14 ms·
Adding capacity to the electricity grid is not a simple task
- spindle 4y agohttps://archive.md/KfiUO https://archive.md/KfiUO
- fwlr 4y agotl;dr Connecting new power generation to the electricity grid is a queue-based permit system that is stupid and slow, but simple and supremely stable. There is a decent chunk of renewable power “in the queue” but speeding up the connection process risks damaging stability. The article notes India’s electrification as a partial counter-example: relatively fast, but correspondingly relatively unstable. (One marker mentioned was “kerosene liters consumed”, as a proxy for how much lighting has been replaced by electricity, they note the amount dropped from 9 billion liters to 2 billion liters, which I take as a very rough indicator of ~80% grid reliability - not even one “9“ of stability. It’s hard to find representative data on developed-world power grid reliability but for instance there is a common estimate that the average Australian resident experiences 200 minutes of power outage per year, which corresponds to somewhere above three-and-a-half 9s and below four 9s. This suggests potentially quite an extreme cost in stability for the moderate benefit of speeding up queue times for renewable power.)
- andreareina 4y agoIf I understand correctly there's little slack in transmission capacity to service new supply, and that new transmission infra isn't built out until new generation is queued. What wasn't clear to me is if construction of the new generation has to be completed before it can be enqueued or if e.g. completed permitting is sufficient.
- bluGill 4y agoAnyone significant planning on new generation will also plan the interconnect at the same time, and that includes transmission capacity. There is no point in having your new generation completed if the interconnect isn't done. In fact the bank shouldn't (and probably is checking, though not always) let you get financing for the new generation if you have not verified that there is interconnect to use that generation. Thus plans for transmission is supposed to happen before you get to permits. Though depending on timelines you may start building on before the other. You putting solar on your roof is not significant. Your whole neighborhood putting solar up should be significant, but odds are this is done by individuals who don't realize their collective action is significant.
- philippgerard 4y agoThe average outage time per year in Germany, as far as I remember, is below 2min. The uptime of my non-USV-backed server at home supports that, but that’s only anecdotal data.
- WJW 4y agoAccording to tennet.eu (the grid operator for the Netherlands and parts of Germany), the uptime for their high voltage grid is about 99.99963%. Obviously it will be lower for individual consumers, since there is a lower voltage grid in between them and the high voltage grid that might fail separately. Still, I think I've personally experienced only one power failure in the last 5 years or so.
- cfstras 4y agoFellow German here, I’ve experienced a total of ~2 hours, in one single outage, about 20 years ago. Not even a single brownout since.
- fsh 4y agoIn my experience, USVs can make the uptime worse in Germany. The hardware is likely to fail before the next blackout.
- cameronh90 4y agoThe only power cut I've experienced since I've been in the UK (8 years) was about 30 seconds long. By the time the operator had sent me an SMS about it, it was already back up. This is despite the UK's rapid transition to renewables. There was a fairly major power cut by our standards in 2019, but it didn't affect me. Personally speaking, power cuts are so rare and short that I don't think about them or plan for them.
- liampulles 4y agoHere in South Africa the power can be off for anything from 2h to 8h a day and given the regularity of that interruption I've since gotten an inverter (with batteries) as well as several battery powered emergency lights to power me through. I know that many residents of India do something similar, and so I'm a little skeptical of this kerosene marker.
- inglor_cz 4y agoA honest, but offtopic question (if Dang sees it fit to remove, let him do it...): why do you stay in SA at all? What are the redeeming qualities of the country, aside from the nature, which is fabulous? If you are white, aren't you afraid of a possible pogrom against your family?
- ido 4y agoI'm not OP but it's incredibly hard to immigrate and as older people are less mobile/flexible it may mean leaving your elderly parents/grandparents behind, as well as your native culture and language and everyone/everything/everywhere you know.
- liampulles 4y agoI am thinking about leaving SA - the usual factors of cost, family, and change apply. Redeeming qualities: I do have pretty good buying power in SA, the weather is great,and it is quite a multicultural place with friendly people by and large. To my knowledge the rate of black on black violent crime is higher than black on white crime - SA has a general problem of violent crime. Its definitely a problem but a pogrom specifically is not a chief concern for me.
- inglor_cz 4y agoThank you for an interesting reply. I come from a fairly safe country, so I cannot really imagine how living in an unsafe country looks like. What precautions do people in SA need to take when travelling? Is there any sort of constantly updated "off-limits area map", or is it just common knowledge? How does security in wealthier neighbourhoods look like? Is hiking in the wild risky? Is public transport generally to be avoided, or are there "better and worse" services? As far as electricity blackouts go, everyone has a generator, right? Is there never a shortage of diesel for those generators? What about the pollution that comes from running generators several hours a day?
- com2kid 4y agoI think reliability should be divided up in different ways. Their is "how well the moving bits are moving" which is different than "lines getting knocked down by acts of nature". So, for example, I live in Seattle. Our power generation is quite reliable, but trees falling down during wind storms and knocking out power lines is also reliable, gravity being what it is. I don't consider the Seattle grid to be unreliable, though I do acknowledge that digging up the entire city and burying power lines would, at great expense, prevent nearly all power outages. But that sort of unreliability feels different than brown outs.
- bluGill 4y agoMy utility concluded that between underground animals chewing wires, idiots with backhoes not locating before digging, and the extra time effort to repair burred lines: overall overhead wires are more reliable than underground. Note that they put a lot of effort into tree trimming near their overhead wires, which made trees falling on them was a rare problem.
- friendzis 4y agoIf you want to really analyze this you have to look at outage distributions (both size and duration). High voltage line disconnecting and leaving half a city in the dark for an hour is weighted-outage-time equal to one town sitting without heating for a week. However, it would be quite hard to call such disconnections equal.
- jillesvangurp 4y agoCentralized grid instability is not going to stop new power generation from coming online. Decentralized power generation is what's already happening in countries with inadequate grids. People install batteries, solar, wind mills, generators etc. Anything they can do to mitigate against loss of power or unacceptably high prices for power. The more unstable the grid is, the more people do this. Just look at most of the developing world. There are lots of countries that never had much of a functioning grid where economic growth is creating demand that cannot be met by their electricity grid. In most of these places, people just go ahead and fix things themselves. And that increasingly means solar panels and batteries rather than expensive to operate generators. In the UK, and elsewhere, there are a lot of home owners that have solar on their roofs. The reason is not power outages but electricity prices. And with recent price spikes, more people are considering doing that all over the world. The whole assumption that most new generation has to come from the grid is increasingly less true. Both companies and consumers invest in cheaper private power generation. Especially companies have a big incentive to reduce their cost. The more power they need, the bigger the potential savings. And of course increased demand with a limited supply creates price spikes as well. We saw that in the last few years. This just speeds up the decentralization. Australia is a good example. About a third of the houses have solar panels already and the building codes are being updated to require solar panels for new construction and renovation projects. Millions of house holds generating tens of kwh every day is adding up to a lot of power. And a lot of it goes straight into the grid as well. Which adds to the instability. Lots more will be coming online in the next few years.
- jacquesm 4y agoRural Canada is also a good example. The grid is horrendously bad and it is pretty easy to outperform the grid reliability wise with a local solar/wind/battery setup. You might even go off-grid completely assuming a large enough battery and maybe a backup generator just in case.
- _hypx 4y agoInterestingly enough, Tesla just released their "Master Plan 3" which admits the need for hydrogen for seasonal energy storage and synthetic fuels. It doesn't admit the need for nuclear though. So we can see it as a first step to coming to reality, but it is not there yet. I bring this up because I am constantly annoyed by those who really haven't thought through their green energy dreams, and forget that compromises need to exist. These compromises actually have no serious penalties whatsoever BTW, it just requires a more complexity thinking process. And in this case, it means that there will be a lot of times where the solution is to build a gas turbine running on hydrogen, ammonia, synthetic fuels, etc., or build a nuclear reactor. Just piling up more and more renewables onto the grid isn't a solution. We are finally seeing some people come to reality on this, and I expect even further shifts to more realistic thinking in the future.
- concordDance 4y ago> These compromises actually have no serious penalties whatsoever BTW, it just requires a more complexity thinking process. Not entirely true, storage does cost money: https://www.energy.gov/sites/default/files/2019/07/f65/Storage%20Cost%20and%20Performance%20Characterization%20Report_Final.pdf https://www.energy.gov/sites/default/files/2019/07/f65/Stora... That said, as the tables in that report indicate its quite a complex topic. (By my back of the envelope maths switching UK to fully wind and storage would triple electricity prices)
- _hypx 4y agoRelative to the alternatives, it does not cost more money. You just need to accept the existence of hydrogen-based energy storage and perhaps synthetic fuels too. Cost will be the same or less as other energy storage ideas. And if you accept nuclear, you don’t even need much energy storage at all. Also, a big chunk of the “energy storage” solution is utilizing biofuels. Like in Germany where wood burning power plants are seen as green (hint: they’re not). Getting rid of this will be a huge boon. The compromise in question will have significant environmental benefits. It’s unfortunate that so many are blind to their own bad ideas and have not noticed the problems of biofuels.
- leoedin 4y agoGrid stability is essentially a different thing than local power availability. You lose your power if a tree falls on your power line, or if your local transformer fails. Sad for you, but completely unrelated to grid stability. Grid instability happens when load and supply are no longer matched. That's when serious things have to happen - load shedding and rolling blackouts. In the developed world we put a lot of money into avoiding this - pumped hydro, battery storage, fast response gas turbines, frequency control programs running with big industrial users, and (opt-in) load shedding of big industrial users. All so that power is available to an end user who needs it.
- zbrozek 4y agoAs someone living under PG&E, I'd love improvements to both. In the late summer we often lose power due to under-supply, in fall due to concern for fire, and in winter due to wind. In one recent month I was out of power for eight days in three tranches.
- fwlr 4y agoYeah, like I said it’s really hard to find representative data on grid stability. Local power outages will definitely overestimate grid instability by a lot, but it’s not entirely unrelated, it should capture ~most of grid stability issues (it is a gross over-estimate because maybe like 1%-5% of the total local power outage experienced is due to grid instability). So maybe the electrical grid is more like 5 or 6 nines.
- Reason077 4y ago> "speeding up the connection process risks damaging stability" The UK has transitioned to renewables perhaps faster than any other major economy in the past decade[1], yet has a very reliable and resilient grid[2]. [1] As recently as 2012, around 45% of the UK's electricity was generated from coal. Now it's almost zero, with the last coal power plants to close by 2025. In the same period, renewables have grown from <5% to over 40% of grid supply. [2] "Five 9s" transmission system reliability of supply nationally in 2021-22: https://www.nationalgrideso.com/industry-information/industry-data-and-reports/system-performance-reports https://www.nationalgrideso.com/industry-information/industr...
- ephbit 4y agoWell. I suppose this stability is mostly thanks to (A) natural gas and (B) biomass, aka wood pellets being burnt in former coal power plants. Those two basically replaced the coal that was phased out. See this plot: https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/electricity-production-by-source?time=2014..latest&country=~GBR https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/electricity-production-by... Agree, the speed of transition has been quite fast. As you can see in the following plot the UK started out at a rather low level of renewables. At this relatively low level the transition is probably easier than at higher levels. https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/share-of-electricity-production-from-renewable-sources?country=OWID_WRL~GBR~DEU~CHN~USA~JPN https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/share-of-electricity-prod... I'd guess the real challenge with grid stability will become more visible when grids all over the world reach some 2/3..3/4 of renewables.
- HPsquared 4y agoGood management must also be counted as a factor, I think. Whatever that entails.
- tialaramex 4y agoI don't think that chart really makes your case since it's measuring total production and on a total production basis it simply isn't true that gas and biomass replaced coal. If you pull that chart to its full timeline, over 200TWh of coal production existed, and it's essentially all gone now, but there isn't 200TWh of gas and biomass, in total they're maybe 140TWh. There is 60 TWh of wind power production. Now, in terms of capacity for instantaneous power, the Combined Cycle Gas Turbine plants probably do add up to similar capacity to older coal plants which were phased out, at least very close, but it's pretty rare for all that generation to actually be needed - this chart doesn't really show that. As to "transition" the countries which look "slower" on this chart are mostly using a lot of hydro, which is very different from wind or solar, as well as being readily available from the mid-20th century a point where solar and wind power were not really established options. So we're not talking about China having a bunch of wind turbines, then kicking back for a decade and only adding more recently, but instead their enormous country has hydro power, and now it also is adding wind turbines. The UK is a small island (and some other even smaller islands which are useful for wind but don't produce hydro power) and doesn't have vast majestic water bodies like Lake Mead, so hydro power has always been a tiny niche here, and that's all you're really looking at.
- IanCal 4y ago> One marker mentioned was “kerosene liters consumed”, as a proxy for how much lighting has been replaced by electricity, they note the amount dropped from 9 billion liters to 2 billion liters, which I take as a very rough indicator of ~80% grid reliability I don't think those are related at all. Someone without electrical infrastructure running to their village is going to burn fuel regardless of how reliable the grid would be.
- tshanmu 4y agoKerosene was subsidised heavily as it was used for cooking stoves widely. At some point kerosene subsidy was removed and people shifted to battery based backup systems/ lights etc. Electricity is unstable in large parts is my experience.
- dmurray 4y agoThe kerosene they are talking about was for burning in backup generators, not lamps. Grid power dwarfed that produced by local generators even when it was 9 billion litres. 80% stability isn't the right conclusion from this.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Reason077 4y ago> "At the turn of the century a couple of power plants a year might be connected ... new plants often using the same connections as old ones." It's still generally true that the old grid infrastructure is re-used. The UK has many closed coal, oil, gas, and nuclear power plants on or near the coast. When those plants are decommissioned or demolished, the grid infrastructure that was built for them (substations, transmission lines) is usually left intact. New off-shore wind farms can now use those access points, which greatly reduces the cost of connection compared to having to build everything from scratch.
- nindalf 4y agoIn theory yes, but the locations in the UK don’t coincide. The old coal plants were built nearer to consumption, most of which is in the South East of England. The planned wind farms are mostly in the North Sea, far from South East of England. It will cost billions to build the infra to connect the north with the south. It’s not a simple matter of reusing what exists.
- robin_reala 4y agoOK, but you left out the existing large wind farms, most of which were built right next to the south east of England, and presumably used the connections that OP was talking about. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_offshore_wind_farms_in_the_United_Kingdom#Map_of_the_UK_offshore_wind_farms https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_offshore_wind_farms_in...
- sokoloff 4y ago£50 per UK resident provides several billion. If it’s important enough, a few billion over the next 5 years to secure electricity needs isn’t actually a hurdle.
- simonh 4y agoYou can't address every problem like that. Those £50 a time would quickly add up. Also that's several hundred pounds per household right out of discretionary income.
- Synaesthesia 4y agoWe are facing a major crisis in South Africa where we used to have more than enough power, 30 years ago, but the government neglected the maintenance of the network, and now we cannot make enough electricity, nor even maintain the existing levels!
- Cthulhu_ 4y agoIt's happening elsewhere too; in NL, there's plenty of incentives to go green - cheap, subsidized solar, hard push from the EU to transition to electric vehicles in less than a decade , etc - but the grid capacity just isn't able to keep up, even with multi-billion investments, which results in some businesses not getting a connection to the grid or new green energy projects being delayed. Which is more an inconvenience than a problem for the general population, but still. The other thing that's happening is that while the energy companies, with help / subsidies from the local and EU government, build large offshore wind parks and the like, at the same time the capacity is bought up by large new datacenters from the likes of Microsoft and Google, meaning that they don't actually replace grey energy sources. Said datacenters also use up drinking water for cooling, for some reason.
- mistrial9 4y agosuper-wealthy polluters claiming that it is "too hard" to go green ?
- marricks 4y ago> capacity is bought up by large new datacenters from the likes of Microsoft and Google That is surprising but also makes a lot of sense. Companies go for the already built cheaper option to maintain that they’re going green while taking it from others! That’s actually kind of harmful and they should have to pay for building energy if they want the moral credit for it.
- marsven_422 4y ago[dead]
- inglor_cz 4y ago
- ZeroGravitas 4y agoPeople are so wedded to fossil fuel religion, they'd rather pretend their country is entirely incapable of the most basic tasks. China isn't playing by the pretend limitations you put on yourself and it looks like you've already admitted they deserve to be the new hegemon. Yay for totalitarian communism I guess. The stat that 80% of the UK queue might be effectively domain squatters with no actual project waiting to flip to real developers is shocking. Pure rent seeking middlemen. Though at the same time, it means all the other stats are BS. Like saying that a concert is sold out and there's no way to get a ticket until the next time they visit in 5 years time because 80% have been sold to scalper's bots. It just doesn't logically add up. The tickets are available, you just need to pay a markup to a scalper who performs no real service to society.
- Gigachad 4y agoLol yeah, I read the title thinking “yeah obviously, nothing at population wide scale is a simple task”. It’s a good thing we are pretty good at performing all kinds of not simple tasks and have been for a very long time.
- aziaziazi 4y ago> have been for a very long time Aren’t we good at this especially since fossils fuels ?
- inglor_cz 4y ago"Yay for totalitarian communism I guess" Unless the government in its infinite wisdom decides to exterminate all sparrows or so and causes a countrywide famine, I guess... Some of the limitations are pretend, but some are very real. European countries in general want their grid to be stable and reliable, and the surges and dips of power that come from "too much sun" or "too much wind", or lack of either, are going against it. On the other hand, India, mentioned in the article, has so many blackouts already that it can cope with some extra instability. Of course, the unreliability of the grid contributes to the reluctance of foreign investors to build industrial plants in India, which is a major downside, but hey, they can alter their grid faster.
- mike_hock 4y agoThis can tip the scale in favor of efuels (as opposed to battery-electric). Just run the electrolysis straight from a windfarm and produce at the rate the windfarm is currently outputting.
- fsh 4y agoThe very low efficiency of e-fuels probably more than outweighs the cost of upgrading the grid. They will be important for sustainable aviation, but anywhere else they don't appear to be economically feasible.
- bradfa 4y agoThis is what’s currently happening. It’s windy in some remote places. Connecting those places to the grid is horribly expensive but building a chemical plant there isn’t. That’s the locations where efuels are being made today. Like the Porsche project in Chile. https://newsroom.porsche.com/en/2022/company/porsche-highly-innovative-fuels-hif-opening-efuels-pilot-plant-haru-oni-chile-synthetic-fuels-30732.html https://newsroom.porsche.com/en/2022/company/porsche-highly-...
- pjc50 4y agoAn idea that sounds good, but has the problem that efuel production capital expenditure is fixed and high. So once you've built it, you want to run it 24/7 rather than intermittently. I'm very much open to suggestions for "low capex ways to make productive use of 'spare' electricity, preferably reversibly even if efficiency is low".
- mikewarot 4y agoJust as with nuclear power reactors, I hope that we can develop standard transformer modules that would reduce the need for "one off" production, and utilize the economies of scale that modern manufacturing is capable of delivering. Smaller standard designs would make it easier to handle disruptions, make a power grid more resilient in the face of natural or man-made disaster. It would also make it easier to scale. Having a power grid with interchangeable parts would reduce the logistical complexity of spares management.
- Gud 4y agoThere are already standardized transformer sizes(e. g. 40MVA). Electrical transmission is pretty standardized already IMO.
- mschuster91 4y agoThe problem is that large scale transformers are expensive to produce which means that it makes no sense to keep stockpiles for a disaster case. Usually that calculation works out, as most electricity grids, even on the low-voltage distribution level, are meshed enough to tolerate one or sometimes two large-scale transformers going offline. You get into problems though if more of these transformers go offline - e.g. because someone shoots them with rifles or artillery - because the lead time is weeks to months. And completely forget about a nuclear EMP scenario... it would probably take a decade to recover from that.
- WJW 4y agoTransformer protection equipment is quick enough to disconnect them in case of an EMP, it's usually the control electronics that are identified in vulnerability studies as the weakest link. Those have a much shorter lead time than the multi-ton copper parts and are also much easier to have a stockpile of.
- pjc50 4y agoThey are standardized, they're just not "mass produced" due to difficulties in automation at that size. I suspect transformer production could be ramped up if the manufacturers were convinced that it wasn't just a temporary blip.
- Glench 4y agoIn the US grid capacity doubled from 1960-1970 and doubled again from 1970-1980. We can do it again :)
- DoneWithAllThat 4y agoDid you actually read the article, or did you just want to say something to try and force fit reality to your preferred narrative?
- bryanlarsen 4y agoDid you? There is nothing in the article to refute the parents really good point. Doubling the size of the grid was not easy any of the other times it happened. It was hard then, but it got done.
- MichaelZuo 4y agoExcept there has been a vast increase in paperwork and potential liabilities since the 1970s.
- bombcar 4y agoWhen the problem gets "big" enough paperwork and liabilities get bypassed; it just needs the political will to force something through. It's happened multiple times in history and it will happen again. In fact, if the only real problems are paperwork and liabilities; the problem is basically solved; it's so solved that we're fretting over details.
- mywittyname 4y agoI think part of the problem is that there's a segment of the American population that doesn't want the grid to expand. They get to point to the grid as a excuse to curb EV adoption. And all politicians have to do is nothing to make it happen. If the options were expand the grid, or give up air conditioning, you can damn well bet the politic winds would hit hurricane speeds.
- goodpoint 4y agoLet's not forget that solar panels or roofs and local batteries (EV cars) *reduces* load on the grid. Hyperlocal power generation does that.
- aziaziazi 4y agoIn theory and absolute metrics, yes. As you said “clean” energy is associated with “clean” consumption, meaning more EV, electric heating, etc. Those local power generations helps supporting the growing needs for electricity but don’t change much to the currently running industry and residential usages (oven, dryer…)
- goodpoint 4y agoThere isn't a growing need, at best it's a want.
- donkeyd 4y agoAt my current company we're working on one of the problems involved in this in much of the developed world. Actually coming to the point where you can lay power lines is a huge issue that has to do with figuring out property ownership, the stuff that's already in the ground, water ways, roads, trees and more. People work months on finding a route that's actually possible and that sometimes involves paying a lot to property owners for using their land. Right now we're creating a tool that gives the engineers insight into all these factors and automatically creates possible routes through all this madness. It's quite interesting to work on and fascinating to learn about all these complexities. It also doesn't scale well, we're building this for the Netherlands, which has a lot of centralized, (mostly) open data that can be used. In other countries that's not so much true.
- eppp 4y agoWhy shouldn't the property owners be paid for a profit taking enterprise to functionally steal their land? I understand that it has to be done to make the world work but it absolutely disproportionally effects rural people while the benefits go to the urban areas. This is one of those situations where a percentage of those gains flow back into the rural areas.
- randommuser 4y agoI don’t think he said they shouldn’t get paid. He is just saying that sometimes the best solution/route is over private property where the owner gets paid.
- donkeyd 4y agoCorrect. It's also not just about the money, it also takes a lot of time and adds a large amount of uncertainty to a project. Not every owner is willing to comply, causing an entire route to have to be reconsidered, which takes a lot of time. Eminent domain is pretty much never used, because judges (in my country) will pretty much always side with the property owner, unless the utility can proof that there's really no other way (which they almost never can). So on a 10km+ route with hundreds of properties, multiple municipalities or other public organizations and other utilities, this gets really complicated really quickly.
- dghughes 4y agoHere in Canada my province went through a hurricane last Sept. I was without power for 10 days. Much of the problems were due to poor maintenance; trees not trimmed, old poles not replaced, transformers old, salt spray on wires, etc. But the parent company crowed each year of profits and dividends. They also raised rates 5% to 10% each year claiming they had no money. Solar would help but we also need a stable grid. But even with solar my local government doesn't even allow the use of battery storage in homes batteries can only go in garages.
- defrost 4y agoI'm in Western Australia which like South Australia is a state with a very high solar | renewable input to our grid. We're currently rolling out required remote management to remotely disable rooftop input on high solar input low demand days and likely to see a future where batteries are larger, isolated (for fire | emergancy), and serving local clusters of ~ 200 homes moreso than every home having batteries. There's an efficiency and robustness at that cluster size.
- paranoidrobot 4y agoI understand the need for grid stability, but just deciding "Nah, we'll turn off solar production en-masse" seems like it's not the best solution. Long distance HVDC runs are apparently now so good that it is commercially feasible to drop a few million solar panels outside of Darwin, and run an under-sea HVDC cable to Singapore. Why there's apparently no push to hook up WA to the rest of the national grid, I don't know. It would seem to be a great way to shift power from solar and wind between the east/west and help match up demand and production more.
- prottog 4y ago> Long distance HVDC runs are apparently now so good that it is commercially feasible to drop a few million solar panels outside of Darwin, and run an under-sea HVDC cable to Singapore. Whoa, that's impressive. Do you know what the per-mile cost would be? The great circle distance from Darwin, NT to Singapore is a little over 2000 miles; call it 2500 to account for routing around the intervening islands and such. Though I'm not sure that Darwin is the best place to drop a few million solar panels, considering its stormy climate. A few hundred miles south towards the desert, maybe ;-)
- dcj4 4y agoIt's an outright trivial task.
- halhod 4y agoHN may be interested in the rest of the special report, which is here https://www.economist.com/technology-quarterly/2023-04-08 https://www.economist.com/technology-quarterly/2023-04-08
- 8bitsrule 4y agoExcellent series - one author, very broad and insightful.
- specialist 4y agoNice survey of challenges. For follow ups, deep dives on the manufacturing of grid hardware and software would be cool. For a (mostly) US perspective, check out David Roberts' Volts, "a newsletter about clean energy and politics". https://www.volts.wft https://www.volts.wft Links below to episodes specifically about grids. But since our grid is the elephant in the room, it's touched on in most episodes. My noob TLDR for USA is: Overlapping jurisdictions are a huge roadblock. To build new capacity, you likely need permits and buy off from every state, county, property owner, and special interest touched. There's no federal plan to reform our currently siloed systems. Build Back Better addressed this. But because the Inflation Reduction Act was passed thru "reconciliation", it doesn't contain those "third leg" of necessary reforms. Huge disappointment. Predictably, progress is being further stymied by a huge reactionary anti-electrification noise machine. All the usual suspects are dumping money into astroturf groups and propaganda to oppose anything and everything, from windmills to induction stoves. NIMBYs have weaponized environmental regulations, created in response to past abuses, to thwart progress. Just like how "the internet treats censorship as damage and routes around it", reformers and innovators are finding alternatives. Stuff like: colocating generation with consumers (industrial heat), embracing geothermal, and beefing up existing grids with storage. -- Transmission week: why we need more big power lines https://www.volts.wtf/p/transmission-week-why-we-need-more#details https://www.volts.wtf/p/transmission-week-why-we-need-more#d... Transmission week: how to start building more big power lines https://www.volts.wtf/p/transmission-week-how-to-start-building#details https://www.volts.wtf/p/transmission-week-how-to-start-build... Transmission fortnight: burying power lines next to rail & roads to make a national transmission grid https://www.volts.wtf/p/transmission-fortnight-burying-power#details https://www.volts.wtf/p/transmission-fortnight-burying-power... Transmission month: how to make the existing grid work better https://www.volts.wtf/p/transmission-month-how-to-make-the#details https://www.volts.wtf/p/transmission-month-how-to-make-the#d... Transmission month: two more ideas to quickly boost the transmission grid https://www.volts.wtf/p/transmission-month-two-more-ideas#details https://www.volts.wtf/p/transmission-month-two-more-ideas#de... The challenges of building transmission in the US, and how to overcome them, with Liza Reed https://www.volts.wtf/p/volts-podcast-the-challenges-of-building#details https://www.volts.wtf/p/volts-podcast-the-challenges-of-buil... What's up with Manchin's plan to reform energy permitting? https://www.volts.wtf/p/whats-up-with-manchins-plan-to-reform#details https://www.volts.wtf/p/whats-up-with-manchins-plan-to-refor... [Bay Area] Peninsula Clean Energy attempts to achieve 24/7 clean energy https://www.volts.wtf/p/an-energy-provider-attempts-to-achieve#details https://www.volts.wtf/p/an-energy-provider-attempts-to-achie... Utilities are lobbying against the public interest. Here's how to stop it. https://www.volts.wtf/p/utilities-are-lobbying-against-the#details https://www.volts.wtf/p/utilities-are-lobbying-against-the#d...
- hcurtiss 4y agoI used to be a permitting attorney. My wife is presently a prominent permitting attorney who works on linear transmission corridor projects at a large firm. Unless we change the permitting process, and several federal environmental laws in particular, we will never realize even a fraction of the capacity required to hit our renewables goals. We can’t get a single new line across the cascades in Oregon, much less the dozens that will be required. Tidal energy faces the same issues vis-à-vis the load centers on the other side of the coast range.
- nostrademons 4y agoThere will probably be a lot of pressure to change the permitting process in the near future. Power outages, along with rising prices, are one of the events that most reliably get politicians thrown out of office.
- CodeWriter23 4y agoThey'll just blame the 'greedy' energy companies for societies woes.
- pascalxus 4y agohere in CA, the CPUC is trying their best to prevent people from adding Solar to their roofs. They've even got rid of Net metering almost entirely with their new NEM 3 rules.
- function_seven 4y agoNet Metering was a subsidy to encourage solar growth at a time when it wasn't nearly as prevalent as it is now. It's not the "natural" way of metering solar-equipped homes. (Assuming there is any "natural" way at all). Now that solar is cheap enough to support itself without subsidy, the math is changing at the grid connection. Everyone is producing gobs of power in the middle of the day, and just expecting the grid to take anything they can't use onsite. Then in the early evening, it all reverses quickly and the demands on the grid quickly flip. In my mind, a connection to the grid should pay per kWh for two things: generation and transportation. When I pull power from the grid, I pay for both of those things. I pay to have those watts generated, and I pay to have them sent to me. When I push power onto the grid, I am paid for the generation. I do not get paid to send it to wherever it goes, that's someone else paying that part.