3 ms·
> We need a more sophisticated debate, but we're not going to get it from the Financial Times. > > Large language models are alien. They are a new thing, not ar
by IshKebab 4y ago
> We need a more sophisticated debate, but we're not going to get it from the Financial Times.
>
> Large language models are alien. They are a new thing, not artificial general human-like intelligence. They sort of think, but not at all like humans, and not at all like previous concepts of artificial intelligence from science fiction.
This is more or less exactly what the FT article said so I think it's a bit unfair to criticise them as you did:
> The truth is that machine learning systems are nothing like us in the way they are engineered, but they are no less significant for it. To take just one example: the fact that non-human AI systems, perhaps with faces and voices, will soon be able to participate in political debate in a sophisticated way is likely to be more important for the future of democracy than the fact that they do not “think” like humans. Indeed, asking whether a machine learning system can “think” like a human is often as useful as asking whether a car can gallop as fast as a horse.
Honestly that's a lot more sophisticated than most of the debate on HN has been. There are a disappointing number of people here who think that it's "just predicting words" or that it can't "think" because it's a machine and thinking is somehow reserved for people with squashy brains (and souls presumably).
- __loam 4y agoIt's pretty generous to say that the models are thinking, and to denigrate brains as merely squishy. During every period of technological progress, people have used the most complicated technology of the day to try and describe brains, like clockwork or hydraulics. This is no different. Brains are special. We know some of their principles but we still don't understand how cognition occurs given those principles. They are, of course, physical machines. They must operate on physical principles. But comparing what is basically a reflex response from an unthinking ml model to them? Come on.
- IshKebab 4y ago> It's pretty generous to say that the models are thinking Why? Only if you pick an especially narrow definition of "think". > Brains are special. Only in that their "algorithm" is better than current ML. As far as we know there's no "soul" or physical process that a computer couldn't theoretically also perform (please don't link that quantum microtubule nonsense). > to denigrate brains as merely squishy They are merely squishy computers. Very very complex and big computers, sure. But check out OpenWorm for example. Same thing, just not squishy.