3 ms·
It very much is a fallacy to attack anything outside the argument. That said while broken clock could happen to be correct, pointing out a clock is broken or s
by Retric 4y ago
It very much is a fallacy to attack anything outside the argument.
That said while broken clock could happen to be correct, pointing out a clock is broken or someone is a nutter is still useful information.
- Dylan16807 4y agoLogical fallacies undermine the argument of the person using them. How can it be a fallacy and useful information?
- Retric 4y agoYou can use imperfect information. It’s the difference between heuristics and logical arguments. Aka there’s a 1 in 500 million chance this is a winning lottery ticket is useful even if it doesn’t guarantee things one way or the other.
- Dylan16807 4y agoI don't think it's a fallacy to use imperfect information. All information is imperfect.
- Retric 4y agoUsing probabilistic logic is perfectly reasonable as long as you track the stacking likelihood it’s wrong. However, making a probabilistic argument without tracking the internal probabilities is a Fallacy. ie: Saying A which is true 90% of the time and B which is true 90% of the time so given A and B then C sounds reasonable until you continue with given C and D which is also X% true…. The individual probability that A, B, or D is wrong makes the chain of reasoning rapidly worthless. Thus the error is using probabilistic statements without acknowledging they weaken an argument.
- Dylan16807 4y agoAre you saying that "You should know A is true 90% of the time." is a fallacy unless I add an explicit disclaimer about probabilistic weakening? Even if I'm not making any conclusions based on it, just suggesting people will want to use that information themselves? If you're not saying that then I don't understand how anything you just said is relevant to the current situation. Telling people to look up a guy's writing history is probabilistic but it isn't turning that into an unjustified boolean statement.