3 ms·
> One of those things is much worse than the other two. Two are limitations in education, the other is not allowing people to come from that country at all. No
by rayiner 4y ago
> One of those things is much worse than the other two. Two are limitations in education, the other is not allowing people to come from that country at all.
No, trying to erase the culture of people who are already here out of xenophobia is much worse than exercising border control over who can immigrate. More importantly, most German and Italian Americans are descended from the people who faced discrimination. By contrast, Asian Americans are most not descended from groups that faced discrimination. That history doesn't help those kids understand their own experience and place in American society.
That distinction is critical insofar as we consider the present effect of past discrimination. In structural terms, Asian and Hispanic Americans are the least disadvantaged of any non-British immigrant group. Life in America has been far easier for me as a brown guy with Muslim name who entered adulthood right after 9/11, then it would have been if I had been Italian in 1930. The California ethnic studies curriculum wildly misrepresents that state of affairs.
- seanmcdirmid 4y agoYou are ignoring the fact that education is local, that education in California is going to be biased to California history rather than New York's history. There is so much to cover, that educators prefer to prioritize local/regional topics. I never heard much about Japanese interment when I went to school in Mississippi, but I heard plenty about the civil war (over and over again, sheesh). But when I went to school in Washington state, it was the exact opposite. That California biases to Asian and Hispanic history in the Americas is purely due to California being located in California rather than New York.
- rayiner 4y ago> You are ignoring the fact that education is local, that education in California is going to be biased to California history rather than New York's history. There are 5.6 million Asians in California. The vast majority have no connection whatsoever to Chinese railroad workers or Japanese internment. Moreover, the model curriculum also covers Hmong and Cambodian immigrants, which number less than 100,000 each, and don't have any particular connection to California (apart from California being a big state and having a lot of every group). Meanwhile, Orange County has 140,000 German Americans, and for some reason they don't merit an ethnic studies unit. > That California biases to Asian and Hispanic history in the Americas is purely due to California being located in California rather than New York. That doesn't explain why the model curriculum frames "ethnic studies" almost entirely in terms of sob stories. Nor does it explain why the curriculum draws a stark distinction between white kids, who aren't invited to identify with historic oppression, and Asian and Hispanic immigrants, who are.
- seanmcdirmid 4y ago> There are 5.6 million Asians in California. The vast majority have no connection whatsoever to Chinese railroad workers or Japanese internment. They definitely empathize with it, more than gangs of New York-style stories pitting Italian vs. Irish immigrants. > Moreover, the model curriculum also covers Hmong and Cambodian immigrants, which number less than 100,000 each, and don't have any particular connection to California Given that there are that many of them in San Jose, why not include it there? I'd expect something like that in Minneapolis as well, I would expect the same. Arabs in Dearborn, seems like fair game to me. > Nor does it explain why the curriculum draws a stark distinction between white kids They actually do mention white kids, Slavic and Jewish are in the books we get at my kindergartener's west coast school. I noticed you didn't mention those, however. Mostly it doesn't matter since white kids are still in the majority, why would they emphasize majority experiences when talking about minorities?