6 ms·
With Sobering Science, Doctor Debunks 12-Step Recovery (2014)
- ilikehurdles 4y agoDoctor sells vulnerable people a dependence on his brand of snake oil, “debunks” one of the valid, well-studied, and free paths to recovery; NPR unquestionably parrots hot air on their weekly hot air power hour.
- mistermann 4y agoI am always fascinated by how "scientific" people use language.
- phs318u 4y agoSigh. As someone who’s had success in 12-step recovery since 1998, I find these sorts of “debunkings” incredibly disappointing. Firstly the measurement of success rate entirely misses the point. The 12-step view is that there isn’t a “once and done” cure. If I were to use an analogy it’s more like having lifelong diabetes. You gotta keep taking that insulin. It’s the continuity that forestalls the disease/ keeps you in remission. Yes, 12-step programs have issues, and a big one is the whole “higher power”/god thing. Maybe this is more of an issue in the USA which is far more religious than other countries. But even that is addressable for atheist 12-steppers. I should know - I am one. If you are interested in a different take by a psychologist expert in the field, check out the writing of Dr. Patrick Carnes. https://www.drpatrickcarnes.com/ https://www.drpatrickcarnes.com/
- labrador 4y agoYes, I get the feeling to. I just posted a comment I hope anyone reading this will find helpful
- KingMob 4y ago> The 12-step view is that there isn’t a “once and done” cure. If I were to use an analogy it’s more like having lifelong diabetes. You gotta keep taking that insulin. It’s the continuity that forestalls the disease/ keeps you in remission. This is actually one of the things that many psychologists are dubious about. It's entirely possible that self-labeling as an alcoholic forever makes it harder, not easier, for some people to remain abstinent. To the extent that it keeps you vigilant and involved in a supportive community, it can be good. But it could also make it harder to get back on the wagon if you have a single drink if you think you're "an alcoholic", and not "a sober person who made a mistake". Due to the anonymous and heterogeneous nature of AA, good data and studies of its efficacy are very hard to come by, so we have little idea if it's actually better than non-AA or pharmaceutical alternatives.
- phs318u 4y agoIdentifying as an alcoholic or gambling addict or drug addict etc, is no different than saying "I'm a diabetic". It's the label of a chronic disease. Applying that label to self is about acceptance of that as a fact of life that you can then work with. If you've ever been unfortunate enough to see e.g. a diabetic who did not accept the reality of their illness - it's not pretty. Acceptance is the price of vigilance. I also believe you've misunderstood how we view ourselves (and each other) when we fall of the wagon/bust/slip. I'm not a "sober person who made a mistake". I'm an addict who made a mistake. Most of us in 12-step programs have tried psychology (and counselling and hypnotherapy and...) before the despair was enough that we'd admit defeat and join *A. Admittedly, there's a cohort of people mandated to turn up. It should surprise no one that this cohort sees very high rates of recidivism. But I'd suspect the same to be the case for people mandated to attend psychotherapy. If you don't want to change, nothing can make you. Pharmaceuticals are interesting. I believe that LSD has been trialled to help those with substance addictions but I'm not sure of the state of research regarding behavioural addictions. Fundamentally though, the evidence is pretty clear that there's a neurological basis to most addictions including the behavioural ones. e.g. check the research of Mira Fauth-Buhler. https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Mira-Fauth-Buehler https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Mira-Fauth-Buehler
- specproc 4y agoPeople can choose to identify as they wish, and I'm not for one second diminishing that identification. But problematic drinking is very different to diabetes, it's also highly varied in its expression and not as deterministic as the label suggests. I totally understand why it's a helpful framing for some people, but it really isn't for others.
- vorpalhex 4y agoTo extend this, there have been programs that have attempted to fix the problems of alcohol addiction but not require patients to remain sober. The core concept being that there is an underlying cause to the alcohol problem and the alcoholism is an expression of that problem, not itself a root. Thus once the root cause is fixed, the alcohol is no longer a trigger. Another form allows participants to drink but uses a medicine which induces unpleasant effects from alcohol. Thus participants self train an avoidance pattern and break the positive feedback loop. These should not be seen as contrary to the AA abstinance approach. For some people that appears to be the most effective means. For many other people, AA is not. I suspect as we advance our understanding we'll come to find distinct subdiagnoses in alcoholism and alcohol abuse that suggest different treatment strategies. Right now our understanding feels very rudimentary.
- JamesBarney 4y agoYeah one of the issues is that much of the 12-step recovery community does not condone alcohol abuse disorder medication. So to extend your analogy it would be like a community that focuses exclusively on curing diabetes through a ketogenic diet, but also tells people they shouldn't take their insulin. Maybe ketogenic diet works, but we do need good data to figure out how it compares to taking insulin.
- rootusrootus 4y agoI think GP was talking about type 1 diabetes, which is an entirely different disease than type 2, and certainly not treatable with diet.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- gray5 4y ago[flagged]
- ChrisMarshallNY 4y agoYeah...been hearing this stuff for 42 years. I could probably make an entirely convincing argument as to why you shouldn't try it. That's because I've heard it all. If you don't want what we have ... no worries. You won't get it. The problem is when we make decisions for other people. Things look very, very different, when it's our own butt on the line.
- bbatha 4y ago> The problem is when we make decisions for other people. Things look very, very different, when it's our own butt on the line. Which is precisely what this article is complaining about. AA both as a program and as cultural push "abstinence first" is harming addicts for which the AA method is not successful. Which is most people. For instance drug therapies are slow to be given approval, people are sent to AA programs through court orders, etc. As an individual if it works for you that's wonderful. But governmental policy and cultural norms should be based on what's effective.
- readthenotes1 4y agoWhat is more effective than AA?
- ChrisMarshallNY 4y agoIf you are looking at raw numbers, lots of things. MAT (Medically Assisted Treatment) is considered more effective, numbers-wise. There's a huge amount of money being made in the field. Also, AA and NA don't collect much, in the way of data. It's actually hard to tell how truly effective they are. Something to do with the second "A," I would guess... That brings up another point that people have been avoiding, here: Desperate people can be squeezed hard. A lot of folks are making a lot of money, from people with their lives in tatters. Some of the therapies are effective, but a lot of them are definitely not. Since people like to cast addiction (and alcoholism is simply addiction to the sedative-hypnotic drug ethyl alcohol) as a moral failing on the part of the addict, it's easy to blame them, and say that "they got what they deserved." It's really pretty hard to feel sorry for many addicts. Pick up the paper, on any given day, and you'll likely see some horrific stories of crimes committed by addicts. That's why programs like AA and NA work. The only people that actually care about addicts, are other addicts. It's also important that they not be in a position to profit from their treatment. 12-Step programs live on a regimen of enforced poverty. They love to fight about money, but the amounts are chicken feed, compared to what the for-profit orgs make. Which begs the question: If someone makes money by selling treatment to desperate, ostracized, people, is it surprising that they don't like organizations that provide highly effective treatment for free?
- paxcoder 4y ago[dead]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- labrador 4y agoI'm a recovering alcoholic who has worked the 12 steps. To get this out the way, I agree that courts should not be sending people to AA. It's no good for anyone. The reason that the 5 to 10 percent do well in AA actually doesn't have to do with the 12 steps themselves; it has to do with the camaraderie. I agree with the second half of the that sentence, but the reason the reason many people including researchers don't think the 12 steps is because so few people understand them to do them properly. Actually, the are a remarkable piece of mental technology based on thousands of years of wisdom 1 - Admit you have a problem. You can't fix a problem you refuse to recognize. 2 - Recognize you've tried to solve it by yourself and have failed. You need help from others. 3 - Humble yourself enough to ask for help and be ready to follow direction 4 - List all the complaints people have about you and analyze what you might be doing wrong 5 - Share your failings, no matter how embarrassing, with a trusted other on the principle that confession is good for the soul and sunlight is the best disinfectant 6 - Ask yourself if you're really willing to change. That's not a given. Maybe you aren't. 7 - If you are then do what it takes to change. This is going to be different for everyone. 8 - Look at step 4 and see who you need to apologize to 9 - When you feel you are ready and sufficiently reformed, apologize and make restitution to those on the list you made in step 8. To those that aren't willing to talk, let it go and don't bother them. 10 - Make it a practice to do steps 4 through 9 as needed. We believe in progress not perfection. 11 - We need to remind ourselves daily that we have a problem that we can't solve alone and that we may need the help of others on any given day. I've heard it called a disease of forgetfulness. We may need to wake up in the morning to read and pray if so inclined. As one person told me, "carve out a little piece of each day for the 12 steps" 12 - Carry this message to others who are still suffering, which I am doing here Edit: I almost forget: Notice I haven't mentioned God. There were atheists in early AA that insisted that Bill Wilson insert the phrase "God of our understanding" in the book Alcoholic Anonymous so people could be free to use the concept of God or not.
- edmundsauto 4y agoThe steps are good advice and can be helpful for some people. That does not mean people who fail (80+% from the data I saw) are doing them wrong. Why is it so hard for people to accept that some things work, for some people. My personal experience of success is not a reasonable blueprint for literally anyone except me. Our experiences are shared but not useful to proscribe behavioral interventions for anyone except us. AA works for some people. It does not work for others.
- MissionInfl 4y agoNot meaning to diminish the role that 12 step recovery plays in the lives of many but given the impact that alcoholism medication had on my own life I can't help but mention it here. I used Naltrexone through The Sinclair Method and rewired my brain by continuing to drink for a year using the medication. I'm now multiple years sober. It took some extra time to deal with some emotional stuff, 12 steps will help you more there. But addressing the chemical addiction first worked well for me. See my comment history for more details.
- thewildginger 4y agoI think most 12 step people who find success actually acknowledge what the psychiatrist is saying. Addiction isnt just one thing, often it can be a bunch of things, a big one being un-treated mental health problems like depression, anxiety, or even add/ADHD. It can be as he said feelings of powerlessness and displacing problems, like chemical procrastination of emotional processing. If that is a source of the issue it would make sense that addiction would be more common in society where emotions are not discussed or stigmatized but alcoholism is not. This is all to say 12 steps isn't enough by itself and as far as I know most addicts in recovery stress that. I have known heroin addicts who are in recovery who go to meetings, but they also take meds, changed where they live, who they hang out with, media they consume, I even think they went to behavioral health therapy for a while to help change how they approach problems like stress, anger, communication, etc.
- specproc 4y agoAs someone who's been on his own journey with alcohol and hung out in a few sobriety forums (/r/stopdrinking is brilliant), I've seen a very clear difference between the 12-steppers and other people who are quit/quitting/moderating. I found the framing of the AA folks to be a lot more extreme. Problematic alcohol use is frequently described as an incurable, progressive disease. There's also this heavy focus on guilt and shame (see steps 4, 5 and 8) which I've always found a little uncomfortable and well, culty. I'm not saying it's not helpful, it's saved many a backside. Nor am I saying that it's success-rate is oversold, I've not gone into the evidence. It was just definitely, clearly not for me.
- specproc 4y agoFWIW, I am not an atheist and no longer drinking like I used to.
- mikestew 4y agoYou can edit your posts within an hour or so. Look for the " edit [–]" up there to the right of your username, just before the title. EDIT: or "edit | delete [–]", as the case may be.
- specproc 4y agoInteresting, can edit with hours gone by but not delete. Ah well, the inevitable next time. Thanks for the tip.
- klyrs 4y agoYou can edit/delete for 2 hours. You cannot delete a comment that's been replied to. Unless you somehow convince your respondents to delete their comments within your edit window, which never seems to work.
- mikestew 4y agoYeah, I should have replied to your original message so that you could delete the follow-up. As sibling comment points out, you can't delete once someone replies to your message. I knew better, I just didn't think it all the way through. Anyway, now you know.
- aaron695 4y ago12-Step Programs have been shown to work within academia. 12-Step Programs are believed to work by most doctors and people in the industry. 12-Step Programs work on a theoretical level, it fits within the frameworks on addiction. 12-Step Program are said to have saved their lives by many people in them (antidotal) The dirty secret why these contrarian articles keep coming out (Or linked back to [2014]) is all addiction programs fail at massive rates. Over 95% failure rates are normal for all 'solutions' depending on how you measure it. It's not good to know this. It will increase your failure rate. If you go down this road you will probably use a mix. Psychologists, rehab, 12 step, drugs like Naltrexone. You might end up on 12 step or it might come first you leave and end on psychologists. Or you might go back. Or around the loop many times. Many end on willpower, after other solutions like 12 step help get them there. Whatever works. 12-Step Programs also have the best stories. That alone makes them worth popping into. You'll see Fight Club in a different (better) light.
- ChrisMarshallNY 4y ago> 12-Step Programs also have the best stories. That alone makes them worth popping into. You'll see Fight Club in a different (better) light. People pay money, for fiction, that is less interesting than a typical ESH share from the front of a room. It's quite something, when someone is talking about being shot, then pulls up his shirt, to show you the scars.
- martco 4y ago"Alcoholics Anonymous, the worldwide fellowship of sobriety seekers, is the most effective path to abstinence, according to a comprehensive analysis conducted by a Stanford School of Medicine researcher and his collaborators." March 11, 2020 https://med.stanford.edu/news/all-news/2020/03/alcoholics-anonymous-most-effective-path-to-alcohol-abstinence.html#:~:text=AA%20shines,to%20be%2060%25%20more%20effective https://med.stanford.edu/news/all-news/2020/03/alcoholics-an....
- lo_zamoyski 4y agoI don't know much about AA, but whatever the case may be, I wonder if measuring effectiveness based on success rate numbers is all that meaningful. That is, does it makes sense to view it in medical terms? While it seems to be the case that some are more prone to alcoholism than others based on genetic factors, whether one actually becomes an alcoholic is not a matter of deterministic factors like a disease might be. There is a huge component of assent. Thus, it is related to character, virtue, and habit. Temperance is, at bottom, a matter of "orderliness" (vs. disorder) of the faculties and appetites moderated and ruled over by reason and a will that conforms to the truth as known by reason. This entails restraint, moderation, self-denial, and the ability to suffer well when illicit desires surface, such as the desire for a drink when you know, rationally, that you ought not drink, that it is harmful and wrong to do so. Indeed, for all of us, to be able to suffer is essential to being a good human being; those who cannot suffer cannot live well and cannot love well. Practices of self-denial, like fasting, and self-sacrifice help cultivate this self-mastery. Sacrifice is always that of the lower for the sake of the higher. My point: perhaps success rates are to be understood also in light of personal commitment, understanding, and what makes commitment possible. Most people struggle with bad habits and addictions of all sorts and sizes. Alcoholism is just one of them and one that happens to be conspicuously destructive. Perhaps the "success rates" for the others are comparable because most people simply prefer to keep the bad habits and avoid (or lack the basic knowledge of the need for) the suffering they must endure to be made free of such things. Why assume alcoholics and alcoholism are any different than most people and most habits, mutatis mutandis?
- autoexec 4y ago> Why assume alcoholics and alcoholism are any different than most people and most habits I think it'd be a mistake to think there's no difference between physiological addiction and "most bad habits" since most bad habit's don't have a risk of killing you when you simply stop doing them (https://www.psychreg.org/cold-turkey-alcohol-dangerous/ https://www.psychreg.org/cold-turkey-alcohol-dangerous/). I think looking at addiction in medical terms is far more appropriate than looking at it as a moral failing or as a lack of desire to change or an unwillingness to "endure suffering" (many addicts I've known were certainly no stranger to suffering and sacrifice). Treating addictions like a medical problem makes it harder for non-addicts to look down on people afflicted with them so a lot of people will resist the idea and continue to think that it's nothing more than a personal shortcoming and that dealing with the problem should be no harder than avoiding any other undesirable behavior. I really don't think telling people that if only they were more orderly and had a stronger character that they wouldn't have an addiction is true or helpful.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- ftxbro 4y agoI'm lucky to not be alcoholic but isn't the headline wordplay a little gauche?
- pookha 4y agoI remember reading a William Burroughs interview where he talked about getting over nasty addictions by just writing "I will not smoke a cigarette" on a piece of paper everyday. This stupid process worked incredibly well for me. Broke a bad smoking habit. Anytime I felt the urge I'd re-write the statement. I could see how the same thing could work with drinking if and when you get triggered (grilling in the backyard, restaurant, etc).
- recoveredtoday 4y agoGuy checking in here that was super skeptical of AA, tried everything else including minimization, psychology, etc. 10 years sober today as a direct result of finally surrendering my ego and walking into the room and giving it a try. From my "class" I'd say about 25 - 30% of us have made it to this milestone so far. No two people are built the same is the truth, if you've tried and failed elsewhere don't be dissuaded to try it.
- emacsen 4y agoNo one is saying that 12 step doesn't have any successes, but: 1. The data is somewhat overwhelming that the rates of success aren't 25-30% as you said, but closer to 7%.[1] This puts it in roughly the same category as no 2. No one is dismissing the idea of doing 12 steps, but 12 steps is often court mandated. 3. 12 Step has more than passing connections to "faith-based" treatments. This is a problem when it's court mandated. 4. Instead of a problem with the program, they categorize inability to complete them as moral failures on the part of the person in treatment. No one thinks that 12 step treatments shouldn't be an option, but they're not effective evidence based treatment options. [1] https://www.theatlantic.com/health/archive/2014/03/the-surprising-failures-of-12-steps/284616/ https://www.theatlantic.com/health/archive/2014/03/the-surpr...
- readthenotes1 4y ago"But unlike AA, I would never claim that what I've suggested is right for everybody. But ... let's say I had nothing better to offer: It wouldn't matter — we still need to change the system as it is because we are harming 90 percent of the people." It is difficult to tell if those are the words of the NPR author or Lance dodes who wrote the book, but it directly contradicts your statement "2. No one is dismissing the idea of doing 12 steps"
- lazyasciiart 4y agoChanging the system doesn't have to mean getting rid of the 12 steps: it would change the system to make other options equally accessible and respectable.
- bjt2n3904 4y agoOh, let me hear the psychiatrist who has a new plan to overcome addiction with his bag of tricks. People worship modern psychiatry/psychology as this scientific insight into the human mind that has finally done away with superstition and religion, and can accurately (and repeatably) tell us what's happening with people suffering from various mental ailments, and how to fix it. But for some reason, every time a shooting spree happens, we all scratch our heads and ponder who could have seen this coming, and bury the fact that the majority of the shooters are on SSRI's and a host of other medication. What happened to our superior understanding of the human mind? Shouldn't modern psychiatry and psychology be able to identify people at risk of shooting sprees? Or at least point back at the missed signs? Why are they so silent on this? It's because when you peek behind the curtain, you find they're just a form of culturally acceptable medicine men. "Here, take these pills and it will solve all your issues! No we don't have any idea what 'chemical imbalance' is happening, or even if it's happening, but that's beside the point! Do not question the great and mighty Oz!" If you ask me, they aren't fixing the problem with young men, they're perpetuating it. Maybe address that before throwing mud on 12 step programs.
- jjulius 4y ago>... and bury the fact that the majority of the shooters are on SSRI's and a host of other medication. Can you please cite a source for this? >It's because when you peek behind the curtain, you find they're just a form of culturally acceptable medicine men. "Here, take these pills and it will solve all your issues! No we don't have any idea what 'chemical imbalance' is happening, or even if it's happening, but that's beside the point! Do not question the great and mighty Oz!" This is an incredibly broad blanket generalization that is not accurate.
- davedx 4y agoI'm in AA at the moment and AA doesn't claim to be a scientific method for staying off alcohol. It's full of religion! TFA is a giant strawman.
- giraffe_lady 4y agoI think that's one of the practical problems both with AA itself and with criticisms of it. It occupies this space in the cultural milieu as the main or even only system to address alcoholism. You have judges sending drunk drivers & domestic abusers to AA and shit, atheists in there freaking out needing help they're not gonna get because they didn't know what they were getting into and the steps very clearly are not for them. I would recommend AA to someone who is already or wants to be religious. It has many or all of the characteristics of a religion in its own right, and the emotional stance of seeking help from god is an explicit prerequisite. AA itself doesn't even think AA is the only approach that works. The writings are very clear that other ways work for many people, and if one works for you you should prefer it because AA is exhausting, endless, and humiliating. That is part of why it works for those it works for, but if you can find another way you'll have a better time.
- ChrisMarshallNY 4y ago> exhausting, endless, and humiliating. That is part of why it works for those it works for, but if you can find another way you'll have a better time. I see what you did, there. I think the word you are looking for is "humbling." Completely different animal from "humiliating." It's not "exhausting," either. Not sure where that came from. > you'll have a better time. Not sure I'd find agreement with that statement. Life is really, really good.
- giraffe_lady 4y agoOf all the places I comment online this is the only one where I'm routinely told I meant to say something other than what I said. I used to think I was just an unclear writer but it continues to only happen on HN. Anyway I'm not anti-AA, I've been in it for years and am happy with it. I've also engaged extensively with what I perceive to be its limitations and constraints. I said what I meant to say and I meant what I said. I meant humiliating. There are recovery programs that emphasize your courage and strength in confronting a highly stigmatized mental illness, that encourage reflection on the routine frailty of the human mind, its susceptibility to this sort of failure, the capriciousness of who falls into addiction and who doesn't. Does that sound like AA to you? AA encourages you to think of yourself as permanently faulty in an irreparable way and to choose your actions with that fault in mind. This is rather practical in preventing relapse, but it's not a resounding message of self-actualization. The "confession of sins" in steps 5, 8, 9 are inevitably going to be experienced as shameful and yes, humiliating. This is effective! It's a powerful deterrent to that behavior in the future. I meant exhausting. There is never a point in AA where you are cured, where you are free of AA, free of the burden of thinking of yourself as an alcoholic. Again this is very pragmatic: it reminds you that readdiction is always possible, it keeps you from letting your guard down even years into recovery. It also means the vigilance is eternal, exhausting. Everyone who has grappled with addiction agrees that sobriety is a better way of life. But that doesn't mean AA is the only way to get to it, or the most pleasant among the options. "We thought we could find an easier, softer way." We could not, but some others can, and those who can will have an easier, softer time than we do in here.
- jedberg 4y agoI have a friend in AA. I'm not sure how to measure if she's been "successful" or not. After completing the steps the first time, she relapsed after a few months. After the second time, she went a bit longer, but didn't quite make a year. She's on her 3rd time now. It's been over a year since she last drank. She's made significant positive life changes and this time feels different. The last two times she constantly talked about fighting the urge to drink. This time she has no urges and nothing to fight. So I guess she's successful now? We'll never really know until she dies, right? Because she could relapse 10/15/20 years from now. I assume they have some arbitrary cutoff of sobriety as "success", but how many people relapse after that cutoff? I'm proud of my friend and hope she stays sober forever, but I also check in with her often to make sure she's staying on track (She has asked me to do this). She says this accountability helps. I'm not sure what my point is, just that "success" when it comes to sobriety is very complicated and not just yes or no.
- hughw 4y agoIf you relapse after 10 years, you had 10 good years. Win.
- abracadaniel 4y agoRecovery is almost never a straight line. If habits are hard to break, addiction is far more so. I’d guess the real benefits are in the support network of people who have first hand experience.
- notch898b 4y agohttps://hams.cc/ https://hams.cc/ is a great resource. Teaches you to keep your ego, empower yourself to change, rather than the helpless feeling of yielding to a higher power taught in AA.
- olliej 4y agoAs the article says, the core problem here is that the AA/12 step step definition of success and failure basically means that it is close to impossible for 12 step programs to ever fail. They definitionally treat any reversion/falling off as being a failure of the patient not the treatment. This is the same as saying “this chemo isn’t working due to your personal failures” and then reporting a near 100% success rate for said drug. The resultant “high” success rate then leads to courts imposing generally religiously affiliated “programs” that claim to not require god, but sure as heck make it difficult to avoid. While I’m sure many aren’t making use of this system to gain coercive power over people who aren’t in a great place it’s very clear that many do.
- 4RealFreedom 4y agoI've been in recovery for a long, long time. AA/NA was the only option when I started. I had my problems with the program - no cross talk, the depressing nature of each meeting, the sponsorship piece of the program. I ended up trying a different program called SMART recovery. It fit me much better. Just throwing this out there for anyone looking for options. There are different recovery programs that might work better if you're turned off to AA/NA.
- AlbertCory 4y agoDisclosure: not an alcoholic, not married to one, either. This is not a debunking. There are "support groups" for almost everything (watch Fight Club to see examples of that). >The reason that the 5 to 10 percent do well in AA actually doesn't have to do with the 12 steps themselves; it has to do with the camaraderie. It's a supportive organization with people who are on the whole kind to you, and it gives you a structure. Some people can make a lot of use of that. And to its credit, AA describes itself as a brotherhood rather than a treatment. I don't know about the 5-10% figure; let's assume that's valid. But saying the other 90% are harmed is a big overstep. The only way that would be true is if there were some other treatment that's more effective, and the 90% could have gone to that instead of AA. But he doesn't claim there is. I'd propose that someone who goes to AA and doesn't like it probably then tries drugs, psychotherapy, and anything else. Or just continues on his own.
- red-iron-pine 4y agoHarmed in the sense there is little reason to think this approach will work for them, and in choosing it (or being forced upon it, i.e. via a court order), we're not using more effective methods. Or just doing nothing.
- AlbertCory 4y agothe court order: you're right. Otherwise, "more effective methods" are yet to be identified, AFAIK.
- sonjat 4y agoThe sad truth is that we just don't know how to treat addiction very well. We don't even define "success" well. Is it sober after 3 months? 6? 1 year? 5 years? 10? Does that still count if one has to continue to get treatment/go to meetings/take medication/etc.? There aren't a lot of good, consistent answers. AA isn't without its faults, but it is readily available, anonymous, and free (that's a big one -- too many anti-AA people are selling something).
- pella 4y agosolution ~= finding meaning in life ? "Little is known about the spiritual mechanism underlying the relationship between involvement in AA and subjective well-being. The aim of this study was to test the beneficial role of existential well-being in the indirect relationship between involvement in AA and the subjective well-being in a sample of individuals with alcohol dependence from Poland. In the literature, there is a lack of research regarding predictors of subjective well-being among participants of self-help groups. Most researchers have focused on abstinence duration or reduced drinking as a recovery indicators. Contrary to most recent studies, subjective well-being was used as a recovery indicator instead of abstinence duration or reduced drinking. It is due to the fact that abstinence is not the same phenomenon as sobriety. Abstinence exclusively refers to the symptoms of the disease, while sobriety is something deeper, manifesting in emotional and mental dimensions, being an expression of sobriety [16]. Existential well-being [17,18] is another construct than subjective well-being [19], but both of them are strictly related. It finds reflections in Seligman’s [20] model of happiness approaches for a meaningful and purposeful life as one of three ways to achieve subjective well-being. Additionally, in Frankl’s conception [21] finding meaning in life facilitates fulfillment and satisfaction." read more: "The Beneficial Role of Involvement in Alcoholics Anonymous for Existential and Subjective Well-Being of Alcohol-Dependent Individuals? The Model Verification" https://www.mdpi.com/1660-4601/19/9/5173 https://www.mdpi.com/1660-4601/19/9/5173
- Melatonic 4y agoFor anyone who does not like AA - definitely check out "Smart Recovery". Many find it much better and it there is a similar comaraderie component but much more science based and no religious aspect.
- zafka 4y agoI stopped drinking 30 years before this article was published. A 12 step program played a big part in it. Since then I have been an amateur student of the field, and I feel these gentlemen are more wrong than right. AA is an easy target because when you read the text there is a lot of BS in it---But the organization created by it does work better than anything before it, and most things since. I am not sure if the record is 5% or 30% or whatever, but it is surely more than zero. One of the best defenses AAs methods I have seen is the opinion of Charlie Munger, who talks about how AA uses several common human tendencies that are hardwired into most of us all at the same time in a synergistic way.