11 ms·
AI is coming for voice actors?
- brucethemoose2 4y ago> giving producers the tools to recreate their favourite voices on demand, without the performer’s knowledge or consent and without additional compensation Well thats just stupid when they can create original voices instead. TBH I am stoked about this, as I am sick of AAAs wasting the talent of good VAs with bad writing. Indies and modders will have access to affordable VA now.
- TigeriusKirk 4y agoI believe there's already a Fallout 4 mod making extensive use of this tech to greatly increase the number of dialogue options.
- CharlesW 4y agoWe've entered the lawless "Golden Age" phase of generative AI, sort of like sampling in the 80s and early 90s — IP be damned, tech über alles, full speed ahead. AI has already begun eating the livelihoods of artists and other creators. It starts with defenestrating the defenseless starving kind, but will quickly progress up the value chain until it hits bone in the form of already-mounting legal resistance from apex creators and the corporate owners of the content without which the generative models would be impotent. Interesting time ahead.
- Dalewyn 4y agoI commend the likes of Adobe for providing training models that can stand up to legal scrutiny. The more anarchist parts of the "AI" community (which is to say the majority of it) will very likely be in for a rude reckoning if they don't become civilized. Society can live without "AI", much less "AI" with no respect for peoples' properties.
- recursive_loops 4y agoBut suppose the government dropped the hammer and banned any AI. Is it even possible to enforce? It kind of seems like the genie is out of the bottle here.
- hn_throwaway_99 4y agoWe enforce copyright law, even though the actual act of copying is technologically trivially easy these days.
- tablespoon 4y ago>> But suppose the government dropped the hammer and banned any AI. Is it even possible to enforce? It kind of seems like the genie is out of the bottle here. > We enforce copyright law, even though the actual act of copying is technologically trivially easy these days. Exactly. Many software engineers have this weird misunderstanding of law that seems to come from misapplying mathematical standards to the legal system. A law isn't a fucking proof, it doesn't have to be 100% airtight, completely preventing all cases of the undesired behavior to work and be valuable.
- pixl97 4y ago>We enforce copyright law Eh... "enforce-ish" I'll make up an analogy on how we enforce it. Imagine that you're watching a bunch of unruly kids on a playground and you have a strict 'no violence' set of rules. The problem is all these children are straight out of hell and just love hitting each other as much as possible. You'd be physically worn out trying to cover lessor acts of violence your actual rule is "If there is bloodshed there is punishment" That is more how enforcement of copyright actually works. You really, really have to screw up pretty big time for it to be enforced. Now imagine the "Copyright Absurdism Universe". This is a place where any copyright infringement is immediately detectable by magic the moment it occurs. Do you think this universe would have anything even close to the laws we have? I do not believe so at all. Effectively it would cause society to fall apart very quickly since society and civilization are built on the sharing of all kinds of ideas including language and imagery where any form of copyright maximalism would cause people to be afraid to use any new ideas for fear of being fined by the owner of said ideas.
- yourapostasy 4y ago> Interesting time ahead. I’m waiting for when The Mouse thinks some fractional percentage of generative AI-produced art infringes their copyrights sufficiently to take to court. With this generation of AI, “fair use” can be sliced and diced quite fine.
- xwdv 4y agoI thought the mouse already came after someone that was producing copyright infringing T-Shirts and selling them?
- xg15 4y agoMy suspicion is that they are currently staying silent and observing the field because they are interested in using the tech themselves. It would be kinda dumb to create a precidence which might paint yourself into a corner later on.
- zirgs 4y agoYou don't need an AI for that.
- blagie 4y agoI'm not quite sure of the impact of AI on any particular industry. Generative AI reduces costs and increases efficiency and means that I use a lot more art than I used to. I can develop better software systems faster too. Does this mean fewer jobs, or more / better systems get built, where the bank teller has something as smooth as an Apple consumer app? It all depends on a bunch of economics curves I have no idea the shape of. One concern I have is capital costs: Up to now, a lot of these industries were a pathway to socioeconomic mobility. If jobs require a $1M farm of GPUs, they will become a lot more exclusive, and move value from labor to capital.
- JohnFen 4y ago> If jobs require a $1M farm of GPUs, they will become a lot more exclusive, and move value from labor to capital. Isn't hat move going to happen regardless of how much or little the hardware costs?
- blagie 4y agoUp to this point, anyone anywhere in the world could buy a $100 notebook computer (~1/3 years' income for much of the world), take a few courses in Python or JavaScript, and find work for ~$10k. Although this impacted a small minority, it gave nearly 100% of the people in the world a pathway to socioeconomic mobility. Although only a tiny portion of people will do that, this has a disproportionate impact; many of these pathways expand exponentially once started for a whole slew of reasons. In other words, moving from mainframes to cheap PCs was democratizing. This is potentially a major reversion.
- stuckinhell 4y agoA major difference now is that USA imperial power is on the decline. It will no longer be able to bully other countries into accepting its copyright laws. History doesn't repeat but it sure rhymes.
- wordpad25 4y agoI'm sorry, but who's there to challenge USA hegemony? China which is facing a massive economy crisis on the verge of recession/depression. EU just lost UK. Russia is... well, they officially made it legal to pirate western content, guess you got me there.
- stuckinhell 4y agoThe USA has an economic crisis on its hands as well. Also USA Hegemony starts with the Dollar. That is already starting to crumble amid developing economies' shift to other currencies for settlements. Russia, India, China, Brazil, Saudi Arabia etc are all ditching the dollar for trade. They all keep dollars in reserve for trading,but now that they are ditching it, Those dollars aren't needed and will return to America causing inflation or some other crisis. https://www.barrons.com/news/china-brazil-strike-deal-to-ditch-dollar-for-trade-8ed4e799 https://www.barrons.com/news/china-brazil-strike-deal-to-dit... Then you have follow on effects such Saudi's decision to cut oil. https://www.npr.org/2023/04/03/1167824124/saudi-arabia-oil-production-cuts-gas-prices-energy-markets https://www.npr.org/2023/04/03/1167824124/saudi-arabia-oil-p...
- 93po 4y ago> AI has already begun eating the livelihoods of artists and other creators. Corporations have been sucking artists dry for more than a hundred years. I think artists are better situated than ever to make a livelihood from their efforts, and would be much more so if not for the entire live performance industry being sucked dry by ticketmaster.
- Spivak 4y ago"Humans should do now useless work that can be done for fractions of a cent on a machine" is a capitalism problem not an AI problem. Can you imagine how cool the future is going to be where 1 dev shops can have the voice acting chops previously reserved for big budget AAA games? If AI art in whatever form it takes is just as good as the human made then we're golden. If it's worse but cheap enough that some choose it then they never actually wanted quality, cheaper was just never on offer before.
- wlesieutre 4y agoEven AAA games could go back to having more dialogue choices than (1) be paragon of goodness or (2) be an enormous asshole
- Blackthorn 4y agoI'd love to go back to written scripts in RPGs instead of voice acting, honestly. Morrowind over the games that came later. The lack of dialog really hurts RPG.
- danso 4y agoThe voice acting in Fallout New Vegas was excellent. Obviously having only written dialog is much cheaper to produce. But I think the bottleneck will ultimately be how many hours are allocated to the writers and designers (e.g. making branching conversations)
- wlesieutre 4y agoAI will be a huge force multiplier for NPC writing as well
- CuriouslyC 4y agoThe problem isn't voice acting, it's bad voice acting that takes longer than reading the text. Judicious use of good voice acting is engaging and adds value.
- yieldcrv 4y agoPeople rationalize about convincing themselves about how the jobs wont go away. But I think this is an overcorrection, yes, people with existing ongoing employment might keep it, with no grand layoff happening. yes, AI will be a tool that employed people use. But what I think is missing from that is how the job openings just wont appear. People on the job wont feel that they need more headcount. People with a project will just keep doing everything themselves until they reach greater friction, and that is close and closer to the end of the project. This is functionally the same outcome.
- boringuser2 4y agoThis is a good point. We're definitely not hiring anymore now. Ever.
- rootusrootus 4y agoGo to any large corporation and notice just how huge the fraction of dead weight is, and well before AI disrupts anything. The entire career goal of a manager is to increase the size of his fiefdom. I don't think he's going to stop hiring.
- nemo44x 4y ago> People on the job wont feel that they need more headcount That’s never stopped VPs and Directors from growing their departments as much as possible. I think a lot of the layoffs we are seeing today is some of that excess over the last few years.
- felipeerias 4y agoNon-scalable jobs have been usually considered safer career paths, as they are less vulnerable to “winner takes all” effects. Dentistry is a typical example of a non-scalable job: no matter how good an individual dentist becomes at their job, they will still only be able to serve one customer at a time. On the other hand, software engineering is a scalable job: the code developed by a software engineer can potentially serve many customers simultaneously. For this reason, it often exhibits “winner takes all” situations. AI will turn many non-scalable, safe jobs into scalable, risky, potentially redundant ones.
- aaron695 4y agoThis is a good example of not replacement but explosion of new. This will allow programable speech. Like LaTeX for video If you want to change your 30 min YouTube video/online lectures voice over, it's a 10 second change and recompile. More importantly people can work on seamless dubbing for Netflix etc. That will open up whole international markets. How many people are watching the The Three-Body Problem which is free on YouTube but subtitled? If you match it to a light deep fake of lips movements it's even more seamless. You can now reprogram video.
- stuckinhell 4y agoThis would be a dream come true for many people, including me!
- ineptech 4y ago...the same could be said of call center and phone support jobs, which will affect about a zillion times more people than professional voice actors.
- nemo44x 4y agoHasn’t this already happened mainly? It’s rare I talk to a human. It’s even more rare I call a help desk instead of using sone other means. It’s sort of the most obvious cost center managers have been actively automating. I still think speaking to a human will be a premium thing for valued customers.
- JohnFen 4y agoWe'll have to find tricks to bypass the robot just like we have to find tricks to bypass call center workers today.
- vagab0nd 4y agoMany of us suffer from this. "AI will take many jobs, and rightly so. But surely not my job".
- Broken_Hippo 4y agoWhich isn't all bad. Call center jobs are pretty brutal and often have draconian absence policies. Some of them (maybe most?) at least require a pre-employment drug test. Some require random drug tests while employed - and some of those will be hair follicle tests - and honestly, I can't understand how smoking weed occasionally will make you bad at taking calls. Some - if not most - will absolutely expect you to put up with an array of abuse from customers and be nice when it happens. Americans don't require this from police. And don't get me started on the conditions for telephone sales. I worked in a call center for deliquent phone bills, and heard stories about how much better it was there. I guess phone sales is really soul-crushing. Truly, the worst part about this is simply that a lot of the folks affected have no realistic safety net.
- danielrpa 4y ago
- m463 4y agoI know the article is canadian, but one interesting thing in the US is that several cases have disallowed copyright for machine generated content. sort of like https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monkey_selfie_copyright_dispute https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monkey_selfie_copyright_disput...
- jeroenhd 4y agoThe generated voice may be uncopyrightable, but there's more than one thing to copyright here. The script itself has a copyright, for instance, just like the lyrics in music. You can't just take the generated audio and use it as you please. The lesser copyright will probably make media productions steer clear of AI, but smaller studios may not. We'll have to see.
- larsiusprime 4y agoI have some prediction markets running for whether SAG-AFTRA is going to get an enforceable contract with anyone that establishes terms for generative AI for voice acting: https://manifold.markets/LarsDoucet/will-sagaftra-secure-a-contract-enf?r=TGFyc0RvdWNldA https://manifold.markets/LarsDoucet/will-sagaftra-secure-a-c...
- furyofantares 4y agoIt seems kind of a quirk that we have the same actor or voice actor play many different parts. It's not exactly without value, we get to become fans of an actor; we have an expectation both of quality of parts they take and of their work, and it often gives us an idea what type of movie it'll be. But it still seems that if there were infinitely many high quality actors available, we wouldn't do this. It's hard for me to accept this, and yet I also think it's true and just too ingrained for me to totally get the vision. I convince myself by way of two observations. #1) Are there any examples of animated characters that are reused to portray a different character? I don't know of any, in any case it's extremely not common. And #2) With voice acting I mostly find it a distraction and not valuable to recognize the voice actor from another character.
- PeterisP 4y ago> #1) Are there any examples of animated characters that are reused to portray a different character? I think there are a bunch of cases in game production where you reuse the animations for a different game for a quite different character with a similar (but different) 3d model; and within a single game you'd often see different NPCs using the exact same movement animations.
- majormajor 4y agoThere are far more actors available then there are actors getting parts in blockbuster movies or top-tier TV shows, or even voiceover work. Famous cliche - waiting tables in Hollywood waiting to be noticed to get your break. Picking a known actor is also a marketing move, not just a talent/quality-selection move. (Sometimes it probably goes the other way too, e.g. if an actor is a fan of a game series and wants to be part of it.) The closest thing to your animated character question I can think of is in video games. There's a LOT of different versions of Link/Zelda/Mario/Sonic in different game editions. Where this falls in terms of "sequel" vs "reboot" vs "different Zelda character" is debatable, but here's where I think the connection to Hollywood actors comes in: reusing Link+Zelda instead of just re-using the game mechanics is a marketing play, just like having a famous actor. If you swapped characters and branding straight-up between Banjo Kazooie and Mario 64, which one would be better known today? There's also the light-reskin variant case in things like "Dr Mario", or fighting game characters, which fits more with the budget restriction aspect.
- NovaDudely 4y agoI have said it before, some famous voice artists will eventually licence their likeness. You can already see a site like Audible allowing you to choose the book and they you get the choose who narrates it. Carl Jung narrated by Stephen Fry or your choice of a thousand others. It will be sold to us as choice. The more far out idea is that a book's text could be generated on any subject you wish and then have the voice actor of choice generated for it. End less content generated on demand.
- WalterBright 4y agoI want Ahhhnold to give directions on my navigator. "To da choppah!"
- Riverheart 4y agoSome time back Waze, the driving app, did have various voice actors including Arnold giving directions.
- NovaDudely 4y agoI think Waze already does that. ;) Although it is just an impersonator replacing out a few lines.
- jack1243star 4y agoAlready exists. See Vocaloid, Voiceroid, CeVIO, Neutrino, etc.
- WalterBright 4y agoI'm waiting for the time when I can feed chatGPT the text of my favorite sci fi novel(s) and have it spew back a fully realized movie version, that actually follows the book!
- number6 4y agoSeems like even NI can't do this right now
- rootusrootus 4y agoOn the bright side, this also means the retail value of entertainment content is going to drop towards zero as well. I suppose Hollywood thinks it'll just capture bigger profits, but that's not how disruption works.
- stuckinhell 4y agoI think we will see a new class of entertainment product. Personalized Content. Instead of watching what other people created, you will get to define the terms of the content you want and generate. Like Harry Potter, but wished they were American, African, Indians, Chinese, sure no problem. Like Harry Potter, but wish you were the main character ? Sure no problem with deepfakes and 3d models. I think this will move fairly quickly since many many Hollywood production companies are jumping on the videogame engine bandwagon for developing cg for tv shows.
- zirgs 4y agoSpotify that composed music just for me would be dope.
- cyrialize 4y agoI'm struggling to see this happen - my impression is that companies will now use AI in the place of paying for a resource. Retail value will stay the same, and companies will pocket the difference. I think there could be situations where other companies undercut because they can afford to now - maybe then, that'll drive the price down. What if that doesn't happen though? Couldn't companies just standardize around a price and remain at that? For example, triple AAA titles are always around $60-70. If there's a smaller company / indie that is dropping the price a ton, they still may not have the resources or IP to compete with a large company. I wouldn't be surprised as well if large companies were aggressive in copyright / ownership of a famous AI voice. They could just swarm a smaller company / indie with lawsuits if they use the voice or a voice they perceive as familiar. It wouldn't even matter if the large company was wrong - they have more than enough money to bury a smaller company in lawsuits since the smaller company doesn't have enough to fight back.
- relativeadv 4y agoThere will be so much shlock everywhere now
- gumballindie 4y agoThis narrative is becoming boring fast.
- whywhywhywhy 4y agoAlready is, in the near future content is going to be generated constantly and canned the second people lose interest but lets not pretend for a single moment the current pillars of media made by the titans are anything but a 8 year cycle of perpetual rehash. Just how many more edgy reboots of Batman am I going to have to be subjected to before I die, feel like I'm living in Groundhog Day which will also surely have a reboot in the next 4 years or so.
- AlbertCory 4y agoI'm coming from a biased perspective since my books are fiction and have characters. A non-fiction work would be a different matter for AI. That said: You can listen to the samples of audible books for me (just search Amazon for "Albert Cory"), because I chose chapters with several characters talking. The voices have to sound like the fictional characters, complete with emotional affect. Of course that's the voice actor Maxwell Glock's skill. I don't see AI taking Max's job there. But I suppose anything's possible. A long time ago I listened to A Brief History of Nearly Everything on audio, and that also had a very human sound to it.
- motohagiography 4y agoKind of interesting that the job of an actor is to represent something, to become a symbol in a narrative, and when we came up with a way to simulate symbols, a kind of semiotic generator, they were among the first people whose work can be automated. I wonder what else we have forgotten is mainly a representation that we might be surprised when it can be automated. We should do politicians next and run simulated candidates against each other as a massive online game. It would take the real ones out of policy areas where they can do harm, and leave them to concentrate on the graft and influence peddling they use their offices as a front for.
- russellbeattie 4y agoI recently tried ElevenLabs AI speech software [1] to clone my voice and was astounded at the results. In the relatively near future I can easily imagine anyone who has publicly accessible examples of recorded speech being cloned automatically. Radio personalities, TV and film stars, existing audiobook narrators, etc. Want to have Morgan Freeman read Harry Potter to you? Step one: Grab some YouTube videos for examples. Step two: Train AI. Step three: Sit back and listen. A future multimodal generative AI might be able to do this for you with a simple prompt: "Create an audio file of Stephen Fry reading The Chronicles of Narnia." It'll be that easy, and basically unstoppable unless there's some legislation involved. 1. https://beta.elevenlabs.io/ https://beta.elevenlabs.io/
- MrVandemar 4y agoThe big thing that's missing so far is performance. Voice-cloned stuff I've heard is pretty flat. A real voice-over artist/reader will put in dramatic pauses, will create both distinct and subtle emphasis on words, and vary the speed of their reading given the tension of the scene. Voice overs dont' just sit in chair, they perform. They'll smile, and you can hear it; they will frown or scowl that that'll come through the voice; they'll gesticulate with their hands. All these things animates the voice, imbues it with feeling and resonance and character. AI is not there yet, and I'm struggling to imagine that they will be able to do this without making some kind of error that'll just take you right out of the story.
- danesparza 4y agoI hear these nuances progressing in the Elevenlabs voices. I think we're closer than you think.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- bitwize 4y agoI saw a sneak preview of this. There's a YouTube meme involving U.S. Presidents Obama, Trump, and Biden discussing gaming related topics. It's hilarious, but the speech models of the presidents' voices is fairly convincing.
- chasd00 4y agomy kids showed me a youtube of Obama, Trump, and Biden playing Minecraft. It was pretty hilarious and impressive at the same time. The voices aren't perfect but pretty good. Biden: Trump, I thought you got arrested yesterday? Trump: How are you awake? it's like 1PM edit: here's a link to one, the language is pretty crass so make sure you have headphones https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-pGT5jLlxb4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-pGT5jLlxb4
- globalise83 4y agoI've already cloned my voice in case one day I would lose it permanently for whatever reason. In such a scenario I could then create an application to be able to say whatever I want in my own voice. Am really looking forward to the day when these kinds of features are available as Web APIs in the browser.
- mobiuscog 4y agoWhat is the most effective way to do this, that completely respects privacy ?
- autoexec 4y agothis is a level of loving to hear yourself speak that I've never seen before. Personally, I think I sound weird when I hear myself from outside of my own head and given the vast world of possible voices (from James Earl Jones, David Attenborough, Optimus Prime, etc), the last voice I'd want to use was my own.
- swores 4y agoI don't feel the same way as you (though I haven't preserved my voice). I hadn't thought of doing it before this comment thread, and like you (and like most people I think, or at least many) find hearing recordings of myself speaking uncomfortable - because it doesn't sound like the same voice as I hear when I speak - but my reaction was "why hadn't I thought of that, I hope they reply to the comment asking how with an answer that tells me it's easy and cheap with instructions!" More because, as bad as the hypothetical possibility of losing the ability to speak already is, wouldn't it be better to not also lose how you sound to everyone else in the world? You'd soon get used to the new way you hear it, or at least as soon as you'd get used to having a completely novel voice!
- karencarits 4y agoA relative suddenly got severe dysarthria and refuses to use artificial voices/ augmentative and alternative communication systems since "this is not my voice" In relation to this, the open source project cboard (https://www.cboard.io/ https://www.cboard.io/) is a very nice AAC web app where you can add custom cards with your own voice recordings. I am very grateful that there exist open source technology in this field as the commercial solutions are pretty expensive, and everyone should have access to a voice
- CHB0403085482 4y agoIce Ice Baby sung by the Matrix (1999) characters by Auralnauts https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gnEIeVWLtbU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gnEIeVWLtbU
- nvahalik 4y agoThis is hilarious. While the usage of various technologies is astounding, there is, I think one piece which I cannot help but consider that could _never_ be replicated. Consider about 1:26 into the video, the video cuts from the Quaker Oats commercial to a scene where Tank says "did you stop?" While AI can do many things—could AI actually come up with the actual cutting of the video? Could it figure out the nuance and the humor of that particular cut? A deep part of me says: no. AI, while it can do many things, couldn't come up with something new and meaningful like that. The AI scripts that have been generated in the past are funny, but they are funny like small kids are funny. They are not funny like BJ Novak is funny.
- estsauver 4y agoI don't know--I think we're going to see a rapid evolution here. AI's were previously not creative and many people said that was the hill it would never be able to climb, but it's hard to argue that Dali and Midjourney aren't art. I think literary & language forms are probably quite hard for it to master, particularly when it's not that sure if it will offend. (The content filter in aligning an LLMs response to "Not offensive" probably prevents it from ever generating jokes that would be in line with Ricky Gervais or Dave Chapelle.) https://openai.com/research/gpt-4#:~:text=Visual%20inputs%3A%20VGA-,charger,-Sample%201%20of https://openai.com/research/gpt-4#:~:text=Visual%20inputs%3A... shows it at least explaining a joke.
- nvahalik 4y agoYeah, but I think that still continues down the pathway: yes, it can explain a joke... but could it create a novel joke? Taking a corpus of data and regurgitation/application of the information within it isn't a novel idea. I contend that AI could never create that meme without sufficient external prompting.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- causi 4y agoIf costs come way down it's going to be truly incredible. I'm already enjoying listening to H.P. Lovecraft as read by Dagoth Ur; I can't wait to start making my own audiobooks out my favorites that never got a narrated release.
- falcolas 4y agoCreating an audiobook still requires the author’s permission, and there will be not insubstantial costs, which authors might not want to bear. Whether you agree with the concept of IP or not, it is the law of our lands.
- causi 4y agoWhether you agree with the concept of IP or not, it is the law of our lands. The whims of publishers and the law are not going to stop me from format-shifting my content however I please.
- JohnFen 4y agoIn the US, anyway, format shifting does not violate the law. You can copy works all you want, but the law requires you to treat all copies as an indivisible whole.
- nickthegreek 4y agoI look forward to the day that when my group plays d&d, we can all have real time voice processing with custom outputs to fit our characters.
- UncleEntity 4y ago> In March, SAG-AFTRA, the labour union that represents film and TV actors in the US, issued a statement saying that any contract involving AI and digital dubbing requires companies to bargain with the union. Kind of curious who they’re representing here? I’m not really a fan of unions but understand the historic reasons they exist, to protect the rights of workers. In this instance they just seem to be purely rent seeking as there isn’t a worker to represent. I suppose the AI companies will have to pay union dues or they can’t work on union gigs?
- crop_rotation 4y ago> Kind of curious who they’re representing here? They are representing the worker would would have done that gig sans AI. They are trying to protect the interests of their members, which is their primary purpose. Whether that is the rent seeking or not is not really relevant to them. I doubt the AI companies can just pay union dues like an actor. The SAG would be more interested in long term strength of their profession (and thus the Union itself) rather than some pennies on Union dues by some companies.
- UncleEntity 4y ago> They are representing the worker would would have done that gig sans AI. So they are representing people who don’t work for these companies and have to bargain with the union to replace them with the robots. I’m sure that will turn out well. Be like every car sold would need to come with a buggy whip because the whipmakers union is strong enough to force the issue.
- sgt 4y agoWhat about for audio description? To do that well it's not just about cramming voice into a short space of time, but you have to be strategic and actually understand the context. Not a trivial task. Could AI do this equally well in say 2-3 years? I seriously doubt it.