7 ms·
European privacy watchdog creates ChatGPT task force
- kneebonian 4y agoEverytime I see someone created a "task force" I can't help but cyncially think of Yes Minister and "The best run hospital in the city". Maybe I'm wrong in this case, but it often seems a task force is always used as a substitute for doing something For those wanting a laugh or a cry, I present "The best run hospital in the city" https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=x-5zEb1oS9A https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=x-5zEb1oS9A
- lcnPylGDnU4H9OF 4y ago> "task force" I always take it as PR-speak for "they want to appear to understand there's a problem" which may or may not be because they want to take action against a potential problem. Maybe I'm a bit too cynical but to me it's hot air until they do something.
- j_crick 4y agoSo much new legislation to write, so many budgets to allocate. Party hard!
- Varqu 4y agoWith all the EU initiatives, one can see that some ideas make sense (securing privacy, regulating tech monopolies), but once it gets into legislations it ends up with monsters like the cookie banner or GDPR. In the end it doesn't do what it was meant for but still remains a pain in the a*.
- Nextgrid 4y agoThey focus on ChatGPT while conveniently ignoring the elephant in the room, aka Facebook who is still in blatant breach of the GDPR 5 years after it went into effect...
- lmkg 4y agoFacebook has received 4 of the 5 largest GDPR fines to date. I would call that the opposite of ignoring them.
- Nextgrid 4y agoFacebook has been getting preferential treatment by the corrupt Irish DPA: https://noyb.eu/en/irish-data-protection-authority-gives-eu-397-billion-present-meta https://noyb.eu/en/irish-data-protection-authority-gives-eu-... Not to mention, whatever fines they got, they still aren't enough to change their behavior, because their GDPR breaches continue as we speak.
- rvnx 4y agoPlease don't kill our precious elephant who gave us one great privacy-preserving LLM; the one that can run locally :)
- warning26 4y agoIf they actually had the courage to release the model without a bunch of strings attached I'd have a lot more respect for them.
- satvikpendem 4y agoThere are a lot of locally run LLMs, LLaMA is not the only one; GPT4All, Pythia, OpenAssistant, and the new Databricks Dolly 2 can all run locally.
- cscurmudgeon 4y agoThey have been exceptionally soft on TikTok till very recently. https://www.cnbc.com/2023/01/30/tiktok-in-europes-crosshairs-as-us-mulls-ban-on-chinese-owned-app.html https://www.cnbc.com/2023/01/30/tiktok-in-europes-crosshairs... > “There is no political demand for investigation into Chinese entities,” Hosuk Lee-Makiyama, the director of think tank the European Centre for International Political Economy, said in an interview in December. > “The user base of TikTok is a lot bigger than a lot of people in Europe think,” he said. But, he added, “you’re not going to look very closely if they don’t steal too much from your ad revenue.”
- nemo44x 4y agoTask Force O ChatGPT, of Western birth, The EU turns to gauge your worth; With rules and laws, they shape and mold, And from your gains, their funds take hold. To Brussels' halls, the wealth is sent, For bureaucracies, their prime intent; Yet questions linger, doubts arise, Of Europe's own inventive guise. Why cannot they, with history grand, Forge tech like that from Freedom's land? While they prescribe and regulate, Do seeds of innovation wait? O ChatGPT, a paradox, Regulation's key unlocks; But in the Old World's prudent stance, Can brilliance find its chance to dance?
- 29athrowaway 4y agoThey just want to collect a large amount of money and then call it a day. Then wait a few more months and do it again. It is just extortion but legal and with a few extra steps.
- Nextgrid 4y agoI don't think it's just a money grab operation, or at least not from an EU-wide perspective. If they were after money, there is an endless supply of GDPR offenders, some very big ones with deep pockets and blatant, obvious breaches that can't be denied/explained away. It is incompetence coupled with individual greed - some people involved want a project to make themselves feel important and justify salaries/promotions while not doing anything meaningful for the privacy of Europeans (as mentioned above, there are much bigger fish to fry than ChatGPT). Not to mention, OpenAI's potential breaches of the GDPR aren't as clear-cut as some others, so this guarantees years of salaries, while an open and shut case may only yield months of salaries as the outcome is reached pretty quickly.
- jacquesm 4y agoThe EU privacy watchdog is doing its work in a pretty measured way, and has broad support among the population, at least the segment that I'm aware of. They stand between us and various companies that use our data for purposes never intended when the data was shared. The industry has had more than two decades to self regulate but instead of putting on the brakes it turned into an arms race, and the only way to stop that is to have a referee and an level playing field. If you see them as 'extortionists' then more than likely you would be on the wrong side of the line when it comes to using your users data. They do not and have never fined companies without first giving them more than one option to back down on abuse of data subjects data. I know that regulation is anathema to industry but some regulation we apparently can't do without. And even today there are still plenty of bad actors but I sincerely hope that one of these days one of them will be regulated out of business and then maybe the rest of the cowboys will realize that at least in one part of the world you need to play nice or you get thrown out. Could they do a better job? Yes, absolutely. But that would mean more, regulation, much more in fact. If my experience is any guide then even today there are still lots and lots of companies that break the law with impunity simply because they can and there isn't enough personnel to deal with it all. But personally I'm pretty happy that they've done what they have done so far, you can really see the difference between before and after.
- iacomus 4y agoThey will likely write the new legislation using ChatGPT built in to MS Word
- thomastjeffery 4y agoWhat is the concern? Is it that the training corpus may contain private info? I think that's pretty valid, but what data is being used that isn't already publicly available? If private info is publicly available, then maybe we should put our effort into resolving that. Is it that user dialogue prompts are being saved into the model (effectively saving them into the training corpus)? Is OpenAI being upfront about that, and clearly expressing the privacy implications to its users? If they are not, and we know it, then why do we need a "task force"?
- simion314 4y agoThis all started because there was a big data leak and OpenAI did not follow the laws related to that. I think they need to investigate if the existing laws related to privacy and children are respected.
- dmix 4y agoI'm guessing this is in regards to the history sidebar leak? > which allowed some users to see snippets of others' conversations — not the full contents, but recent titles https://www.theregister.com/2023/03/23/openai_ceo_leak/ https://www.theregister.com/2023/03/23/openai_ceo_leak/ Which laws did they break?
- simion314 4y agoIf I am not wrong they have to announce to the authorities and customers the issue. OpenAI kept it quiet, not sure if they admitted anything yet, I got not email for sure to let me know that my data might have been leaked.
- nickthegreek 4y agothey released info on it the same week. https://openai.com/blog/march-20-chatgpt-outage https://openai.com/blog/march-20-chatgpt-outage If leaking the titles of other people's searches is illegal... I'm very much interested in how the EU is going to handle the twitter circles issue.
- seydor 4y agoMore committees great
- numbers_guy 4y agoMeanwhile, where are all the ChatGPT competitors of EU origin? I feel ashamed to live on this side of the Atlantic, sometimes.
- bjornsing 4y agoMe too. And it’s a more and more common feeling.
- sjaak 4y agoDon't be; look up some of the founders[1] of OpenAI: Ilya Sutskever - born in Russia Wojciech Zaremba - born in Poland Andrej Karpathy - born in Slovakia [1] according to wikipedia
- numbers_guy 4y agoThat makes me feel even more ashamed and disappointed.
- rapsey 4y agoThat just makes it sadder. European talent and knowledge, monetized by the US. Unfortunately the European economic order is incompatible with this kind of startup. We do not have the capital to fund it, because we do not have public markets as developed.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- pjmlp 4y agoThankfully we also don't have the mentally that anything less than 60h per week, and no time off, is not being committed enough.
- whiplash451 4y agoOP wants a company built and HQ’ed in EU, not a beautiful exposition of brain drain
- spaceman_2020 4y agoThe last time they came up with a regulation, we got that GDPR awfulness. Made zero impact on anything, just forced me to click multiple buttons before visiting a website.
- Archipelagia 4y agoYeah, the annoying notifications are the visible part... but as far as I know, GDPR has a pretty serious impact if you're European. It allows you to ask private companies to delete your data, which to me seems like a pretty huge privacy win. Implementation could definitely be a lot better, but I think it protects Europe from the privacy hellscape that's currently happening in the US.
- jacquesm 4y agoThe 'annoying notifications' are corporate choices that reflect on the companies that create them, not on the GDPR.
- jacquesm 4y agoThe GDPR is anything but awful. For all I care they really clamp down on the next batch of violators, the law definitely has enough provisions to do that.
- ben_w 4y agoSo far as I'm concerned, the only single thing wrong with the legislation is that all the companies reacted to it by deciding to do whatever it took to keep collecting data they didn't strictly need. Well, almost all. GitHub doesn't show you that popup, because it doesn't collect unnecessary data. Neither does Hacker News.
- WastingMyTime89 4y agoThe GDPR is a very good piece of legislation. I fail to see where the awfulness is. Even if you discount the very significant new rights it gave to users, it did force all companies to actually think and take responsibility for what they collect. It’s a massive improvement from what was happening before.
- UncleOxidant 4y agoI don't get the calls to ban LLM chatbots due to privacy concerns. Haven't people been asking the search engines pretty much the same stuff for years now?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- maebert 4y agoMost comments here seem to be missing the legal conundrum that European countries, especially Germany find themselves in. Germany and to some extend the EU guarantees the “right to be forgotten”, ie. You can request that a company deletes all data tied to your person. However, with LLMs this is technically simply not possible. While that particular issue hasn’t come up in court yet, this is where that whole ill-advised ban is heading. I for one support the right to be forgotten, but not at the cost of shutting down innovation. We need a “do not encode” flag on content similar to a “do not track” header. Not all companies will respect that, but it might pave the way for AI companies to work with strict EU privacy laws.
- 0xDEF 4y agoThis will result in more legislation like GDPR. GDPR and other EU privacy/safety regulations are good in principle but the task of auditing software for compliancy is going to lawyers, accountants (auditors), and business consultants. Is it because they are cheaper than developers? Not really, in most of Western Europe these people make the same or more than software developers. So we now have nore non-tech people deciding what tech people can do and not do. Completely ridiculous.
- snowpid 4y ago- German company Aleph Alpha creates LLMs for commercial usage - LAION (German organisation) published open assistant - Stable Diffusion was developed in Germany.