8 ms·
ATC staff shortages: 11,000 flights cut from NYC and DCA in summer 2023
- mensetmanusman 4y agoCovid destroyed the workforce equilibrium. I think we will be dealing with these types of effects at least four times the length of the pandemic.
- mwint 4y agoOur reaction destroyed the workforce equilibrium. It's a subtle but important difference.
- DJBunnies 4y agoDo go on.
- HarryHirsch 4y agoYou could say that - in my circles there's quite a few oldtimer lecturers and professors who decided to retire instead of exposing themselves to the pestilence and risk death, the older you are the more likely that you won't survive. If mitigation methods hadn't totally gone out of the window they'd have stayed on.
- dmix 4y agoNot to be dismissive or mean but what percentage of the workforce are "old timer" professors and lecturers? If I've learned anything about academia is that the most common personality trait of this demographic is their own sense of self-importance. Often as a consequence of their own local job/life experience where young people look up to you before entering real life, combined with the typical boring institutional hierarchies. Making a big deal about their retirement/exit, or at least connecting it to something wider and currently culturally relevant, is on-character in that context. This was satirized very well in a film I just watched recently so maybe I'm biased https://www.imdb.com/title/tt5536736/ https://www.imdb.com/title/tt5536736/
- the_only_law 4y ago> If I've learned anything about academia is that the most common personality trait of this demographic is their own sense of self-importance. Lmao if I’ve learned anything about software developers…
- darth_avocado 4y agoExactly. The whole economy is paycheck to paycheck, from the government to multi billion dollar corporations to hourly gig employees. We need to build a more resilient economy than the one that maximizes profits for Wall Street.
- mensetmanusman 4y agoOur reaction was inevitable due to the flaws of human nature. It’s part of the pandemic. Kind of like how stampedes are inevitable after a certain human body density with the proper noise trigger.
- lotsofpulp 4y agoI think an aging population pyramid would inevitably cause the same problems, but the response to Covid accelerated them by a few years.
- newZWhoDis 4y agoOverpopulation was a lie, the effects of the population inversion will define the politics of the 2050’s on
- Ancalagon 4y agoCouldn’t overpopulation and the problems caused by an inverted population pyramid both be true? Arguably they both are for the moment. But the pain of an inverted pyramid was always likely if you want to bring a population down ethically.
- mensetmanusman 4y agoChina inverted it unethically with forced sterilizations and forced miscarriages that were mandated during the one child policy. Overpopulation may be a myth depending on whether you believe humans will ever leave earth or are destined to disappear when the sun goes out.
- irjustin 4y agoIs this post COVID pains or is it more fundamental, that the latest generation workers are not willing to take up the ATC staffing work and the overall pool of talent is shrinking? I can easily see it as post COVID pains that training new ATC workers takes months to years.
- woodruffw 4y agoCOVID probably didn’t do the FAA any favors, but it goes back further than that[1]: it’s hard to entice people to a high-stress job when the president can declare your union illegal and erase your entire career permanently. [1]: https://www.npr.org/2021/08/05/1025018833/looking-back-on-when-president-reagan-fired-air-traffic-controllers https://www.npr.org/2021/08/05/1025018833/looking-back-on-wh...
- ars 4y agoThat's not unique to an air traffic controller. If you are warned if you don't go to work you'll be fired, and you don't go to work, then guess what? You will be fired. That's true in basically any industry.
- Scalene2 4y agoHave you ever heard of unions and strikes?
- woodruffw 4y agoATCs are government employees, not in industry. And they belonged to a union, through which they engaged in collective bargaining (as is their right, under federal law). The actual circumstances of their firing are worth reading about: striking is legal for unions except for unions of government employees, for whom it is explicitly illegal. What makes the situation unusual is the extreme response by the Reagan administration.
- DangitBobby 4y agoRely belies the notion that the arrangement between businesses and workers is symmetrical, doesn't it?
- diceduckmonk 4y agoJust checked out the requirements to be an ATC and you have to be 30 years old or under in order to apply. https://www.faa.gov/levelup https://www.faa.gov/levelup
- SOLAR_FIELDS 4y agoIs there any reasoning as to why this requirement exists?
- toomuchtodo 4y agohttps://www.businessinsider.com/becoming-air-traffic-controller-career-pros-cons-of-job-2022-1 https://www.businessinsider.com/becoming-air-traffic-control... https://libraryonline.erau.edu/online-full-text/faa-aviation-medicine-reports/AM71-36.pdf https://libraryonline.erau.edu/online-full-text/faa-aviation... > All ATC applicants must be 30 or younger on the closing date of the application period to qualify for the position, according to the FAA. This is because the agency has determined through extensive research that the older someone is, the harder is it for them to complete the rigorous training. Having sat with a controller for an hour while they managed Midwest airspace (ARTCC ZAU) in my younger years, I am somewhat inclined to believe it. EDIT: Pilots had mandated retirement at 60, which was bumped to 65 in 2007 due to pilot shortages, and there are discussions of pushing it to 67. https://www.reuters.com/business/aerospace-defense/senators-propose-raising-us-commercial-pilots-mandatory-retirement-age-2023-03-21/ https://www.reuters.com/business/aerospace-defense/senators-...
- thelock85 4y agoRecently met two ATCs and got some interesting perspective: new ATCs are trained on COVID levels of air traffic. So as things ramp back up (still not at pre-COVID levels across the board) there are a myriad of issues. The fact that flights are being cut instead of throwing new ATCs into the unknown is actually refreshing even if frustrating.
- irjustin 4y ago> The fact that flights are being cut instead of throwing new ATCs into the unknown is actually refreshing even if frustrating. I do appreciate this given the "option" to literally just let it run its course. But realistically, this is not a true option. You have to cut flights. Too many lives are at risk.
- rob74 4y agoIt has happened before, so it can happen again: > On August 5 [1981], following the PATCO workers' refusal to return to work, the Reagan administration fired the 11,345 striking air traffic controllers who had ignored the order, and banned them from federal service for life. In the wake of the strike and mass firings, the FAA was faced with the difficult task of hiring and training enough controllers to replace those that had been fired. Under normal conditions, it took three years to train new controllers. Until replacements could be trained, the vacant positions were temporarily filled with a mix of non-participating controllers, supervisors, staff personnel, some non-rated personnel, military controllers, and controllers transferred temporarily from other facilities. (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Professional_Air_Traffic_Controllers_Organization_(1968)#August_1981_strike https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Professional_Air_Traffic_Contr...) At least the Wikipedia article doesn't mention anything about cutting flights...
- mrguyorama 4y agoMy understanding is that ATC performance took a nosedive for decades after that. It's possible people died because Reagan wanted to crush a union.
- 4y ago
- caslon 4y agoWhy would anyone bother when you're stripped of your career for life if you try and organize collective action as an ATC? It's a sacrifice of a good deal of freedom and submitting yourself to malevolent companies and a government that doesn't care about you.
- madars 4y agoNot sure why you are being downvoted. It is widely known that Reagan broke PATCO strike https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Professional_Air_Traffic_Controllers_Organization_(1968)?useskin=monobook#August_1981_strike https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Professional_Air_Traffic_Contr... (Whether or not public sector unions should exist is a different question, of course. FDR, for example, was of the opinion that "no", because you can't effectively negotiate with a police/teachers/etc union.)
- catminou 4y agoAnd strangely Reagan was the president of the actors union and a supporter of the Polish anti-communist labor movements.
- slater 4y agomoney and power for meee, not for theeee
- koolba 4y agoIt’s not strange at all if you understand the differences between a private sector union and a public sector one. What’s really strange is how anyone that’s not a member of a public sector union could think it’s a net benefit for society as whole.
- DangitBobby 4y agoYou could argue many things are a "net benefit to society" but which are untenable for moral, political, or practical reasons. In this case, however, I think you have to exclude government employees to from society to consider this a "net benefit" instead of a zero-sum benefit. The benefit to society is offset pretty much exactly by the income government employees are screwed out of by being denied basic rights to negotiate for themselves (amazing that sentence can be written about a free country). It might even be net-negative if it turns out the government can't hire good people due to artificial wage suppression created by short-term thinking.
- granzymes 4y agoIt’s interesting that the airlines seem to be jumping at the opportubity to cut flights (or at least that is the impression that the article gives with words like “authorized” and “opportunity”). Does anyone know why?
- icegreentea2 4y agoSlots at the busiest airports are subject to a "use it or lose it" rule. Historic slot allocations are also part of what decides future slot allocations. The FAA is saying that they're waiving the "use it or lose it" rule for this time/airports. If airliners feel that can consolidate enough of their passengers into larger flights without losing out on future slot allocation rounds, then this is an overall win for them (especially if they can couch the move in terms of safety and cooperation with the FAA). In a sense, part of the value of holding a slot is just denying it to your competitors (in addition to directly making revenue off of it). This waiver allows airliners to gain this portion of the value of the slots, without partaking in the risk of actually trying to generate revenue off it is (which is why exactly the use or lose it rule is usually in effect).
- CydeWeys 4y agoTake-off/landing pairs are use them or lose them. Presumably they're being given the option here to not use them all without suffering any penalty for it. This allows them to drop only their least profitable flights
- mathogre 4y agoFrom the article: "The FAA is encouraging airlines to use bigger aircraft with fewer take-offs and landings." I worked in ATC R&D for many years. NY Tracon, N90, is crazy busy and very complicated. DCA handles lots of Regional Jets. Each aircraft is an "operation". If you're an airline and can carry the same amount of passengers in fewer aircraft, re: fewer operations, you're at an advantage, and the system continues to work. The airspace and airports with the available controllers can handle only so many operations, and the FAA will limit operations accordingly. The airlines can either let the FAA randomly deny flights, or they can say to the airlines, as they apparently did, "We can only handle so many operations. How do you want to do this?" In situations like this, airlines themselves can decide how they're going to change their operations. In NY, it's probably easier to use/lease larger aircraft. Yes Teteboro, TEB, could take some traffic if this were just airport operations limited, but I suspect it is an N90 issue, so offloading to TEB really isn't an option. With DCA, it's more likely the airport. Airlines like United can offload to Dulles, IAD. Additionally, the airlines could even work with each other to some degree to get through this. They do that in significant weather events, though this is a much bigger event than a snowstorm at someplace like O'Hare (ORD).
- loeg 4y agoWashington DC, not Washington.
- catminou 4y agoIsn't this related to the fact that the FAA themselves shutdown the recruiting & training pipeline and now we're seeing the impact of that?
- wankle 4y agoIs it a cover, is the US expecting any impending major actions or disasters.
- cagenut 4y ago[dead]
- kepler1 4y agoI wonder, have they considered recruiting from the Vatsim online community? Not sure what side effects this might have of course, but you would think that that is already something of a helpful screening mechanism for people who are both interested and have shown some ability to do the job.
- achates 4y agoSecretly connect the real pilots to the gamer ATCs, problem solved.
- aynyc 4y agoFor those asking about why max age of entry. ATC has mandatory separation age of 56. In order to qualify for full pension, you have to join before 30. * You are age 50 with 20 years of service * You are any age with 25 years of service Many other jobs have mandatory separation age, such as firefighters and law enforcement. FBI for example has max age of 36 unless you have other experience. https://fbijobs.gov/special-agents#eligibility https://fbijobs.gov/special-agents#eligibility
- neilv 4y ago> FBI for example has max age of 36 unless you have other experience. I learned about the age limit right after I missed the cutoff. I'd been watching the TV show "Numb3rs", and thought I could do some good. (Today, local housing costs preclude doing good, anyway. :) )
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- frontiersummit 4y agoWhy not cut back on general aviation flights first? My naive solution (granted I know little about ATC) would be to give commercial flights priority over GA flights if ATC is overloaded. No 8-seat business jet is more economically important than a 200-seat airliner. Say nothing of recreational piston-engine flights. At the very least slap a $5000 surcharge on every GA takeoff or something.
- catminou 4y agoGA folks generally aren't taxing the atc system. Most are vfr and not on a plan.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Cyberdogs7 4y agoTypically your single piston GA flight will be operating in very different airspace than a 200 seat airline. Just as you can't take a single piston pilot and put in as the pilot in command of a 200 person airliner, ATC personal are not easily hot swappable between airports or airspace.
- User23 4y ago> No 8-seat business jet is more economically important than a 200-seat airliner Devil's advocate: Prove it.
- kortilla 4y agoSame fee for every aircraft. Increase until the congestion reduces. This is called a congestion tax, it works. No need to distinguish between purpose of the flight. If it’s economically important, they will pay.
- catminou 4y agoCanada already has a usage fee for using ATC services fwiw. Based upon type / weight and distance traveled you get charged per flight. Same thing could be used here - not sure it's going to fix some of the fundamental issues of lack of staff and poor FAA management.
- gabereiser 4y agoWhile I love aviation and I love our ATC’s, I can’t help but think that it’s an antiquated system desperate for disruption. Growth of air travel is outweighing growth in staffing for the FAA. We need a new system. Maybe automate parts of flight that are the routine parts (cruise handoffs, etc) and have staff for the complex bits (takeoff/approach/landing/taxi).
- chaostheory 4y agoIt will be inevitability disrupted due to the age demographic bomb. Too few people are being born, and retirees are beginning to outnumber working adults. we will either be constantly short of staff in multiple industries or we will start augmenting staff shortages with AI and eventually full replacement
- themitigating 4y agoThat's why immigration is so important
- justrealist 4y agoThe third world is not an infinite factory of human flesh to patch societal issues that the developed world can't be bothered to address. Birthrates in the developing world are mostly at or below replacement already.
- themitigating 4y agoYes it is actually and birthrates in third world countries are much higher
- shjake 4y agoOnly the case in parts of Subsaharan Africa at this point. India for instance is at around 2.0 and many Latin American countries at a similar level as the US.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- bruce511 4y agoSo I read the article, but my immediate question was, "is 11 000 a lot?" There seems to be no reference to how many flights these 2 areas serve in a "normal day" so it's hard to know if 11000 is "all the flights" or "a drop in the bucket". Plus the period in question seems to be "the summer", which seems to be "May to September". So 5 months? NYC = JFK + LGA + EWR DCA = Washington Reagan JFK averages about 42000 flights per month for that period [1] EWR around 24000 flights per month. [2] LGA - Google says around 5000 flights per month DCA - around 25000 flights per month. [3] so that's 96k per month, or 480k for "the summer". So 11000 flights is around 2.3% reduction. I'm no aviation expert, but this seems like "normal variation" to me. Linking this to ATC Staff Shortages seems like a bit of a stretch. (I mean sure.... if we need 3% more ATC staff....) As a percentage of "all US flights" of course it's microscopic. So 11 000 - is it a lot? Well I guess that depends on whether you're a headline writer or not. [1] (https://jfkairport.net/statistics/ https://jfkairport.net/statistics/) [2] https://ewrairport.net/statistics/ https://ewrairport.net/statistics/ [3] https://www.mwaa.com/financial-statistics/reagan-air-traffic-statistics/2022-reagan-air-traffic-statistics https://www.mwaa.com/financial-statistics/reagan-air-traffic...
- walterbell 4y agoLinking this to ATC Staff Shortages seems like a bit of a stretch https://www.fox5ny.com/news/air-traffic-controller-shortage-faa-nyc-flights-cut-summer-2023 https://www.fox5ny.com/news/air-traffic-controller-shortage-... > According to the FAA, the air traffic control center in New York is staffed at 54% compared to the national average of 81%. The agency is asking all major airlines ... to cut service to all New York City area airports by as much as 10% for the summer months. "This is another unprecedented situation," Pauline Frommer, editorial director for Frommer's guide book, said. "We've never seen the FAA asking the airlines to cut flights because they simply don't have enough air traffic controllers"
- bruce511 4y ago>all major airlines Delta, Jet Blue, United, and American Airlines to cut service to all New York City area airports by as much as 10% This pretty much excludes most international flights, and also regional flights. From my walk through the stats quite a bit of traffic is regional, and I'd expect some hefty proportion of flights into JFK at the very least is international. Plus of course the "minor" airlines servicing the same location. So 10% from this select group of airlines, is not out of line with an overall reduction of 2.5%. (and of course "asking" is not necessarily "getting" :)
- georgeplusplus 4y agoI think it is worth to point out a majority of these shortages are due to those who quit or were told to quit because of the COVID vaccine.
- walterbell 4y agoCould they be rehired now that vaccine mandates have been widely dropped, due to court rulings and other reasons?
- vxNsr 4y agoThere’s a lot of mistrust and bad blood. Many of those people have moved on.
- walterbell 4y agoSo much avoidable tragedy :(
- mrguyorama 4y agoGot any actual evidence of this claim?