4 ms·
I'm seeing a lot of hysteria in response to this random tweet by the Denver FBI's social media person. Do we know of a single real-world use of this hypothetic
by CharlesW 4y ago
I'm seeing a lot of hysteria in response to this random tweet by the Denver FBI's social media person.
Do we know of a single real-world use of this hypothetical exploit? Do we know that iOS's (and presumably Android's) protection against untrusted device access isn't enough?
- WakoMan12 4y ago[dead]
- enguinq123 4y agoAnecdotally, I have had a previous iphone infected by using a public charging station at SFO a few years ago.
- ghostpepper 4y agoCan you elaborate on this? What kind of phone? Android or iOS? Fully patched? What kind of infection? How did you discover it? How did you get rid of it?
- kevviiinn 4y agoI bet their iphone was running android
- Alupis 4y agoThere have been many jailbreaks available that only required plugging the phone in and running some program on the other end of the cable. There's been jailbreaks where all you needed to do was visit a website... Apple's security isn't as bullet-proof as some make it out to be. So, is it plausible a malicious charging station could gain root and sideload something nefarious on an iPhone? Absolutely. Particularly for non-tech-savvy folks desperate to get a charge before their connecting flight... Has it happened? ...No idea. I guess that's where the anecdotes come in...
- kevviiinn 4y agoMy point was that the person who made the comment stating that they had an iPhone, the person I'm replying to went on to ask them if they had iOS or android
- Alupis 4y agoGood point, I missed that bit upstream. My general point about how easy it can be to maliciously root someone's device stands, so I will leave my comment as-is. Folks - don't plug your devices into untrusted USB ports...
- ghostpepper 4y agoIt’s been many years since I rooted (or even owned) an android phone but is there really no interaction from the user required beyond plugging it in? On iOS there’s a pop up asking if you want to trust the computer, and that’s after you’ve unlocked the screen
- kevviiinn 4y agoUsually it requires enabling developer mode and enabling USB adb
- Alupis 4y agoFor a non-techy, the hurdles you just described are an annoyance in the way of getting a quick charge - not obvious security issues. After all, this charging station is operated by the amusement park/airport/conference/whatever... if it asks you to approve it why not? And yes, in the past many iOS jailbreaks were shockingly simple. The website one in particular - you went to a URL and clicked a button... your phone rebooted and was jailbroken.
- Tagbert 4y agodid you have to say yes to the “trust this computer” question to enable data exchange?
- Alupis 4y agoYour non-tech-savvy folks will pound through nearly any popup if they are desperate to get a charge before their connecting flight, for instance. The popup really should be a toggle somewhere in the settings that forces a user to explicitly enable data - not a popup users are mostly self-trained into ignoring. Additionally, real charging stations should not offer cables with data lines at all.
- rsync 4y agoYou’re going to need to elaborate here … that’s genuinely interesting if true … More details?
- l33t233372 4y agoI think I recall such a thing happening at DEFCON. It was either that or USB sticks being handed out.
- _fat_santa 4y agoIt just doesn't seem like a plausible hack when you take in all the circumstances that have to line up correctly: 1. The station has to be using USB Ports / Charging cables that are data enabled, not just cables that carry power 2. The hacker would need some way of injecting the malware into the charging station ports without being seen, I doubt many charging stations are internet connected so you would have to be at the device. 3. You need to have an active exploit for iOS or Android (or both) that will compromise the device and steal it's data. It just seems like alot of work for something that in all likelyhood would not work.
- pphysch 4y agoMore practically, you visit a place that has public chargers, you study them and create a compromised clone, and then you swap out the real one. Like card skimmers.
- feoren 4y agoNone of these are necessary, except half of #2. All you'd need is a "middleman" device that is subtle enough to avoid notice by the person plugging in, just like how credit card skimmers work. > 1. The station has to be using USB Ports / Charging cables that are data enabled, not just cables that carry power Doesn't matter, because you're (unwittingly) plugging into the attacker's device, not the station's. > 2. The hacker would need some way of injecting the malware into the charging station ports without being seen, I doubt many charging stations are internet connected so you would have to be at the device. You don't need to "inject" anything; you just need to physically place it between the user and the actual port and disguise it enough that people not paying attention won't notice. Or even just put a fake "charging station" in a place that the station didn't have one. > 3. You need to have an active exploit for iOS or Android (or both) that will compromise the device and steal it's data. People are plugging in their phone so they can use it. They'll plug in the phone, unlock it, and browse the internet. What can't you do in that situation?
- marcellus23 4y ago> They'll plug in the phone, unlock it, and browse the internet. iOS devices (maybe Android too, idk) ask you if you want to allow new accessories to access your device. That's why they said you need an exploit.
- marcosdumay 4y agoWe do know of shady companies that sell "own this phone" USB devices to governments, but AFAIK they only sell to governments and the details aren't available to the public. I have never heard about a non-government sponsored attacker doing that kind of thing. If this is relevant or not to you, it's a matter of your threat model. If I were a journalist, I would be very weary. Personally, I don't plug my phone on random outlets and don't plug random devices on my computers, but it's clearly an overreaction.
- tonyarkles 4y agoHeh, if I'm remembering right, a couple of years ago there was a public charging station at DEFCON that was sponsored by the NSA. I did not plug my phone into it :D
- marcosdumay 4y agoThat one became famous. It said something like "Powered by the NSA. You know you want to do it." (And no, I've never been to DEFCON. It really became famous.)
- thinkmassive 4y agoThousands of O.MG cables are out in the wild… https://shop.hak5.org/products/omg-cable https://shop.hak5.org/products/omg-cable
- CharlesW 4y agoWouldn't this be considered the same attack? Users would connect the cable, unlock their phone, and then would need to explicitly "Trust" the external device attempting to connect to their phone via USB. I suppose the difference is that people may be using the cable to connect to a device where that prompt is expected, in contrast to the "charging port in an airport" scenario where it would seem appropriately alarming.
- thinkmassive 4y agoIf the phone is unlocked, a badUSB-type device can do anything a keyboard can do, so it’s far from completely harmless.
- thrashh 4y agoUsually the risk for something like is that if there's some unexploited bug in the USB stack or the OS. Which, from what I know from writing software, I don't trust shit. I think the risk is insanely low for your average person because you'd have to use an unpatched bug on a well-supported system, you'd have to put bug a USB port in a popular place, and you'd need a reason to do all that. But at the same time, this is well in the wheelhouse and capability of some bored teen with a lot of time who wants to screw with people FWIW. You could also have fun and write a worm that infects everyone that connect to your USB port and have it DDoS a website or something. The first worms were created by bored people.