6 ms·
U.S. SEC sees decentralized crypto platforms as exchanges
- HPsquared 4y agoI wonder what side effects this decision will bring.
- monero-xmr 4y agoMeanwhile Hong Kong is rolling out the the red carpet https://www.wsj.com/articles/hong-kong-banks-are-netting-crypto-customers-as-citys-push-gains-steam-ccb5811f?mod=markets_lead_pos5 https://www.wsj.com/articles/hong-kong-banks-are-netting-cry... The crypto industry is extremely adept at moving across borders, and as power politics between nations dictate different priorities, crypto will make its home base where ever the doors open. Right now China and Russia are in a West vs. East struggle, and anything they can do to reduce the power of the US Dollar and banking system will be supported.
- VWWHFSfQ 4y agoHasn't the CCP been pretty adversarial to cryptocurrency?
- DANmode 4y agoDepends on if you mean officially or unofficially, from what I can gather.
- snacktaster 4y agoChina has outright banned it at various times. USA has taken legal stances against things like tornado cash, but never anything close to the broad strokes of banning that the Chinese government has done. If anything the slowness and deliberateness of USA regulators to respond has enabled the entire worldwide crypto economy to flourish. So China is now going to "roll out the red carpets" for crypto exchanges? Yeah right.
- wnevets 4y ago> So China is now going to "roll out the red carpets" for crypto exchanges? Yeah right. The "this is good for bitcoin" crowd never ceases to entertain.
- cherioo 4y agoCCP doesn’t want crypto due to risk from capital flight and monetary control in China. Hong Kong has no such risks given its freer capital control. The only thing non-free that CCP care is speech.
- bobthepanda 4y agoWell, HK is also a conduit of money entering and leaving China, so if people start using crypto for that then China will crack down, the same way they cracked down on the Macanese money-laundering via casinos.
- anonymouskimmer 4y agoWhen used by their own citizens.
- jjtheblunt 4y agoSince Russia has lots of energy, maybe they can use it to settle transactions? Meanwhile Visa keeps on clearing incomparably more (by “several orders of magnitude”) encrypted transactions per second globally for miniscule energy?
- robcohen 4y agoI’d be very surprised if Visa can clear transactions with less energy than Ethereum Proof of Stake requires. https://ethereum.org/en/energy-consumption/ https://ethereum.org/en/energy-consumption/ The energy argument is correct for proof of work, not proof of stake.
- thisgoesnowhere 4y agoBit odd to see the comparison of ethereum to YouTube and netflix. What is that supposed to show?
- robcohen 4y agoIt’s supposed to show relative power consumption. Which it does. What would you like to compare it to?
- thisgoesnowhere 4y agoOther payment networks? Stripe, square, interac? One is a streaming service and the other is a payment network. It's like comparing a construction site to a restaurant in terms of fuel consumption.
- crote 4y agoI could also compare it to the power consumption of the lightbulb in my garage. It is apples-to-oranges to compare a payment network to a video streaming platform, the only useful comparison is to another payment network.
- kodah 4y ago
- bobthepanda 4y agoHong Kong may not be a great place to invest long term given that China has a far more precarious legal system and is willing to override Hong Kong’s on a whim.
- nostrademons 4y agoFor a technology that seeks to replace the legal & financial system, this is the perfect place to invest. It's like how Uber couldn't have gotten started anywhere other than SF, because the transportation system there is so bad that people will hop into cars with strangers instead. You don't found a startup in places where your competition is strong, you found it in places where it's nonexistent.
- bobthepanda 4y agoHK is a fairly mature financial sector (HSBC is literally HongKong and Shanghai Banking Corporation) and is also well integrated into both Chinese and international financial systems, I would hardly call the competition “nonexistent.” HKD is probably the largest dollar peg. The legal system also exists; it’s British-descended common law unless the CCP decides to use its authoritarian instinct.
- bandrami 4y ago> hop into cars with strangers instead I'm pretty sure every city has taxis?
- LapsangGuzzler 4y agoAfter the collapse of Silvergate and Signature, I say “let them have it”. The crypto industry may be adept at moving across borders, but so are seasoned criminals. That shouldn’t automatically qualify them to operate with impunity. Millions of people lost savings in the wake of FTX, and we’re all just supposed to pretend that it was some singular, isolated incident? Their name was on an NBA arena, they spent millions on celebrity endorsements and ads, and were touted among what many consider to be one of the top tier venture firms in the world. The SEC had every right do this.
- PretzelPirate 4y ago> Millions of people lost savings in the wake of FTX, FTX...which was a regulated exchange in the US and failed because the SEC wasn't regulating. The issue with expanding the SEC's reach is that they're refusing to do their job and they're asking for more work that they aren't going to do. Commissioner Hester Peirce has a great statement on this: https://www.sec.gov/news/statement/peirce-rendering-inovation-2023-04-12 https://www.sec.gov/news/statement/peirce-rendering-inovatio... We also see this statement in the article: > The officials estimated about dozen crypto firms would fall under the expanded definition, but declined to provide any more specifics about which firms. Which means that the SEC isn't creating clarity about their proposed changes and the effects that they will have. They need to create clarity before asking the public to comment on something. If the SEC had been doing their job all this time and regulating the industry which they claim falls under their jurisdiction, people probably would have been saved from a lot of scams and loss of assets while still enabling blockchain products to be built by people who enjoy working on them.
- zefalt 4y agoPretty sure FTX was not a US corporation and catered to non-US customers. FTX.us, which was a minor branch that catered to US customers, was thought to be relatively solvent but ultimately collapsed like most things associated with FTX. Not saying that the SEC would have prevented anything in the fallout, but blaming them for failing to regulate seems somewhat incorrect. Though, I am unclear why FTX filed bankruptcy in Delaware. Someone please correct me if I'm wrong.
- Gigachad 4y agoNot sure why the SEC would care if people from other countries are being scammed. As long as the local citizens are protected.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- 3dfan 4y agoCan't decentralized exchanges be completely anonymous? If a user sends some ETH to an adress and on some Bitcoin address a balance shows up - how would the SEC want to regulate that? Let alone exchanges that are just a contract on Ethereum and only exchange tokens on the Etherum blockchain. What is the SEC going to do about those? And what would happen if some country in the world tokenizes their property. Say a certain token on the Ethereum blockchain means ownership in a company in Sweden. What if a US citizen buys such a token by sending ETH to a smart contract? So many questions. Shouldn't these have been kinda answered already in regards to international exchanges? What if a US citizen buys stock on the Euronext Paris, the French stock exchange? Would the Euronext Paris have to be registered with the SEC? What if they are not? Are they committing a crime in the eyes of the SEC?
- LapsangGuzzler 4y agoNot really, because the major service that exchanges provide is to convert between crypto and cash. The tremendous growth seen in the industry over the last few years was fueled by an influx of cash into the crypto markets by way of exchanges. Dealing in cash means managing some sort of bank or brokerage account, which falls under federal purview.
- charcircuit 4y agoDeFi platforms do not deal with cash. Everything has to be on chain.
- bfung 4y agoSo how does one get a token on one of these platforms? I certainly won’t pay cash for a token!
- charcircuit 4y agoYou get a token by swapping other tokens you already have. If you don't have any tokens and don't wasn't to bup tokens for cash than you can enter give aways, or work for someone willing to pay you with tokens.
- charcircuit 4y agoWhat do they mean? Is Ethereum itself an exchange or would a website like https://app.1inch.io https://app.1inch.io be considered the exchange? Or would 1inch itself be the exchange and holders of 1INCH be responsible for it? It makes little sense.
- Cypher 4y agoEverything is an exchange a security and rules are for our safety, eat ya bugs, stay in doors and take your vax
- rkagerer 4y agoLet alone exchanges that are just a contract on Ethereum and only exchange tokens on the Etherum blockchain. What is the SEC going to do about those? EthetDelta was exactly this, and they went after the guy that maintained the contract (plus in this case some ancillary order book matching servers). You need fully decentralized right up to governance. Those aren't viewed as favorably by regulators.