4 ms·
Minnesota man gets 2 years in prison for laser strike on jet
- haswell 4y agoOn top of everything, it was a blue laser, which can cause the most rapid damage to human eyes. It has always surprised me that it’s so easy to acquire these devices. With that said, the judge’s comparison to shining a flashlight in an officer’s eyes seems rather stretched. Perhaps similar from a behavioral standpoint, but rather dissimilar in terms of risk/danger.
- karmakaze 4y agoIt was explicitly stated in the context of behavior. > He also said the behavior was similar to a 2017 arrest when Link shined a flashlight in the eyes of the arresting officer. I've noticed that there's a slight rise in comments that seem to be adding information but is only restating what was written. I've done this myself from not reading articles fully or carefully. I hope it's not from losing the ability to actually absorb facts/details when actually trying.
- haswell 4y agoI’m aware of the context and that’s why I acknowledged the behavioral similarity. My point (which I didn’t state very well) was that in noting the behavioral similarity, the Judge seems to be implying that one somehow is connected to or informs the other. That shining a flashlight is somehow as problematic as shining a laser, or at least somehow linked. Beyond the similarity of “shining something”, it’s unclear what the Judge’s thought process could be that links the two in any meaningful way. One could conclude that shining the flashlight at an officer is an egregious lack of respect for authority, or that it’s just a bad idea to mess with police, but the context and potential harm here seems quite different than shining lasers at airplanes. Put another way, I recognize the apparent similarity, but I don’t recognize the relevance.
- karmakaze 4y ago> That shining a flashlight is somehow as problematic as shining a laser, or at least somehow linked. This isn't what I got from reading it at all. To me it seemed to be saying that both actions may come from a similar motivation, to bother, distract, and annoy an officer or authority figure, etc. We're not discussing the literal behavioral actions but rather the psychological intentions.
- rdtsc 4y ago> Put another way, I recognize the apparent similarity, but I don’t recognize the relevance The judge recognized the similarity too. He was arrested for the previous incident so as far as this criminal’s arrest record goes, he was arrested for a similar thing already and never learned to do better. I guess you’re arguing, his subsequent crime is a lot more serious and deserves a harsher punishment? Previous he tried to disorient and incapacitate a police officer, probably with a firearm which can then be taken while they are incapacitated, and here it’s a whole plane full of passengers.
- randyrand 4y ago> the judge’s comparison to shining a flashlight in an officer’s eyes seems rather stretched Cheap lasers are not very coherent. At a distance of ~500 meters the spot size is typically more than 1 meter. There’s no injury risk at large distance, for most handheld lasers.
- kordlessagain 4y agoIf there is intent to blind, or incapacitate, that is enough to prosecute. Doesn’t matter if one threatens with a stick and it’s too small. What matters is the intent to cause harm.
- lostlogin 4y ago> It has always surprised me that it’s so easy to acquire these devices. To make a parallel - guns are somewhat further along the ‘can cause harm or damage’ spectrum, actually cause deaths and are available (with varying degrees of restrictions).
- lockhouse 4y ago[flagged]
- randyrand 4y agoIt’s worth remembering no airliner has crashed due to a laser strike as far as records go. This is a longer sentence then drunk driving, which kills ~10,000 people annually.
- operatingthetan 4y agoIf you read pilot subs or forums it's pretty clear that this happens quite frequently to pilots and they report it and the report goes into a black hole or they look for the perpetrator and they never find them. I think the strategy then is hard consequences for those who are actually caught. I use a green laser for astronomy in a city and if we see planes around we turn it off.
- demarq 4y agoSo punish other people by punishing someone else?
- operatingthetan 4y agoI don't follow. Punish those who are caught with harsh sentences in order to deter other crimes. A common legal and law enforcement strategy around the world. I don't agree with it, but that's the concept.
- multjoy 4y agoThe deterrent is not the sentence, but the risk of getting caught.
- dolni 4y agoThat's such a tired argument. It is very obviously a combination of consequence and risk of getting caught. If you reduced the maximum sentence for murder to one day in prison, there would absolutely be a lot more murdering going on even if everything else stayed the same.
- furyofantares 4y ago> “The laser strikes caused a major distraction in the cockpit as they were not able to look at their iPads to brief the new approach,” prosecutors said in a statement. iPads?
- ultrarunner 4y agoAlmost every pilot nowadays is using Foreflight or something similar instead of paper sectionals
- phendrenad2 4y agoCheap, powerful lasers have been available for years, and people are stupid. We need to do a better job of warning people. I'm thinking mandate that they come in a box with a big red "do not point this at any vehicle OR PLANE thank you, FBI" sticker that you must remove.
- olliej 4y agoThe people deliberately shooting lasers at aircraft know what they’re doing is dangerous. They’re doing it because the danger doesn’t impact them. Just like people shooting guns into the air - which is similarly illegal.
- Maursault 4y ago"Air traffic control called a Minnesota State Patrol aircraft, which flew to River Falls. The State Patrol aircraft was also struck by a blue laser. The pilots spotted the suspect and worked with River Falls police, who found Link with a blue laser on his person." Wow. "Hey! OVER HERE!! Looking for me?"