8 ms·
I know some experts have poo-poo'ed the theory that Jeanne Calment's daughter impersonated her ( https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jeanne_Calment#Scepticism_regardi
by hn_throwaway_99 4y ago
I know some experts have poo-poo'ed the theory that Jeanne Calment's daughter impersonated her ( https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jeanne_Calment#Scepticism_regarding_age https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jeanne_Calment#Scepticism_rega... ), but I don't find their arguments convincing. I'm not saying it's settled, but I think the evidence strongly points to her not being as old as she says, and I think the "experts" downplay the evidence for the switch theory too strongly, even if it is largely circumstantial:
1. The age gap between Calment and the next oldest person is the strongest evidence. It's very, very hard to ignore this.
2. As outlined in this article, there is a strong economic motive for the swap.
3. I think there is other evidence (e.g. some of the photos) that wouldn't be that strong on their own, but just add to the weight of the other, stronger pieces of evidences that there was a swap.
- GalenErso 4y ago> 1. The age gap between Calment and the next oldest person is the strongest evidence. It's very, very hard to ignore this. That doesn't mean her record isn't legit. Michael Phelps won 23 Olympic gold medals. The most decorated Olympian after him won 9. There can be a big gap between the top performer and the second best performer. I'm sure a professional statistician would like to chime in.
- ihaveajob 4y agoThe size of the data sample is massively different. Only a few thousand people have earned any Olympic medals, so variance is expected to be higher than in the "years lived" metric, where we have literally billions of data points.
- masklinn 4y agoAnd Calment did not live twice as long as the runner-up, so the variance is indeed much lower in the "years lived" metric.
- tsimionescu 4y agoThe numbers are actually the other way around: there are far more Olympic medalists than there are people who (are believed to) have lived over 110.
- ianferrel 4y ago"Number of Olympic medals" is a very poor analogous concept here, because it's not a directly measurable and variable trait, it's a complex tail-end derivative of several factors. If you looked at "swimming speed", for example, which is the simple directly measurable thing, you would find that while Phelps is faster than other swimmers, , he is only a tiny bit faster than the next fastest swimmer, not 2.5 times faster than the next fastest swimmer.
- masklinn 4y ago> "Number of Olympic medals" is a very poor analogous concept here, because it's not a directly measurable and variable trait, it's a complex tail-end derivative of several factors. As if extreme longevity is not a complex tail-end derivative of several factors?
- grandinj 4y agoOne is rank data, the other a continuous variable. Two very different sub-fields of statistics apply to the two kinds of data.
- ianferrel 4y agoWell, so is swimming speed. I may not have the statistical terminology correct, but the difference is that "age" and "swimming speed" are directly measurable continuous aspects of reality, while "# of olympic medals is some kind of discretized derivative of others. Imagine that instead of measuring "age" we measured "number of days person was the oldest person in the world". You'd get wildly divergent results for the latter that would be more like the olympic medal count. Or if we determined how wet or dry a climate was not by measuring "annual rainfall" but, like "number of minutes per year in which more rain was falling here than other places".
- chongli 4y agoYeah, plus swimming is anomalous in and of itself due to the large number of very similar events. I’m sure we’d see sprinters like Usain Bolt win a lot more medals if there were events like “100m in sandals, 100m on grass, 100m barefoot” to go along with the usual 100m race.
- hn_throwaway_99 4y agoOne thing I would highlight, because this is what I've seen the French experts in this situation do, is look at each piece of evidence in isolation and say "Ha, this alone doesn't prove it." And, to that point, I agree, it doesn't prove it (and, to clarify, I don't think the controversy is proven one way or the other). But I think it's wrong to look at each piece of evidence by itself - it's the totality of all the evidence that makes me extremely skeptical of the overall claim. E.g. if the age gap was the only piece of evidence, it wouldn't alone lead me to believe there was a swap, but all the evidence that Novoselov and Zak present together have convinced me of their theory.
- Y_Y 4y agoTaking each word of your comment alone and not in relation to the other words around it I find that you're talking complete nonsense!
- roflyear 4y agoThere's lots of people alive not an incredible amount shooting for swimming world records.
- anonymouskimmer 4y agoThe current, known, oldest living dog is almost 1.5 years older than the second oldest. The current one is also still living, so could exceed this number. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_longest_living_dogs https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_longest_living_dogs Proportionately this compares quite favorably to Calment, being about double her spread from the next oldest human.
- Murfalo 4y agoConspiracy-theorist goggles on... this is also fraud?! (I have no evidence, just pointing out the possibility)
- anonymouskimmer 4y agoYeah, I think we've all considered that. Accurate record keeping for pets is worse than for humans.
- bryanrasmussen 4y agohow do you know? I'm pretty sure that record keeping for dogs in Denmark is more accurate than record keeping for much of the world's human population, especially when you consider going back 100+ years for those humans. The oldest dog is evidently Portuguese. Not sure what that country's record keeping for dogs is like.
- anonymouskimmer 4y agoSignificant numbers of dogs are feral, or of uncertain age and origin when adopted.
- duskwuff 4y agoAnd it's much easier to pass off one dog for another similar-looking one. There's substantial reason to suspect this may have happened with the current record holder for world's oldest dog ("Bobi"), for example -- IIRC, some of the photos show some sudden, inexplicable changes in coat patterning...
- Workaccount2 4y agoFor me one of the strongest bit against this is that her daughter would have had to pull the wool over everyone in their towns eyes, or they would have had to have been in on it too.
- jquery 4y agoWell, either something like that happened... or she won a lottery with a 10 billion to 1 chance. My money is on the former. I've read enough stories about people assuming false identities to understand there's a number of ways to pull something like that off.
- amluto 4y agoWhoa, watch out for a very common statistical error. For any particular property with a 10 billion to 1 chance, the probability that it applies to someone living is quite high. If you have a group of properties, each with an independent 10 billion to 1 chance, the probability that someone living has one of these properties is very high indeed. The fallacy of thinking that winning a lottery is rare is common and has horrible effects like sending innocent people to jail on a regularly basis. For example, if you search Clearview AI for someone who is a 99.99% match for a surveillance picture of someone committing a crime, you should expect tens of thousands of matches. If the AI really did its job, it would return many hits along with a prominent warning that, with very high probability, any given one of these people did not commit a crime! And, of course, someone always wins the lottery, since that’s the whole point.
- lovemenot 4y agoSimilar example leading to false imprisonment: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sally_Clark https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sally_Clark >> Sir Roy Meadow, who testified that the chance of two children from an affluent family suffering SIDS was 1 in 73 million. He had arrived at this figure by squaring his estimate of a chance of 1 in 8500 of an individual SIDS death in similar circumstances. The Royal Statistical Society later issued a statement arguing that there was no statistical basis for Meadow's claim, and expressed concern at the "misuse of statistics in the courts".[3]
- deanCommie 4y agoAll the discussion makes it seem like the difference would be of 20 years or something. But she died at 122. There are 63 people who lived at least 115. I would say if it's reliable that humans can live up to 115, it's not a huge difference to my mental model on longevity if they CAN'T (yet) live to 120.
- hn_throwaway_99 4y agoLook at the list of longest living women: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_the_verified_oldest_people#100_verified_oldest_women https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_the_verified_oldest_pe... If you look at, say, the top twenty, the gap between each woman tends to be on the order of weeks to a few months. The gap between Calment and the runner up is over 3 years. Statistically, this is a giant chasm for continuous data like this.
- joshuahedlund 4y agoReminds me of Usain Bolt's 100m dash records, when he would shave a tenth of a second off a record crowded with incremental millisecond differences.[0] [0]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/100_metres#All-time_top_25_men https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/100_metres#All-time_top_25_men
- kevinmchugh 4y agoI'm reminded of the long jump record: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Men%27s_long_jump_world_record_progression https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Men%27s_long_jump_world_reco... There's only one in-competition jump better than Bob Beamon's in the last 55 years
- oblio 4y agoAlso Bubka: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Men%27s_pole_vault_world_record_progression https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Men%27s_pole_vault_world_recor... Started in 1984 at 5.85, ended in 1994 at 6.14, after breaking the world record 30 times, I think, took 20 more years for someone to beat his record.
- canjobear 4y agoAlso she had her personal documents and photos burned, a damning piece of evidence which is mentioned without comment here: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jeanne_Calment#Age_verification https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jeanne_Calment#Age_verificatio...
- masklinn 4y agoThere is nothing damning about it? Half of HN would immediately start throwing paper into the BBQ if the city requested access to personal documents.
- jquery 4y agoIt doesn't damn her as a person, but if you're gonna claim to have won the lottery twice in a row, I think you had better have the receipts or people can safely assume you're either lying or confused.
- TylerE 4y agoBut ALL family photos too? That smells rotten.
- vidarh 4y agoI do genealogy. Of the family members that were born that long ago, we have pictures of maybe 1/4. It's not at all certain that "all family photos" amounted to much.
- gopher_space 4y agoIt's not an uncommon occurrence after a nasty divorce or a death. It smells less rotten when you learn that people generally regret doing it to some extent. Box full of memories into the fire in a fit of rage/grief.
- TylerE 4y agoWhy burn photos of yourself, though, at an advanced age?
- masklinn 4y ago> 2. As outlined in this article, there is a strong economic motive for the swap. Which one? We're not talking about Sogen Kato here, we're talking about Jeanne Calment. Calment's daughter is supposed to have died in 1934, did the swap happen then? But there was no economic motive at all, the Calment family was part of the city's wealthy upper class and french social security was only introduced in 1945. So what else, did the Calment's daughter fake her death somehow (despite her father, mother, husband, and son remaining public figures), then take over after the primary financial coup, the sale of the apartment to the notary in 1965, after what would have been the death of her husband and son both? Not to mention the notary's strong incentive to uncover such a fraud: the flat was purchased in annuities, he ultimately paid twice the value of the flat (and waited 20 years before being able to use it, when Calment finally moved to a retirement home).
- hn_throwaway_99 4y agoNo, the economic incentive was not pensions, it was avoidance of death duties. It is precisely because Calment's family was wealthier that this motive is stronger: https://yurideigin.medium.com/jaccuse-why-122-year-longevity-record-may-be-fake-af87fc0c3133#ad61 https://yurideigin.medium.com/jaccuse-why-122-year-longevity...
- anonymouskimmer 4y agoCould a 59 year old's body be substituted for a 36 year old's body? If not, what did they do with the supposed daughter's body?
- crote 4y agoSure, why not. It's not like you are trying to swap a 70-year-old with a teenager. If the family ages gracefully, it is definitely possible.
- pineaux 4y agoYes. A bit of make up here or there. You should dive a little bit deeper into the j'accuse. Its quite a brilliant piece. I also like part 3 where he talks about the strange fact that the husband and son died of non-natural causes. I have a feeling that Yvonne might have been quite the psychopath. Great subject for a documentary.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- jquery 4y agoExtraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence. The extraordinary evidence simply isn't there, there's too much fog in which some thing could have happened where the daughter assumed the identity of her mother, for whatever reason. It could've been taxes, could've been something temporary that turned into something permanent. Hell, maybe she was a bored housewife and thought that cosplaying as a grandma would be fun. I'm sure she had a grand old time as a "90 year old" that was able to act like a spritely 60 year old. I simply don't believe she was the oldest, although I do acknowledge there is a very slim possibility of it being true. This is a scenario where science fails us, I think. Social scientists have "proved" she was the oldest with "99% accuracy". But Bayesian statistics would pose the question, "if the odds of being the world's oldest person are 1 in 5 billion, and you took a test that was 99% accurate that confirmed you were the oldest, what are the odds of you being the oldest if the test is positive?" It turns out the odds of you being the oldest person are still astronomically unlikely... you have better odds of winning the PowerBall than of being the world's oldest person.
- neaden 4y agoThe extraordinary claim here is that a 34 year old woman would impersonate her mother for decades, including living with her father, and no one would ever notice or say anything. Your perspective is like arresting anyone who wins the lotto for fraud, because it's more likely that they would cheat then just happen to guess the right numbers.
- kevinmchugh 4y ago> including living with her father, Mother and daughter lived side by side in the same building with their husbands. After the daughter passed and the grandson married he took that apartment, so Jeanne and her son-in-law cohabitated. Whichever explanation you choose you have to say that they were a close family who really liked their apartments.
- jquery 4y agoThere's no plausible way to cheat the lotto, every sold ticket is tracked. There is a fairly plausible (and fairly ordinary) explanation for her extreme age (outstripping the next oldest by 3 years, and even with modern medicine and more people nobody is coming close to beating it).
- mlcrypto 4y agoAt this point I'm willing to believe any theory that the "experts" are scrambling to to hide
- gifnamething 4y ago>experts have poo-poo'ed the theory Because the experts are in a joke, pseudo-scientific field in which the most prominent person is the man who verified her age with laughably poor methods and has a vested interest in not being proven wrong.
- neaden 4y agoI was initially prone to believeing this, but the more I looked into it the more I realized how little sense it would make. For your points: 1. This was the thing that initially made me skeptical, but it's just not enough to say. Sure living 3 years more then anyone else is pretty unlikely, but at the same time it's not proof. 2. The swap would have had to happen so early, when Yvonne was just 34 years old she would have had to impersonate her mother, pretend to be married to her father, and fool everyone in the small town she lived in. That is just not a credible thing. And the alleged payoff to avoid taxes doesn't seem big enough to be worth the immense effort that this swap would have had to go through. 3. Photos are fairly worthless for these sorts of things. Different angles, lighting, camera techniques all can make people look very different. At the end of the day I find the alleged swap to be less believable then someone just living a long time
- BobbyJo 4y agoWhen you impersonate someone, you don't have to fool everyone, you only have to fool your mark. No one else is likely to know or care what you're doing.
- neaden 4y agoYou think in a small town if someone's mom died and they started pretending to be her and pretending their dad is their husband people wouldn't think that was weird and talk about it?
- cissou 4y agoAt first you just "pretend" to the taxman. You only start pretending publicly when all the people who could confound you are dead.
- btilly 4y agoIt is worthy of note that until she was in a nursing home, at a claimed age of 110, "Jeanne Calment" avoided any publicity about her claimed age. For example she refused the local mayor's congratulations when she "turned 100" - instead newspapers wound up running a story about someone turning 95. She literally waited nearly 50 years after the claimed switch, after she was in a new environment, with new people, without the people who would have most easily challenged it, to publicize her claim. This is exactly what we would expect from someone who was trying to hide a fraud. Search for "Publicity (lack of)" in https://www.liebertpub.com/doi/10.1089/rej.2018.2167 https://www.liebertpub.com/doi/10.1089/rej.2018.2167 for more details on that.
- littlestymaar 4y ago> 1. The age gap between Calment and the next oldest person is the strongest evidence. It's very, very hard to ignore this. This is in fact a very weak evidence, that only appears to be a strong one because of a common epistemological mistake, let me explain: The odds of such an age difference are extremely small according to a certain model of how people age, such a model has proven to be pretty accurate for the majority of the population, but that says nothing about the outliers. For biological entities like humans, one only need a single exceptional mutation or pathology to be a super-human of some sort, not fitting into the model at all. In fact, the tallest man in history is also a statistically impossible outlier, yet there's no doubt about his existence and actual height, he just happened to have a rare condition that caused him to grow up to a disproportionate height. (And if you grabbed a Guinness book of records, you'll find these kinds of things in almost every category related to human anatomy or physiology). Confusing the models with reality is a very common mistake in the history of science, often committed by people having a math background instead of a physics one, but not only. A very famous example is how French explorer Dumont d'Urville was ridiculed when he described the rogue waves he witnessed in the Indian Ocean, because such a wave would be statically impossible. It turned out that the physical model of waves at the time was just too simplistic, as rogue waves do in fact exist (and AFAIK we're still looking for a proper model explaining the phenomenon entirely).
- philegibbs 4y agoAging does not work like height. There are several biological processes that contribute to aging so one gene mutation would not make someone live longer. We can make people taller by giving them growth hormone. If aging was as simple we would have easy ways to slow aging by now.
- ars 4y agoI know that lots of people would discount this, but it's interesting to note that Jewish tradition holds that the maximum lifespan for a person is 120 years. And Calment is the only person that might have exceeded this. To me that's another bit of evidence toward the impersonation theory.
- bentley 4y agoThis belief is commonly held by Christians as well. It comes from Genesis 6:3: “The LORD said, ‘My Spirit will not strive with man forever, because he also is flesh; so his days will be one hundred twenty years.’” At that point, Genesis had described several individuals as having lifespans in the hundreds of years, most famously Methuselah at 969 years. This is sometime before the Flood. Note that interpreting this verse as a lifespan limit is not universal—an alternative reading (possibly a more popular one) is that 120 years in this context refers to how many years were left until the Flood. After the Flood, Genesis continues to describe individuals with long lifespans, but they decline rapidly. Abraham, for example, died at 175, ten generations after Noah. Later, in the post‐Exodus era, Deuteronomy says that Moses died at age 120.
- paulpauper 4y ago1. The age gap between Calment and the next oldest person is the strongest evidence. It's very, very hard to ignore this. The age gap is is just a few years. not inconceivable at all.
- tim333 4y agoI had a read of Yuri Deigin's blog post on it, "J’Accuse…!", and found it fairly convincing. It has lots of photos of mum and daughter and you can amuse yourself figuring which is which https://yurideigin.medium.com/jaccuse-why-122-year-longevity-record-may-be-fake-af87fc0c3133 https://yurideigin.medium.com/jaccuse-why-122-year-longevity... Here's maybe the key photos, showing the daughter, mum and the lady who lived on. Seems to me the daughter had a wider face and she's the one who lived on https://imgur.com/a/DsqLWdR https://imgur.com/a/DsqLWdR
- janmo 4y agoProbabilities can be tricky. Many people here in the comments point out how unlikely it is that Jeanne Calment would have been able to pull off such an identity fraud. Let's say you believe there is a 0.00001% chance she could have done it. Now compare that to, the probability of becoming the world oldest person to have ever lived, it is 1 in billions. Add to this that she outlive the second oldest person by 3 years. The probability is now somewhere in the 1 to 100 billions. Then there is actually a 99.99999..% chance that Jeanne Calment was indeed a fraud. The only way to prove her record beyond the reasonable doubt would be to do an extensive DNA testing with her deceased and living relatives as such tests have a one in billions accuracy as well, but this hasn't been done. Here is an interesting paper on the subject: https://www.liebertpub.com/doi/10.1089/rej.2019.2227 https://www.liebertpub.com/doi/10.1089/rej.2019.2227
- philegibbs 4y agoThis summary misses a lot of recent developments in the case that were published recently in a book "Jeanne Calment, the Secret of Longevity Unravelled" New evidence includes examples of signed documents showing that her signature changed suddenly in 1933, about a year before Yvonne is supposed to have died. There is also testimony from the family of a doctor in Switzerland that it was Jeanne who was ill with tuberculosis in 1931, not Yvonne who had recovered by then. There is also analysis of her recorded interviews showing that she often spoke more like Yvonne.