8 ms·
Apple and global suppliers expand renewable energy to 13.7 gigawatts
- acidburnNSA 4y agoGigawatts of capacity, I assume? What's the capacity factor of their investments, I wonder? E.g. how many GW-years of electricity do they generate in a year on average? It's much more important these days to measure progress is integral terms like low-carbon energy generated/year rather than max low-carbon power when in ideal conditions. It's even better to measure with things like lifecycle mass CO2-equiv/kWh avoided, which avoids traps of crediting things like forest combustion as "green" like drax does in the UK.
- ericpauley 4y agoThis is so often under appreciated. For reference, non-FF capacity factors here: https://www.eia.gov/electricity/monthly/epm_table_grapher.php?t=epmt_6_07_b https://www.eia.gov/electricity/monthly/epm_table_grapher.ph... So you’re probably looking at a 2-3x difference between renewable nameplate capacity and the equivalent replaced fossil fuels.
- jacquesm 4y agoFossil also has downtime, as does nuclear. It just isn't as frequent. But in some cases (reactor shutdown for instance) it can be much more sudden and long than the way wind and solar vary. And prediction of near future solar/wind availability is getting better all the time helping a lot in dealing with the variability.
- acidburnNSA 4y agoAverage is what matters here when you're on the grid. Nuclear capacity factor averages 92% in the US. Solar averages 25%. Wind 35.
- jacquesm 4y agoI've been 100% off grid for two consecutive years in Northern Canada. We did have a backup generator but it wasn't used after the windmill went up. 48 KWh of storage was enough to tide us over any period without sun/wind.
- aeyes 4y agoWhat kind of windmill do you have? I did some research to see if it would make sense as a homeowner and found it to be mostly not worth it. You shouldn't attach it directly to the building because wind speed near surfaces slows down significantly. So you need a large pole which will make maintenance very expensive. You usually can't attach the pole directly to the building either because it isn't rated for such high forces. Wind mills are also quite noisy so you probably want to have a huge amount of land to put it far away from the house. The power produced rises to the power of two with the diameter of the rotor and to the power of three with wind speed. This means that you want an installation which is both large and high.
- jacquesm 4y agoI built my own. 16' diameter, variable pitch, and silent as can be. The noise a windmill makes is closely related to the thickness of the trailing edge of the blades.
- coda_ 4y agoHave you done any write ups or posts on your build? Or do you have any suggestions of other posts about similar builds? Would love to learn more about what it takes to do this.
- jacquesm 4y agoAbsolutely. Part II has the diagrams and pretty much everything else. If you build one let me know! https://jacquesmattheij.com/how-to-build-a-windmill/ https://jacquesmattheij.com/how-to-build-a-windmill/
- brookst 4y agoCan you elaborate? Are there significant differences in ratios of power produced to max power? Naively I would expect some scaling factor to apply in most cases, as regional and seasonal differences come out in the wash.
- acidburnNSA 4y agoHuge differences based on region and technology. In California solar PV may generate 30% of its max capacity in a year due to nights and clouds, whereas in Seattle it may be well below 20% due to no sun in winter. Wind averages 35% due to lulls. Nuclear is about 92% (has to shut down every 2 years to refuel). Hydro often is run around 40% (depends on water availability). So building 13.7 GW of nuclear capacity in a northern region could generate ~5x more clean energy per year than 13.7 GW of solar capacity. Not sure if Apple is investing in nuclear or not. (:
- Retric 4y agoNameplate capacity is so vastly cheaper with solar it more than offsets that difference in all but the worst locations. In Nevada you nuclear is means paying 10x as much to get a 90% capacity factor vs 30% for solar. So you build 3x as much solar and a ton of batteries and still cost less than nuclear while being able to follow the demand curve.
- acidburnNSA 4y agoIf you only look at LCOE and ignore backup, transmission, recycling at scale, etc then sure!
- Retric 4y agoLCOE is vastly lower for battery backed solar, that’s why it’s so cheap. You also don’t need backup with batteries that’s the entire point. Individual nuclear power plants are single points of failure and go offline randomly. Nuclear needs redundancy to ensure a stable grid which further increases its costs. Transmission is again worse for nuclear because it’s so centralized. With solar you can locate it much closer to end users which cuts down on annual transmission losses.
- edhelas 4y agoAlso it's mandatory to take care of the backup used when there is "no-wind/no-sun". You can have your electricity share coming from renewable that is increasing, if in the end you have 30-40 of gaz/coal as a backup to handle the time when renewable is not producing you'll no go way further. Example: Germany.
- sveme 4y agoCare to put some numbers on the no wind/no sun scenario? As an example, the share of renewables in Germany never dropped below 30% last year and that only happened a couple of days. Average renewable contribution was >50%.
- aeyes 4y agoI imagine that this is only for the grid production? If I charge my car with solar at home it won't move the meter, energy consumed by households with solar might not show up in the statistics. In reality renewable contribution might be even higher, unless there is correction for this.
- KptMarchewa 4y agoWind in Poland right now works on 2% capacity factor. 152MW out of 7.72GW installed. There is solar now, so renewables are not so bad. However, at 5AM it was bad - wind was only on 5%, zero solar. https://i.imgur.com/LAJ2cKP.png https://i.imgur.com/LAJ2cKP.png
- barney54 4y agoWhat is your source for this? I’m highly skeptical because it means there was never a time of low wind at night ir when it was cloudy. February 26th of last year sure looks like a lot less than 30% renewable. https://mobile.twitter.com/energybants/status/1497392463731908614 https://mobile.twitter.com/energybants/status/14973924637319...
- sveme 4y agoThere's also hydro (incl. imported from Norway) and biomass. Source for total renewable over time is here: https://www.zeit.de/wirtschaft/energiemonitor-deutschland-gaspreis-spritpreis-energieversorgung https://www.zeit.de/wirtschaft/energiemonitor-deutschland-ga... There might be spells during the day where this is less than 30%, but that's what short term storage would be there for. The nightmare scenario, often mentioned, is weeks of clouds and low winds, which does not seem to have occurred last year, at least. And even when it's cloudy you still have some solar. By the way, I'm not arguing that all is well and everything is solved, I just hate this juvenile argument of "but what if it's cloudy and there is no wind for weeks", because that does not happen often, especially not on a continent-wide grid with lots of offshore wind power in one of the windiest seas in the world.
- edhelas 4y agoSo Apple is producing iPhones and powering their datacenters only on windy days I can imagine ? ...or they also have gaz/coal and other backups ? ...or they also invest in nuclear energy ?
- ginko 4y agoKudos for actually specifying energy production in gigawatts instead of something stupid like GWh/year like so many journalists like to do.
- acidburnNSA 4y agoYou have it backwards. GWh/year is what matters. GW is just a max instantaneous power and is borderline meaningless as a decarbonization metric. X GWh/year means that they produced x actual clean GWh of energy over a period of 1 year. X GW can mean they produced X GW of clean power for some arbitrary amount of time, like 1 hour or 1 week or 1 second.
- Aachen 4y agoJust like wind/sun/hydro won't produce the same number of GW at any given moment, wouldn't it be similarly silly to predict a GWh/year? It all depends on how many orders Apple places with the suppliers, how efficient they turn out to be in a given year (maybe they buy newer, more/less power-hungry machines in 2024), and indeed how much the sun shines and the rain falls. Having a capacity figure sounds roughly as meaningful to me as an average yearly production forecast. > some arbitrary amount of time, like 1 hour or 1 week or 1 second I think anyone would understand a vehicle going 200km/h to mean "at most, when you put in fuel". Not "for the next 1 hour right now specifically". Specifying how many km you're promising to drive the customer is a bit weird, one can assume Apple's commitment for the capacity figure is in perpetuity. It's a rare moment where I don't fully agree with a comment from acidburnNSA, and I really hate to be defending Apple and won't buy a device that isn't mine no matter how green the energy is (if they would do fair material sourcing, like Fairphone, that would honestly make me doubt my stance, but not the relatively easy decision to use green energy as one the richest companies on earth), but this skepticism that they might stop it before the year is out is also kind of weird.
- ginko 4y ago>GW is just a max instantaneous power That's one definition you can also use GW to specify average power over a year. 1 GWh/year is 1 GWh/8760h is ~114KW, the time element cancels out
- fooblaster 4y agoI remain incredibly skeptical of any tech companies promises around carbon emissions reductions. Literally all previous promises around carbon offsets are essentially fake. It is impossible to distinguish green washing from legitimate efforts in press releases, which implies to me a huge pressure to greenwash. I do not know how exactly to fix this problem.
- themitigating 4y agoTesla might not have been successful if it wasn't for carbon credits.
- ChrisRR 4y agoEspecially a company that is known for advertising so heavily to try and get people to replace their highly complex piece of electronics every year with an extremely similar piece of electronics
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 4y agoIf it wasn't bullshit it wouldn't require a long and slickly-designed page to explain. They should switch to releasing new phones biannually and embrace repairability.
- matthewmcg 4y agoFor U.S. public companies, at least, the SEC views greenwashing as securities fraud matter. There are examples of the SEC bring enforcement actions for misleading ESG statements: https://www.sec.gov/securities-topic/enforcement-task-force-focused-climate-esg-issues https://www.sec.gov/securities-topic/enforcement-task-force-...
- deafpolygon 4y agoWell beyond 1.21 gigawatts.. so can we travel through time yet?
- exabrial 4y agoWho honestly believes in this load of crap from companies? Right, so can I repair my iPhone without proprietary screws and glue yet? Can I install any OS on legacy hardware yet to extend its life without intentional roadblocks? Do your cables still have embedded chips in them making them needlessly complicated, wasteful, and energy intensive to manufacture?
- iamgopal 4y agoMost energy is used to heat the home, would you stop that ? They are doing something and improving at it. It’s good.
- kruuuder 4y agoYes, what they're doing is good. It's still greenwashing though.
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> still greenwashing This term is becoming overinclusive to the point of uselessness. Greenwashing implies deception. If Apple were buying nonsense carbon credits and claiming that was renewable energy, that would be greenwashing. If actually deploying renewable energy is greenwashing, then everything is greenwashing.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- kruuuder 4y agoTo clarify my previous comment: I didn't mean to say that Apples use of renewable energy is greenwashing. It's a great move, it's important, and more companies should do it. However, Apple presents itself as a sustainable company and suggests to the consumer that it's sustainable to buy Apple products. That's not true. Many of Apple's products are environmentally hostile (the most extreme example being the AirPods that are impossible to repair and have a limited lifespan), and Apple actively lobbies against the right to repair. That's the opposite of sustainable, and they know it. So, Apple's marketing is deceptive, and that's why I call it greenwashing.
- photochemsyn 4y agoIf they can't even get the units right in their title, it's hard to take the rest of it seriously. A watt is a unit of instantaneous power. A joule is a unit of energy. A Tesla supercharger that delivers 100,000 watts can fully charge a 100 kilo-watt-hour capacity battery in one hour storing about 3.6 million joules. At solar noon in the mid-latitudes, charging your average Tesla like this would take about 400 250-watt solar panels, (a 100 kilowatt system) running for one hour under full sun, which requires about a 25 * 25 meter surface area, or about 1/8th of a football field. However, the total energy produced by a rated 100 kilowatt solar array over a 24-hour period is not 24 * 100, because earth spins. Hence, comparing a 100 kilowatt coal plant (running 24-7) to a 100 kW solar array (at noon)... How many 100 kW solar arrays do you need to completely replace the output of a single 100 kW coal plant? Well, we need to integrate the solar power curve over time to get the energy under the curve which is the energy produced by the solar array, and we just have to multiply 100 * 24 to get it for the coal plant... And that's why when you see companies reporting their green credentials in terms of 'rated renewable power' instead of actual energy produced you should be somewhat skeptical.