7 ms·
Is the US education system in a state of collapse, and what caused it?
- kranke155 4y agoThe US seems to be having a general collapse on multiple fronts due to the apparent unwillingness to tax corporations and the wealthy to a reasonable level. I’ve heard the same thing about infrastructure. Yet European nations that are not as rich as the U.S. seem to be having issues but doing ok on healthcare, infrastructure and public education.
- csdvrx 4y ago> Yet European nations that are not as rich as the U.S. seem to be having issues but doing ok on healthcare, infrastructure and public education. They seem to be having issues with at least pensions, healthcare and public education
- rendall 4y agoPeople keep speaking about "Europe" as if it's not 44 nations and many more languages and peoples.
- replygirl 4y agothe united states has a similar land area, similar number of states, over 500 sovereign constituent nations, two widely spoken languages, with largely unrestricted travel and trade within. europe does fund and coordinate social investments that involve multiple states. it's a useful comparison
- rendall 4y agoIt is definitely not reasonable to say that Europe is having trouble with public education or pensions or infrastructure.
- replygirl 4y agosure it is. many aspects of the continent are subject to federal governance, and before that was the case, much of the social and infrastructural development was interdependent due to support+direction from the us in the west and the soviet union in the east
- replygirl 4y agoinfrastructure too: they have the same problem with old bridges, with a few recent collapses and many closed to freight; they have an ongoing energy crisis; they have coastal cities in both the north and south where the flood risk is both more imminent and more potentially destructive
- base698 4y agoWhy do you think more taxing would fix it when we are already near the top of per capita spending per student? https://nces.ed.gov/programs/coe/indicator/cmd https://nces.ed.gov/programs/coe/indicator/cmd
- kranke155 4y agoMight not help there, I’m not an expert. I just said it because Americans will come in and say “there is no way”. Sorry, there is another way and Europe lives in that other way.
- midoridensha 4y agoUS public education (pre-college) is sorta similar to US healthcare: they spend the most per-capita in the world, and get, on average, very poor results.
- nine_zeros 4y agoThe American social contract is broken. Government services are utterly broken, not just due to incompetence but because taxing the rich is seen as anti-capitalistic. If it were not for the strength of the dollar, the US would have been no different from a third world country. Crony capitalists, uneducated populace, politicians lying to said uneducated populace, corruption at all levels (there is county-level lobbying too), healthcare is inaccessible to the average person and the homeless and prison population is greater than the population of some US states combined
- musicale 4y agoAm I reading these charts correctly? They seem to be showing relatively high spending on education and health care compared to other countries. https://nces.ed.gov/programs/coe/indicator/cmd https://nces.ed.gov/programs/coe/indicator/cmd https://www.statista.com/statistics/281589/countries-with-highest-health-expenditure-as-a-percent-of-gdp/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/281589/countries-with-hi...
- kranke155 4y agoThe health care system is problematic not because it’s not well funded but because parts of the population can’t access it? I have bipolar and I know online communities where the Americans with BPD talk about not being able to afford their meds.
- belugacat 4y agoCan you be a bit more specific with what you mean by "collapse"? When we talk about a bridge or a building collapsing, we're talking about a very obvious and immediate mode of failure. Are you using "collapse" to mean "noticeable degradation"? FWIW, the European nation I'm from (France) is definitely not doing OK on healthcare and public education (and debatable on infrastructure). Hard to compare with the US 1:1 in any case, but I'm not sure I'd designate either as a collapse.
- kranke155 4y agoIm just taking it from Americans. I’ve never visited and maybe I best stay quiet. But the HN trend with these things is always to say “the whole world is like this” No no it’s not. The US is lagging behind on many indicators. Another world is not only possible, it actually exists.
- midoridensha 4y ago>Are you using "collapse" to mean "noticeable degradation"? Do you believe that the Roman Empire never "collapsed"? Probably every historian would agree that it did, however that collapse took centuries to complete.
- megaman821 4y agoIt is not sufficient to merely fund something, you have to competently execute on it too. The US education system has more than adequately funding, but suffers from terrible administration. On top of that schools are tasked with too much stuff. On top of general education, schools have to deal with child hunger, child abuse, mental well being, gender and sexuality issues. These should all be separate government provided services. Do we want our teachers to be educators or social servants?
- kranke155 4y agoSounds like the public school system is being made into a scapegoat. Very easy to say “public schooling is broken” when you’ve assigned it 500 tasks and funded it for 10.
- ams92 4y agoYou wouldn’t even need to raise taxes to improve some of these programs. Just stop spending such an absurd amount of money on the military.
- midoridensha 4y agoThe US doesn't spend that much on the military in terms of percentage of GDP. Compare it to other developed nations, and it looks pretty average really. The US already spends more per-capita on students than any other nation. The problem is not funding. Throwing more money at the problem isn't going to help.
- dragonwriter 4y ago> The US doesn’t spend that much on the military in terms of percentage of GDP. Compare it to other developed nations, and it looks pretty average really. All of the countries with higher GDP share in military expenditures than the US are in one of the following groups: (1) Middle Eastern countries, (2) Non-Western-aligned former Soviet Republics, (3) Greece, Pakistan, and Morocco. Of 145 countries with data, the US is #15. It is #3 in the G20, #1 in the G10, #8 of 48 among “high income countries” – with Greece and 7 Middle Eastern countries making up the top 7. It is nowhere close to “pretty average” among “other developed nations”. https://www.theglobaleconomy.com/rankings/mil_spend_gdp/ https://www.theglobaleconomy.com/rankings/mil_spend_gdp/ > The US already spends more per-capita on students than any other nation. Funny that shift from percent GDP to make your (false, even with that standard) claim about US not having high military spending, but shift to per capita rather than per GDP for education spending. On that, the US is merely fairly middle of the pack for developed nations, with 3.2% of GDP in primary/secondary education, compared to 3.1% OECD average.
- alecco 4y agoOf course a forum for teachers does not admit they are part of the problem.
- replygirl 4y agoCan you elaborate?
- alecco 4y agoMultiple comments complain they are blamed and multiple comments complain about pay. Yet education spending is at its highest (relative to GDP). I agree with them about bad parents and mobile phones/social media, though.
- nova22033 4y agoHigh education spending doesn't equate to good teacher pay. The pay for administrative staff has gone through the roof. IMHO, teachers are underpaid for what they do and what we expect of them.
- musicale 4y ago> High education spending doesn't equate to good teacher pay. The pay for administrative staff has gone through the roof. Am I reading this chart correctly? It seems to indicate that US teachers' salaries are at #6 in the OECD countries (behind Luxembourg, Germany, Netherlands, Canada, and Australia): https://data.oecd.org/teachers/teachers-salaries.htm https://data.oecd.org/teachers/teachers-salaries.htm Surprisingly Finland is at #17. And this chart [2] seems to indicate that administrative expenditures have consistently accounted for around 40% of public elementary and secondary education expenditures since 1980. However they were lower in 1970 (32%), so there seems to have been some expansion in the 1970s. [2] https://nces.ed.gov/programs/digest/d21/tables/dt21_236.10.asp https://nces.ed.gov/programs/digest/d21/tables/dt21_236.10.a...
- sethammons 4y ago
- iamerroragent 4y agoI'm not sure it needs to work beyond getting people prepared enough to consume advertising. As long as you can import talent and expand the public funding of private education there's little incentive in America to improve public education. https://www.nbcnews.com/politics/politics-news/betsy-devos-american-federation-children-private-school-rcna76307 https://www.nbcnews.com/politics/politics-news/betsy-devos-a...
- deepthunder 4y agoFinland has no private education. The rich elite have to send their kids to the same public schools as everyone else. The rationale is the rich elite will demand that the public school system will maintain education standards. And the converse that if the rich can send their kids to private schools why would they care about the standards of public schools?
- wslh 4y agoThis was part of series of Sunday morning posts in HN [1]. [1] A 'Science of Reading' Revolt Takes on the Education Establishment (nytimes.com): https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35589013 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35589013
- alecco 4y agoAn issue often overlooked by the establishment pertains to the erosion of democracy's fundamental principles as a consequence of a deteriorating education system. This makes me thing it is intentional. There is at least correlation with voting patterns.
- brookst 4y agoIMO it's emergent more than intentional, in the sense that our slide towards authoritarianism gives extremists more power to attack institutions that dissent. I don't think any of the villains responsible for degradation of democracy are strategic enough to have multi-decade plans.
- quanticle 4y agoI don't think that there will be a collapse. The linked post [1] has this telling line: Because I’m in a very very blue state and city Emphasis on city. Every time I've read something about how the education system in the United States is on the verge of collapse or is collapsing, it's been from a teacher (or has quoted teachers) in a city school district. City school districts are in dire shape. But that's because many city school districts are massively overbuilt for the amount of children they need to serve, and politicians are loath to shutter schools. So these school districts chug along, spending more and more money on buildings and facilities that are hardly used, while, at the same time shortchanging teachers and the education of children. Suburban school districts are smaller, have more children (which equates to more funding) and generally have newer buildings and facilities, so they're not in the same dire shape as city school districts. For that reason, you hear much less about them. After all, who wants to write a news story that reads, "Okay, everything is actually functioning as it more or less should?" This leads to a mistaken impression that all school districts everywhere are on the verge of breakdown when in reality the failures are localized to city districts like San Francisco or Chicago. [1]: https://www.reddit.com/r/Teachers/comments/11620il/the_us_is_going_to_have_a_massive_wake_up_call/ https://www.reddit.com/r/Teachers/comments/11620il/the_us_is...
- adgjlsfhk1 4y agoI think a lot of it is just that cities still have functional newspapers to report when schools are failing and the suburbs don't.
- bart_spoon 4y agoMost suburbs are reported on by the newspapers of the neighboring city when something newsworthy occurs, educational or otherwise.
- base698 4y agoI live in a smaller red city and it's as bad at select schools as it is in SF. Generally public education is horrendous here and everyone with an above median income sends their kids to private school.
- recursivedoubts 4y agoThe US has worked so long as people were and/or felt they were getting rich, or at least had a shot at it. Everything, including education, was designed around getting rich: being a good worker, being a good consumer, consume current product, excited for next product. Can't afford it? Here is cheap credit. As people no longer feel that they are getting rich, america will increasingly stop working. Ironically, love of money is the only thing we americans still have in common: https://archive.is/FYZtc https://archive.is/FYZtc We live in a society.
- midoridensha 4y agoThis is the most insightful comment about American society I think I've ever read.
- lumb63 4y agoI have several friends who work or worked in schools, and they all have told me that students lack respect. They cuss out teachers on a regular basis, are insubordinate, and do not respect authority. Teachers cannot discipline the students, either. Doing so gets them calls from angry parents, or in trouble with the administration that got said calls. The above factors cause people who want to teach to stop. It is brutal to their mental health to be disrespected constantly and be powerless to do anything about it. I believe children are mostly reflections of their parents. If a child is not respectful, my hunch is that their parent(s) are not respectful. I’m curious to hear from parents: how do you ensure (if you do) that your children are respectful toward their teachers? How do your fellow parents do so? When I was a kid, the idea never occurred to me to be disrespectful toward teachers. I don’t think my parents ever had to tell me to be respectful toward my teachers. It came naturally, probably because I saw my parents be respectful toward my teachers. I of course saw children in my classes who weren’t, and I assume their parents were the same. I’m inclined to think something changed, though, since the disrespect sounds much more prevalent today. Or maybe I’m hearing about it more since I’m older, now.
- taeric 4y agoThis is a dangerous line. As often, when people speak of not getting respect from others, they describe not getting subservience. Especially from kids. Especially, again, when it is authority speaking
- bigtex88 4y agoCan you provide proof of what you're saying? Respect does not equal authoritarianism. That's an extreme stance to take.
- taeric 4y agoMy experience growing up in the US south. I almost certainly counted as a respectful student. But I also saw what was around me. As a parent now, I have seen disrespectful kids, sure. Oddly, they are rarely "disrespectful" to me. Certainly no more so than my peers. Considerably less so than older folks, oddly.
- nova22033 4y agoThis is a post on r/Teachers so it's not surprising they don't talk about gatekeeping via unnecessary but mandatory certifications. Teachers are directly responsible for this via the teachers unions.
- revlolz 4y agoJust an anecdote and not necessarily representative of the majority, in certain areas, teaching has taken on cult-like characteristics. Teachers engage in a radical cycle of self-sacrifice, constantly striving for virtuous superiority over their colleagues, often to the detriment of their own financial and emotional well-being. This mindset justifies exponentially increasing demands each year, requiring teachers to sacrifice more of themselves in the name of what is best for the children. District administrations, influencers, unions, and politicians seem to be enabling this as much as possible in order to cut costs (financially and risk). If one questions this approach, they may be labeled not only as ineffective in their profession, but also as morally deficient for putting children's futures at risk. From afar it appears as toxic nightmare that undermines a better education system.
- etempleton 4y agoThe problem I believe is three fold: 1. Lack of discipline. Parents are less likely to discipline their children and don’t want schools to either. Admins are reluctant to remove problem students from classrooms and even more reluctant to suspend or expel them because of… 2. Metrics and Data Around the early 2000 the fed, states, and districts became obsessed with data. The problem is the people making decisions are not researchers and even if they were they would probably still go down the wrong route because they fail to identify causations vs correlation. So schools are obsessed with minimizing referrals, suspensions, and expulsions because they are correlated with low graduation rates. They are obsessed with test scores. So much so that much of the school year is spent prepping for or taking standardized tests. 3. Lack of Backing from Community Parents are questioning everything teachers are doing and in my school district some parents are convinced teachers are trying to turn their kids trans or queer. Book banning is at an all time high from parents who have never read the books they are trying to ban.
- sethammons 4y ago> Metrics and Data When I taught, we considered all the standardized testing as weighing your cows more often to increase their weight.
- jmclnx 4y agoIs the US education system in a state of collapse ? * yes What caused it ? * greed, union busting, no one wants to pay taxes. This started with Pres Reagan, continued on with Bush, Clinton and went into overdrive with Bush II. * Racism, I do not want my kid going to school with "those people". * Now in some places we have the war on Edu, where if it is not in the Bible all facts are false. Plus some States want to teach falsehoods when it comes to what really happened in US history. So we have a case were rich people are sending their children to private schools and trying to get their Taxes redirected to these private schools. This just started to work in many places and now and Public Education quality is falling again. Not to mention good teachers are leaving in some states because to teach real facts they risk prison and/or hefty fines.
- taraharris 4y agoI had an incredibly bad experience going through public schools in Mount Horeb, Wisconsin in the 1980s and 90s. I did my best to hide it, but I began suffering from gender dysphoria starting at age 7. I was known by my classmates as the weird Jewish kid, and I stuck out badly in every possible way. I was a year younger than most of my classmates because I skipped third grade. I was bullied for years and treated as a behavioral problem by my teachers. I hated every minute of school. It has always been a prison for children who are different. My mother became a substitute teacher for the Madison Metro School District in the late 1990s, after I had graduated. As she learned about the way these institutions are actually run, she saw the need to apologize for sending me to school instead of just letting me stay at home to learn what I wanted to, at my own pace. At a minimum, the truancy laws need to be abolished and you should be automatically exempted from property taxes if you homeschool your children. We have the remote work and the Internet now, so there is absolutely no humane justification for forcing all children into the same cruel torture chamber just for making the mistake of being born in the United States. I am 42 years old now, so I've had decades to reflect on all this and consider my position very carefully. Edugenic harm is very, very real.
- Fatnino 4y agoShould I be automatically exempt from property tax if I don't have school aged kids yet/anymore?
- taraharris 4y agoPlease have compassion for those harmed by what is by nearly all accounts a heartless, unaccountable institution. My comment is not substantially about taxes at all, and I mention that as a remedy knowing full well that the chances of it coming true are close to zero. What's the harm in letting a girl express her utopian dream? The worst that could happen is that I drag us forward a little bit
- Fatnino 4y agoI came off harsher than intended. I'm actually all for everyone's property taxes being spent per kid not per school to see to their education. So a private school that is acredited (insert details here) would get funds from that pool too. Saying that it should be contingent on learning outcomes sounds nice, but that's clearly not enforced in public schools today anyhow.
- BigCryo 4y agoI was in school when the change started. In 1970-71 I was in 8th grade. And up until that time I never saw any disrespect toward teachers ever really.. students were paddled if they misbehaved.. and then in 1971-72 everything changed.. I know why it changed but I can't really say anything here because of censorship.. but now you know when it changed
- hellisothers 4y agoSome comments here and in the Reddit thread suggest a lack of respect for authority which is causing several downstream problems. This especially makes sense in a country where more and more people distrust the government (authority) or any authority outside their community and their kids pick up on this. I’m all for questioning authority (you should!), if you’re sending your kids to an educational authority though, everybody will get more out of it if you respectfully do so.