4 ms·
Meanwhile, feminists in the western world fight to wear a hijab, burkha, abaya, etc. and don’t see them as signs of oppression. I wish i understood the logic. W
by victorcreator 4y ago
Meanwhile, feminists in the western world fight to wear a hijab, burkha, abaya, etc. and don’t see them as signs of oppression. I wish i understood the logic. Wish we could all stand up against this together.
- bwb 4y agoThe point is the power to choose, not the result A or b.
- letrowekwel 4y ago"Power to choose" in the eyes of law and general society, as advocated by feminists, is not much use if women's family, relatives and other close community strongly disapprove and don't respect that law.
- madeofpalk 4y agoWhat's your objection? That it's moral to be forced by law to wear jeans?
- letrowekwel 4y agoThe law should not force anything. Western feminists should focus on improving women's rights in migrant communities, rather than calling people who point out real problems racist. Then more women actually do have the choice to wear what they want.
- simfree 4y agoOne of our elected feminists, Kshama Sawant did focus on migrant families issues, and passed landmark legislation banning discrimination based on caste. Considering how many Indian Americans convert to a different religion for the sole purpose of escaping the social implications their caste ties them to, this is a good starting point.
- nashashmi 4y agoIt is the opposite. Feminists are fundamentally anti religion and anti establishment. If govt is railing against what women can do, feminists are the first to fight. If religion is dictating what women can/should do, feminists will be the first to fight. Feminists are to authority like atheists are to religion.
- colechristensen 4y agoI had a conversation with a young progressive atheist woman about first hand accounts with women of Muslim backgrounds wearing the mandated clothing out of fear. She had a hard time accepting that what people said and how they acted publicly wasn’t the whole story. I used to smoke weed with some people that included some Muslim girls who would talk openly about what they were afraid of and the family pressures. If you don’t actually know people well you don’t get the whole story. In other words I’ve had direct experience with feminists who supported religious clothing in a misguided attempt to support other cultures. I’m of course not saying that there aren’t people who freely choose to wear such things. But it’s rarely without at least some pressure. We should be careful about what we force people to do but also be aware that not everyones outward choices are free.
- revscat 4y agoThese anecdotes are completely useless. It is far too common to see some conservative somewhere trot out anecdotes such as this, claiming some stupidity being said by someone they don’t like. Frankly I do not believe you, no matter how taboo it is the say so. To use a phrase that seems to have lost favor: link, or it didn’t happen.
- colechristensen 4y agoI’m not conservative and I’m not recording sensitive private conversations for the amusement of internet strangers. I’m relating my first hand experience using my real name, you can choose to believe whatever you want.
- sosborn 4y agoIt's real simple: "Don't take away my choice to wear what I want." For whatever reason, fragile people get real offended by what other people wear.
- bartkappenburg 4y agoOr don't wear
- ybinator604g3 4y agoIs it really a choice when you are talking about religion? I am from Iran. In the school they teach (scare) children that if you don’t wear hijab, you will be hanged from your hair and burned on a stick till eternity in hell after you die. By the way that subject is not elective. You have to pass it. What kind of choice is this? Update (context): I am not talking about the people in west who want to (not)wear hijab. I understand the premise of that choice. But this word (choice) is used daily in government propaganda. Maybe its analogous to talking about the choice of working in a cotton field to a slave. It’s a whole different environment/context. Hence my negative reaction to this word. It’s a matter of feeling which I just expressed. Nothing against someone who has a real choice, without religious stigma.
- madeofpalk 4y agoYou're right - that's not a choice. No one (progressive) is arguing for that.
- renewiltord 4y agoObviously that's the reason why people in (say) France are arguing to be allowed to wear it and people in Iran are arguing to be allowed to not wear it. It's the same argument: don't make me do something I don't want to do.
- Macha 4y agoYes. Compare the commercial secular Christmas to the mainstream Christian versions to the biblical literalists version. People in different parts of the world treat their religion and culture with different levels of severity and it's possible for an item associated with an oppressive interpretation in one part of the world to be a cultural pride item in another.
- khochesh_kushat 4y agoThey want the freedom to choose, rather than be forced by some other party to wear (or not wear) it.
- kube-system 4y agoBecause it’s not about the clothing, it’s about people having the freedom to choose.
- colechristensen 4y agoA lot of “liberal” people are starting to get progressively more strange ideas and it’s troubling. Jumping from not wanting to prosecute minor drug crimes (reasonable) to not wanting to prosecute murder (troubling). Trying to support other cultures (admirable) by encouraging oppressive practices (troubling). Not seeming to understand that very much of the women’s clothing is worn out of fear ranging from family shaming to extreme violence. The far and even moderate left is becoming increasingly bigoted classifying people into bins and setting behavior standards. You’re not just a person you’re a complex set of race, gender, and creed and you have to stay in that lane or you’re immoral. It’s all very odd.
- tadfisher 4y agoI feel like you're doing the classifying here. There is no single "left" position on this issue, because "the left" is not an entity. You got very close to self-awareness in your last paragraph, but projected onto it a twisted view of liberalism as an authoritarian morality police, which makes me question where you source your information.
- colechristensen 4y agoTo be clear, I’m explicitly calling out the average liberal as increasingly advocating for authoritarian solutions on many societal issues. Not the fringe, not a few, but the majority of the political left in the US. Do other people not see this?
- tadfisher 4y agoYou're going to have a hard time convincing others without naming those solutions and the mainstream liberal figures who support them. In my experience, there's nothing exceptional about American liberalism in contrast with most of the Western world, while American conservatism has an unhealthy obsession with authoritarian solutions to problems that aren't problems: transgender people, women who don't want to be pregnant, people who want to marry those of the same sex, and books about any of the above that children might read.
- throw545454 4y ago[flagged]
- matthewmacleod 4y agoI know I'm not being particularly constructive here but it's really simple: - Women should not be forced to wear particular items of clothing - Women should not be forced to not wear particular items of clothing What's difficult to understand?
- wetpaws 4y ago[flagged]
- jabradoodle 4y ago[flagged]
- akomtu 4y agoMany of such movements were created by people with noble intentions, but over time they have been replaced by selfish actors who use the movement's past reputation as a shell. Today they are wolves in sheep's clothes. Those hijabs is a clumsy measure to contain the power of sexuality. They recognize its power and the danger of getting it unleashed, but they aren't wise enough to know how to transform it into creativity at the society level, so they just chained it.