4 ms·
Teachers are in the midst of a burnout crisis
- lcnPylGDnU4H9OF 4y agoI remember when I was in school and teachers complained about the costs of supplies they needed to provide for themselves, including things like markers to use on the whiteboards (public school in Utah, roughly the ages 12-18). As far as I know, these public school administrations (in Utah) don't have a legal mandate to pay for or reimburse such costs. More recently -- within the past two years -- I worked with someone who moved into software development from being a music teacher at a local high school (still in Utah, roughly ages 15-18, not where I went) where her boss (the principal) made her cry on many days with verbal abuse about how she's not working hard enough, not meeting certain metrics, whatever happened to be the problem at the time. In high school I had a teacher who put in absolutely no effort to teach unless / until the school district sent someone to sit in on (one of) his classes to verify that he does his job. To make it appear that he did his job, he coached the class to always raise their hand whenever he asked any question. Over the years he devised a system for this: if you believe you know the answer to the question raise your right hand, otherwise your left. To my knowledge, there wasn't any sort of disciplinary action taken against him. (Otherwise, that class was "read this chapter of the textbook and then rewrite and answer the questions at the end" and I'm pretty sure I failed it. It was a World History class, for the curious.) I doubt the school had a budget that not only allowed competitive salaries but also some mechanism to increase the budget and therefore salaries. Some teachers put up with the bullshit, at least for a time, because they have a passion (sound familiar?) for teaching. Others, I think, give the effort they get. It's nice to see this getting some amount of attention even if I'm not particularly surprised by the headline (or might have some reservations about the wording "midst of a ... crisis"; kinda think we've been here since before I was in school but what do I know?).
- cafard 4y agoHow exactly does one measure how hard a music teacher works? Do largo passages count against the metric?
- lcnPylGDnU4H9OF 4y agoStudent performance. Some students don't care about getting a good grade in the class, these students don't learn (at least not as measured by the school), and it's obviously the teacher's fault from the perspective of this particular principal. Admittedly, I don't know how the grade was determined. Even if it's just participation, there may be students who wanted an "easy A" and actually don't participate.
- TheCaptain4815 4y agoI can see an eventual battle between teachers unions and Ai usage in classrooms, with pressure to limit or ban them. How effective can an individually tailored GPT6 service be at teaching kids? What happens when the image/video models advance and these models can not only teach through text but also through image examples/video examples? I was never a great in-person learner so to me it would have been a God send. What percentage of kids are like me in which society could save untold amounts per child WITH better outcomes.
- dangwhy 4y agokhan academy seems to doing this.
- 121789 4y agoI think a significant part of teaching is people management, then the actual teaching comes second. This might actually help teachers do things like create lesson plans. I think the challenge is the other way. Going to be really hard to grade homework if you can get a good answer from an LLM for any question you ask it.
- nradov 4y agoAutomated educational tools are great for helping intelligent, motivated, disciplined students move ahead even faster. There will absolutely be a market for educational software based on LLMs. Neal Stephenson's novel The Diamond Age had a system like that as a plot element and the basic concept seems sound. I'm sure there are already stealth mode startups building this. But automation isn't a magic solution to improving educational achievement or reducing costs. We haven't figured out how to automate the human touch that allows good teachers to engage students who might have learning disabilities, or are just lower on the general intelligence scale, or lack self discipline, or are distracted by bad home environments. Obviously human teachers aren't perfect at dealing with troubled students but most of them at least try and can engage specialized resources to get more help. Will a chatbot recognize that a student is being abused at home and call CPS?
- dangwhy 4y ago> class size has nearly doubled since he started teaching 11th grade U.S. history at Pflugerville High School 23 years ago, thanks to a persistent teacher shortage and a flock of families migrating to trendy Austin, a mere 30-minute drive south. why are families migrating here despite bad schools. Whats so appealing about austin.
- throwaway5959 4y agoNever been to Austin but I imagine lower COL and no state income tax. If you’re coming from SF, you’re probably used to shitty schools.
- dangwhy 4y ago> lower COL and no state income tax. Tons of places in the country with this but with good schools. Houston and dallas maybe?
- lockhouse 4y agoHouston schools are so bad that the state of Texas is taking over management of the entire Houston ISD. https://www.texastribune.org/2023/03/16/tea-hisd-takeover-texas-houston-schools/ https://www.texastribune.org/2023/03/16/tea-hisd-takeover-te...
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Jaygles 4y agoAmerica is a story of people wanting to have their cake and eat it too. We want top notch public services but at the same time low taxes. I wish there was a straight forward way of comparing the value of the things your taxes get you versus what the equivalent cost of those same things at a private market rate would be. If people understood how good of a deal they are getting they might be inclined to pay more taxes.
- rolenthedeep 4y agoI think a lot of it is the opaque way our taxes are collected and used, as well as corruption in government. People get mad about taxes because the government takes 25% of our income and leaves our infrastructure to rot and crumble, continually reduces funding for schools and other social programs. Meanwhile we spend an absolutely bonkers insane amount on """defense""", which really gets used to pay grifters and to blow up other poorer nations who don't actually pose a threat. Taxes should be about paying in for the common good. The way it works right now is we pay, and the commons get worse. It's really difficult to feel good about paying taxes when you don't actually get anything out of the deal. Where do my tax dollars actually go? It's impossible to tell, but it is clear that every single level of government which takes taxes from me are not using it responsibly. Otherwise we'd have working roads and rails, educated and healthy citizens, less hunger and homelessness.