5 ms·
I find it hard to believe that expanding government power to put people in custody without a crime being committed is really the answer. Especially since the cu
by giantg2 4y ago
I find it hard to believe that expanding government power to put people in custody without a crime being committed is really the answer. Especially since the current laws would allow for a mandatory screening if the person commits a crime ("overt acts would almost always fall in that category or be rife for abuse). I think NY has already used mental health as an excuse to take away rights even when there was no danger to themself or others (retired NY police having firearms seized for having mild symptoms of depression with no risk of harm to themself or others).
There's a ton of background in this story, but very little about what the solution is, at least in detail.
- lotsofpulp 4y agoThe alternative to this is 3 (or whatever number) strikes type laws where successive crimes, even small ones, are punished more severely.
- giantg2 4y agoThat could be one option, but still has room for abuse. Maybe a homeless person shoplifts some candy three time. That's a felony in many states. Maybe they have a mental condition that causes them to shoplift, or maybe they were hungry. Now it's up to someone's opinion, who is likely overburdened, to decide which one it is. Either way, it's likely to result in custody, but one of those ways might involve mandated medication and a lifelong (mis)diagnosis. At least in this case it would be going through the court, and under the current laws should require some input on the part of the defendant to seek an insanity plea.
- dionidium 4y agoWe're quite literally to the point where something like a 20-strike law, which sounds like parody, would actually be quite useful.
- Red_Leaves_Flyy 4y agoSo you want to spend 60k/yr on prison times the homeless population of America? Because that’s what your comment suggests and there’s a litany of better options.
- lotsofpulp 4y agoI have yet to see a better option in action. It would be nice to have sufficient supply of quality mental healthcare and oversight to prevent abuse of involuntary committal, but as far as I see, that is a pipe dream.
- Red_Leaves_Flyy 4y agoHave we tried dragging the army Corp of engineers in to build housing? What about a national jobs guarantee? National healthcare that can’t bankrupt people? I’ve met a lot of homeless people in my life, most have no use for a counselor. They’re largely uninterested in self actualization or recovery. They want safe shelter, affordable and accessible healthcare, reliable transportation, a job they can be proud of that provides for them and their family consistently. These people are gripped by despair and acting it against society at large because society has relegated them to the fringes as useless, hopeless, and expendable. Housing, healthcare, and respect for each individual human is the minimum. Just because that won’t scale does not it can be ignored. Ignoring this is how we got here. Continue ignoring it and we’ll probably see more tech bros murdered in broad daylight. We might also see the security teams of these tech bros commit a few massacres.
- notch898b 4y agoIt does seem frighteningly easy to lose everything and be locked up. See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rosenhan_experiment https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rosenhan_experiment . After just one episode of telling professionals that they "heard voices", patients were diagnosed and forced to take medication despite never again showing symptoms or evidence of illness. Once admitted and diagnosed, the pseudopatients were not able to obtain their release until they agreed with the psychiatrists that they were mentally ill and began taking antipsychotic medications, Even if they weren't ill... the only way to get out was to lie and say they were.
- 35208654 4y agoThe Rosenhan experiment is now widely believed to have been a hoax.
- kelseyfrog 4y agoIt sounds like a great opportunity for the field to put their skin in the game and replicate it.
- throwaway646465 4y agoThis is an interesting recent addition to the Wikipedia article. From the summary: > In 2019 and 2023, historians of psychiatry published evidence that the experiment is a hoax. And following the link: > In The Great Pretender, a 2019 book on Rosenhan, author Susannah Cahalan questions the veracity and validity of the Rosenhan experiment. Examining documents left behind by Rosenhan after his death, Cahalan finds apparent distortion in the Science article: inconsistent data, misleading descriptions, and inaccurate or fabricated quotations from psychiatric records. Moreover, despite an extensive search, she is only able to identify two of the eight pseudopatients: Rosenhan himself, and a graduate student whose testimony is allegedly inconsistent with Rosenhan's description in the article. In light of Rosenhan's seeming willingness to bend the truth in other ways regarding the experiment, Cahalan questions whether some or all of the six other pseudopatients might have been simply invented by Rosenhan.[11][12] In February 2023, Andrew Scull of the University of California at San Diego published an article[13] in the peer-reviewed journal History of Psychiatry in support of Cahalan's allegations. Still - it’s scary how many rights you lose once you’ve been declared unwell. We might just want to start using more recent evidence since that experiment has come under question.
- loeg 4y agoThis concern isn’t really a problem for the homeless mentally ill that are the target of these schemes because they’re already committing small crimes all the time.
- giraffe_lady 4y agoIt's basically impossible to be homeless and not commit crimes as a matter of course, which is intentional. This will absolutely be used punitively against homeless people.
- HideousKojima 4y agoThe homeless mentally ill though, specifically, are the ones usually committing extra crimes beyond mere vagrancy and squatting. I.e. the ones taking shits on bus seats and getting into drunken fights in public.
- ada1981 4y ago[flagged]
- HideousKojima 4y agoYou're right, we can't make any efforts to make our streets safe and free of crazed, violent hobos until we've gotten rid of all polluters and warmongers first.
- giraffe_lady 4y agoSeeing now how y'all talk about homeless & mentally ill people where you think they can't see you, they are right to hate us.
- HideousKojima 4y agoIf they didn't shit on bus seats I would have no reason to talk about them shitting on bus seats.
- woeirua 4y agoI understand the civil liberties concerns, but you really want to treat severe mental illness as soon as possible. Earlier treatment is linked to better outcomes, lower costs, and a significantly higher chance of being reintegrated into society as a whole.
- luxuryballs 4y agoAnd if they don’t want to be treated?
- woeirua 4y agoNot an option because severe mental illness affects us all. We already have a similar principle for other diseases that negatively affect others, e.g. tuberculosis.
- giantg2 4y agoThose other diseases have definitive tests. Most mental disease diagnosis are based on opinion, which is more prone to mistakes, abuse, and finality. Going through the courts provides some level of safeguard at least.
- dionidium 4y agoWe're not nihilists so we treat them anyway against their will. "If the rule you followed brought you to this, of what use was the rule?"
- Red_Leaves_Flyy 4y agoNo questions asked, no strings attached treatment offered where they are is going to need to be a national reality before this is a meaningful concern. Back here in reality the real barriers to treatment are means testing, provider burnout, arbitrary rules, general inaccessibility, cost, scheduling conflicts, etc. people want to live better lives. Their definition of better may not reflect yours or others and we need to accept that if the only person that they’re hurting is themself. Anything less is more of this tired song and dance while real people suffer because rich pearl clutchers can’t handle gay trans drug users with face tattoos or whatever getting a cent of tax money so they won’t die preventable deaths.
- stainablesteel 4y agoi also find it important to note that therapy is becoming more and more a religious practice there are different flavors of therapy, and some may use more empirical methods than others, but there's a lot of infiltrating ideology and opinions that fight over what is and isn't science, and therefore what is and isn't empirical but if none of this is truly empirical, the therapeutic aspects are religious so locking people up for what are essential religious violations is way beyond illegitimate control
- bigtex88 4y agoGoing into public and throwing filth at people, accosting them, and generally endangering the safety of other citizens is implicitly a crime by virtue of "Every civilized society in the history of man has cleaned up this behavior". We don't need to wait around for a court to indict a person for "being a crazy homeless person". That's insanely reductive to the point of absurdity.
- loeg 4y ago> Going into public and throwing filth at people, accosting them, and generally endangering the safety of other citizens is implicitly a crime It's not just implicit -- assault is explicitly a crime, everywhere.
- tomjakubowski 4y ago[dead]
- giantg2 4y ago"We don't need to wait around for a court to indict a person for "being a crazy homeless person". That's insanely reductive to the point of absurdity." They would be arrested based on the crime they commit, such as assault. Then the court would make a determination on their insanity plea. Adultery and sodomy have been crimes in most civilization of history too. That doesn't mean we convict people based solely on the spirit of the law, nor ignore the principle of innocent until proven guilty.
- dragonwriter 4y ago> Going into public and throwing filth at people, accosting them, and generally endangering the safety of other citizens is implicitly a crime In the US, there is no such concept as “implicit crime”, but, yes, some of those things are just plain explicit crimes. > We don’t need to wait around for a court to indict a person for “being a crazy homeless person” If you are going to treat it as a crime, then, yes, it has all the procedural safeguards generally applicable to crime.