3 ms·
If virtual particles "fit the math" the same as real particles, what makes them not real? What do they not fit?
by nine_k 4y ago
If virtual particles "fit the math" the same as real particles, what makes them not real? What do they not fit?
- evanb 4y agoWhat makes particles travel long distances as lumps is that they are on-shell. Virtual particles are not on shell. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/On_shell_and_off_shell https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/On_shell_and_off_shell
- nimish 4y agoYou don't _need_ them, and IIRC _can't_ (in general) use them if you deal with non-perturbative effects, unless you do stuff like re-summing infinite series of diagrams and that really makes interpreting the ultimately observable effect in terms of virtual particles interacting difficult.
- burnished 4y agoAn example that comes up in semiconductor is the 'hole' virtual particle. It is the absence of an electron. It is not a real and independent phenomenon. But you can treat it like a particle just fine
- gizmo686 4y agoElectron holes are quasi particles, not virtual particles.
- burnished 4y agoAh hell, guess I have to start treating the stuff I learned in undergrad into the unreliable narrator category. Thanks for the correction!
- cwillu 4y agoVirtual particles are not particles. Virtual particles are all the disturbances in a field that don't behave like particles do. It's really a terrible name to have entered the lay vocabulary: “virtual memory is something that behaves largely like real memory” is _exactly_ wrong, it's more like “virtual memory is all the circuitry that doesn't perform any memory function, but is still made of silicon”.
- cwillu 4y agoThe more correct idea is that particles aren't fundamental. There are fields, and a disturbance in one field will cause a disturbance in the fields that the first couples with. Most chains of disturbances die out really fast (“virtual particles”), but some combinations will resonate for a significant amount of time before they die out (“unstable particles”) and others don't die out at all (“stable particles”). And if the lifetime of a disturbance is fairly short compared to the frequency of the disturbance itself, it becomes hard to even make a solid distinction between those types, but again, that's a flaw caused by imposing a categorization scheme (“particles”) based on something that isn't fundamental.