7 ms·
I still remember vast majority of HN comments suggest SpaceX's Starship couldn't be done.
by ksec 4y ago
I still remember vast majority of HN comments suggest SpaceX's Starship couldn't be done.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- rendang 4y agoInteresting! Do you have the link to that discussion?
- 93po 4y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35219490 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35219490 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33973607 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33973607 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31368497 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31368497 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31153986 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31153986 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21944855 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21944855 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30353028 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30353028 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21400885 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21400885 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24215739 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24215739 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27010713 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27010713 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27765151 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27765151 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23077358 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23077358 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24460854 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24460854 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10497425 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10497425 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19874192 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19874192
- shkkmo 4y agoMost of those are not skeptical that starship can work. Lots of doubt around the specific claims for the amount that it can drop launch costs by, launch cadence, first launch time frame (which was correct in it's prediction of no 2022 launch), but not really much actual doubt that SpaceX can successfully launch starship.
- 93po 4y agoThe skepticism is always around the ability to have a successful Starship program, which includes all of the above. I don't think people are doubting the physics of it. The 2022 timeline comment focus for me was about the need to fundraise and have a "down round", which was wrong. Also their implication with "there's never been an engine production line which could build much more than one engine per week" and "the raptor engine production line is running much too slow" was resolved less than a year later when SpaceX was up to building a raptor engine every day[1] and is, as of February, at nearly 2 engines a day [2] [1] https://arstechnica.com/science/2022/11/spacex-is-now-building-a-raptor-engine-a-day-nasa-says/ https://arstechnica.com/science/2022/11/spacex-is-now-buildi... [2] https://www.nasaspaceflight.com/2022/02/starships-self-sustaining-city-mars/ https://www.nasaspaceflight.com/2022/02/starships-self-susta...
- shkkmo 4y agoI think you are trying too hard to fit those comments to your narrative. Even if starship fails to fully achieve the very optimistic estimates on every one of those fronts, the starship program can be very successful. HN has in my experience been fairly supportive of Starship's chance of success while pushing back on some of the wildly optimistic claims made about the program.
- belter 4y agoI made one of those: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31368497 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31368497 And there was nothing in the comment saying Starship could not be done. Was about something else.
- 93po 4y ago"Will be landing uncrewed Starship on Mars in 3 to 5 years" I assume you quoted this to demonstrate it being inaccurate or wrong. My point is that Starship is theoretically able to do this today. The launch got scrubbed so we're missing confirmation of how ready it is, but presumably there's a high confidence level it's ready for orbital flight because otherwise the wouldn't be launching it just to explode millions of dollars of rocket. And going from orbital flight to ready to land on mars is a pretty simple roadmap and clearly something they'll have within 4 years (5 years from the comment being made)
- belter 4y agoIf you really believe they will be on Mars in 3 to 5 years, I publicly commit to pay you a dinner on the best restaurant of your choice, in the Olympus Mons district.
- dragonwriter 4y ago> My point is that Starship is theoretically able to do this today. Well, no, its theoretically capable of doing it in 6 months from an optimal launch window, which eats up at least 10% (I don’t have a calendar of launch windows for the 6 month to Mars mission profile handy) of the high end of the 3-5 year window for landing off the bat. But theory and practice are only the same in theory, not in practice.
- _Tev 4y ago> And going from orbital flight to ready to land on mars is a pretty simple roadmap Not really, unless you mean "crash" landing. The 4 year estimate is overly optimistic as a result. Forget launch windows, just handling refueling and long term loitering (with engine restart after that) required for Mars mission with any reasonable chance of success will take majority of those 4 years. Especially if you are not willing to blow starships all the time. And that's also ignoring the tiny detail that Mars is not even in top3 priorities for starship even after successful fully orbital test and landing of both stages. Getting to high flight rate / launching Starlink v2 sats / HLS is much more important for SpaceX
- mardifoufs 4y agoAnd the countless grifters on youtube DEBUNKING and SLAMMING starship. I think there's a channel that is basically just living off debunking spacex at this point. It's a really weird phenomenon.
- ksec 4y agoExactly. I could understand the more recent ones simply due to political nature. Especially in the US. But slamming Starship goes back much further than that, as if they dont want this to happen. It is really strange.
- mardifoufs 4y agoYeah I totally get not liking the billionaire, and I'm sure some of it started as a reaction to the elon musk worship that used to be common back then... but then it turned into a weird culture of random dudes thinking that they are smarter than NASA, SpaceX, the american military, the FAA... and having an audience for their groundbreaking "research".
- adhesive_wombat 4y agoI don't think that's unique to SpaceX specifically. It's just that it's packed with recognised emotive names like Musk and SpaceX and it's unconventional: no prior rocket looks like that or does the same landing thing. However, rockets are basically understandable enough ("big fire go down, thing go up") that everyone can have some opinion, and when they go wrong there's often a huge cinematic explosion. Musk's companies are also high-cadence and PR-rich so there's always a video to make, unlike, say, SLS which just grinds away dully outside the limelight. A diss video rather than a technical video is easier to make and draws using emotions: fans to argue and critics to validate. It's perfect capital-C Content. What video gets more clicks: "Elon Musk's new StarShip is DOOMED, here's why" with a flaming explosion in the thumbnail. Or "TLB invalidation strategy in certain ARMv7a cores is slow on some workloads: here's why"? If there are clicks on the table, there's money on the table.
- grecy 4y agoSadly, the internet has become a place to criticize and throw hate and doubt on basically anyone doing anything that is new, different or extraordinary. Heck, even when I set out to drive around Africa there was a mountain of hatred and anger saying it was impossible, and I would be beheaded in the first country. (Spoiler: I wasn't, I had a great time). I think it's important to remember that the very, VERY vast majority of people on the internet have absolutely no idea what they're talking about. Unfortunately it seems the people with the least idea are the loudest, and get given the biggest microphone.
- ksec 4y agoThat same with media as well. It seems we are in a death spiral.
- brookst 4y agoFortunately we have HN, where doubts about SpaceX are not allowed, in the name of open discussion.
- grecy 4y agoOf course doubts are allowed, but what I'm saying is that SpaceX clearly have a team of world-class experts. They've all spend decades training, practising and honing their craft. Based on their track record, I'd say they're pretty good at what they do. They may even be the best in the world. That makes it hard when some rando on the internet comes in to doubt or criticize, because it's virtually impossible for that rando to have more expertise than the entire SpaceX team. If a person actually run the numbers and backed up their thoughts with legitimate reasons and a better idea that would be one thing. But that never happens, which is the problem. If a government is aiming to increase the amount of renewable power, or a car company aims to make their cars more efficient, or a public transit operator wants to increase their service, or literally any one of billions of things that can be done, it is a waste of everyone's time for someone to chime in and say "Won't work because I said so" when they have absolutely zero experience, expertise or evidence to back up their thought that has no basis in reality.
- macintux 4y agoIn fairness we still don’t know that reusability is going to work. The heat shielding is afaict a big unknown. Can they use a mostly modular tile? Can they hold the tiles in place with their current strategy? Will their approach to both of the above sufficiently protect the vehicle? How much will it take to reset the shielding after each launch?
- philistine 4y agoYeah those tiles are clearly the weakest link in the whole Starship ecosystem. The shuttle was built on the idea those tiles could be inspected and replaced within days. It ended up taking half a year.
- elil17 4y agoWell it's vastly scaled down from what was originally proposed. The original proposal (ITS) was for a vehicle that could deliver 300 tons to LEO. Then that got scaled to down to 150 tons. They had proposed doing "Earth to Earth" (rocket travel from city to city) with it. Not on the table now as I understand it. They did pull off a steel-based design and an FFSC engine which is really cool. But they HN commenters were absolutely right that the original design was a fantasy.
- greedo 4y agoThey actually were awarded a contract in 2022 for point to point travel for the USAF. A logical extension of that would be city to city. https://spacewatch.global/2022/01/spacex-wins-102-million-air-force-contract-for-point-to-point-transportation/ https://spacewatch.global/2022/01/spacex-wins-102-million-ai...
- kitsunesoba 4y agoIf I'm not mistaken, MCT/ITS is something that's potentially still on the table, just kicked down the road until after Starship+Superheavy have proven themselves and demand for cargo+crew delivery capacity greater than what Starship is capable of (which is already absurdly high relative to predecessors) has materialized. It makes sense, because at that point building MCT/ITS is a matter of "just" scaling up Starship+Superheavy instead of starting from a blank slate. I believe earth-to-earth is still a consideration, too, if only because the US military has expressed interest in such capabilities.
- cwillu 4y agoEarth to earth is still listed prominently on https://www.spacex.com/vehicles/starship/ https://www.spacex.com/vehicles/starship/
- GuB-42 4y agoIt is still not done, in fact there is a good chance that this launch will go boom, which is actually expected by SpaceX as part of the iterative development process and not as bad as, say, a failure of the SLS, but it still means we are not ready yet. Remember that the Soviet N1 launched 4 times, all failures, and it was the end of the program, I don't think Starship will suffer the same fate, for many reasons, but just because we get to launches don't mean the program will succeed. That it can be done never really was the question. The tech is actually pretty well proven, a lot of it coming from soviet design. The issue is more about economics: do we need a super heavy reusable rocket, will reusability keep its promises. It is not like everyone and his dog has to put something into orbit, and in fact, we don't want too much stuff into orbit mostly because of the risk of space debris. Interestingly, the biggest customer may be SpaceX itself, with Starlink, and I think it is not a coincidence. We already had the Space Shuttle which was supposed to revolutionize space operation, and while the shuttle did work as a launcher, but it was ultimately a failure, hence the skepticism over Starship, it addition to the well known tendency of Elon Musk to overpromise and underdeliver. Personally, I think SpaceX did better than I expected, and I think Starship will become at least a working launcher. SpaceX is essentially the only hope of the US government when it comes to rocketry, they won't let them go, especially now that the relationship with Russia is a bit tense. But as for how game changing it will be, I have absolutely no idea.
- greedo 4y agoWhat tech would you describe as coming from Soviet designs?
- GuB-42 4y agoIt is something Elon Musk himself said and I don't really know the details. But the Soviet were at the forefront of staged combustion engines, of which the Raptor engine famously is. And the "Super Heavy" booster is reminiscent of the N1 rocket, using a large number of small, efficient engines.
- philistine 4y ago
- adaml_623 4y agoCounting comments means nothing when only a biased subset are making comments.
- pclmulqdq 4y agoI'm pretty sure most of the discussion here was suggesting that he could get one of these off the ground, but that it won't necessarily accomplish its goals. The skepticism was more about whether the claimed cost reductions could be reached, whether the craft could do any sort of reasonable missions, or whether the desired launch cadence could be achieved. Falcon heavy is still doing 1 launch per year or so, so that doesn't seem to be a given at all.