4 ms·
> It's why I don't understand why in the US, the president is also the top military commander. Somebody has to be in charge of the military. If that person is
by tialaramex 4y ago
> It's why I don't understand why in the US, the president is also the top military commander.
Somebody has to be in charge of the military. If that person is just someone promoted from within, you're never more than one person's decision from a coup d'etat, "A republic, if you can keep it". So, an elected leader it is.
Of the three branches of the US government, only one is intended to provide an executive function, to decide, in an instant where necessary, without deliberation and compromise. The President. So that's the right person for the job of ultimate military commander, and it's one of the few things about that job which the voters seem to actually have some idea about.
Both the US and UK systems are under-staffed. The UK shares the job of executive leader and legislative leader (very different skill sets) under one role "Prime Minister" - while the US shares the job of executive leader and head of state (a figurehead) which also require totally different skill sets under the role of "President". This would make sense with a very small population, but it's crazy to imagine these huge countries couldn't find two people to do these very different jobs even a little better than one man (and in the US it has always been a man somehow) can do both.
- eru 4y agoIn Germany the (civilian) defense minister is the head of the armed forces. (Though I think that role might go to the chancellor in times of war. Not sure.)
- Sakos 4y agoAccording to the wiki, it's the chancellor in wartime (https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bundeswehr https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bundeswehr). Either way, it's a civilian position that's temporarily filled by the ruling government which was democratically elected.
- eru 4y ago> Either way, it's a civilian position that's temporarily filled by the ruling government which was democratically elected. Yes, just like in the US. My main point was that the chancellor is not the commander in chief by default. Only under exceptional circumstances.
- Xenoamorphous 4y agoIn Spain it’s the King… anachronic af, I know.
- sofixa 4y agoIt's traditionally the head of state, so King makes sense. In Bulgaria the president is mostly a figurehead with very limited power (basically easily repeatable veto, appoint ambassadors and temporary cabinets when there's no active government pending elections), but is still the commander in chief of the armed forces.
- eru 4y agoIn Britain, you have the Royal Navy, Royal Airforce, Royal Marine, but no 'Royal Army'. That might have something to do with a leftover from the English Civil War. See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_Model_Army https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_Model_Army
- runlaszlorun 4y agoInteresting point. I never knew that.
- TheOtherHobbes 4y agoThe UK - as usual - is a patchwork of conflicting traditions. There is no Royal Army. But all members of the armed forces, police, and certain prominent political appointments, swear an Oath of Allegiance to the monarch. Note this is not to the country. And certainly not to the people. Not even to the Crown, which is a kind of abstract superclass of British monarchs in general. The Royal Navy does not have to swear this oath. It exists by direct Royal Prerogative which means it's assumed to be loyal, pretty much by definition.
- Earw0rm 4y agoThe individual regiments are very often royal titled though. "Royal Artillery", "King's Fusiliers" and so on.
- ralfd 4y agoWhat counts as "war" though? Technically every President since Roosevelt has used military force without a formal declaration of war by Congress. And modern Germany is not a military power projecting hegemon. I can't imagine a civilian defense minister (who in a coalition government maybe isn't even the party of the chancellor) is ordering politically important drone strikes like the US President. If Germany was in similar role the system would quickly evolve that the Chancellor would order the military.