4 ms·
> I addressed this - systems without IME exist, but are not available for purchase, for any price, except for governments. That's not economics. As I understan
by kube-system 4y ago
> I addressed this - systems without IME exist, but are not available for purchase, for any price, except for governments. That's not economics.
As I understand governments just set a bit to disable IME on already existing processors. But if you want a feature and are willing to give them billions of dollars, Intel or anyone else absolutely will add a feature for you. You can call up any fab and have them make whatever you want. Custom silicon is absolutely a thing, but it requires big bucks. Nobody makes bleeding-edge node processors for applications with tiny markets precisely because of economics. They are made for the only market with enough revenue to support the R&D cost: the mass market.
> I specifically said "non-rootable", i.e. non-privileged by default, but that can be unlocked. So mainstream phones would remain non-privileged except for those motivated enough to follow an unlock procedure.
Mainstream phones don't do this. They still sell. Therefore it is proven that the market DGAF. The largest customers for a company like Samsung are businesses who don't want the phones to be unlockable. They want that shit locked down and surveilled like Fort Knox. Pun intended. https://samsungknox.com/en https://samsungknox.com/en
> If MS prevented users from running any compiler except Visual Studio on Windows, would you excuse it because those that need it are a niche market, for whom the more expensive Windows Pro licenses are made?
I don't think they have a reason to expend resources to affirmatively make this change -- but the few products they've released for which it was inconvenient to add support for things like this, they absolutely have. eg: S mode.
> There are no non-smart TVs on store shelves next to smart ones, just for a higher price, despite demand [1]. In fact it's a challenge to find one at all.
You can find sometimes find Spectre dumb TVs at walmart. Know why the they're hard to find? Because TVs have large fixed costs to produce, and if you don't move enough units to cover both the marginal and fixed costs, you cannot afford to offer the product at all.
> "This question of smart-TV data privacy and security is by far the most-asked among Ask Wirecutter readers."
I don't doubt that Wirecutter has received maybe hundreds of questions about this topic. But almost 225 million TVs sell annually. People buy smart TVs.
It's just the reality that privacy is not a primary purchasing consideration for mass market customers. The mass market doesn't care. If you even read a privacy policy, people will think you're weird. I wish it weren't the case, but it plainly is. It really won't change until people stop buying these products.
- Bran_son 4y ago> But almost 225 million TVs sell annually. People buy smart TVs. There's literally nothing else on the consumer market. Edit: There may be a dumb Sceptre TV hidden in a Walmart warehouse somewhere, but I checked and there are none available in my entire EU country. Meanwhile the smart TVs sure don't advertise their spyware as prominently as their price, so we can add fraud in addition to robbery. > As I understand governments just set a bit to disable IME on already existing processors. But if you want a feature and are willing to give them billions of dollars, Intel or anyone else absolutely will add a feature for you. [..] Custom silicon is absolutely a thing If all it takes is setting a bit, I don't see why you'd invoke custom silicon except to muddy the waters.
- kube-system 4y agoThat's not even true, as I mentioned. Examples: https://www.sceptre.com/TV/4K-UHD-TV-category1category73.html https://www.sceptre.com/TV/4K-UHD-TV-category1category73.htm... https://www.walmart.com/ip/Sceptre-55-Class-4K-UHD-LED-TV-HDR-U550CV-U/46784939 https://www.walmart.com/ip/Sceptre-55-Class-4K-UHD-LED-TV-HD... Also, it's besides my point. The fact that people buy smart TVs in large numbers is proof of the fact that the privacy concerns are not a factor in the mass market's buying decisions. Do you own a TV? Did you buy a Sceptre? Why not? Did you not care enough about the privacy consideration to do a quick search to see that they exist? Most people don't. > If all it takes is setting a bit, I don't see why you'd invoke custom silicon except to muddy the waters. Because I was responding precisely to your gripe about "impossibility of buying a CPU without Intel Management Engine (or AMD equivalent)". If you are happy setting that bit, then the problem you are complaining about doesn't exist: https://hackaday.com/2020/01/28/factory-laptop-with-ime-disabled/ https://hackaday.com/2020/01/28/factory-laptop-with-ime-disa... https://hackaday.com/2023/04/12/disabling-intels-backdoors-on-modern-laptops/ https://hackaday.com/2023/04/12/disabling-intels-backdoors-o...
- Bran_son 4y ago> Do you own a TV? Did you buy a Sceptre? Why not? I do, I did not, because my TV is old enough to not yet be "smart", and because Sceptres are literally not available anywhere in my country. Am I now virtuous enough by your standards to point out how hostile manufacturers are to users? > The fact that people buy smart TVs in large numbers is proof Hey I wonder if you asked ten random people if they knew their smart TV was reporting the contents of their USB sticks and their viewing habits to 3rd parties, how many would answer yes? This is the same revealed preference tortured logic that concludes people don't care about child labor because they still buy chocolate. Out of sight out of mind. > If you are happy setting that bit, then the problem you are complaining about doesn't exist Then this is a recent development, because in 2017 even Google was unable to get rid of IME: As of 2017, Google was attempting to eliminate proprietary firmware from its servers and found that the ME was a hurdle to that. - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intel_Management_Engine#By_Google https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intel_Management_Engine#By_Goo...