11 ms·
U.S. proposes 56% vehicle emissions cut by 2032, requiring big EV jump
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- riffic 4y agomake smaller cars getting more people on electric scooters would do a lot of good too, if there was safe infrastructure to ride without getting hit by an oversized pickup. The city of Paris is doing the right thing here: https://www.forbes.com/sites/carltonreid/2020/10/20/paris-mayor-anne-hidalgo-to-make-good-on-pledge-to-remove-half-of-citys-car-parking-spaces/amp/ https://www.forbes.com/sites/carltonreid/2020/10/20/paris-ma...
- ARandomerDude 4y agoThe problem with these solutions is they always ignore one major detail: families. It's pretty hard to pack your kids and groceries into a tiny car or on a scooter. Encouraging tiny cars for the masses may also encourage a Japan-style demographic time-bomb.
- m4rtink 4y agoFamilies cant travel by train/bus/tram ?
- theGnuMe 4y agoThat's a leap!
- dpkirchner 4y agoThe solutions don't need to address every use case or family size -- smaller vehicles could work very well for commuters, that's enough to make a dent in emissions.
- sublinear 4y agoWhat happens when the bigger family vehicle inevitably crashes into people on their scooters? Just trading one problem for another.
- adgjlsfhk1 4y agobuild better infrastructure. cars hitting bikes/scooters/pedestrians happens because you don't have good separation. Better bike lanes and road design do a lot to reduce accidents (see the Netherlands for examples on how to do this).
- riffic 4y agoread A Pattern Language. families can get by when we stop doing development around anti-patterns that have the inconvenient external cost of burning up the planet.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- rqtwteye 4y ago"Encouraging tiny cars for the masses may also encourage a Japan-style demographic time-bomb." This needs some explaining.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- yamtaddle 4y agoI've known people from whom the "have a 3rd kid, or stop at 2?" question probably was tipped over to "stop at 2" by the cost and hassle of having to buy a bigger car to comfortably & safely fit 3 car seats, on top of all the other painfully-high expenses of having a kid. And I've repeatedly heard needing to get a minivan or largish SUV mentioned in conversations about whether to have more than 3 kids, as a downside to going higher. I'd absolutely believe that car-dependence has played some measurable role in suppressing birthrates, by causing step increases in transportation costs at certain counts of kids. 1 or 2 is no problem with almost any car, but 3 means at least a large sedan, and 4-5 means a van or SUV. More than 5 and you're looking at a fullsize van or a minivan with dual bench seats or something.
- SECProto 4y agoOne thing I loved living in Japan was availability of minivans that were actually small. The Toyota Sienta (note: not sienna) had 7 seats while being built on the Vitz (Yaris) platform. 3 feet shorter than a north american minivan, a foot narrower, and an engine roughly half the displacement (but still could go highway speeds without issue). I would happily upgrade from a small hatchback to one of those.
- yamtaddle 4y agoYeah, such cars are hard to find in the US and I'd hesitate to buy one, personally, given the ever-increasing size and weight of the average car on the road, mostly from trucks and SUVs. I don't want to pack my family into a car with little crumple-room and low weight, on American highways. Cracking this chicken-egg will require forcing huge-ass vehicle ownership down first, and good luck with that in the US. :-(
- local_crmdgeon 4y agoI use public transit, a bike, and I haul my family in a GMC Sierra. Most of the time, bikes are better. Sometimes, I use the truck. We shouldn't require use of the truck, which we do in 95% of the urban areas of this country. I'd rather just put my kid on a bike like they do in NL.
- kizunajp 4y agoTying small cars to demographic might be a bit of a stretch. Small cars are an effect of the demographics and environment, not the other way round.
- maherbeg 4y agoI'm a huge fan of the 15 minute city. It's a bit hard to retrofit that into existing sprawling cities. One avenue I'm excited about in places like Austin is building dense mixed use development areas like https://brodieoaksredevelopment.com/ https://brodieoaksredevelopment.com/ which turns a massive strip mall into a much denser area as a destination. This then makes it feasible to build public transit between these areas and start building things up along those transit lines.
- panick21_ 4y agoUS cities are so absurdly overbuilt that it's actually much easier to add bike lines, protected intersections and bus lanes.
- SECProto 4y ago> The city of Paris is doing the right thing here Note that your source is very outdated. Paris just opted to ban electric rental scooters effective September. https://www.reuters.com/world/europe/parisians-vote-ban-e-scooters-french-capital-2023-04-02/ https://www.reuters.com/world/europe/parisians-vote-ban-e-sc...
- walthamstow 4y agoOnly rentals though, private ones are still fine I think. When someone personally owns an object, it's far less likely to be found laying across a public footpath or at the bottom of a canal.
- rqtwteye 4y agoA lot of commuting could be done on e-bikes. They are fantastic.
- bryanlarsen 4y agoThese regulations should result in a lot of smaller cars. The easiest way for a manufacturer to get the fleet average down is to build and incentivize the sale of small EV's, because they will bring the fleet average down a lot more than a Hummer EV which has a horrible MPGe. Assuming of course they are successful in closing the truck loophole. They claim to be trying to close it, but time will tell.
- QuarterReptile 4y agoDo they need to sell the efficient vehicles, or just offer them?
- jwcooper 4y agoSmall cars already exist. The Chevy Bolt, Nissan Leaf, Tesla Model 3 are small EVs for USA standards. VW Golf, Mini Cooper, Mazda 3, Kia Rio are more examples of smaller cars. They're just not as popular as SUVs and trucks in the USA. People want big cars, so companies manufacture big cars too. Electric scooters would work for 5 months of the year where I live (and we have and use them when we can).
- SV_BubbleTime 4y ago>make smaller cars I am an automotive EE that was on before 2008… there is no much irony in your post that hurt feelings by Californians be damned I’m going to explain it to you. Thank Obama for large cars. When he came in and you saw the “all cars will have xx MPG by 2025” or whatever year seemed like a lifetime away, the car mfgs said ”ok, but unless you reinvent the stoichiometric ratios of gasoline, this can’t be done”. And they were right. There are some truths to ICE vehicles that until we have drastically different tires, and roads, and aluminum or composites are way cheaper (the latter not recyclable at all btw), some of these climate change proposals and dreams are just PR bullshit for the people that want to see it. Now… what happened next was the car manufacturers explained, they came to a compromise. Between CARB and CAFE and NITSA and etc, the administration agreed that they would judge on footprint of vehicle. Actual quote from one of these closed doors discussions: ”If you are going to grade us on footprint, we’re going to give you footprint”. A single car going down the road today in CAFE eyes, is not one car. It might be 1.3 cars, because its footprint is 1.3x a 2008 comparable vehicle. It’s not just footprint though! It’s drivetrain, weight, exemptions, regulation workarounds, class. Chrysler, erm Fiat, erm Stellanis sell Jeep Wranglers 2dr electrics, so they can sell more diesel trucks. Among 20 other examples. I don’t know the future with what is about to happen here. But I FUCKING PROMISE YOU this isn’t what it seems and the Biden Admin knows it already. If I had to guess, I would expect the mfgs to push a lot of basically disposable EVs that will last 50k miles and have batteries destined for landfills to make up for the vehicles they want to sell. Recycling lithium is not currently cheaper than mining new, and I do not expect that to change soon. If you ask me, I would rather a steel car that lasts 300k be made over vehicles that won’t make it to 100k and are just trashed. But… I don’t get a say. EDIT: As a nearly non-sequitur anecdote, I did cause a guy recently to have an ideological breakdown. He is a city planner complaining that a 9’x20’ parking space is killing him, and cars are only getting larger. I explained in detail the history and he had a lot of trouble coming to terms with it. He thought “his side” could do bo wrong.
- panick21_ 4y agoIt's nonsense that batteries die after 100k and also totally wrong that they end up in landfills. Car batteries have high reuse value for letting lots of us cases. Recycling is irrelevant because the amount of batteries going offline is a tiny pitence compared to what is produced knew. There are actually not enough batteries for all the companies wanting to do recycling. Eventually recycling will make sense but it will be quite a while from now. You assertion that all EV fail after 50k is disproved by ever analysis on repair cost. But you are right lobbying and bad choices led to larger cars. However the solution was to force those under the same law and only allow very targeted exception with special licences.
- Glench 4y agoyay :D
- Justsignedup 4y agoyeah, im pretty sure the US can cut a lot of emissions by making any car with an average fuel economy of under 25mpg considered a truck for license purposes (which includes training). Boom. So far I bought a small suv because there were pretty much no other options on the market. Even Ford Mustangs are now SUVs.
- neogodless 4y agoBut you are aware only the all-electric Mach-E version of the Mustang is an SUV and uses 0 gallons of gas per mile?
- Justsignedup 4y agoIndeed I am, but the US obsession with SUVs is a bit insane. Like what is even the point of a mustang SUV?
- bryanmgreen 4y agoI am working on research towards the goal of introducing strict federal weight penalties for consumer vehicles. Cars are simply massively overbuilt for their average use case. Reducing weight of vehicles is a very achievable goal that will cut emissions dramatically while also having additional benefits like global supply chain material and emission reduction, pedestrian safety, and road maintenance. If you are involved in automotive, environmental, political spaces - or know someone who is - please reach out, email in bio.
- ajross 4y agoNaively that's going to end up disproportionately penalizing EVs[1], which sounds exactly backwards to me. "Weight" is not the correct factor to optimize, basically. [1] Which are heavy, because they can't source 2/3 of their reaction mass from the atmosphere and have to keep all the reactants in the battery at all time.
- troutwine 4y ago> "Weight" is not the correct factor to optimize, basically. Is it not? Particular matter from tires is a major factor in air pollution and the heavier the vehicle the more that ramps up.
- ajross 4y agoAbsent numbers, I'm gonna go with "Mass-dependent increase in tire-derived particular air pollution" isn't the right factor to optimize either.
- calvinmorrison 4y agoIts not just tire pollution but road wear
- troutwine 4y agoAlright? It's not clear by implication what you actually do want to optimize for but the weight/particulate problem is a fairly well-known problem. For instance, from the California Air Resources Board: https://ww2.arb.ca.gov/resources/documents/brake-tire-wear-emissions https://ww2.arb.ca.gov/resources/documents/brake-tire-wear-e... It's something the tire industry has been fretting over for a while: https://www.tiretechnologyinternational.com/news/regulations/pollution-from-tire-wear-1000-times-worse-than-exhaust-emissions.html https://www.tiretechnologyinternational.com/news/regulations...
- 35208654 4y agoI’m a huge EV fan. My family has owned four over the past 6 years. That pedigree out of the way, I’ll give my cynical take: this will get rolled back by President DeSantis in a hot fucking minute.
- mint2 4y ago“In a hot fucking minute” Which is why his attempt will be thrown out in court. Making changes to regs likes these requires bureaucratic paperwork or they get thrown out like many of 45s rushed regulation reversals did.
- Spivak 4y agoI mean this sincerely because I don't get it -- even if you're a republican DeSantis is batshit insane and is arguably closer to neo-fascism than Republican. What's the draw? Like even if I liked the policy changes he's proposing I would be wary of him being the one to make them since he seems to give zero fucks about the democratic process or procedure if it gets in his way. Once you break the glass and people don't accept democratic results or don't believe it matters I don't see us repairing it.
- abhayhegde 4y agoI wonder what this means for net zero carbon emissions though. The target date set by US is 2050.
- davidw 4y agoWe got an eBike a year ago, and have put nearly 1500 miles on it. We took our kids to school with it for a while (we moved away from the area their schools were in), and I regularly do grocery shopping for our family of 4. I am pretty comfortable getting around on a regular bike, but the eBike is really a game-changer. If it's hot out, I can use more assist and not show up sweaty. If it's cold and/or wet, I can layer with pretty thick gear and not worry about being hot/sweaty, for the same reason.
- bdcravens 4y agoWhat part of the world are you in? In hot humid areas like Houston, you'd break out in a sweat just sitting stationary.
- davidw 4y agoOregon east of the Cascades. If you use a lot of pedal assist you actually get a lot of air rushing by you without too much effort: it's nicer than hopping in a hot car.
- timbit42 4y agoWe'd be better off moving away from areas where it is so hot that it requires a lot of energy to stay cool, also areas where it is so cold that it requires a lot of energy to stay warm.
- einpoklum 4y agoSo, US proposes to basically do nothing and hope that technology will improve its emissions to something that's not remotely tolerable. That Biden sure is a epic leader.
- bryanlarsen 4y agoVery similar rules work in Europe.
- bdcravens 4y agoCurrent projections show half of new cars being EVs by 2035; this proposal is only adding mild optimism.
- hardtke 4y agoMy brother is a contractor in the Bay Area and he told me that PG&E will not allow the installation of 220 volt EV charging infrastructure in new construction or a home remodel unless the homeowner can prove they already own an EV. Add to that the issue of people who live in apartment buildings and condos and I don't see how we can scale up consumer demand quickly enough.
- QuarterReptile 4y agoDo you know what the story is with that prerequisite? Speaking for literally everyone, I'd rather have charging infrastructure I can't utilize quite yet than a car I can't charge to use quite yet.
- hardtke 4y agoNot directly related to cars, but PG&E is unable to handle the incoming requests for electrical system upgrades[1]. Many older houses don't have the electrical panel capacity and they need engineering signoff from the utility. [1] https://www.sfchronicle.com/bayarea/article/home-pge-electric-upgrade-17832767.php https://www.sfchronicle.com/bayarea/article/home-pge-electri...
- mike50 4y agoSubject and writer are idiots. Any electrician worth their master license would not have installed a 125A panel in 2019 unless this woman lives in a converted cottage. Also unless this woman is running a grow house or has a 4000 square foot home they intend to heat with resistive heating she will never use 300A service.
- KingMachiavelli 4y agoHow does PG&E have the authority to regulate the instalation of EV charging? Do you mean they won't install a higher amp service panel like 200A instead of 150A? If that's the case, it's not that crazy or unusual. While you used to be able to pay to upgrade your service panel, if everyone on the same block or segment of the grid all wants the higher service panel then it will require upgrades to the existing electrical lines and sub stations. It makes a lot of sense to limit installing larger service panels to customers who will actual use it rather than haphazardly over provision the grid. But you can still easily charge an EV at 50A on a standard 150A or even 100A panel.
- nikanj 4y agoMy biggest shock: they included trucks. For the past many years, the restrictions on cars have been tightening, but everyone drives a truck that’s exempt from the requirements
- bdcravens 4y agoIn many areas as many people drive trucks for personal vehicles as cars, so that would create a loophole so big you could drive a ... well, you know.
- hdhuegau6hfhd 4y agoEh. And who will suffer? Poor people. Why? 'Drive a bus', that is why is the gist of reasoning here. Naturally, upper income and wealthy individuals will still drive crazy toys, but that is ok.
- bdcravens 4y agoThese requirements apply to new vehicles. Most poor don't buy new, and if they do, there are vehicles like the Bolt that are cheaper than your typical new SUV. Presumably the market will respond with options, similar to how in 2008 the poor couldn't afford smartphones. Additionally, the cost of "fuel" to go 300 miles is roughly $10-15 for EVs versus $40-50 for gas (assuming an efficient 4 cylinder), along with eliminating costs for 2-3 oil changes every year.
- hdhuegau6hfhd 4y agoAnd presumably those same people will charge it.. where? where is infrastructure and please dont say presumably -Most poor don't buy new, and if they do, there are vehicles like the Bolt that are cheaper than your typical new SUV on avg. poor people buy cheap, because it is what they can afford. iirc, bolt is not as available as it used to be. plus, even after incentives evs are not cheap - Presumably the market will respond with options, similar to how in 2008 the poor couldn't afford smartphone great. we will throw away working system for presumably great system. presumably, the poor will get to drive a golf cart ewuivalent that requires iris and palm scan for 'helping improve customer experience' -along with eliminating costs for 2-3 oil changes every year. yeah.. because its the oil change that is killing me and not thousands for new battery
- bdcravens 4y ago> where is infrastructure and please dont say presumably Just look at the infrastructure 5 years ago and extrapolate where it will be going. Walmart, a staple of the poor, has announced plans to expand its EV charging footprint. https://www.axios.com/2023/04/10/walmart-ev-fast-charging-electric-cars https://www.axios.com/2023/04/10/walmart-ev-fast-charging-el... > a golf cart ewuivalent that requires iris and palm scan for 'helping improve customer experience' My wife and I drive EVs that we get in, press a button, and it starts, similar to our previous ICE vehicles. > because its the oil change that is killing me and not thousands for new battery My Kia has a 10 year/100k warranty that includes the battery. Also, Nissan, which has some of the oldest mainstream EVs still on the road, said they are seeing very low failure rates, often outlasting the car itself. https://cleantechnica.com/2022/09/21/surprise-nissan-leaf-batteries-last-much-longer-than-expected/ https://cleantechnica.com/2022/09/21/surprise-nissan-leaf-ba...
- cpascal 4y agoI really want an EV, but they don't work for me. I live in an urban area and park on a city street. EV ownership would add a lot of complications to my life due to the current state of charging infrastructure. I think EV adoption will eventually plateau until we solve overnight charging for cars parked on city streets or there is a large increase in rapid charging availability and speed.
- ambicapter 4y agochicken and egg problem, there won't be a need for increased charging infrastructure until there are more EVs on the road.
- tablespoon 4y ago> chicken and egg problem, there won't be a need for increased charging infrastructure until there are more EVs on the road. Which we don't have the electricity infrastructure for. The solution is to get rid of cars, period. Ownership should require a permit like gun ownership requires in some cities (i.e you should only be able to buy one of the DMV agrees you have good reason to need a car).
- dang 4y agoCan you please stop posting ideological flamebait to HN? You've unfortunately been doing it a lot lately. It's not what this site is for, and destroys what it is for. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- bdcravens 4y agoFor many, a 30-minute charge once a week is more than adequate. I assume you don't have a gas pump at your parking spot on the street. > EV adoption will eventually plateau until we solve overnight charging for cars parked on city streets In the US there are 140 million homes and 3 million EVs. Not to diminish your needs, but there's a lot of low-hanging fruit there.
- PeterStuer 4y agoHow sure are we there will not be some accounting shenanigans allowing you to offset your rolling coal fleet with some paper certificates scheme that assures you might have cut down some rainforest but didn't.
- wmf 4y agoAfter decades of SUV loopholes, why would the EPA about-face now? Is there any chance this will actually happen?
- panick21_ 4y agoIf they really wanted to cut, emissions bycicles and trains are the way to do it.
- tablespoon 4y ago> If they really wanted to cut, emissions bycicles and trains are the way to do it. Exactly, what we really need to do is have a restrictive permitting system for cars like some cities have for guns. If you can't show good cause for needing a car, you shouldn't be able to get permit to buy one. Just use public transit or bike.
- timcavel 4y ago[dead]