6 ms·
I hope it doesn't. Because it essentially sets us up for a repeat. If Mastodon was 'just not the thing people were looking for' then at least it solves the prob
by jacquesm 4y ago
I hope it doesn't. Because it essentially sets us up for a repeat. If Mastodon was 'just not the thing people were looking for' then at least it solves the problems that both Twitter and Substack have, which is that they are not federated. Better to fix Mastodon than to waste another decade on something that will ultimately blow up and with the way Substack has - in my head at least - been associated negatively with crap content it will probably be sooner rather than later.
- davidw 4y ago> Better to fix Mastodon Is that possible? Seems kind of difficult due to its nature, but I admit I'm just a very casual user of it and don't know much. Signed up for the Substack thing. Seems worth a look - it's very similar to Twitter.
- jeroenhd 4y agoWhat do you consider difficult about it?
- Gareth321 4y agoMastodon is never going to take off. I’ve been building SaaS applications for 15 years. I don’t think you understand the very low level of complexity required for mass adoption. Let’s just look at the signup process for a few minutes, using the UX convention of actions. Twitter: 1. Search for Twitter. 2. Click on the first link. 3. Click sign up. Mastodon: 1. Search for Mastodon. 2. Click the first link: mastodon.social. 3. Click create account. 4. Message modal pops up alerting the user that it is currently impossible to sign up to mastodon.social. But don’t worry, you can sign up on another server by clicking “Find another server.” At this point I’m confused. Why are there different servers? Will my friends be on the other server? Do we need to sign up on the same server? No explanation. I click the link. 5. Long page of options. No indication of quality or why I should choose one server over another. Now I am in choice paralysis. I click the first option (which has an anime figure on it). Surely - surely - the first option is the best option. The suggested option by whoever is running this application. 6. I land on a Korean language portal and I am done. I’m never coming back. Mastodon is dead to me. Forever. You might think this is hyperbole, but I promise you it is not. I’ve been in charge of A/B testing and UX centric development for web applications just like this for a very long time. Mastodon’s sign up process is easily one of the worst I have ever seen. Not a single UX person has been involved in the creation of this protocol.
- rybar 4y agoExcellent illustration of the awful onboarding experience. No one wants to waste their time connecting a constellation, they want to get to content as fast as possible.
- Andrex 4y agoThe fact Mastodon sites don't even load without JS is absurd, a huge not-talked-about barrier to entry (globally), and a betrayal of its "protocol-first" talking points. Until that changes Mastodon isn't trying to be a serious player.
- commoner 4y agoBrutaldon is an alternative FOSS client for Mastodon that does not use JavaScript: - Brutaldon: https://brutaldon.org https://brutaldon.org - Source: https://gitlab.com/brutaldon/brutaldon https://gitlab.com/brutaldon/brutaldon Because Mastodon has an open API, you don't need to use the official Mastodon web client. Twitter upset a lot of users when it limited access to its API because many alternative Twitter clients were rendered useless.
- IshKebab 4y agoDoes Twitter load without JavaScript? I do not think the tiny number of uber-nerds who disable JavaScript have any effect on Mastadon.
- jeroenhd 4y agoI disable Javascript on occasion to save power. Twitter definitely does not load without loading several megabytes of Javascript. Nitter.net is a quick and easy substitute that loads instantly without it, though some video playback still requires Javascript (HLS video).
- rybar 4y agoHow much power have you quantified saving by disabling JavaScript over the course of a week?
- jeroenhd 4y agoI can't do any objective measurements but there's a clear impact in battery life while browsing with Javascript disabled. The entire web becomes snappier and loading times instantly drop. Doing so also breaks all web applications (and web applications posing as websites, i.e. React rendering) so it's not something I turn on permanently. I usually only disable JS when my phone is running low and I'm not near a charger, or when I'm trying to read something and the terrible website hijacks scrolls/taps/somehow makes my phone run hot doing stuff in the background.
- Zetice 4y agoBluesky is building AT, what mastodon should have been. That will kill Twitter in a way that’s at least new. Not sure how to solve the HOA problem though…
- hackernewds 4y agoDo not trust any Jack Dorsey product anymore as the next alternative again
- Zetice 4y agoIt’s a protocol, not a product.
- sanderjd 4y agoUnfortunately, this perspective seems very head-in-a-bubble to me. It's a tiny tiny number of people who think the problem with Twitter and Substack is that they aren't federated. Federation isn't a feature people broadly care about. If it makes the platform work better, great! But I don't think that's the case for Mastodon or any other federated platform I've come across. It's the opposite, they make concessions on the experience in order to support federation. That would be ok if those sacrifices were for functionality people really want, but federation just ... isn't that.
- jeroenhd 4y agoI disagree. Federation is a feature people want, but they don't know about the concept. When I show people that I can talk to Signal, WhatsApp, and Signal through a single app, they're pretty impressed. I wouldn't expect most people to set up a Matrix bridging system like I did, same with most Mastodon servers, but it's a feature people do generally want. With Mastodon, most people first ask "but how do I follow people on Twitter", which often leads to pointing at bridges that may stop working at any point and have no official status, and often get blocked on small servers because of the overwhelming wave of moderation spam they cause. Phone manufacturers back in the day used to have quite commonly used "social hub" apps that would combine various social media sources into a single UI, but they were all tied to their own brand that either got too difficult to maintain or lost the phone wars (HTC and Blackberry had quite well-received integrations if I recall). The past years we've been stuck with a locked in ecosystem for so long that the mere idea of two different apps interoperating has become inconceivable to the mainstream. I hope the DMA, which will force messenger apps to interoperate, will bring back the knowledge that it's possible to do so at the very least.
- Ecstatify 4y agoFederation is someone doing a cool card trick at a cocktail party. Does it look cool? Yes. Is anyone going to go out and buy a deck of cards the next morning and learn how to do it? No.
- 4y ago