3 ms·
In terms of measurable outcome, what does "catastrophic" mean? At some point, language about everything has transformed into having zero dynamic range. Everythi
by renewiltord 4y ago
In terms of measurable outcome, what does "catastrophic" mean? At some point, language about everything has transformed into having zero dynamic range. Everything is either a disaster or nothing.
And considering high rises by the sea side, scooters on sidewalks, and bike lanes are all "catastrophic". It would be useful to get a scale here that is continuous non-binary-value.
For instance, if it's as bad as the article's claim that the FAA's failed to hold a bilingual hearing, I'm not really that concerned. Lack of bilingual hearings don't rise to the level of disaster, by my reckoning.
- brookst 4y agoIt all depends on your frame of reference. For someine deeply concerned with endangered habitats, a few hundred or thousand dead animals is an unbearable catastrophe. For someone focused on progress at all costs, it's not even a slight concern. It's just how the world works, that the people whose concerns are most impacted seek to advocate for their positions.
- freejazz 4y ago> For someone focused on progress at all costs, it's not even a slight concern. Whose progress?
- renewiltord 4y agoWell, they're the ones doing the advocacy so I won't armchair quarterback but my reaction to the thing when language like that is used without corresponding numbers is that it's a cry-wolf fearmongering scenario. Perhaps the general public is different. I think not, but we shall see.
- brookst 4y agoWait, you didn't see numbers and analysis in that article? I'm willing to believe the numbers are falsified, the analysis is biased, and the author is a dirty commie, but it seems odd to claim there are no numbers. Are you sure your head is clear on this?
- renewiltord 4y agoAre you sure yours is? I'm asking for outcomes numbers, which is what I care about. It is not important to me for this argument that thrust is 74 MN. That's a numeric value but tells me nothing about this guy's predictions. I made it clear that I wanted to know what "catastrophic" meant. It is not important to me that the stand is 30 ft tall. That is numeric but not relevant. Come now, you know that numbers don't make an analysis. But suppose you do believe they do, I will include some here for you to refute. The SpaceX launch is safe because: 1, 2, 3, 6, 11, 23, 47, 106, 235, 551
- brookst 4y agoGood rhetoric, but not good faith. Numbers the article mentioms: - Approvals were done for a 62MN rocket, launch is 74 - A test at 50% thrust in February measured sound at 110db three miles away when the model used for approval estimated 90-110db for 100% thrust - Starship will have 10x the power of Falcon 9, launched from a complex 1/4 the size - The approval process used has never been used for a rocket complex before And lest you think I'm some owl-loving hippie, I am pro rockets and excited for the launch tomorrow. I just think it's important to allow dissenting views, especially when they do have data. Just suppressing them with smug "rockets good, any disagree bad, and disagree numbers meaningless" rhetoric is really not in the spirit HN claims to foster.
- renewiltord 4y agoMate, let's go back to where the conversation started: > In terms of measurable outcome, what does "catastrophic" mean? Does "catastrophic" mean that launch thrust is higher? Does catastrophic mean that the sound is going to be higher? Does catastrophic mean that Starship will have 10x the power? Does catastrophic mean that the approval process hasn't been used? I mean, if the answer is that "catastrophic" was referring to one of those, then I think it's pretty clear it's hard to care right? From my perspective, having more power in a smaller size is not a catastrophic thing. That's what engineering is: doing more with less ("any fool can build a bridge...") It's perplexing to me that you have quoted things that are complete non-sequiturs to the question and then started giving me this "not in the spirit of HN" crap. Come on. I know Internet arguments require that you double down, but I think it was pretty clear from my very first sentence what I was looking for and it's pretty clear this blog post has none of it.