3 ms·
> So instead, Warden’s company is releasing a new sensor that can scan a QR code. The idea behind this $6 sensor is that appliance makers can put it inside thei
by vlovich123 4y ago
> So instead, Warden’s company is releasing a new sensor that can scan a QR code. The idea behind this $6 sensor is that appliance makers can put it inside their products as a method of getting devices onto Wi-Fi easier. A user could simply show their Wi-Fi QR code (I find mine in my router app) to the sensor and get their, say, fridge or washer online. I think it could be neat as a way to transfer a recipe to an oven, or specific washing instructions to a washing machine for particular items of clothing. Unfortunately, unlike scanning a new shirt and getting the machine to change its parameters to provide the best wash, many of the use cases for TinyML are going to be kind of boring.
Sorry. What’s the ML piece here? QR codes are from the 90s and don’t use any ML I’m aware of…
> However, at the conference Warden told me that, while he’d quickly discovered that the model worked, educating people about new gestures was tough. “No one knows that these gestures are available,” he said. This makes sense. If you remember back to the launch of the first iPhone and its touchscreen, the first ads and demonstrations focused on things like taps and pinch-to-zoom. Those weren’t intuitive; they were taught.
And if that were true, that’s solvable just like with the iPhone by having tutorials when you boot your TV. I think what’s actually the case that the CEO doesn’t want to admit is that he’s having trouble convincing TV makers this is a useful model when they’re all going into voice-operated UIs. That and the BOM cost makes it unappealing.
- vlovich123 4y ago> Elsewhere at the event, HP showed off two TinyML implementations with ST Micro that are embedded in new laptops. The first TinyML model uses a gyroscope to detect if a laptop has been placed in a bag or taken out of a bag. The idea behind the implementation is that the laptop will start booting up when it’s taken out of a bag in preparation for its owner to use it. If the model detects the laptop has been placed in a bag, it will change heating and cooling parameters to make sure the laptop doesn’t overheat. And when the model gets it wrong (which it invariably does) you’ve got a laptop that failed to be in sleep in a bag (maybe you fallback to more primitive models that are foolproof like increased temp + lid closed = in bag). But seriously. If you go to sleep on lid close, putting it in a bag doesn’t really change your thermal envelope (should have happened on lid closed). And booting before your lid opens seems silly when Apple shows that it can be done near instantaneously. In other words, this seems like a PM developed feature for promo instead of good engineering being done. > The second use case also helps with thermal management. In that use case, the laptop detects when it is on a hard or soft surface. If it’s on a soft surface, like a bed or a person’s lap, it will try to run cooler so as to avoid overheating. Ok. Maybe this is interesting. But do you actually need ML or is it enough to define a thermal budget and recognize a solid surface can probably dissipate heat more quickly and anything beyond that doesn’t buy you all that much.
- digging 4y agoAll of these use cases seem like AI will only do a worse job of solving the problem.
- Xelynega 4y agoThis is giving blockchain/cryptocurrency ptsd. "We are early, it's just not there yet"
- marcosdumay 4y agoHow dare you? AI pioneered that kind of empty promises decades before blockchain was even a thing! But, seriously, this is just a "look at me!" scream to get customers or investors. People do that with every single thing (doesn't even need to be an actual thing), and it's no fault of the thing at all. It's not a matter of being there yet or anything, it's just dishonest people.
- nelgaard 4y agoYes, with these kind of issues you need to keep it very simple. I have an old Chromebook that runs Linux. I did have the problem that it would sometimes wake up in my backpack and run very hot. Eventually I found out that the plastic lid was soft enough that it would bend and let the screen touch the touchpad which would wake up the Chromebook. It was possible to disable this behavior but it was not simple enought.
- lupire 4y agoIt's not so much about "booting" or "waking" befor opening the lid. It's more about improving what Apple calls "power nap": to get on wifi and download updated mail/chat/info before opening the lid.
- taneq 4y agoYeah, these are not good use cases for ML. They're tractable with traditional sensors and approaches, and they're horribly annoying when they get it wrong, but even more horribly annoying when they get it wrong inconsistently.
- Joker_vD 4y ago> I think it could be neat as a way to transfer a recipe to an oven, or specific washing instructions to a washing machine for particular items of clothing. ...is there also a neat way to remotely transfer the recipe's ingredients to an oven or load clothes into a washing machine? One of my buddies once joked about the smart homes that they allow you to unlock your front door while being anywhere in the world — but sadly, there is almost never a useful reason to unlock your house's front door from 2000 km away.
- throwaway1777 4y agoAirbnb is about the only one.
- zmix 4y agoOr your children lost/forgot the key and nobody is at home.
- cossatot 4y agoOr letting someone in to feed your cat.
- throwaway1777 4y agoHousesitting is a good one
- vlovich123 4y agoWhat about when you’re at work and want to let the repair person in? Or you run an Airbnb and want to let in your guests without having to worry about keys and lockboxes. Or you want to let in a family member. I think there are valid reasons for that.
- justrealist 4y agoYeah, this reminds me of the other article on the frontpage, about Google not understanding why anyone needs 5m files in Drive. Well, maybe you don't. Maybe it's not something that affects you, or 80% of people, 80% of the time... that doesn't make it useless. Try to step outside your own life even a few steps...
- __MatrixMan__ 4y agoProbably you're washing more than one shirt at a time, so the optimal washing parameters for the whole load is going to be some not-quite-average of the the data on all of the input QR codes, combined with whatever the machine sensors learn. Seems pretty ML to me, though the writing could use work.
- vlovich123 4y agoAt which point the user can pick the optimal parameters anyway (and likely do a reasonable enough job) without fancy ML. Fancy ML would be things like “take out items xyz” to wash just whites. That being said, it’s possible the ML piece is about reading multiple QR codes at once in different angles. I could see that requiring some ML. But still. It feels like a solution in search of a problem since they seem to be taking the “throw spaghetti at the wall and see what sticks” approach to building products.
- nelgaard 4y agoYeah, about 15 years ago when there were companies planning to replace barcodes with RFID tags on all products, a big selling point was that washing machines could detect red socks in a white wash. Someone did make such a washing machine, from 2012: https://www.appliancesonline.com.au/academy/appliance-news/smart-washing-machine-can-read-your-clothes/ https://www.appliancesonline.com.au/academy/appliance-news/s... Note the caption: "The washing machine's brains do the thinking for us".
- __MatrixMan__ 4y agoI can't be bothered to go through the tags and think about settings. If the laundry destroys it I'll just stop buying things like that going forward. Probably there are people as lazy as me, but with a better eye for fashion. Maybe they would care?
- JohnFen 4y agoIs this an actual problem that needs solving?
- otabdeveloper4 4y ago> get their, say, fridge or washer online Yeah, no thanks.
- lupire 4y agoWith local TinyML, Jian-Yang's Not Hot Dog can work without needing privacy-risky online services.
- Dalewyn 4y ago>Sorry. What’s the ML piece here? QR codes are from the 90s and don’t use any ML I’m aware of… You must have missed the memo, everything is AI now. Your toaster? It toasts your bread with AI. Your microwave? It heats your food with AI. (Yes this is sarcasm. "AI" has become a meaningless buzzword thanks to marketing and the media. Same goes for "machine learning".)
- sleepybrett 4y agoGiven that this stuff was built into the original and revised kinect software on the xbox (360 and one) and no-one really knew or cared. I believe that the initial setup stuff on the xbox one covered the voice commands / gesture commands. I have a feeling they were soon forgotten. Unfortunate given how powerful the kinect, especially version 2, is. When it comes down to it, gesture control is often fiddly and obscure (there is no button on the screen to push to remind you the function exists, you just have to know 'if i wave at it, it will probably turn on'). Both of those downsides turn it into a non starter for most users.
- neodypsis 4y ago> Sorry. What’s the ML piece here? QR codes are from the 90s and don’t use any ML I’m aware of… Presumably they are using object detection to recognize where the QR codes are located in the image? Which they then feed to the standard QR decoding algorithms.
- vlovich123 4y agoYeah I note that down below in my response: > That being said, it’s possible the ML piece is about reading multiple QR codes at once in different angles. I could see that requiring some ML. But still. It feels like a solution in search of a problem since they seem to be taking the “throw spaghetti at the wall and see what sticks” approach to building products. What I’m saying is that washing clothes doesn’t seem to benefit from any QR codes. And the cooking example is even more confusing because presumably you’d have one for the recipe, not per ingredient
- neodypsis 4y agoI can see how it could be useful to have such an input method in an embedded system for some configuration options like WiFi credentials. > What I’m saying is that washing clothes doesn’t seem to benefit from any QR codes. And the cooking example is even more confusing because presumably you’d have one for the recipe, not per ingredient Well, we are in the age of IoT. Every appliance now wants to be connected to the Internet.
- lupire 4y ago> washing clothes doesn’t seem to benefit from any QR codes Clothing has care labels on it. Washing machine should read that.