that the rate offered GS & Apple, is greater than GS's own banking product Marcus? WTF is going on?
- PKop 4y agoteaser rate to get people to move from other banks, probably won't last
- DueDilligence 4y ago.. guaranteed for 12 consecutive months.
- randomopining 4y agono the rates can change at any time
- smugma 4y agoIt's 0.25% higher than the rate they pay for Marcus. I've been a Marcus customer for a few years, and the rates consistently go up (and down) after the Feds change their rates. Why is the Apple rate higher than the Marcus rate? It could be a higher intro rate, but there's no indication that that's the case. My guess is that they can afford to give an extra 0.25% because they don't need to spend any money on customer acquisition/marketing costs. Marcus and Betterment often go back and forth on who provides the higher rate. Right now Betterment is 4.2%, so the rate that Apple/GS is providing isn't outrageously high, it's potentially a real rate that can be sustained. It's only outrageously high compared to the 0.01% that many big banks offer.
- PKop 4y agoThe higher rate is a customer acquisition cost. But perhaps you can say Apple is contributing to the expense whereas for Marcus they don't.
- Finnucane 4y ago
- sakopov 4y agoI don't bank with them, but Betterment has been advertising 4.2% yield on savings for a couple of months now.
- PartiallyTyped 4y agoRevolut is advertising 4.3% yield in Polish Zloty (what I am paid in) and the currency has been going up in value since November.
- wintermutestwin 4y agoI got an Apple Card and used it for all of 2022. Then I went to do my taxes and tried to download a CSV of all my transactions and found that you can only pull it down one statement at a time! Thanks Apple for making tax time just a bit more painful...
- nanidin 4y agoBetter than Amazon that removed the ability to do any csv exports of orders or transactions sometime between when I prepared tax year 2021 and tax year 2022.
- wintermutestwin 4y agoYes - I now have an amazon policy where each item is one transaction. Then I have to go through the whole year 10 at a time. Yet another mind blowingly bad customer experience. I am getting closer and closer to ditching my Prime account...
- clintonb 4y agoWhy do you need a credit card statement for taxes? Business expenses?
- smith7018 4y agoThat would be strange imo because there are obviously far more advantageous business cards out there. The only reason I could maybe imagine someone using the Apple Card for business is to get 3% back on hardware purchases.
- danielfoster 4y agoI agree but for many people optimizing credit card spend is not worth their time, especially if you’re just spending a few thousand per year on a side hustle. There are plenty of reasons one might want a csv, though.
- wintermutestwin 4y ago
- euroderf 4y agoThis is playing footsie with an evil empire.
- cududa 4y agoI have some bad news to tell you about banks in general
- smy20011 4y agoWhy not just buying bonds?
- rabuse 4y agoMost people don't even know what a bond is. This is enticing for the average person who has an iPhone, and just wants a better savings rate than the laughable big banks currently at 0.01%.
- thewataccount 4y agoI'm one of the people my sibling comments talks about - I barely know what a bond is. But are bonds liquid? Part of the appeal of a savings account is that it's still cash you can spend immediately by check/debit/cash with no need to sell/transfer to an account. I agree that a 4% savings account is not a good way to invest money - but that's why I don't think they're comparable to bonds.
- adam_arthur 4y agoYes, can buy a T-Bill fund like SGOV and get ~5%. Can buy/sell it as you would any other stock. Carries no credit/duration risk (effectively)
- anotherman554 4y agoI just went to the Ishares web site and 3.55% is the reported yield to maturity for SGOV.
- adam_arthur 4y ago“30 day SEC yield: 4.68%” The fund will lag Fed hikes by a few months, but otherwise will yield the same as buying T-Bills directly. Using trailing distribution data to compute yields will not work for a T-Bill fund in the middle of a Fed hiking cycle.
- deleted 4y ago
- rabuse 4y agoOther high-yield savings options for those that want to compare options. https://phatwalletforums.com/topic/109/best-nationally-available-high-apy-liquid-accounts https://phatwalletforums.com/topic/109/best-nationally-avail...
- pqdbr 4y agoI'm not from the US, so please don't mind if the question is stupid: are these options all FDIC insured?
- howinteresting 4y agoI believe so. Some even have higher limits than the $250k (Wealthfront, Betterment at least) because they spread your deposits across multiple banks.
- jmyeet 4y agoI remember saying years ago that the difference between Apple and Google is that Apple will do fewer things but will be more committed to them. As soon as Apple Pay came out and people kind of laughed it off, I thought (and said) that Apple will slowly plug away at it, adding new countries and banks incrementally and at some point you'll look up and realize Apple owns a massive electronic payment ecosystem. I've had an Apple card for awhile and have found myself using it more and more just because it's convenient. Not having to enter CC details into every app and instead just double clicking the side button to pay for something is incredibly convenient. Personally I have way more confidence in Apple's ability to manage a pool of depositor funds than I do for pretty much any bank.
- ok_dad 4y agoYep, most of my purchases today are using ApplePay and it's like magic that the button appears and I can just press it, choose my shipping address and card, and be done with the purchase.
- spacemadness 4y agoThey aren’t managing anything to my knowledge, Goldman Sachs is.
- boh 4y agoI'm a little paranoid about putting my cash in the Apple ecosystem. The easy-to-use functionality actually makes me uncomfortable when it comes to banking. Here in NYC there's been news stories of muggers/thieves using Face ID (by force or drugging the victim) to access banking and payment apps, siphoning off money in bulk. There's something useful about having a middle man with limited functionality managing payments and deposits. Given the risks, I'd rather not participate in the "whole-life-in-the-phone" lifestyle. *plus there's other banks offering comparative rates
- devoutsalsa 4y agoI’m also concerned about the the iPhone passcode problem. You can change the password on someone’s Apple account with only the passcode. There’s no prompt to enter the old password at all. Apple’s iPhone Passcode Problem: Thieve’s Can Ruin Your Entire Digital Life In Minutes | WSJ https://youtu.be/QUYODQB_2wQ https://youtu.be/QUYODQB_2wQ
- kevin_thibedeau 4y agoDon't do banking on your phone. I consider mine compromised and too much of a security threat to risk it.
- riku_iki 4y agohow it is better from buying short term treasury ETF?
- potmat 4y agoI've heard a lot of people in the USA are "unbanked". I'm willing to bet a fair share of those people have an iPhone (if not necessarily a top-of-the-line one). Does this make it any easier to get an account? Or do you still have to jump through hoops. (not US citizen so I have limited knowledge of getting banking there).
- evan_ 4y agonot really, you need to have an Apple-branded credit card to even apply for this. I don't think it's particularly difficult to get an Apple Card but if you have lousy credit this doesn't make anything easier for you.
- potmat 4y agoToo bad. But I suppose Apple couldn't really solve this without actually setting up their own bank.
- shagie 4y agoOn r/AppleCard there's a fairly consistent stream of people (often college students?) with their first credit card. The Path to Apple Card opens it up for a lot of people with poor or no credit history - people with credit limits of $1000 to $2000 (there are even some at $500 - https://www.reddit.com/r/AppleCard/comments/mwg9bn/this_is_my_first_credit_card_shoutout_to_apple/ https://www.reddit.com/r/AppleCard/comments/mwg9bn/this_is_m... ). It gives people who are poorly banked an option to save in a higher yield account than what they may have with a big bank. One of the things that Apple Card does better than others is show that information about how much you're spending. With the savings account, showing that you are saving money can be useful in knowing that you've got it and its change over time (compared to logging into a bank that you otherwise rarely interact with).
- crazygringo 4y agoNot really. The unbanked are mainly poorer and use much cheaper Android devices. Also if you're unbanked, a savings account isn't going to be your first step. It will be a checking account with an ATM/debit card.
- 71a54xd 4y agoHas anyone been able to actually enroll today after the announcement?
- dogma1138 4y agoWe’re really moving closer and closer to a corporate dystopia where a single corporation is going to provide you with everything.