7 ms·
Heres what really happened: Tesla decided they wanted 'birds eye view', which most of their competitors had. To get that, they needed more cameras and more c
by londons_explore 4y ago
Heres what really happened:
Tesla decided they wanted 'birds eye view', which most of their competitors had. To get that, they needed more cameras and more camera inputs on their autopilot computer. It would be a big redesign of many features of the car. With birds eye view, parking sensors aren't really needed anymore, so they didn't place an order for new sensors.
However... The big new birds eye view feature gets delayed by ~ a year, because it depends on new autopilot silicon (HW4).
Tesla is now stuck - they don't have the sensors to make the old version, the sensors themselves are EOL by the manufacturer, and the new version isn't ready yet.
So - the CEO takes the fall, and announces that this was the plan all along. Software would replace the sensors.
That kept people happy for months. But the software team was pulling their hair out - the camera placement on the old HW3 cars was insufficient to see things very near the vehicle needed for parking, so it was never going to work well.
And the autopilot software team is being pulled in a lot of directions, and hasn't really met expectations on any targets lately - although perhaps they're trying to achieve the unachievable.
Given the original screwup (not having a backup plan for when this big new feature was delayed by a year), I think they made the best of a bad situation. Their approach of 'promise the impossible, and then underdeliver' will hurt the brand, but probably less so than any other approach.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Clamchop 4y agoCan the cars sold without the sensors plausibly be retrofitted later by Tesla service? That would be a good gesture and solution but depends on how completely they removed it I suppose.
- londons_explore 4y agoThe cars without sensors could be retrofitted with sensors, but those sensors are no longer manufactured. You could maybe take some from scrapped cars, or design an entirely new but compatible sensor.
- therouwboat 4y agoWe are talking about car company thats worth 600 billion? Cant they just pay someone to make those sensors?
- kube-system 4y agoOnly about 1/30th of that is cash. Still enough, but also, they can just not pay someone to make the sensors, as they're doing.
- judge2020 4y agoBased on investigation by GreenTheOnly it's unlikely a retrofit will be possible https://twitter.com/greentheonly/status/1625905186387505155?s=20 https://twitter.com/greentheonly/status/1625905186387505155?...
- modeless 4y agoThis sounds plausible to me, but do you have any sources?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- outworlder 4y ago> The big new birds eye view feature gets delayed by ~ a year, because it depends on new autopilot silicon (HW4). Why? Cars with orders of magnitude less processing power have that. Is that because of the lack of camera inputs?
- freeqaz 4y agoThey also said "the camera placement on the old HW3 cars was insufficient to see things very near the vehicle needed for parking, so it was never going to work well." So it's probably more of that!
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- bumby 4y ago>Software would replace the sensors. This is a fault in design philosophy. Remember MCAS, where Boeing decided their solution to a hardware design problem was a software workaround? I know it's tempting, but these types of design decisions need a very careful thought process to work; they shouldn't be a last-ditch workaround. I guess I give TSLA some slack here because it's only applied to parking, but I hope they don't apply the same design philosophy on more safety critical systems.
- m463 4y agoI think there are some parking scenarios that might be catastrophic. "backing into the pedestrian" is pretty bad, but what about fire hydrants or gas pumps?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- jjoonathan 4y agoThose don't move, so memorizing their location/occupancy should work better.
- Arrath 4y agoHow much object persistence does this system actually have? Watching objects jitter around the screen and morph from a sign to a cone to a person back to a sign hasn't inspired confidence in me.
- doubled112 4y agoAren't fire hydrant valves usually a few feet underground, which makes running them down not as exciting as it could be? Gas pumps (gasoline), at least in Canada, the pump is underground and you're really just holding a big nozzle. Bad, but not too bad. People have been driving into and through those for years. Natural gas lines and meters could be a catastrophe, but they're usually pretty close to a wall.
- Xenoamorphous 4y ago
- bonestamp2 4y ago> Their approach of 'promise the impossible, and then underdeliver' will hurt the brand, but probably less so than any other approach. I have worked for several other automakers and they plan platform changes 3-7 years out. I know that's not Tesla's style, but that long term planning usually prevents these cases of under delivering what you promised. That's because the marketing department isn't promising anything until engineering has it working on a mule and manufacturing operations has the parts on order for production.
- paxys 4y ago> With birds eye view, parking sensors aren't really needed anymore, so they didn't place an order for new sensors. I believe it was more that they couldn't get the sensors due to supply chain issues.
- rootusrootus 4y agoThe idea that bog standard 'birds eye view' would require HW4 is the saddest thing I've heard today. How powerful is the computer that Nissan puts in a rogue to provide that view, as compared with HW4?
- nicpottier 4y agoI'm guessing they mean more it's a limitation of where the cameras are placed rather than the processing power. HW4 slightly tweaks the camera positions and angles which I believe removes the current blindspots that make birds-eye impossible.
- nomel 4y agoThe processing power probably isn't the limitation. It's probably hardware, like the number of hardware ports for the cameras are limited. These aren't webcams stuck into a USB hub. If they're physically out of pins, then hardware development will be required, either for some hacky, relatively dangerous (you would be switching out primary cameras), multiplex solution, or the addition of a computer and the support/supply chain nightmare that entails.
- dawnerd 4y agoIf they can't source the older sensors why are the S and X still being manufactured with them?
- RetpolineDrama 4y agoThey're not. March 2023 model X does not have sensors.
- dawnerd 4y agoAh recently then!
- mertd 4y ago> With birds eye view, parking sensors aren't really needed anymore, so they didn't place an order for new sensors. Sorry but that's a large logical chasm you just casually leapt. How does bird's eye view magically determine the distance to a textureless wall when parallax fails to detect it? Why do cars with birds eye view still come equipped with parking sensors if they are obviated?
- gnicholas 4y agoParking sensors are handy if you're looking to the side or back when reversing, since you can hear them without looking at the screen in front. I honestly don't know where I'm supposed to look when backing up sometimes — it feels irresponsible to just look forward at a camera display, but in most cases that shows more than looking all around would. Parking sensors are nice because you can hear them chirp no matter where you look.
- pohatoo 4y agoA friend of mine was backing in to an unfamiliar parking garage and was watching the screen and all of a sudden we hear a scrape. There was an air duct over hanging the car and we hit it. The camera didn't think to show the roof. Luckily for us we hit the duct before hitting the sprinkler. That would have been a disaster.
- officeplant 4y ago>honestly don't know where I'm supposed to look when backing up sometimes Even with the addition of backup cameras I still look all around and check blind spots as if I didn't have a camera. No backup camera I've used shows enough information to be confident enough otherwise. Unless ya'll have some truly high end cars I don't see how anyone can confidently back up with just a camera and not fear hitting objects/children etc. I never even thought about my habit until a friend who is very terrified of riding in cars told me they were made comfortable by how much I look around me while driving. Which just convinces me further that most people shouldn't be on the road.
- 4y ago
- ModernMech 4y agoIn a nutshell, this whole process is the reason two Tesla owners are without heads. I realize that has nothing to do with the parking sensors, but the real problem is the engineering process. Tesla is single handedly responsible for setting the robotics industry back decades (pre 2007) with their capricious and glib attitude toward autonomous safety. Back then, its was completely unheard of for people to be testing 2-ton autonomous hardware in public on consumers. Enter Tesla and Elon Musk, and suddenly they are responsible for a general attitude that it's okay to just put these things into your community without any warnings, or laws, or safety protocols, or apparently even sensors.
- throitallaway 4y agoCapitalists gonna capitalist, and unless laws or regulations prevent Tesla from testing their software in the public, they're going to march forward. As for the accidents/deaths, responsibility needs to be shared between the owners as well as Tesla's marketing. Naming a feature "full self driving" when it's only level 2 autonomy is disingenuous at best. This may be a large part of the reason that people trust the system more than they should (fall asleep, stop paying attention, etc.)
- ModernMech 4y agoI place blame first on Musk and the executives, but then on the engineers, and third on marketing. Because the engineers know, or should have known, better. They were educated to know better. I know some of those people and they are smart people. I know for a fact they know better. And yet two heads are without bodies. They knew what the fix was after the first decapitation. Real sensors. Don't test on public roads. Don't test on consumers. That they didn't quit en masse after that is on them. That they went on to continue building and shipping the car without fixing the problem, leading to a second decapitation... there are no words. Malpractice doesn't cover it. It's as if you were an engineer for a bridge which resulted in a collapse that caused loss of life due to the poor bridge design. If you go on to make that same bridge again... that's on you.
- cstejerean 4y ago> With birds eye view, parking sensors aren't really needed anymore, so they didn't place an order for new sensors. I can see someone at Tesla making this determination if they never actually drove a competitor vehicle that has birds eye view and parking sensors.
- sschueller 4y agoSo in other words an amature failure in leadership. How many other things did they fail to consider or plan for?
- speedgoose 4y agoThe common one is the lack of a rain sensor for the automatic wipers. It relies on image recognition, and it’s very bad. They could perhaps train the model a bit better, to perhaps not start the wipers at full speed when it’s a blue sky with a dry road. But the cameras are on top of the windshield, and it can’t easily water at the bottom.
- l33tman 4y agoRemoving the wiper stalk. That decision killed one German driver who was busy fiddling in the menues to figure out how to get the wipers to max when hit by heavy sudden rain (and yeah their sensors don't work well, because they saved money by removing the industry standard IR sensor for rain and tried to rely on their front-facing camera). They have changed it now so if you push the button to do a single manual wiper stroke, the wiper speed icons pop up on the left side on the screen so you can then proceed to set them to max, but it's still a ridiculous decision that is dangerous. I guess it doesn't rain in California so nobody in charge bothered :) It's happened many times driving that I have for example overtaken a trailer that splashed an infinite amount of water on me while passing, and I had to hit the max-wiper just to see anything. A delay of a second there could mean a crash..
- judge2020 4y ago> They have changed it now so if you push the button to do a single manual wiper stroke, the wiper speed icons pop up on the left side on the screen so you can then proceed to set them to max, When did this event happen? Since very early on in the Plaid I remember this popup wiper selection happening: https://youtu.be/gHTdsOImKmo https://youtu.be/gHTdsOImKmo
- CorrectHorseBat 4y ago
- croes 4y ago>the CEO takes the fall, and announces that this was the plan all along. Software would replace the sensors That's the opposite of taking the fall. That's shifting the blame to the software department.
- greenthrow 4y agoThis is not accurate. Most cars that have 360/top down views still have parking sensors. Tesla has just been steadily removing features to increase profit margins.
- masklinn 4y agoI fail to see what works be inaccurate. That other car manufacturers are conservative has no bearing on it, it’s easily believable that Tesla would want a 360 view, and given their all in approach on vision would assume they would get rid of the seed for parking sensors (see: LiDAR). It’s also easily believable that they would go with that ahead of anything being ready because Tesla hubris and would end up where they got.
- benmorris 4y agoThis still doesn't add up. The new HW4 Model 3 "highland" doesn't have more cameras. Notably there is a no front bumper camera. It also have one LESS camera in the windshield. The HW4 board DOES have space for more cameras though.
- btilly 4y agoRegardless of their desire, it is very easy for the cameras on a Tesla in the rain to have water in front of the lens. This makes it very hard to see anything from the camera. I dread how software trained on cameras working under normal conditions will interpret the resulting mess of an image.
- joe_the_user 4y ago"Given the original screwup (not having a backup plan for when this big new feature was delayed by a year), I think they made the best of a bad situation." Yes, by greed and arrogance they shot themselves in the foot. But the day after that happened, they had no more opportunities for greed so they dealt with things as well as they could and you can't criticize them for that, now can you? The scenario of "we'll go from the old thing to the new thing, burn our bridges to the old thing and not have the thing ready" these days in a multitude of industries and isn't something that should be taken as OK by those who caught by it.
- alkonaut 4y agoI have both birds eye and ultrasound sensors all round and I’d give up the Birds Eye first easily. And there is no way Tesla will completely replace the ultrasound distance sensing with software. Ultrasound sensors are cheap compared to making multiple cameras equally reliable for depth sensing which I imagine must require deicing and wash nozzles to work well. I need to rub my finger over the lenses of my side and rear cameras every day with rain or snow (So daily for at least half the year).
- jasonmp85 4y agoWho is the CEO, again? What fall did they take? Must’ve been big to avoid naming them.
- unlucio 4y ago> the CEO takes the fall, and announces that this was the plan all along. Software would replace the sensors. the CEO doesn't "take the fall", he __has__ the fall. He's the one deciding to gamble people safety and to hand to his engineers yet another unnecessary hot potato for sake of profit and share holders dividends.