9 ms·
FBI seizes bot shop ‘Genesis Market’ amid arrests targeting operators, suppliers
- trulynissin 4y agoHonestly surprised that this site was able to function undisputed, entirely on the public internet for this long despite it's entirely illegal nature.
- bennyg 4y agoI work, kind of, in this space - and it's been wild to me how incredibly easy it is to embed myself into public Discord servers that offer fraud/abuse bots. That might speak to the sophistication of what I find (vs. groups with better OpSec). I agree though, I'm surprised this was operated on the public internet with a great domain name.
- dmix 4y agoProbably much the same for phone spam which is why all of us get (semi-targeted) calls from indian call centers daily. Plenty of these are spawn out of Discord/Telegram networks to coordinate infrastructure. Via the grey/blackhat versions of Twilio. It's far too common for the operators to give a shit. See: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=le71yVPh4uk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=le71yVPh4uk
- rejectfinite 4y agoYea but whats the option? They need to sell to people so the Discord/Telegram and website need to be easy to access. And Discord/Telegram and websites want it to be easy to make stuff with/on them. The alternative is some vetting process where you submit a form for what the site is for and then someone from an authority logs in and checks manually.
- bennyg 4y agoI'm under the assumption that there are groups that require reputation to join (e.g. on private Telegram) that have a higher barrier of entry than a public Discord invite.
- Panino 4y agoIt looks like before the seizure, they had Chinese DNS (dnspod) and Russian web hosting (CLOUDX-AS, RU).
- mardifoufs 4y agoSo they complied to US requests? Or did the FBI go for the tld?
- hrrsn 4y agoThe wording ("domains have been seized") implies they went for the TLD. The registry for .market is Rightside, who are US based.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- sbierwagen 4y agoBack when Brian Krebs was still on twitter, it was a pretty constant parade. New cybercrime site goes up, it's compromised by LEO on week two, they hang out collecting evidence for a year, then roll it up and send everyone to jail. A month later, a new site goes up...
- aksss 4y agoWell, it’s worth considering that FBI had control over it long ago and ran it themselves for a while (hence it’s ability to be so public), and the impetus to give it up could be any number of things from threat of revelation to the more mundane cause of it having outlived its usefulness or just new projects taking priority/reassignments. This is not conspiracy, the FBI seriously does shit like this.
- trulynissin 4y agoYeah this is entirely true, wouldn't be surprised if this is exactly how it went down, FBI can be very clever.
- nostromo 4y agoI love these silly FBI "teenage boy badass" images they put up after they seize a website: https://genesis.market/ https://genesis.market/ The FBI agent in a hoodie, eating a cookie while hacking into the Matrix is just too good.
- boomboomsubban 4y agoAt first glance, it looks like they have twenty sponsors donating for them to host some kind of public hackathon.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- pph 4y agoAlso a typo in the alt text & wonky css that leads to weird stretching when the aspect ratio is not the same as the intern's who put up the page.
- PrufferFrish 4y agoLooks great on mobile, too. https://ibb.co/hBG7sgL https://ibb.co/hBG7sgL
- capableweb 4y agoSeemingly both their graphic designers and web developers (probably call them "webmasters") are stuck in the 90s judging by the source.
- cuttysnark 4y agoThe content="text/html; charset=windows-1252" was interesting to me since I'm so used to seeing utf-8. Caring about charset seemingly makes little sense here, given everything is embedded into the image. I wonder if this page was created by a generator.
- paulpauper 4y agoGenesis Market provided access to a wide list of services with user accounts from all over the world. Among them were Gmail, Facebook, Netflix, Spotify, WordPress, PayPal, Reddit, Amazon, LinkedIn, Cloudflare, Twitter, Zoom, and Ebay. This is why 'strong passwords' will never be good enough when hackers simply control the actual session
- Kenji 4y ago[dead]
- MrStonedOne 4y ago[dead]
- legitimayzer 4y agoI feel safer and better about the future already, thanks for the good work guys! this kind of access to hacking should be reserved only for the legitimate institutions of civilized society.
- JohnFen 4y agoIn other words, it should be legitimayzed?
- legitimayzer 4y agodude. it already is accessible to military powers.
- consumer451 4y agoI wonder why Spain and Poland topped the list of bots.
- jjcm 4y agoInterestingly, CenturyLink wont even let me visit the site. There's a "Continue to Site" button, but it does nothing.
- capableweb 4y agoFew ISPs around in Europe I tested with also blocks the site wholesale, took over the DNS request and serves their own blocking page.
- summarity 4y agoGood old https://www.dnsleaktest.com/what-is-transparent-dns-proxy.html https://www.dnsleaktest.com/what-is-transparent-dns-proxy.ht...
- javajosh 4y agoSo, as a web programmer, I'd like to infer how this data got into the marketplace in the first place. The offerings are all powered by browser data exfiltration! Which means their vector is another process on the host, or it could be a malicious browser extension, or a resource 0-day. Or the tokens could be exfiltrated from from the server-side, too.) Does anyone know how they get this data?
- rckoepke 4y agoChrome has a browser extension API which allows plugins to access all cookies, but its use is considered suspicious and a red flag; an extension which uses it would generally get caught during initial review. However, Chrome extensions are also allowed to “hotload” portions of their own code/scripts from external 3rd party servers. So an extension will seem benign when it initially gets checked by Google as part of becoming part of its submission to the Chrome Store. Then, later, the external “3rd party” script that is hosted remotely will get replaced with a different, malicious script. The malicious extension carries on stealing cookies, credentials, and fingerprints until someone reverse engineers it and reports it to Google. Google will not always recognize the issue immediately because the 3rd-party malicious code is not strictly “part of” the extension so there’s a bit of a song and dance while the person who reversed it convinces Googles reviewers that “yes, this really is actually malicious, you need to analyze the third party code that loads later” and then Google eventually takes it down after a semi-involved back-and-forth where extensive documentation and video walk-throughs are provided by the exasperated white-hat Good Samaritan.
- LelouBil 4y agoSeems like you speak from experience. Do you have any specifics to share ?
- TedDoesntTalk 4y agoRemote loading of code has been banned by Google and Mozilla for several years now. The automated review tools pick up script injection and eval() calls. Unless you can craft something unique, you’re not going to get past the automated review. I’m guessing the malware is something else besides a browser extension.
- ourmandave 4y agoBe nice if the FBI could get a hold of their customer list and go after those clowns as well.
- ourmandave 4y ago...all ten of the ten most expensive bots at the time included Coinbase credentials. Is it ironic that you can pay bitcoins to steal bitcoins?
- EGreg 4y agoNo!
- tylersmith 4y agoNo, it's not.
- lacker 4y agoIt's like ten thousand spoons, when all you need is more spoons.
- jxf 4y ago> Been active on Genesis Market? In contact with Genesis Market administrators? Email us, we're interested: FBIMW-Genesis@fbi.gov This has big "congratulations, local felon, you've won a ticket to the Super Bowl" energy [0]. But if it was enough to fool criminals in 1985, it's probably enough to fool criminals in 2023. [0] https://www.sportskeeda.com/nfl/what-operation-flagship-how-u-s-marshals-used-super-bowl-tickets-conduct-sting-operation https://www.sportskeeda.com/nfl/what-operation-flagship-how-...
- chongli 4y agoNot necessarily. There’s nothing illegal about contacting criminals if you have no intention of committing a crime. The FBI might in good faith be looking for witnesses to come forward and be available to testify in a criminal case against the administrators. It’s actually entirely reasonable for regular people to contact botnet administrators without any intention of purchasing criminal services. Security researchers sometimes do this when investigating the source of botnet attacks or when tracing machines they deliberately allowed to be infected (honeypots). The FBI may be very interested in getting testimony from these security researchers, even outside the scope of expert witnesses they may select out of the researchers they’re regularly in contact with.
- jxf 4y agoWhat fraction of people on Genesis do you think were security researchers versus criminals, though?
- chongli 4y agoA very tiny fraction. But I have to assume that most criminals on there would be smart enough not to reach out to the FBI unless they were facing far worse trouble than the possibility of being charged with a crime for this. I could be wrong, there could be criminals dumb enough to expose themselves to prosecution — they are criminals after all — but I would expect them to be smarter than the average street criminal.
- Nova0G 4y ago
- mindcrime 4y agoI'm just waiting for hackers to seize fbi.gov and replace their page with a "this page has been seized by Anonymous" (or whoever). I will laugh my ass off when it happens.
- SamuelAdams 4y agoIf the FBI did that intentionally it would be a great April fool’s joke.
- totetsu 4y ago> Purchasing a bot kit with the fingerprint, cookies and accesses, you become the unique user of all his or her services and other web-sites. Are these bots using the cookies stored locally by the browsers that the compromised systems user is using?
- codezero 4y agoSounds like it and it sounds like they built a chrome extension that effectively acts as a proxy for traffic through the target IP with the appropriate metadata to trick fingerprinters.
- resonant123 4y ago[flagged]
- rendall 4y agoAt first I thought a bot shop was a robot or gadget company, and I looked forward to reading about crime committing robots.
- qikInNdOutReply 4y agoImagine a DAO Contract using Chat GPT to re-opening such markets with laundered drug funds every time the last one expires. Talk about whack the mole debugging of the virtual by the real space. It could even come to a "arrangement" with the agents, increasing the number of markets to "bash" over time, so a metric for success exists and grows.
- vrglvrglvrgl 4y ago[dead]