7 ms·
We've entered the lawless "Golden Age" phase of generative AI, sort of like sampling in the 80s and early 90s — IP be damned, tech über alles, full speed ahead.
by CharlesW 4y ago
We've entered the lawless "Golden Age" phase of generative AI, sort of like sampling in the 80s and early 90s — IP be damned, tech über alles, full speed ahead.
AI has already begun eating the livelihoods of artists and other creators. It starts with defenestrating the defenseless starving kind, but will quickly progress up the value chain until it hits bone in the form of already-mounting legal resistance from apex creators and the corporate owners of the content without which the generative models would be impotent.
Interesting time ahead.
- Dalewyn 4y agoI commend the likes of Adobe for providing training models that can stand up to legal scrutiny. The more anarchist parts of the "AI" community (which is to say the majority of it) will very likely be in for a rude reckoning if they don't become civilized. Society can live without "AI", much less "AI" with no respect for peoples' properties.
- recursive_loops 4y agoBut suppose the government dropped the hammer and banned any AI. Is it even possible to enforce? It kind of seems like the genie is out of the bottle here.
- hn_throwaway_99 4y agoWe enforce copyright law, even though the actual act of copying is technologically trivially easy these days.
- tablespoon 4y ago>> But suppose the government dropped the hammer and banned any AI. Is it even possible to enforce? It kind of seems like the genie is out of the bottle here. > We enforce copyright law, even though the actual act of copying is technologically trivially easy these days. Exactly. Many software engineers have this weird misunderstanding of law that seems to come from misapplying mathematical standards to the legal system. A law isn't a fucking proof, it doesn't have to be 100% airtight, completely preventing all cases of the undesired behavior to work and be valuable.
- pixl97 4y ago>We enforce copyright law Eh... "enforce-ish" I'll make up an analogy on how we enforce it. Imagine that you're watching a bunch of unruly kids on a playground and you have a strict 'no violence' set of rules. The problem is all these children are straight out of hell and just love hitting each other as much as possible. You'd be physically worn out trying to cover lessor acts of violence your actual rule is "If there is bloodshed there is punishment" That is more how enforcement of copyright actually works. You really, really have to screw up pretty big time for it to be enforced. Now imagine the "Copyright Absurdism Universe". This is a place where any copyright infringement is immediately detectable by magic the moment it occurs. Do you think this universe would have anything even close to the laws we have? I do not believe so at all. Effectively it would cause society to fall apart very quickly since society and civilization are built on the sharing of all kinds of ideas including language and imagery where any form of copyright maximalism would cause people to be afraid to use any new ideas for fear of being fined by the owner of said ideas.
- waboremo 4y agoIt's very possible to enforce when you realize most AI stems from a very select bunch of platforms, and even "rogue" AI makers rely on these choke points. In the current stage, enforcing a ban against current AI tools would be quite devastating. For clarity, I'm not in favor of banning, just that we're still a very long way away from the genie being out of the bottle here. Maybe within the next 5 years if pace keeps up.
- blibble 4y agogovernment could force nvidia/amd to add circuitry to their products to detect the linear algebra operations and slow down in the same way it was done for crypto on gamers cards of course this doesn't fix china but they don't have the technology anyway due to sanctions
- staunton 4y ago> they don't have the technology anyway due to sanctions that won't be true for long
- ronsor 4y agoThe same way it was done for crypto and then cracked not long after?
- BeFlatXIII 4y ago> they don't have the technology anyway due to sanctions As if they don't use shell buyers.
- blibble 4y agotheres like 3 EUV machines made over a 3 year period made by one company (ASML) if you aren't Intel, TSMC or Samsung you aint getting one
- MichaelZuo 4y agoI think the parent is implying that someone in Vietnam or Kazakhstan could just buy the finished product and drive across the border. So the restriction is effectively an inconvenient tax.
- blibble 4y agohow does that help if the finished product has been made to detect LLM workloads in hardware and slow down?
- carlosjobim 4y ago> Is it even possible to enforce? Not a chance. But it can be added to the list of laws that everybody breaks all the time, that can come in handy when law enforcement wants to get you for other reasons.
- pca006132 4y agoYou can't even draw a clean line between AI and optimization, so I don't think it is possible to enforce.
- brookst 4y agoIt’s next to impossible to ban outcomes. That’s why the idiotic war on drugs is all about banning ingredients for drugs, and still doesn’t work. The only practical way to ban AI is to ban the hardware that makes it possible. Maybe ban silicon with more than X transistors, or ban clusters with more than Y total transistors. It would be dumb and would not work (you can still AI on a one CPU, just very slowly). But that would be the angle prohibitionists would have to take.
- antifa 4y agoMaybe this actually a good idea, then "AI" companies will say things like "It's not AI, it's Machine Learning" instead of everyone claiming everything they do is AI.
- logicchains 4y ago>Society can live without "AI", much less "AI" with no respect for peoples' properties IP is not real property; it's fundamentally different in an economic sense. If you have an apple and I steal it from you, you can no longer consume that apple. If you have poem and I make a copy of it, you still can consume (read) the poem. The notion of IP is fundamentally incompatible with a free society, because it necessitates a huge apparatus for violence and surveillance such that if Bob memorises your poem and tells it to his friend without your permission you're able to notice this and punish Bob for doing so.
- LiquidPolymer 4y agoThis is fundamentally incorrect. I'd also wager that more than 50% of the commenters on here benefit from robust IP protection.
- AlexandrB 4y agoWhile this is true, 100% of the commenters here also give up a "natural" right to copy certain information for robust IP protection. At the extreme end, this can result in absurdities like the attempt to ban dissemination of the DeCSS key for DVDs.
- EntrePrescott 4y ago> give up a "natural" right to copy certain information Practical as it may be, that's not a natural right but merely a physical possibility. More generally, the concept of natural rights - except for a very narrow niche of special subjects closely centered on the individual's own life and bodily autonomy - is a shortcut to total subjectivity at best. And even for that very narrow niche, the "rights" part is a normative civilizational convention/construct, whereas nature conspicuously ignores such "rights" (as do humans for the most part when it comes to other species)
- chrismsimpson 4y agoMany here benefit from the industry and economy associated with IP, only a very small few actually benefit from ownership of IP.
- anonylizard 4y agoIt is magical thinking to think 'the government' can stop a truly revolutionary technology. No, the technology will change the government, not the other way around. AI is not the internet, not the mobile phone, not social media, it is the printing press, it is the horse. The roman empire and its legions were replaced by feudal kingdoms and knights. The knights, armed with massive improvements in horse-breeding, saddles and horseshoes, became massively more powerful than previous types of soldiers. 500 knights, plus 10000 peasants, would have demolished a roman legion of 10000 expert and well paid soldiers. Thus knights became their own social class, trained in warfare since childhood. Civilian based militaries absolutely could not compete, so societies moved away from imperial bureaucracies, into aristocratic courts. AI will be the same. People who use AI intensely, will be far more productive than those who don't, and don't think politicians will be able to stop this. Trump merely mastered social media, and it made him the president, you have no idea how powerful a politician who fully exploits AI will be. AI should be regulated, and people's livelihoods should be compensated to an extent. But if you think 'society can live without AI', then you'll soon find a changed society that can live without you. The rude reckoning will come for the people who think they can just regulate or ignore AI away, the wise know there's no turning back, and its time to surf the tsunami, for good or bad.
- majormajor 4y agoMy issue with these projections is that they're so wildly ambitious yet so vague. What does "mastering AI" look like to you? Do you mean "mastering the generative language/image/video models we have today?" Are you expecting further massive leaps in capabilities and mean to refer specifically to people who master those? You compare it to knights and horses, yet "hard power" technologies like that have obvious aspects that today's "AI mastery" doesn't. (As an aside, I lose track of your telling of history, it seems like you're saying knights replaced Roman Legions but also that they made civilian militaries obsolete, but you also say those legions were "expert and well paid soldiers" already?) I'd also expect a lot of things to be more "reinforcing" effects vs "generating" effects. Trump, for instance, was already famous as both a big businessman and a television personality; lots of other people "merely" mastered social media and "only" got a bunch of money for it. Could Trump have become President before Twitter? Reagan did it... it took a slightly different path back then, but being famous is a REALLY BIG starting point.
- SanderNL 4y ago"Society" cannot, because capitalism. If you want to stay in business internationally that is. Curious to see how we are going to compete without AI.
- brigadier132 4y ago> Society can live without "AI" Much in the same way society could live without electricity or the personal computer.
- JohnFen 4y agoElectricity and computers are now deeply embedded into our society. AI isn't. Yet, anyway. So yes -- right now, if all AI vanished overnight, we'd be just fine.
- MichaelZuo 4y agoEven if electricity and computers vanished overnight, humans won't just keel over tomorrow.
- JohnFen 4y agoHumans won't go extinct -- but a lot of people would certainly suffer and die, at least in the nations that have become dependent on them. For instance, if electricity and/or computers vanished tonight, store shelves would be empty of food in just a handful of days.
- qikInNdOutReply 4y agoSurely, consequences of copying will hit china any day now. And when the streaming industry collapses, the music labels will recover. This lawless local optimum for the masses, that is the market, will give way to a guild free monopoly. Any day now.
- stuckinhell 4y agoWhose society and properties? Corporations ? I'm asking because many corporations push copyright extension when it benefits (Disney) and then fight patents when it helps them too. A famous supreme court case Alice Corp. v CLS Bank nternational should be looked at. https://www.wipo.int/wipo_magazine/en/2019/04/article_0006.html https://www.wipo.int/wipo_magazine/en/2019/04/article_0006.h... Major tech companies like Google and Amazon wrote amicus briefs that were AGAINST patents because they had the money and power to stomp on the little guys. "Civilized" really has no meaning when laws are bent constantly by corporations.
- BeFlatXIII 4y agoThat's why it's important for lawless AI to be freely distributed. It may be legally banned, but it'll still be used widely.
- zirgs 4y agoOur current copyright laws are too aggressive already so why should I stop doing things that are legal just because some copyright activist demands me to? They impose a century long copyright terms on me, and then have the audacity to demand me to stop training the AI to imitate the style of their movies - which is legal to do.
- tomjen3 4y agoDo you think this will stop China from producing AI? The choice we have isn't to live with or without AI, it is to build AI or be crushed by it.
- yourapostasy 4y ago> Interesting time ahead. I’m waiting for when The Mouse thinks some fractional percentage of generative AI-produced art infringes their copyrights sufficiently to take to court. With this generation of AI, “fair use” can be sliced and diced quite fine.
- xwdv 4y agoI thought the mouse already came after someone that was producing copyright infringing T-Shirts and selling them?
- xg15 4y agoMy suspicion is that they are currently staying silent and observing the field because they are interested in using the tech themselves. It would be kinda dumb to create a precidence which might paint yourself into a corner later on.
- zirgs 4y agoYou don't need an AI for that.
- blagie 4y agoI'm not quite sure of the impact of AI on any particular industry. Generative AI reduces costs and increases efficiency and means that I use a lot more art than I used to. I can develop better software systems faster too. Does this mean fewer jobs, or more / better systems get built, where the bank teller has something as smooth as an Apple consumer app? It all depends on a bunch of economics curves I have no idea the shape of. One concern I have is capital costs: Up to now, a lot of these industries were a pathway to socioeconomic mobility. If jobs require a $1M farm of GPUs, they will become a lot more exclusive, and move value from labor to capital.
- JohnFen 4y ago> If jobs require a $1M farm of GPUs, they will become a lot more exclusive, and move value from labor to capital. Isn't hat move going to happen regardless of how much or little the hardware costs?
- blagie 4y agoUp to this point, anyone anywhere in the world could buy a $100 notebook computer (~1/3 years' income for much of the world), take a few courses in Python or JavaScript, and find work for ~$10k. Although this impacted a small minority, it gave nearly 100% of the people in the world a pathway to socioeconomic mobility. Although only a tiny portion of people will do that, this has a disproportionate impact; many of these pathways expand exponentially once started for a whole slew of reasons. In other words, moving from mainframes to cheap PCs was democratizing. This is potentially a major reversion.
- stuckinhell 4y agoA major difference now is that USA imperial power is on the decline. It will no longer be able to bully other countries into accepting its copyright laws. History doesn't repeat but it sure rhymes.
- wordpad25 4y agoI'm sorry, but who's there to challenge USA hegemony? China which is facing a massive economy crisis on the verge of recession/depression. EU just lost UK. Russia is... well, they officially made it legal to pirate western content, guess you got me there.
- stuckinhell 4y agoThe USA has an economic crisis on its hands as well. Also USA Hegemony starts with the Dollar. That is already starting to crumble amid developing economies' shift to other currencies for settlements. Russia, India, China, Brazil, Saudi Arabia etc are all ditching the dollar for trade. They all keep dollars in reserve for trading,but now that they are ditching it, Those dollars aren't needed and will return to America causing inflation or some other crisis. https://www.barrons.com/news/china-brazil-strike-deal-to-ditch-dollar-for-trade-8ed4e799 https://www.barrons.com/news/china-brazil-strike-deal-to-dit... Then you have follow on effects such Saudi's decision to cut oil. https://www.npr.org/2023/04/03/1167824124/saudi-arabia-oil-production-cuts-gas-prices-energy-markets https://www.npr.org/2023/04/03/1167824124/saudi-arabia-oil-p...
- 93po 4y ago> AI has already begun eating the livelihoods of artists and other creators. Corporations have been sucking artists dry for more than a hundred years. I think artists are better situated than ever to make a livelihood from their efforts, and would be much more so if not for the entire live performance industry being sucked dry by ticketmaster.