8 ms·
I know it's not a popular opinion, but the AM/FM radio bands have become such (corporate) crap that I laud people like this radio pirate. I wish a kind of publi
by JKCalhoun 4y ago
I know it's not a popular opinion, but the AM/FM radio bands have become such (corporate) crap that I laud people like this radio pirate. I wish a kind of public-access could open up on half the frequencies on the dial.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- myself248 4y agoPretty damn popular with me. Licensing and ownership rules are as corrupt as can be. Radio belongs to the people, it is the definition of a public good. It is incontrovertible that the ownership rules will be tweaked in the direction of corporate interests at every opportunity. People (you and I, and our elected representatives, and pirates) need to do everything possible to yank it back, as far and as hard as we can. The fact that LPFM hasn't even _pretended_ to offer the _opportunity_ for a license in _ten years_ is everything you need to know about that farce.
- RF_Enthusiast 4y agoThe timing of LPFM windows can't really be closer than 10 years from the previous window. Filing windows with LPFM and certain other services can't overlap, and there legally needs to be time between each for consider objections and competing applications. An LPFM window can not overlap with: (1) Full Power Non-Commercial FM Stations, (2) Full Power Commercial FM Stations, (3) FM Translators (or, repeaters), (4) Full Power TV Stations, and (5) Low Power TV Stations. These windows can not overlap because each of the above services must consider each other in their applications. The FCC is still wrapping up decisions from the recent 2021 Non-Commercial FM filing window, and has said that they expect LPFM to be next. But they can't do that until the public has the opportunity to object to the final permit granted.
- giantg2 4y agoWhat's stupid is that LPFM stations have a regulated max range of 3.5 miles, which means you could have a ton of them throughout the country without overlap, even if you reserved only 2-3 frequencies for them. This really shouldn't be an issue.
- RF_Enthusiast 4y agoYeah, spectrum is not being used in the most efficient way. I've heard many different valid ideas on how to do it better, but, in most cases, requires a literal act of Congress.
- KyeRussell 4y agoA great example of your opinions being too strong compared to your actual knowledge of the subject.
- hellojesus 4y ago> Radio belongs to the people, it is the definition of a public good. Public goods are defined as nonrivalous and nonexcludable. While you cannot exclude anyone from listening to your transmission, the very act of you transmitting prevents others from doing so on the same frequency, within the same locale. It is not a public good by definition. Im very against government interference, but this is one situation in which government regulation makes sense, so long as the portions of the spectrum allocated to the public are fairly auctioned. Admittedly, I have no idea how the private allocation works.
- pyuser583 4y agoBut it’s not really a public good. A public good can’t be provided to just a few people. Protecting “scarce” bandwidth is about managing private goods.
- xattt 4y agoCorporate crap or not, but disregarding regulations around spectrum use will cause modern society to ground to a halt.
- chrisdhoover 4y agoMay the loudest transmitter win. 50,000 watts out Mexico, I heard it on the X
- tinus_hn 4y agoLet’s reenact the discovery of the microwave!
- zikduruqe 4y agoLaughs in Russian Woodpecker. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Duga_radar https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Duga_radar Back when I was really active in HF, this thing was nuts.
- MereInterest 4y agoAllocating radio spectrum by the loudest transmitter is like allocating infants by tug-of-war. It destroys the resource in the process.
- thangalin 4y agoI develop radio transceiver software for FCC-compliant radios. The FCC helps ensure that specific radio bands are allocated for emergency purposes. There are regulations based on numerous performance characteristics of radios that must be met before a radio transmitter can be sold and operated. The problem with pirates is that they either aren't aware of these considerations or don't care. Either way could lead to interference with firefighters, police, or ambulance dispatch in life-critical situations. (The P25 digital radio communications standard was written specifically to address interoperability between different manufacturers, as a direct result of the inability for first responders to coordinate efforts during 9/11, which led to more lives lost than would have happened otherwise.) Beyond the FCC, counties need to stay within their allocated spectrum band, lest they interfere with neighbouring transceivers. Yes, corporate radio is trash. In Canada, we have CBC Radio, which is free of advertisements. Allowing radio pirates to jam airwaves is neither a good idea nor a good solution to corporate crap.
- ipaddr 4y agoCBC radio is an advertisement. What emergency services are operating under its Steeple in this case?
- RF_Enthusiast 4y agoIn this case, they're blocking out the Emergency Alert System of KBOO. Since KBOO is operating in HD mode, both stations were occupying the bandwidth between 90.5 and 90.6 MHz. KBOO is charged with providing emergency alerts for the immediate vicinity of the 90.5 pirate, but was compromised there. EAS is expanding to provide visual alerts as well, which the 90.5 pirate fully blocked.
- djur 4y agoWorth pointing out here that KBOO is a non-profit community radio station, pretty close to the "public access" radio that people here are wanting.
- 4y ago
- jandrese 4y agoI agree 1000% about legal AM/FM being a corporate wasteland. The 1996 Telecommunications Act was a huge mistake and should be repealed.
- jker 4y agoDuring pandemic I set up a little automated FM radio station for my block and the surrounding ones. It had a voice-synthesized DJ and a big randomized playlist of great music. The whole thing ran on an RPi with a little USB FM transmitter. My neighbors - the ones who still owned radios - loved it.
- nonethewiser 4y agoJust to clarify, was this illegal?
- jker 4y agoI don’t think so, the transmitter was under the power limit for amateur FM, and it didn’t overlap any local stations. That was my interpretation of the law as I read it before I built the station, doesn’t make it accurate or authoritative though.
- lelanthran 4y ago> I don’t think so, the transmitter was under the power limit for amateur FM, and it didn’t overlap any local stations. I think the broadcasting of the music without a license[1] might have broken some laws. [1] Unless you only broadcast music/content that was in the public domain, or free for broadcast, or similar license.
- RF_Enthusiast 4y agoA legal unlicensed FM transmitter could possibly cover a small area as described. If it's line-of-sight on a frequency with no interference and stays at the legal limit of 250 microvolts per meter measured at 3 meters, and there's a good receiver with a good antenna, it's possible.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- binarymax 4y agoFor the most part that’s unfortunately true. In some towns (like mine) I’m fortunate that there are a couple stations that are either listener supported, or run by a local university as a vocational program to teach broadcasting and DJ disciplines. Good radio is (for me) the best way to discover music. I love my local stations WITR college radio run by RIT and WBER which is listener supported. I totally get pirate radio as a cultural necessity to fill that gap for cities where the radio is all commercial shit.
- bnralt 4y agoThe guys hijacks a public frequency to put whatever he personally wants on, broadcasts Alex Jone's Infowars and Steve Bannon's War Room[1], and people are celebrating it as "the people" taking back the airwaves? [1] https://web.archive.org/web/20201101121303/https://preoradio.wixsite.com/pirate https://web.archive.org/web/20201101121303/https://preoradio...
- ok123456 4y agoMore interesting than a Clear Channel radio station.
- brightlancer 4y agoFYI, the company Clear Channel was bought out long ago and split up, with the billboard company keeping the name Clear Channel while the radio/ broadcasting/ media company re-branded as iHeart. You may think the radio stations are still awful, but it's an entirely different company.
- giantg2 4y ago"I wish a kind of public-access could open up on half the frequencies" You can always run a net on ham.
- wkat4242 4y agoI like this opinion. When they move corporate radio to DAB+ or whatever I'd love to see the FM band or part of it become available to special user groups. Of course with a centralized planning authority and certified equipment. Shouldn't be a huge deal, it would be similar to CB, just a bit more regulated. This way this band and its ubiquitous receivers would still be very useful.
- levidos 4y agoThe only reason governments are pushing DAB/+, so they can sell off the FM bands to corporations. Don't expect those to remain empty to amateurs.
- wkat4242 4y agoI doubt that's very feasible though. There's so much equipment around for this band. The same way with the 27Mhz CB band. If they ever sell it it will be swamped with interference by people still using their old radios.
- SpaceL10n 4y agoIf you're lucky enough to have a college radio station nearby, those are usually okay.