4 ms·
And facilitating organized crime, terrorism, and investment scams.
by neilv 4y ago
And facilitating organized crime, terrorism, and investment scams.
- charlieyu1 4y agoWhich of these do not happen when using conventional money?
- lottin 4y agoYou're missing the point. Cryptocurrencies are specifically designed to evade regulations. Everything else —efficiency, cost, convenience, usability— is sacrificed in order to achieve this goal.
- charlieyu1 4y agoCall me old school but I don’t understand the hype about regulations. The less power the government has, the better. They certainly don’t need to know my spending habits. And a stack of banknotes evade regulations pretty well anyway.
- hnbad 4y agoThe function of the state is to enforce private property rights. Regulations exist to alleviate the consequences of private property rights by adding various forms of exceptions. Whether you think that's a good thing depends on whether your idea of utopia is a egalitarian commune or a neofeudal federation of corporate city states. Note that I'm talking about private property not personal property. Variations of the latter exist and have existed in almost every society but the concept of the former has increasingly been maximized to the point that patches of land, ways to do things, ideas in your head and sincere promises are now things you can own and exchange and people refusing to suffer hunger or lack of shelter are seen as unreasonable if they want to use what isn't eaten or isn't lived in. Abolishing the state as long as other organizations (or individuals) are allowed to hoard resources/wealth/power seems as catastrophic a suggestion as abolishing the police as long as other gangs exist. You're just substituting one evil for another without affecting any material change.
- Zuiii 4y ago> Cryptocurrencies are specifically designed to evade regulations. No, most are not. (I'd go as far to argue that even monero is not specifically designed to evade regulation.)
- codehalo 4y agoAnd human trafficking.
- it_citizen 4y agoAnd funding North Korea.
- colestantiago 4y agodon't forget ransomware enablement and burning the planet up with mining.
- midmagico 4y agoHeavily debunked nonsense trope.. https://medium.com/@nic__carter/comments-on-the-white-house-report-on-the-climate-implications-of-crypto-mining-8d65d30ec942 https://medium.com/@nic__carter/comments-on-the-white-house-...
- Zuiii 4y agoYeah, I wish cryptocurrencies haven't been invented so that human trafficking wouldn't exist at all. I mean just think about it. A FULL 3%* of all cryptocurrency transactions are related to criminal activities! If we ban those 3% (and the other 97% because why not), we will stop all human trafficking or at least make a noticeable dent in it because most traffickers rely on cryptocurrency and absolutely don't use traditional currency as the main way to transact. Perhaps if cryptocurrencies do finally get banned, it would at least help certain individuals to think more critically, or perhaps start thinking at all. One can only wish. [*]: 3% because it's the most extreme reputable statistic out there. Most reputable studies place transactions related to illicit activities well bellow 1%.
- dingosity 4y agoCareful. You're going to be accused of furthering an "ideological debate" in violation of HN's Terms of Service.
- overthrow 4y agohttps://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=3942181 https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=3942181 > For example, illegal transactions, scams and gambling together make up less than 3% of volume.
- VWWHFSfQ 4y agothe other 97% is bots sending small amounts of bitcoins back and forth to each other for no reason whatsoever
- trogdor 4y agoIn fairness, that kind of thing arguably happens with stocks as well, though algorithmic trading. Though it’s not small amounts.
- eru 4y agoThough they do have reasons. But the 'bots' in Bitcoin probably have too. After all, there are transaction costs.
- Psychoshy_bc1q 4y agoback this claim up. wait you can't
- RestlessMind 4y agoAnd also to fight oppressive governments. Compiled some examples here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32406095 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32406095 Though those governments would love people like you who paint all the use cases as "organized crime, terrorism" etc
- igsomething 4y agoAdd countries with hyperinflation too such as Venezuela and Argentina. Every cryptocurrency-related post here in HN is flooded with extremely negative comments, even if the post itself does not promote cryptocurrencies. These people have seen countless examples of cryptocurrency scams, but they cannot understand what life under an economically oppressed or unstable country is because they never experienced it.
- Zuiii 4y agoI'd also add: - People living abroad who are completely debanked because local banks refuse to open banks accounts for people who are merely suspected of being US citizns, despite them not being US citizns, with no path to resolve their predicament. This is a real problem that is effecting real people right now. - Any legal activity that the banks and payment processors don't like for one reason or another; onlyfans, "right-wing" websites (whether actual or merely alleged), ...etc. We no longer live in a world where you can live a dignified life with cash alone. Cryptocurrecy is a net positive to humanity, even if the technologies behind it may currently be more wasteful and make the lives of criminals a bit easier. There is simply no alternative for a lot of honest people in financial dead-ends the government can't or won't help. Thank you Satoshi and anyone who works to support this technology for making the world a slightly better place.
- Psychoshy_bc1q 4y agoHN is flooded with overprivileged richkids with no connection to reality
- hnbad 4y ago
- jeffhuys 4y agoEh, every good thing can be used for bad. And it's a pandora's box anyways. So who cares.
- midmagico 4y agoBitcoin specifically, even at the height of Silk Road, and at Bitcoin's nearly weakest-by-comparison point, has been and is cleaner by proportion when compared with virtually all countries' grey markets in terms of what proportion of its economy is used for crime. The crime trope is ancient, old, and has been repeatedly debunked. The evidence for its prevalence simply isn't there—because Bitcoin is not anonymous.