3 ms·
> Why pay someone who produces less, or can bear a lower wage, the same as someone who produces more or can't? If it turns out that any companies are trying to
by neilv 4y ago
> Why pay someone who produces less, or can bear a lower wage, the same as someone who produces more or can't?
If it turns out that any companies are trying to do the things the article alleged --- exploitative (e.g., using intimate data to determine the minimum they can offer each individual gig worker, while they have them over a barrel) and bad-faith (e.g., blocking an individual worker from gigs when they're about to hit a bonus threshold) -- the corpus of HN comments tells us that there will always be a tech worker with logic and values aligned with making it happen.
> Emotional reasoning abounds.
Many of us would do well to be more logical in our thinking, and many of us would do well to discover more "emotional" values based wanting to lift up everyone rather than dominate them.
- lotsofpulp 4y ago> do well to discover more "emotional" values based wanting to lift up everyone rather than dominate them. The right way to do this is via wealth redistribution via taxes. Not letting markets determine appropriate prices simply leads to society wide misallocation of resources.
- carlitossway 4y agoOne thing is to prevent the market to decide prices, and a very different thing is to let bad-faith actors to continue going around unchecked. The first scenario allows us to collectively make a bigger cake and then figure out how to share it. The second scenario allows the two biggest bullies to stomp over half of the cake while fighting who is to claim a bigger slice! It is ok to let people with bigger appetites to eat more; but if you cannot be civil and keep wasting food, why wouldn't the others kick you out of the table?
- ipaddr 4y agoThat leads to waste, corruption and the rich paying even less.
- pdonis 4y ago> Not letting markets determine appropriate prices simply leads to society wide misallocation of resources. So does wealth redistribution via taxes (and printing money, which is a significant component of wealth redistribution in all developed countries, and not to the advantage of the poorer people). The right way to prevent exploitation is to equalize bargaining power. But doing that requires less government interference, not more; free markets aren't perfect, but they do better at equalizing bargaining power than the alternatives. For example, the reason Uber can exploit its gig workers is that its competition, taxis, is already regulated up one side and down the other by the government, and hence is horribly inefficient (and exploitative of its drivers), so Uber can compete simply by being a little bit less inefficient. Nobody has ever even tried to see what an actual free market in transit would come up with.
- SketchySeaBeast 4y agoThis equalizes companies but not workers. If we remove government restrictions to become a true free marker that's going to be removing labour laws as well. Given the already existing power discrepancy between employee and employer I can't see this helping.
- flandish 4y agoThe problem with removing regulation for corps so they can work a “free” “market” is that they will exploit. It’s what they’ve always done. It’s what they will always trend toward. See also: kids in auto plans, meat facilities, etc. The issue is that the labor has no ability to correct the market - in the same fashion. (Ie: labor cannot exploit and downright _murder_ capital owners - like the owners can and have done. There are laws preventing that.) If humans are not treated with a higher priority than roi or profit, the business is inherently evil. (Hint; they all are.) If we have laws for some and not for all - that is to say privatization of all corps with no regulation - that is deplorable and will not end well. A solution, imho, is for all services required for life, health, education, and safety to be public owned and not corporations. All other services are owned equally by those that operate them, co-op like. Free markets can still exist like this. But hey. That’s not really what capitalists claim to want when they say “free market”; that phrase is a dog whistle for “legal exploitation of the labor pool.”
- jacquesm 4y agoMis-allocation of resources is to some degree acceptable if it leads to people experiencing a more fair world. That's why we no longer have piece-work but hourly rates.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]