8 ms·
Lithium battery ripe for disruption, inventor says
- baybal2 4y agoI want to underline, it's not about any other chemistry overtaking lithium he is talking. Lithium will almost certainly remain the one, and only mainstream battery chemistry simply because of physics. Lithium ion has the lowest mass per unit of charge. It's about cathodes, and electrodes which may change, as well as their manufacturing technology.
- _hypx 4y agoThere's an element above lithium on the periodic table that has an even lower mass per unit of charge. Weird that no one talks about this. Also repeating what I said elsewhere: > It's bizarre how people refuse to accept that hydrogen fuel cells are technically batteries and have absurdly high energy densities. And if pressed, you usually hear some excuse like poor efficiencies, as if that isn't a powerful justification for pouring billions of dollars into the problem.
- hinkley 4y agoI’m always surprised when some dev comes up to me to delicately ask if we can rewrite or remodel something I did my first year at the company. Oh god yes, please. Some things you did long ago are just plain wrong, others are only eighty percent right. There’s an expectation that something better will come along, even discounting fads. You just can’t see it or have been sucked into worrying about ten other things. Someone should take that baton. As an inventor I suspect there comes a day where you open the trade journals expecting someone to have supplanted your old inventions. You were trying to improve the state of the art and having lived with it for years or at this point decades, you start wondering where the flying cars went. Please supplant my work.
- slaw 4y ago[flagged]
- IanCal 4y agoThe other kind of situation is a prototype you wrote before you understood the business and problem well enough, but it was more useful than nothing so is now an integral part of the sales pipeline.
- Etheryte 4y agoThe parent comment doesn't even remotely touch on anything like this, why do you need to bring a pointless strawman into this?
- hinkley 4y ago> even discounting fads. I did touch on it, with a ten foot pole. That’s a conversation that requires beers.
- Arbortheus 4y agoIf that is your org’s existing, established, supported, observable, and familiar tool/deployment method for on-call individuals then it would be foolish to use anything else.
- danans 4y agoDisrupting Li-ion has to do with disrupting the high energy density + high power + high round trip efficiency use cases that it currently dominates. Much of these are existing use cases, like personal electronics and cars. The leading horse there is sodium ion last I checked. But there are many emerging energy storage use cases for which lithium ion was never a real contender. Trading off those constraints gets you options like cheap long term energy storage (metal air batteries, flow batteries, heat batteries), or batteries for lower performance vehicles or stationary storage (lithium iron phosphate).
- sroussey 4y agoYou get 2-4x the energy density with aluminum over lithium. But the tech needs a decade and lithium will keep getting better.
- jacquesm 4y agoThose are all important but degradation is very important as well and a limiting factor in many use cases, as well as low temperature performance and safety.
- danans 4y agoLiFePo handle temperature extremes much better than Li-ion, have many times the cycle life, and can be more deeply discharged and charged. The downside is the increased weight.
- jacquesm 4y agoIndeed they do. My personal favorite is Lithium-Titanate but they are still a bit expensive. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lithium-titanate_battery https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lithium-titanate_battery These are not very good for mobile applications such as vehicles due to the lower energy density but for stationary applications they hold a lot of promise and they are in production already. The volume is still too low though, once that goes up this will be a serious contender for things like home batteries. They have some really interesting properties, one of which is a very long predicted life span (30 years!!).
- Torkel 4y agoDisrupting lithium for batteries is like disrupting silicon for transistors - sure there are niches and areas where other things, like silicon carbide or gallium can be used! But to any one trying to pour money into something competing with the trillions of dollars invested into the existing techniques I say: good luck with that.
- philipkglass 4y agoThe article actually says that lithium batteries aren't going away any time soon. The "disruptions" the inventor calls for are more about how lithium ion batteries are made, in particular: - Reducing energy inputs for manufacturing - Eliminating cobalt from cathodes (largely achieved already, depending on what performance characteristics the application can live with) - Using clean energy while mining for battery materials, and ensuring that there are regional supply chains around the world - Expanding battery recycling These sound more incremental than truly disruptive to me, but mining and heavy manufacturing change on a much slower cadence than microchips and software. So maybe these changes would be disruptive in context.
- acyou 4y agoLithium is great, the low atomic mass of 4 is close to as good as you can get. They haven't invested trillions, the lithium ion technology is in a relatively young and poorly optimized state and is similar to the state of the art 40 years ago. You are right, disruption isn't the correct word. Investment, incremental improvement and niche applications are where we see most progress. Other chemistries are not seeming particularly promising for mobile, lightweight applications.
- _hypx 4y agoQuoting what I said elsewhere: > It's bizarre how people refuse to accept that hydrogen fuel cells are technically batteries and have absurdly high energy densities. And if pressed, you usually hear some excuse like poor efficiencies, as if that isn't a powerful justification for pouring billions of dollars into the problem.
- stetrain 4y ago
- AstixAndBelix 4y agoBattery tech is clearly a gargantuan problem. The amount of industry that desperately wants better density is stunning and the fact that despite the billions spent we are still stuck with basically the same tech is a testament to its stubborness
- oblio 4y agoI think we've had, what? 3 major battery techs in 150 years? The first one, then lead acid, now lithium ion. It's a hard problem. 50% extra energy density with the same performance characteristics as lithium ion otherwise would probably level us up as a civilization.
- maxerickson 4y agoLithium-ion is 50% better than it used to be (in terms of energy/mass, it's done better than that for energy/volume). A problem is that lithium is more or less the best choice for materials, and we've been pouring resources into developing it.
- jodrellblank 4y agoDon’t forget the frog battery https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Frog_battery https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Frog_battery And quite a lot of others: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_battery_types https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_battery_types
- oblio 4y agoAdding clauses: mainstream rechargeable battery techs.
- Tagbert 4y agoThere has been steady progress over the last couple of decades in battery tech. Much of it has gone into better Lithium-based batteries. We haven’t exactly stuck with the same tech. “Eternally five years away? No, batteries are improving under your nose” https://arstechnica.com/science/2021/05/eternally-five-years-away-no-batteries-are-improving-under-your-nose/ https://arstechnica.com/science/2021/05/eternally-five-years...
- EntrePrescott 4y agoMaybe the next big disruption is not about making better batteries based on Li (Lithium) but to ditch Li for most mass use purposes and go with a different material, e.g. Na (Natrium, vulgar name: Sodium)… which unlike lithium is extremely abundant. It would (at least in its early less optimized versions) have a slightly lower energy density at about 200 Wh/kg compared to the current best lithium-based state of the art batteries, but still be in a similar ballpark and easily enough for many applications, especially given the much cheaper price. Some manufacturers (e.g. CATL in China) are apparently already ramping up for Na battery mass production. https://archive.is/qJQPn https://archive.is/qJQPn
- _8j50 4y agoI am sure you're not the first person to not want dependency on foreign countries that have lithium deposits. Why is this not done already with sodium? Is it costly to manufacture with it? Durability?
- Lev1a 4y agoMy guess as a layman would be that AFAIK the reaction of alkali ("group 1") metals with water is more violent the further down it's situated in that column in the periodic table. Since Na is one down from Li it should react more violently to any water contact (even water vapor in the atmosphere) which would make it inherently more of a safety concern.
- canadiantim 4y agoLithium actually is super abundant
- kube-system 4y ago“Abundance” is kind of a tricky concept. 99.999%+ of earth’s resources are not yet within human’s ability to mine. Mostly either inaccessible or too sparsely concentrated or locked in compounds difficult to industrialize. Titanium for instance is also very abundant. But it hasn’t been until relatively recently that humans were able to mine and process it at industrial scale.
- philipov 4y agoI tried disrupting my lithium battery, and it blew up.
- acyou 4y agoNowhere in the article does he say the industry is ripe for disruption. Can we please change the title to something more accurate, such as "Lithium ion technology is not going to be disrupted in at least the next 5-10 years, inventor says"?
- laurowyn 4y agoPetition IEEE to change the title. Hacker news just parrots the original title. Them's the rules, always has been.
- Retric 4y agoThat’s not the rule. HN Titles rules aren’t long but they have many exceptions to that general principle. The relevant bit is here: “Otherwise please use the original title, unless it is misleading or linkbait; don't editorialize.” https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- DennisP 4y agoThe title doesn't have to mean that alternative chemistries are around the corner. "Ripe for disruption" can just mean that something needs to be disrupted because it has stagnated and has obvious room for improvement. That's what this guy is saying, by calling for "radical changes in manufacturing, mining, and recycling" of lithium-ion batteries.
- px43 4y agoI feel like I've seen 10 or so cutting edge separators that allow for the use of metallic lithium without dendrite growth or dangerous rapid discharge. This would apparently lead to a massive increase in power density. Are they all being sat on by patent trolls or what? I'm all for making sure that inventors get paid, but at some point I feel like the US government should just be handing out 10 million dollar prizes to people who come up with humanity saving tech, and then making the tech fully patent unencumbered so anyone can build with it. Battery tech is too important for the survival of our species to get caught up in these silly hostage negotiations.
- epistasis 4y ago> “We need to reduce the 60 to 80 kilowatt hours) of electricity it takes to produce a one kWh battery,” Was this transcribed correctly? 60-80kWh for a device that can be charged thousands of times doesn't seem that bad... And even for the higher performance lower-cycling number batteries in phones, it doesn't seem that bad.
- Dead_Lemon 4y ago60-80Kwh is enough to power a house for a week+, for a battery that can store 2 hours of power? Sure its reusable, but the energy debt is large and it will remain a power consuming device. Mostly due to charging the battery from non renewable sources, essentially, never paying off the power debt to create it.
- epistasis 4y agoComparing to a house is not insightful unless compared to the function of that 1 kWh. On the grid, 1kWh of battery will shift multiple MWh of energy in its lifetime. The energy for production is on the order of 1% of its utility over time. If, say, fracking for natural gas produced so much utility for so little energy input, we would have to worry a lot more about natural gas competing with batteries. The primary metric to focus on for batteries should be total cost, which is what will give batteries an even bigger edge over natural gas peakers. Reducing the energy input for 1kWh of capacity from 60 kWh to, say, 6 kWh will have minimal benefit for speeding the transition tk a carbon free energy system. With solar costs as $0.02/kWh, that 60kWh is only $1.20 of a battery pack that costs multiple hundred dollars.
- tyingq 4y ago"He called for a U.S. federal government mandate requiring that all products that incorporate lithium-ion batteries by approved by Underwriters Laboratories or an equivalent testing and certification organization." That would be interesting given how far away we've moved from that. You can find sketchy electrical products now not just on AliExpress or Amazon, but in lots of US retail stores.