5 ms·
Scientists Don’t Agree on What Causes Obesity, but They Know What Doesn’t
- exfatloss 4y ago> The three-day meeting was infused with an implicit understanding of what obesity is not: a personal failing. This weird push that "it's not a moral personal failing" is so strange. Is anybody serious claiming it is? Sure, your weird uncle might. But I'd hope the actual scientists would focus on finding the causes instead of whatever this is.
- sp332 4y agoBecause on a policy level, it's often treated that way.
- exfatloss 4y agoDo you have an example? Besides banning big gulps and ineffectual ad campaigns I don't recall much policy on the topic.
- throwawaysleep 4y ago> Is anybody serious claiming it is? Most Americans. https://www.nytimes.com/2016/11/01/health/americans-obesity-willpower-genetics-study.html https://www.nytimes.com/2016/11/01/health/americans-obesity-...
- exfatloss 4y agoHa, ok. On the other hand I'd argue "evidence it's genetic" is also clearly false. There are certainly genetic factors that make some people vulnerable but our genetics haven't changed that much in the last 30 years. Obesity has. The combination of genetics with our lifestyle and dietary context is where it's at IMO.
- chiefalchemist 4y agoWe know what causes obesity...less activity than what's consumed. Yes, there are contributing factors (e.g., gut bacteria, urban food deserts) that can tilt the scale (no pun intended) against you, but at some level it's a lifestyle issue. Why is that politically incorrect to say? Moral failing? Not really. Cheating on your spouse is a moral failing. But not watching your diet and/or not making an effort to exercise is simply denial.
- exfatloss 4y agoI'd argue "less activity than what's consumed" is not causal but an accounting of what's already happened. Just like "more money in your bank account" is a mere measurement, whereas "getting paid for your job" is what was causal.
- AnimalMuppet 4y ago> We know what causes obesity...less activity than what's consumed. In general, yes, but it's a bit more complex than that. First, it's not "activity". It's total calories burned, which includes base rate metabolism. Base rate metabolism is something that can be affected by exercise, disease, maybe diet, and certainly by chemicals (weight loss "aids" often work on this route, but can cause some nasty side effects). Second, it's not quite what's "consumed", it's what's extracted or absorbed. Gut bacteria show up here, but so do enzyme and other digestive issues. You can eat as much as you want and never gain weight if you have a high enough base metabolism, or if your digestive system is flawed.
- chiefalchemist 4y agoI understand all that. That's way I generalized over absolutes. Nonetheless, drink soda, eat foods with low nutritional density, watch TV, play video games...where is the surprise? Again, there are things that tilt one way or another but to say the individual has no say and no influence is simply no true. And it's a dangerous mindset to normalize.
- AnimalMuppet 4y ago
- paulpauper 4y agoFood cravings are intense and real. It's like being addicted to drugs...maybe even worse. People will suffer withdrawal-like symptoms when deprived of calorie dense food. Obesity can be prevented by preventing kids from ever tasting this stuff in the first place.
- proc0 4y ago"Personal failure" is a stretch, and in contrast broadly saying it's never about willpower is also a stretch. Humans are capable of accomplishing amazing feats of physical control. Our minds have incredible power over our bodies. Buddhist monks are a testament to this. There is a huge factor of belief becoming a self-fulfilling prophecy when it comes to willpower. If you don't think you can control your own behavior, then it becomes negative reinforcement until it becomes true. Thinking you cannot control yourself from putting food in your mouth is the epitome of a 1st world problem in current times.
- anenefan 4y agoOff the top of my head - Sugars and <edit> complex carbohydrates </edit> that break down to derive a lot of fructose - being used in excess in manufactured food. New Scientist had an article in the 90s in regard to tests on fructose free and normal diet on rats. Pretty much tended to show the increase of appetite as well as more storage. In recent years Harvard did further studies why. However there's a lot more than that going on, iirc didn't Michael Moore produce a doco on some of the tricks big fast food industry use to entice more food consumption. I don't think there's just one box and everyone is the same, but in my 20s due to an accident I gained a lot of weight where I needed suspenders to keep my jeans and trousers up, and once I was well enough I first walked a few mile every day and eventually using a push bike to travel to my nearest town for further studies about 30 miles (50km) away. Sure those trips moved from taking around 4 hours down to just over 2 and peddled near everywhere at that point, I still had most of that excess fat around the gut. Even after I stopped riding a bike, it was about the same but I still did quite a lot of manual work at that point and ... I tried that experiment more or less they'd done on rats, I used glucose instead of sucrose and maybe it would help ... in a mere matter of weeks instead of months the fat just fell away, and even before much had fell away I'd felt so much better.
- exfatloss 4y agoI think starch only breaks into glucose, not fructose.
- anenefan 4y agoI believe you are right, I did mean complex carbohydrates so I'd better edit that in.
- 876978095789789 4y ago> Sugars and <edit> complex carbohydrates </edit> that break down to derive a lot of fructose https://twitter.com/sguyenet/status/669638118400749568 https://twitter.com/sguyenet/status/669638118400749568
- 4y ago