6 ms·
Apple Continues Efforts to Keep Retail Stores from Unionizing
- alberth 4y agoOff-topic: Is there a correlation between Gen-Z and Pro-Unions? It’s just an obversarion I have, but it seems like the younger generation is pro-union and was wondering if it’s just my imagination.
- capableweb 4y agoAs everything, it goes in waves. The first people who were pro-union, were the ones who had 6-day work weeks, probably started working when they were ~13 years old (at least in the country where I was born) and had basically no work safety at all. Generation after generation got better and better working conditions, until modern times where many don't see what a union would even do for you. Probably lots of unions are riding their history as well, and have become complacent. But the more workplaces start abusing their employees, the more pro-union workers become. So that's what we're seeing today, people don't start to become pro-union just because.
- alberth 4y ago> But the more workplaces start abusing their employees It’s hard to characterize these white collar jobs with great benefits, as being abusive. It’s not like these workers are in coil mines 15-hours/day making below minimum wage. They are working in an ultra luxury retail store selling premium devices.
- vuln 4y ago> It’s not like these workers are in coil mines 15-hours/day making below minimum wage. No but with the advent of communication devices beepers, mobile phones, mobile computers, etc the typical office worker can be reach and in some situations is expected to be reached and respond _27/4_ in a salary type position (I’m not saying this is the 100% norm, no is it abused by every employer). Coal miners don’t have the luxury of a _connected_ job.
- rvnx 4y ago> No but with the advent of communication devices beepers, mobile phones, mobile computers, etc the typical office worker can be reach and in some situations is expected to be reached and respond _27/4_ Sounds very unlikely that Apple store employees get paged at night :/
- capableweb 4y agoManagers be managers, no matter if it's in retail, software or warehouses, no matter if it's Apple, Toy'r'Us or whatever. If they have something they consider an emergency and have your personal phone number, it's not super uncommon to be contacted by your boss outside of regular working hours. Repeating what last commentator said, not every boss is like this, obviously. But if you ask around in your circles (outside of software), then you'll see it's not super uncommon either.
- lostlogin 4y agoMany professions have unions, eg doctors. Whether or not your job is dangerous and physical, collective bargaining is a powerful tool thats challenges the inherent power of the employer.
- fatneckbeard 4y agoworking retail during the pandemic meant risking death. a lot of retail workers died. the fact they weren't coal miners doesn't mean they didn't die from their work.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- brightlancer 4y ago> working retail during the pandemic meant risking death. a lot of retail workers died. I've not read about such a correlation; age and obesity had high correlations but I hadn't seen such for retail workers. Do you have a source?
- fatneckbeard 4y agoits common sense and you just proved it. poor people have shitty health. retail workers are poor. i.e. retail workers have shitty health. without any additional correlation you have that by definition.
- bluefirebrand 4y agoRetail is never cushy, no matter what you're selling. You're always viewed as a low value employee and very replaceable which justifies offering really low pay and low benefits, if any. Not to mention many customers of retail stores behave outrageously badly, and as the front line staff you're going to bear the brunt of it.
- uni_rule 4y agoAnecdotally yes. It underlies the broader sense of hopelessness and pessimism a lot of people in this generation feel in terms of never being able to afford things like housing. Going from "why can't I afford to live anywhere?" to "maybe I should try to organize" is not a particularly hard jump to make if you already feel so hopeless in your ability to move up by other means. Especially in modern retail / restaurant jobs, they're fucking brutal for the pittance they try to pay out. Really no wonder organizing feels like the only outlet to improve those jobs in particular considering how those companies like to treat their "peons". For hard numbers, a Gallup Poll made in the last year shows 71 percent of all Americans approve of labor unions more generally, the highest it's been since the twilight of the New Deal Coalition in the mid 1960s. Source: https://news.gallup.com/poll/398303/approval-labor-unions-highest-point-1965.aspx https://news.gallup.com/poll/398303/approval-labor-unions-hi...
- News-Dog 4y ago[flagged]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- frob 4y ago[flagged]
- paulryanrogers 4y agoWhy?
- totetsu 4y agoApple Continues Efforts to Keep Retail Stores From Unionizing
- spinningarrow 4y ago> held meetings with staff members to discuss the risks of unionization and provide a planned update on bargaining between the company and the first unionized store Re: the risks of unionization especially in retail - are they ever greater than the risk of not unionizing? And are there examples of workers at companies that benefited from not unionizing?
- 35208654 4y agoIt’s not like we can run an A/B on the benefits for every employee and every company, but I can speak for one particular industry and one company during one particular point in time: automobile manufacturing and Toyota. During the 2008 financial crisis, the perception at Toyota by many employees was that, while their wages were nominally lower than their counterparts at unionized companies, it made them more robust to the economic downturn, resulting in fewer layoffs of permanent workers. This is not to say that unionization didn’t have its place in the conversation. What I heard directly was that “the threat of unionization is enough for us to get the benefits and pay raises we ask for.”
- mnd999 4y agoIt hardly seems worth the effort. If they want to unionise, let them. It’s not like retail stores employees are a huge part of the business.
- lostlogin 4y agoApple stores are some of, if not the most profitable retail stores per square metre in the world - Apple cares about its stores and you can see that when you go to them.
- jjtheblunt 4y agoHow did you find that statistic?
- lotsofpulp 4y agoPresumably a report from Costar. Technically, it is sales per square foot, but I cannot imagine any other retailer is beating Apple’s profit margins. https://9to5mac.com/2017/07/29/apple-top-retailer-per-square-foot/ https://9to5mac.com/2017/07/29/apple-top-retailer-per-square...
- lostlogin 4y agoYeah, and it’s been re-reported a load of times. I’ve seen more recent reports in a similar vein but can’t seem to locate them now.
- mnd999 4y agoOutlier profits are further evidence that the salespeople are underpaid and should seek to remedy that by collective action.
- 35208654 4y agoHere’s the problem I have with this discourse: > Apple also withheld new benefits from unionized locations, drawing outcry from labor advocates. I am pro-union. Fight for your rights! But understand what you’re getting into: once you engage with a third party (union) to negotiate for you, you will only get what you bargain for. The animus around unequal benefits ought to be directed to their union leaders, who need to do their fucking jobs and bargain for the benefits. That’s what you pay them for! It’s up to the individual and the collective to figure out how and whether unionizing benefits them in the context of their employer-employee relationship. Eyes open: the company has interests too. Mischaracterizing those interests is a disservice when you’re at the negotiating table.
- shrike 4y agoStarbucks did the same thing, arguing that - “Wages and benefits are mandatory subjects of the collective bargaining process,” the company said. It rejects the union’s argument that it could offer the wage and benefit enhancements to unionized stores at any time. The NLRB countered - "...the NLRB said Starbucks violated labor law by offering raises and benefits — including increased training, career development opportunities, expanded tipping and even looser dress code policies — only to nonunion stores."* Source: https://www.seattletimes.com/business/starbucks-shortchanged-union-workers-in-seattle-labor-board-says/ https://www.seattletimes.com/business/starbucks-shortchanged..., @ https://archive.ph/CrZTh https://archive.ph/CrZTh
- 35208654 4y agoIs there an update to this story? The story doesn’t cite what law the NLRB claimed was violated, only that doing what starbucks did interfered with their ability to organize. The final paragraph mentions that the case is yet to be heard: >The regional complaint will be heard by an administrative law judge at the NLRB. Once a decision is reached, either side can appeal to the full National Labor Relations Board in Washington. Full disclosure: I’m operating on logic, not an expertise on labor law. I am genuinely interested in expanding my understanding of labor laws and process.
- 4y ago
- endisneigh 4y agoSlightly off topic: Have there ever been any unions that simply started their own co-op?
- none_to_remain 4y agoNot a co-op, but in NYC the UFT (teachers' union for the school districts) started its own charter school, which ended up performing horribly and getting shut.
- javajosh 4y agoThis would be an actually interesting story if you removed the word "from". Otherwise, it's "dog bites man".
- user3939382 4y agoIt’s always been obvious to me that for all these corporations with the loud progressive “values”, it’s all marketing, they have no values and it’s all bullshit. So satisfying watching them be forced to take the mask off in public view for once.
- kevingadd 4y agoApple has ended up having to go mask off in some other recent legal struggles as well - their decision to describe itch.io as a source for 'unspeakable games' in an attempt to win points against Epic is a good example of how they haven't changed their stripes since the old days when you were banned from including religious or sexual themes of any kind on the App Store, even stuff as mundane as 'my project gutenberg app allows you to read the Kama Sutra'. In general all of these big companies only hold progressive values if it's profitable to do so. You'll see rainbow-colored logos on big corporate campuses but when it's time to censor or surveil minority groups for the government they all line up.
- abirch 4y agoThere is a spectrum of progressive values. Like business leaders can be pro-marriage equality but not be pro-union, like there are union members who aren't pro-LGBTQ.
- smoldesu 4y agoThat's not a spectrum, they are separate and non-contradictory ideas. They might exist along a spectrum of progressiveness, but the point the parent made is that money triumphs over them all. It triumphed over privacy, it triumphed over freedom, and it's capable of a lot worse if we don't legally obligate these companies to act right.
- abirch 4y agoThe parent appeared to show hypocrisy because the businesses espoused certain separate non-contradictory ideas and not others. The businesses were never pro-union as far as I can see; so I'm missing the hypocrisy. Apple is definitely pro-LGBT, so trying to diminish their progressive values such as gay rights seems wrong.
- noloblo 4y agoarchive unpaywall : https://archive.is/I15dd https://archive.is/I15dd
- catiopatio 4y ago“The iPhone maker rejected proposals on having weekly instead of biweekly pay, a third-party arbitrator for resolving grievances to replace existing procedures, a respect and dignity clause, basing promotions and layoffs on tenure, and scheduling policies.” I can’t blame them — especially for tenure-based promotion/layoffs, which cripple an organization’s ability to promote the best qualified and remove under-performers.
- scarab92 4y agoTenure is poorly correlated with performance. In unionised organisations it is usually negatively correlated with performance. Boards are never going to accept basing promotions or layoffs on tenure.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]