4 ms·
> Every bank check lists the bank account number, which serves as the only information needed for a party to issue a request to withdraw money from that account
by lxgr 4y ago
> Every bank check lists the bank account number, which serves as the only information needed for a party to issue a request to withdraw money from that account.
The same principle (i.e. knowing an account number means being able to debit it) works surprisingly well in many European countries for direct debits, and the account number is considered even less of a secret than it is in the US. For example, many freelances routinely print it on their invoices sent out to clients, have it as part of their e-mail signature, or even prominently feature it on their website.
What makes it work is that, under the SEPA Direct Debit framework, the risk of fraud and insufficient funds is 100% on the party initiating the direct debit. An accountholder can literally click a button on their bank's app or website and they get the funds back immediately, no questions asked, within 8 weeks of the original debit date.
This, in turn, means that it is in the initiating party's self-interest to only accept this form of payment in high-trust situations, and not just like a low-fee replacement for credit and debit cards that shifts some amount of fraud risk to the accountholder or their bank.
- marcosdumay 4y ago> What makes it work is that, under the SEPA Direct Debit framework, the risk of fraud and insufficient funds is 100% on the party initiating the direct debit. It also helps that the accountholder has to allow each party that will debit money from their account. By default, those requests are denied. AFAIK, the US works the other way around.
- Denvercoder9 4y ago> By default, those requests are denied. This depends on your bank, mine allows them by default.
- oblio 4y agoWhich European bank is it?
- organsnyder 4y ago> AFAIK, the US works the other way around. "Positive pay" is available for checking accounts in the US, though I've never heard of it used outside of business accounts, and only then by request (and probably extra fees).
- lxgr 4y ago> By default, those requests are denied. That's not the case in Germany, at least.
- RandomLensman 4y agoBanks don't need a SEPA mandate to allow a direct debit?
- germanier 4y agoThe SEPA mandate is between the parties in the transaction. While banks require their existence, it is usually not shared with the banks involved.
- RandomLensman 4y agoSo only a creditor ID is needed if someone has a set of IBANs and then things will be processed?
- germanier 4y agoA creditor ID and a direct debit agreement with some bank, yes. After you have those, (usually) the banks won't verify individual transactions.
- oblio 4y agoDo you mean that if I know a German bank account number I can just withdraw money for me? Be right back, asking some German friends for their bank account numbers. Jokes aside, you're probably wrong. There's NO way I can just pull money from their bank account just by knowing their bank account number.
- germanier 4y agoYes, if you set up a direct debit agreement with a bank you can do that. If you'd actually try what you suggest it will be revoked quickly and charges filed as your identity is known.
- Denvercoder9 4y ago> What makes it work is that, under the SEPA Direct Debit framework, the risk of fraud and insufficient funds is 100% on the party initiating the direct debit. Additionally, you need to have a direct debit agreement with your bank to be able to initiate a direct debit. You need to show at least some legitimate banking history (and a government-issued ID) to get one, and they come with limits on how many and how much you can debit per period, and your bank will terminate the agreement if your reversal rate is higher than normal.
- janosdebugs 4y agoThis does have a minor drawback on the service provider side as allowing people to sign up for a service with direct debit is hard to get right, so many services prefer to offer credit card payment even if it is more expensive. There is no way for you to verify that a person signing up is actually the account holder save for doing the "we debited 1c on your account" thing, which takes a few days.
- lxgr 4y agoYes, and that's arguably by design. If you need confirmation of funds, cardholder/accountholder authentication, and a dispute mechanism that doesn't side with the customer in 100% of scenarios, SEPA Direct Debit is probably not the payment method you want. > the "we debited 1c on your account" thing This doesn't actually work with SEPA Direct Debits, since there is no such thing as "disputing a reversal" or "compelling evidence": If the accountholder says "funds back, please", the involved banks have to oblige. In fact, direct debits are so reversible/non-final that it's SOP for bankruptcy managers to claw back all of the last 8 weeks' worth of direct debits drawn on a bankrupt person's or entity's account, which can be quite surprising for debtors. In other words, it's possibly a better mental model to think of direct debits as a request for a wire in 8 weeks that gets earmarked for approval by default if enough funds are present, but that accountholders can cancel at any point in time, as far as finality (but not liquidity) is concerned.
- janosdebugs 4y agoThe main problem is that if the service provider has no proof that they legitimately had a contract signature, the account holder can reverse the transaction for much longer.
- jeltz 4y agoAt least with my bank, and I think most banks here in Sweden, I need to approve people before they can make direct debits.
- lxgr 4y agoHow do you approve a payee with your bank? At the time you grant them permission to debit your account, or at the time of the first payment? There is no technical channel for the former within the SEPA Direct Debit framework (i.e. the first time the payer's bank learns about a mandate is with the first direct debit), so I'm wondering if this is a different/domestic direct debit scheme.