4 ms·
Nuclear is fundamentally cheaper than nearly any other energy source. However our laws are backwards: regulators are required to increase safety standards for n
by adastra22 4y ago
Nuclear is fundamentally cheaper than nearly any other energy source. However our laws are backwards: regulators are required to increase safety standards for nuclear so long as it is cheaper, until the costs are brought up to par with other energy sources. As a result, nuclear is orders of magnitude safer than anything else, and burdens costs that other energy sources don't have to account for, yet it is perpetually no cheaper than coal or natural gas. It's blatant regulatory capture by fossil fuel in the name of "environmentalism."
- pydry 4y agoIt isnt the law making it expensive. It's capital costs. It would be even more expensive if it didnt get a free ride on insurance - through disaster liability caps set at ~0.05% of the costs of one Fukushima.
- adastra22 4y agoBut the point is those capital costs are so high because nuclear is required to meet a threshold of safety far, far in excess of any other energy source. There are instances of nuclear plants having to shield radiation to be lower than background levels. Which beyond being absolutely pointless, it adds weight, which adds concrete, which adds capital costs and CO2 emissions.
- pydry 4y agoThe only reason it exists at all is because it gets a free ride on insurance through the catastrophe liability cap. IMHO it's a bit premature to talk about deregulating it without first making sure it shoulders full liability for the damage it would cause by neglecting important safety.
- nullc 4y agoYou can easily find the locations of coal power plants by looking at maps of cancer rates. Nuclear is the only 'energy source' that is required to capture pretty much any of its externalities at all, so arguments that they don't capture all of them are a bit odd.
- pydry 4y agoIf it has a catastrophe liability cap how can it possibly be capturing all of its externalities? Nuclear power never pays for disaster cleanup and still can't compete with renewables.
- jltsiren 4y agoThe real issue is the risk profile. When you build a new reactor, it's almost certainly going to be safe. But there is a small risk of a catastrophic outcome, where most of the damage is local or at most regional. Normally this would be the kind of a situation where insurance is the right solution. But because the potential magnitude of the catastrophe is too great, the insurance sector is incapable of handling it. No one is willing to provide a sufficient insurance policy on a commercial basis. Because the assets of the company operating the reactor are also insufficient in the worst case, that leaves the government as the ultimate insurer. And as with any insurer, they require you to take various steps to mitigate the risks.
- rainsford 4y ago> However our laws are backwards: regulators are required to increase safety standards for nuclear so long as it is cheaper, until the costs are brought up to par with other energy sources. Any citation for that? It's a convenient villain to blame, but absent any proof regulators are deliberately trying to make nuclear less competitive, it seems much more plausible that regulations are driven by concern over accidents. If a wind turbine fails it doesn't make the entire region uninhabitable for decades.
- joseph_grobbles 4y agoThey made it up. Similarly you frequently see claims on here that nuclear came to a standstill because of all the ignorant beatnicks, when in actual reality raw capitalism is why nuclear stalled: Endless disastrously expensive projects tainted the industry into picking everything but nuclear. Nuclear is a fantastic base load. It is, done right, clean and safe. The weird pro-nuclear cult that spreads manufactured nonsense is just noise, however.
- adastra22 4y agoI did not make it up: https://www.nrc.gov/reading-rm/basic-ref/glossary/alara.html https://www.nrc.gov/reading-rm/basic-ref/glossary/alara.html https://www.nrc.gov/docs/ML1610/ML16105A136.pdf https://www.nrc.gov/docs/ML1610/ML16105A136.pdf
- joseph_grobbles 4y ago[dead]
- richk449 4y agoIt’s not a conspiracy theory, it’s just the way some of the nuclear regulations are written. Operators are required to achieve radiation dose as low as reasonably achievable. https://www.nrc.gov/reading-rm/basic-ref/glossary/alara.html https://www.nrc.gov/reading-rm/basic-ref/glossary/alara.html
- nicoburns 4y ago> As a result, nuclear is orders of magnitude safer than anything else How exactly is nuclear safer than solar or wind? Solar panels in particular are about as dangerous as an inert rock.
- metalspot 4y ago> Solar panels in particular are about as dangerous as an inert rock just wait until they are abandoned by bankrupt companies and start to break down and all of the highly toxic substances they are made of leech into the ground water.
- crote 4y agoVery few people die in nuclear accidents, but quite a lot of construction workers end up falling off roofs while installing solar panels.
- nicoburns 4y agoThat's an interesting point. I think my view on this is that I think we've been pretty lucky with nuclear accidents thus far, and that we don't have nearly enough to data to conclude that we will continue to operate them as safely as we have thus far. A single bad nuclear accident affecting a major city would turn that statistic entirely on it's head for centuries worth of solar panel installation.
- adastra22 4y agoThat amount to saying "I'm going to ignore all the evidence because I don't like the conclusion."
- nicoburns 4y agoIt's simply interpreting the data differently. Statistical conclusions always depend on your priors. We may also have a difference in risk tolerance. I'm willing to accept "accidents almost never happen" for something like air travel because the consequences are much less severe even if a worst-case accident does happen. I'm not nearly so willing accept even a small risk of nuclear accident because the consequences are so potentially awful (the worst case is not death IMO, but slow, painful radiation poisoning).
- crote 4y agoNuclear has to be orders of magnitude safer because nuclear incidents have a way bigger economic impact. A gas plant or solar farm blowing up will be in the hundreds of millions of $, but Fukushima is counting in the hundreds of billions of $. The nuclear industry has a history of creating plants which are "totally safe, really, you can trust me!" and ending up with really expensive accidents. If they can't get their shit together and get basically unlimited insurance for whatever accident might still happen, the government has to enforce safety rules for them so the taxpayers don't end up having to pay for their whoopsies over and over again.
- metalspot 4y agothe nuclear industry has a history of creating the safest power source ever. that is just a fact. as mentioned, everything fossil fuel related has a massively higher death and injury cost than nuclear. the california wildfires caused by the criminally negligent failure to maintain power distribution systems killed more people and cost more money that Chernobyl (look it up).
- 35208654 4y agoReally expensive accidents that cost money and very few lives. Meanwhile, coal had gotten a pass on hundreds of years of added costs to healthcare and loss of life expectancy.
- sbaiddn 4y agoVery few lives because of the high standards, loads of luck and extraordinary courage of first responders. Lets not forget the helicopter crews at Chernobyl knew they were flying to a certain, slow, painful death and did so without a complaint. Absent those heroes nuclear's mortality record would be much worse.
- 35208654 4y agoChernobyl-style reactors haven’t been built for decades and the kind of failure that happened with it has long since been addressed. We even have designs where meltdowns are basically impossible. I agree that the people who stepped up are heroes. I don’t agree that Chernobyl’s failure has any place in the discussion about the safety of modern nuclear plants.
- deepsun 4y agoThere's no conspiracy here -- the nuclear safety is just so darn expensive, and for rational reasons. It is safer, yes, but only once a lot of resources is spent on safety. So nuclear power generation is very inexpensive and expensive at the same time, depending on amount of effort put into its safety (with modern scientific knowledge on fission, I'd say like 90% of a reactor cost is ensuring its safety). I honestly hoped that NuScale production could reduce some significant fraction of that safety costs by "commoditizing" the production. Kinda like airplanes are very safe in a big part because their production and maintenance processes are streamlined and actively practiced ("economy of scale").
- adastra22 4y agoYou can read about the NRC's stance on requiring radiation to be "as low as is reasonably achievable" here: https://www.nrc.gov/docs/ML1610/ML16105A136.pdf https://www.nrc.gov/docs/ML1610/ML16105A136.pdf ALARA, in practice, has been interpreted by the NRC as to mean "radiation levels as low as can be achievable while still being competitive with alternative energy sources." Which means that the cost of nuclear goes up until it matches or exceeds traditional baseloads (coal, gas, etc.).
- Kon5ole 4y ago>Nuclear is fundamentally cheaper than nearly any other energy source. It is not, the main costs are simply not included in the calculations. Operators are legally protected from most liabilities, and even setting liabilities aside they get bailed out if they fail to be profitable. You have to bail them out, there is no option not to. You can't simply turn off a nuclear power plant and leave it. France recently had to bail out their nuclear operator to at least 50 bn euros. We reached the point where we're "the future" that had to pay for the energy that our parents got from nuclear. Our children will be the next to pay for it, and so on for centuries. This means that even in a country that has had no disasters, nuclear power has operated under a cost model that was severely underestimated. The cold truth is that nuclear power is not cheap even in a best-case scenario, and "not cheap" is the most precise estimate we are able to give.