4 ms·
Not surprising. It's part of the general economic decoupling that is occuring between the US and PRC. This specific case is because of the (justified) increase
by alephnerd 4y ago
Not surprising. It's part of the general economic decoupling that is occuring between the US and PRC.
This specific case is because of the (justified) increased oversight into Chinese IPOs in the US. Specifically, the issue was US regulators not being allowed to audit PRC operations of Chinese companies because to IPO, Chinese companies would create a parent org in the US that held a stake in the Chinese operations [0]. Because the SEC obviously didn't want companies potentially pulling an Enron, there was a crackdown on Chinese IPOs in the US in the 2019-2023 period, and these IPOs where overwhelmingly in the "tech" sector (which in reality is too broad a term. Even Luckin Coffee - a Chinese coffee brand - IPOed as a tech company).
Tit-for-tat retaliation like this is pretty normal to be honest, and this kind of title editorialization around US-China business news is honestly really stupid.
Hell, we in the US almost had a similar trade war with the EU because of the Inflation Reduction Act.
[0] - https://www.lexology.com/library/detail.aspx?g=6c966b88-0395-44ae-95a3-92676b72f486 https://www.lexology.com/library/detail.aspx?g=6c966b88-0395...
- moose_man 4y agoThe part where it is a war, is the demand that companies sell products in China that are on US sanctions list. That isn't typical. In order to get approved you have to do something that would undermine the US policy and have your firm hit with sanctions. I don't think pretending things are normal is helpful because it stifles the conversation on the huge fork in the road the US and China faces in terms of peaceful coexistence or all out war. If we're going to come to a peaceful solution then it is important that we have a real debate. What's at stake has to be clear. Otherwise we're all going to stumble into a war like in 1914. I think part of the reason the situation now is so dangerous, is that for business reasons, people kept insisting there were no stakes at all, that there was no conflict. So it's all been much quieter military buildup on both sides. Business says we need to make money, so the problem gets delegated exclusively to Pentagon which isn't as loud as the business lobby.
- jpgvm 4y agoUS will need to be the ones to start said war. China is forming the BRICS coalition which will see them completely sated in terms of energy and raw material needs for the foreseeable future. They have no need or desire for war, their economy, influence and power will grow even with full decoupling from the US. War if anything is the only thing that can disrupt that so they are increasingly unlikely to be an aggressor. Why try change the state of the game if you are going to win by default with enough time? At some point the US has to come to terms with the fact that the Western sphere of influence only covers a tiny portion of the globe and an even smaller fraction of it's population. They are the ones driving the division but are being left on the smaller and long-term ultimately weaker side of it in terms of economic and even military potential. They hold the upper hand for now but things don't look good if they keep moving in the same direction. It's a numbers game in the end the East has more people, more land, more resources and more motivation.
- moose_man 4y agoI don't know if this is serious or not to be quite honest. But I think the South China Sea and Taiwan provide ample tinder to spark an inferno in the very near term like the next 5 years. https://www.reuters.com/world/china/china-builds-mockups-us-navy-ships-area-used-missile-target-practice-2021-11-08/ https://www.reuters.com/world/china/china-builds-mockups-us-... The point is, if no one knows what the stakes are, it becomes easy for an accident to escalate into a war. A plane collision leads to war, war-games around Taiwan lead to war. The military is on autopilot without a substantial debate about what the US should do. Neither side wants WWIII but neither did the people who stumbled in WWI. Even Hitler thought he would be able to take Poland without France or the UK intervening and was not happy when they declared war. There is no winner in WWIII. It's not a numbers game because we all die.
- jpgvm 4y agoIMO China has very clear doctrine that should make it very easy to avoid war with them. Taiwan is part of "One China". Violate that, expect war. China isn't really an aggressor otherwise. Little border skirmishes with India but that is going to get sorted out eventually once they finally decide on a damn border together. It's not like they are planning invasions of Japan, Philippines etc and not really relatable to either Ukraine currently or Poland in WWII. To me it seems pretty clear that China is happy to win economically. US really doesn't want that to happen so there is a good chance they start a war over Taiwan to prevent it.
- alephnerd 4y agoThe topic of decoupling has only become mainstream/noticed by normies in the last 1-2 years. In reality, there has been an active economic decoupling going on since 2012-13. The primary manufacturers for intermediate parts (the main portion of the supply chain that Chinese industry is competitive in) are Japanese, South Korean, and Taiwanese conglomerates like SK Hynix, Samsung, LG, Toshiba, Panasonic, NEC, Mitsubishi, Foxconn, etc. All these companies began leaving for ASEAN in the 2012-17 period when political crises between PRC-Japan (Senkakou/Diayou Islands), Taiwan, and South Korea (THAAD) lead all 3 countries to move FDI to Vietnam or reopen factories in Thailand and Malaysia that moved to PRC in the 2000s. And this isn't just in Hardware. Even in Software, American VC investment in PRC peaked in 2015 before crashing after that. Basically, what I'm trying to say is those of us who have worked in or work adjacent to the policy space know that we are in a period of elevated tensions between the PRC and the US, but it's not at the "we're going to start a shooting war" level yet. The kind of hyper-hawkish and paranoid rhetoric among "normies" is ridiculous and I say that as a China Hawk. But then again, if you have intimate knowledge of how those specific agencies and governments operate, it starts looking less scary.
- moose_man 4y agoI mean if we just look at economic and diplomatic arenas war may not be on the table. The military policy on both sides are acting in a way where war is an inevitable outcome they must prepare for. China is practicing on mockups of US ships and building systems designed to take out US military assets. US military is in the process of dispersing forces to smaller bases in preparation. China's military practiced a full naval blockade of Taiwan this past summer. Both sides are in a slow rolling mobilization. https://www.forbes.com/sites/davidaxe/2021/06/07/anticipating-war-with-china-the-us-air-force-is-spreading-across-the-pacific/ https://www.forbes.com/sites/davidaxe/2021/06/07/anticipatin... https://www.cnn.com/2021/07/15/asia/us-air-force-f-22-guam-tinian-exercise-intl-hnk-ml/index.html https://www.cnn.com/2021/07/15/asia/us-air-force-f-22-guam-t... https://www.armytimes.com/news/2022/10/11/army-prepares-for-dispersed-warfare-with-high-casualties/ https://www.armytimes.com/news/2022/10/11/army-prepares-for-... People may have been talking about decoupling for 1-2 years, but the military has been sprinting to prepare for the last decade. Look at the B-21 raider, there is a reason it was one of the quickest and most efficient programs in US contracting history.