25 ms·
Tesla removes parking sensors, the results are predictably terrible
- jacobgorm 4y agoI am surprised noone has brought up Andrej Karpathy's role in all of this. He was the one who proposed vision-only self-driving, but his rep seems to have survived unscathed.
- joenathanone 4y agoI appreciate Telsa's ambition to push technology forward but they shouldn't experiment with customers in real time like this. You want to replace parking sensors with vision, go right ahead, prove it in the lab first, don't remove the parking sensors and just assume that the engineers will figure it out.
- Eji1700 4y agoSeeing this as "pushing technology forward" is a pretty generous interpretation. It reeks of cost cutting.
- MPSimmons 4y agoAgreed. I suspect there were parts shortages, and Elon was like, "The best part is no part, take it out of the design and do it with cameras". Same story with radar. Now both radar and sonar are coming back because it's far better to have the sensor data, even if you have to wade through it, than to not have it, particularly in adverse conditions.
- gonehome 4y agoKarpathy gave a talk about radar - they were getting worse results with radar than without (according to him). Mostly because they would get false readings from radar shooting under the car and stuff like that - vision alone was more accurate.
- ryanwaggoner 4y agoIf you're talking about his appearance on Lex's podcast, he didn't say this. He said that the additional accuracy wasn't worth it. Which to me sounds like it was more accurate, but they didn't want to deal with the additional cost and complexity and thought that vision only would be good enough. But the link we're commenting on, along with the ongoing complaints about FSD, seem to indicate that the real world results haven't proven that theory out.
- JoshCole 4y agoHe is talking about the long technical talk at CVPR. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=g6bOwQdCJrc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=g6bOwQdCJrc For example look at this section: https://youtu.be/g6bOwQdCJrc?t=1370 https://youtu.be/g6bOwQdCJrc?t=1370 Also if you look into it you will find Google's self-driving car project ran into similar issues. They upgraded the radar in response to the issues rather than removing it, but there are actual issues. Vision only was better than radar plus vision in their stack. For real world situations that frequently come up in driving radar wasn't worth it. The theoretical accuracy of the sensor fusion didn't happen in practice because in practice you needed to have vision tell you when sensor fusion wasn't going to be accurate. It isn't naive sensor fusion as in toy math models of sensor fusion. So when there was a disagreement you needed to go with vision. Yet vision was already able to predict both the failure of and the actual result of radar. In theory, you could just have done the more complicated sensor fusion. In practice, the relative advantage of improving other parts of the vision stack far exceeded improving the sensor fusion. Over time one would expect the relative advantage to change as other improvements were made such that this was no longer true. That doesn't mean the time at the decision wasn't correct, it just means people who evaluate it with future changes already in place are suffering from hindsight bias/committing an anachronistic fallacy.
- gonehome 4y agoYep - this is the one I was talking about, thanks for linking!
- ryanwaggoner 4y ago
- ModernMech 4y ago> Now both radar and sonar are coming back because it's far better to have the sensor data, even if you have to wade through it, than to not have it, particularly in adverse conditions. This is something that every roboticist has known for 60+ years. It's just galling to me that two people had to lose their heads because new born Tesla Inc. and the know-nothing manchild running it, felt they had the right (due to the size of their wallets, not their knowledge or experience) to overrule people who knew better. And people call this "pushing technology forward".
- Someone1234 4y agoAgreed. Actually pushing technology forward would involve replacing parking sensors with two additional cameras to cover the blind-spot, then using vision to exceed what parking sensors could do. It isn't simply to remove parking sensors, have areas of the vehicle with blind spots, then hack the problem by trying to "guess" what in happening in those locations. It has been suggested this removal saved Tesla less than $150/car. That's crazy for a $40K+ vehicle. There's nothing to defend here, it makes their vehicles objectively worse.
- saurik 4y agoFWIW, while I am in the camp if people who think this was a dumb move and who in fact cancelled my buying a Tesla over it at the last possible moment I could still walk away from the car, I had thought Tesla wasn't just running into cost issues: they also were also quickly reacting to the semiconductor shortage and even had tons of cars sitting around missing just a few parts as they frantically tried to ship, and so maybe dropping this part wasn't as much "cutting costs" as "cutting dependencies".
- inferiorhuman 4y agoIt has been suggested this removal saved Tesla less than $150/car. Far be it for me to defend lord elno, but $150 is a pretty hefty amount in automotive circles. Car manufacturers (especially the Big 3) do all sorts of shit to save literal pennies on unit cost. The idea is that their cars are sold in such high volume they're saving a ton of money. Of course it's myopic since that doesn't account for customers' willingness to pay a bit more here and there for a higher quality product.
- jeffbee 4y agoTesla is way behind everyone on computer vision. They have not "pushed the technology forward" at any time in any respect.
- amluto 4y agoHaving tested a modern Tesla car a few weeks ago, I was mostly impressed by how bad the vision algorithm was at understanding the roads. There were plenty of entirely fixed curbs, intersections, lane lines, etc that it could not handle correctly, and this was on a clear, dry day with excellent visibility. They’ve certainly pushed the willingness to use so-so technology forward, but I was really not impressed by the underlying technology. The odd thing is that these type of errors really ought to be correctable by training with a small fleet of humans annotating data. AI is very, very good at getting examples from the training set right, and fixed roads a few tens of miles from the old headquarters ought to be in or at least very similar to the training data.
- kiratp 4y agoCost cutting is a good thing if it makes things cheaper and more accessible. Yes, I know that in the short term Tesla will see expanded margins but longer term this will make things cheaper.
- moogly 4y agoI don't really see how putting a bunch of Californian developers on the task to write software to solve a problem that $114/car (according to an estimate) already solved could be considered cutting costs. They've already spent 6 months on 1 out of 5 features they lost by getting rid of their sensors.
- rootusrootus 4y agoThis is the same company that continues to waste countless hours of development time trying to get a camera-based solution to an IR rain sensor that costs about 5 bucks. I think there is a strong ideological component, not just cost cutting.
- pclmulqdq 4y agoThe biggest Wall Street "bull case" for Tesla these days is around the gross margin on their cars. Tesla has always been a little bit of an accounting project (around subsidies, etc.), and this sounds like the kind of thing that a company with a keen awareness of their stock price and a lot of comfort with accounting sleight-of-hand would do. The accountants capitalize a huge R&D loss, which fits with the company being "innovative," and in return the gross margin of the car is higher.
- tpmx 4y agoEspecially when the software-based solution very likely will fail in weather that is very unusual in California but relatively common elsewhere.
- onlyrealcuzzo 4y agoHow much do these sensors even cost? My understanding is not much. It's amazing what Tesla can get away with and keep this reputation of being the best company to ever grace the surface of the Earth.
- blibble 4y agoabout $2 each
- SQueeeeeL 4y agoThey have blatantly shown a pretty large disregard for consumer safety multiple times, this really isn't surprising. Not using lidar and releasing "self-driving" modes which routinely caused accidents both come to mind. Telsa is basically done now that real players have entered the EV market, you can kinda see it with the upper managements strange sudden shift to social media operation
- jackmott42 4y ago> Telsa is basically done now Its been a long time since the other players entered the market and they still have a horrible state with their charging networks. There are many non Teslas I would like to buy but none are viable options unless its a car that will stay in town only. I know electrify America is "ok", I've used it, multiple places with success, though always at least some stalls are broken, in weird ways, and its less pleasant to use even if it works.
- gambiting 4y agoFortunately US isn't the only country in the world - elsewhere Tesla is failing to take hold, it's just way too expensive for what it is. No idea why you'd buy a Model 3 over a Skoda Enyaq for instance.
- brandonagr2 4y agoAre you sure about that? https://www.torquenews.com/15475/europe-embraces-tesla-model-y-record-breaking-sales-february-2023 https://www.torquenews.com/15475/europe-embraces-tesla-model... "if this trend continues, the Model Y could easily secure a place in the top 10 best-selling cars in Europe by the end of the year"
- brandonagr2 4y agoWhere have you see FSD routinely causing accidents?
- jandrese 4y agoFull Self Driving has arguably been regressing as they try to do everything with just a few cameras as well. Here's what self proclaimed Tesla fanboys discovered when they tried the newest FSD beta: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9ND2ibwue_E https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9ND2ibwue_E You will often see people saying that they've put thousands of miles on their Tesla without incident, but pretty much inevitably when you dig into it you will discover that those were all highway miles where it's little more than spiffy cruise control with basic lanekeeping.
- varispeed 4y agoThere is inescapable fact that the AI at its current state can't reason and it can only deal with problems it had been trained on. Which means that on the road, where _anything_ can happen, there is a ton of blind spots where the AI rather than taking a reasonable decision, would hallucinate one, that could turn out to be disastrous. The current solution is to train for every possible scenario and hope for the best, but I don't think that should cut it when the human lives are at stake.
- iknowstuff 4y agoYou’re talking out your butt. That’s not how these cars make decisions. It’s not AI in the deep/learning neural nets sense making decisions.
- varispeed 4y agoSuch an eloquent reply, well done. ChatGPT: Tesla's Autopilot system uses a variety of machine learning algorithms to enable its autonomous driving capabilities. Here are a few examples: Convolutional Neural Networks (CNNs): These are commonly used in computer vision applications and are particularly useful for object recognition. In the context of Tesla's Autopilot system, CNNs are used to identify and track objects on the road, such as other vehicles, pedestrians, and road signs. Recurrent Neural Networks (RNNs): These are commonly used in natural language processing and sequential data analysis. In the context of Tesla's Autopilot system, RNNs are used to predict the behavior of other vehicles on the road and to make decisions about how the Tesla vehicle should respond. Decision Trees: These are commonly used in classification and regression tasks. In the context of Tesla's Autopilot system, decision trees are used to make decisions about the behavior of the Tesla vehicle based on its sensors and other inputs. Reinforcement Learning: This is a type of machine learning that involves an agent (in this case, the Tesla vehicle) learning to make decisions based on feedback from its environment. In the context of Tesla's Autopilot system, reinforcement learning is used to teach the car how to navigate complex driving scenarios, such as merging onto a busy highway or navigating a crowded intersection. Overall, Tesla's Autopilot system uses a combination of these and other machine learning algorithms to enable its autonomous driving capabilities, with the goal of providing a safer and more efficient driving experience.
- jackmott42 4y agoYou still can't use cruise control on a tesla safely because they refuse to put in a normal cruise control option and their traffic aware one still slams the brakes inappropriate at intermittent times. And careful! If you are about to tell me YOUR Tesla cruise control works fine, it is just a matter of time before it doesn't. We have all been there. auto wipers are still also wonky because the ambition is to do it with vision but they haven't figured that out yet either.
- breck 4y agoI love the Autosteer. I just did a cross country trip with it. I did get 2 or 3 of those brake slamming moments though (they keep it...interesting?). Auto wipers aren't there yet. I agree with you. Also, often when I would say "Wipers off", it would try to navigate to "Microsoft". The voice recognition is not quite ChatGPT smart.
- rootusrootus 4y agoI rest my foot on the accelerator pedal so that I can react quickly when using AP. "Interesting" translates to "my wife gets irritated when I engage AP" because the occasional phantom braking destroys any sort of confidence she has in the car. > Auto wipers aren't there yet. They are better than my first Model 3 in 2019. But not that much better, and it is 2023. Auto wipers will work on a Tesla as soon as they start using the ubiquitous $5 IR sensor everyone else has been using for the last few decades, and not a moment sooner. > The voice recognition is Incredibly shitty, that's what it is. Let's just admit that. It gets used as an excuse for all the missing controls, but it's pretty awful. They should just offer a retrofit stalk that has proper wiper controls on it. On most other mainstream manufacturers that would be easy, the stalk is just a module that hooks into the CAN bus and is replaceable with two screws.
- chankstein38 4y agoChatGPT is not a speech dictation engine.
- robbiep 4y ago> I did get 2 or 3 of those brake slamming moments though (they keep it...interesting?). Not a word you want to describe your car trip?
- kypro 4y ago> You want to replace parking sensors with vision, go right ahead, prove it in the lab first, don't remove the parking sensors and just assume that the engineers will figure it out. That's what surprised me about this. Some of these tests were really obvious. Failing one or two edge cases is forgivable, but being this inaccurate so consistently says far more about the company and their priorities. Clearly they are not QAing their products properly. This is a customer facing feature so it's easy for a reviewing to identify and test, but they're willing to cut costs on a safety feature like this then who knows what else they're doing to save costs that isn't so obvious.
- rideontime 4y agoThe logical next step is to remove all windows and windshields. Who needs them when you've got cameras?
- onlyrealcuzzo 4y agoWho even needs the car? Just send the camera out on a little drone!
- dejj 4y agoWho needs the drone? Just play Gran Turismo 2049 over Neuralink.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- buildbot 4y agoIt’s really crazy they removed the forward looking radar too, those are so useful and life saving when used for emergency braking. They can even “look”under the car in front of you and get a return for the next car in front of them, to better predict braking needs.
- joenathanone 4y ago>They can even “look”under the car in front of you and get a return for the next car in front of them, to better predict braking needs. I miss that feature the most, even though my Tesla has radar it has been disabled via software. With that feature I would know if the person immediately in front of me was going slow, and I could/should overtake or if there were a line of cars in front. I used that feature daily, made me feel a bit superhuman.
- quasse 4y ago> even though my Tesla has radar it has been disabled via software The fact that people put up with this is crazy to me. If I bought a car with a feature and then it was later taken away via an OTA update because the manufacturer didn't want to support it I would be pissed.
- joenathanone 4y agoOh, I am, just not much I can do about it.
- trogdor 4y agoIt’s surprising to me that it’s legal to sell something and subsequently remove functionality from that already-sold thing.
- moralestapia 4y agoDoes a $100 sensor really change the bottom line of a $55k+ car?
- MPSimmons 4y agoOnly when you can't ship a $55k car because you don't have any $100 sensors.
- genericone 4y agoThis holds true until Tesla/Elon gets into the business of semiconductors to control that level of supply chain and the vertical monopoly gets taller.
- foobarian 4y agoIf you need a million dollar team to support the sensor, maybe.
- stefncb 4y agoThat seems way over the top. An ultrasonic sensor is really not a difficult thing.
- icegreentea2 4y agoApparently Tesla makes on the order of 10k per car. If they can drop $100 on cost of goods and keep the same sell price, that's a 1% bump in profit/margin. Alone, that's not significant, but it's also not trivial. 1% bumps can quickly add up to "real" growth. Another way to look at is, is $100 BOM cost reduction would be like finding ~2 hours of man-hours saving in producing a single vehicle. Which at this point in Tesla's lifecycle (they've been building Model 3s for years now), is probably not an easy or cheap task.
- detritus 4y agoIf they are, as I assume they are, ultrasonic sensors - schlub punters like us can get them for £3 a pop. I've got some sat in my drawer here (for yet another project that's not gotten very far in over a year now :\ ...).
- Analemma_ 4y agoTesla is behaving like a company which doesn't realize the competition is catching up fast. For a long time they were the only game in town if you wanted an actually-good EV, which let them get away with some of their weirder and worse decisions, but now there are lots of good options available and it's no longer necessary to put up with this. I think they're in for a bad couple years if they don't return to putting the customer first.
- user3939382 4y agoI’d never want to rely on the power grid to be mobile in a widespread emergency. EV might be okay as a second car. I’ve lived through civil unrest so maybe just my bias.
- baggachipz 4y agoYou rely on the power grid for gasoline too. Gas doesn't pump without electricity. Also, refineries are a more concentrated source of failure than power stations and a grid.
- gjsman-1000 4y agoIf I'm getting nervous from Civil Unrest (or just a really bad snowstorm coming up in Canada), I can always grab a few 5-gallon containers, fill them up at a Gas Station, and keep them in my garage just in case, along with filling up my car. If nothing happens, I'll just use them up. If something does happen... I don't want to be the guy with the EV trying to get away when everyone else is also trying to use the EV charging stations for the same reason. If the charging stations are even functional. Plus, an electric car (or any valuable car) is prime target during civil unrest. It's fun to destroy expensive stuff. It's not fun to destroy a mid-2000s Civic.
- optymizer 4y agoI understand buying something extra just to be prepared, but to drive a Civic because someone might destroy it 5 years from now seems like optimizing for 0.001% of the time at the expense of 99.999% of your time. Plus, there's insurance.
- ChrisMarshallNY 4y agoI have a friend with a three- or four-year-old Caravan, with all the sensor bells and whistles. It works much better than what they are showing, here.
- jack_riminton 4y agoWhilst this obviously seems like a dumb move (and likely will stay that way) is there not a case that the vision software will continue improving rapidly until it is better than the original parking sensors?
- gambiting 4y agoHow can it be better than parking sensors? Seriously, what is the area where normal parking sensors are failing at?
- iknowstuff 4y agoPoles and curbs
- te_chris 4y agoThere is, but why ship a bad product until it does?
- jack_riminton 4y agoFull agreement there. Although I think there's nothing like finding your edge cases by deploying!
- Hamuko 4y agoNot seeing it. I feel like there's a reason why we have backup cameras AND parking sensors, even though we have a pretty intelligent vision system inside our brains.
- justeleblanc 4y agoA good stance to have if you have access to a crystal ball that can tell the future, and you don't care about safety today.
- amluto 4y agoYes and no. IMO the major benefit of parking sensors is that they see things that the driver and the cameras can’t. Not because of perceptual or image processing issues — because the obstacles are obscured by the rest of the car. So surely a good enough machine vision algorithm could do the same things if it had camera on the bumper, but they would get dirty and be more expensive than ultrasonic sensors on the bumpers. How many times have you not been sure whether there’s an obstacle right in front of your car because you can’t see there? (Maybe a really nice mapping algorithm could remember what’s in the way, but that’s not terribly useful when un-parking if obstacles move, or when parking and approaching obstacles of which the driver and the cameras have never gotten a good view.)
- crorella 4y agoWorsening products to improve stakeholder value. But they forgot that the value itself is generated by good products that people actually want to use. Very shortsighted.
- hospitalJail 4y agoI'm not sure I agree. I've meet enough Tesla owners to know that they bought it because it was a "Tesla". The same car with any other branding would not have sold it. They have a Veblen good and Tesla knows it. The best thing they can do now, is take the profits and push their 1 extraordinary feature that no one else cares to compete on(take your pick, fans will embrace it).
- electrondood 4y ago[flagged]
- xeromal 4y agoIt really is.
- mikestew 4y agoFUD? My neighbor across the street coincidentally bought a Tesla this weekend. Having just returned from driving Hyundai IONIQ 5s, I of course scurried over to check it out. He's thinking about returning it. Why? No parking sensors. Seriously, that's the reason he gave, unprompted from me. He seems otherwise happy with the car, but for this sole feature he might take it back. IONIQ 5 has parking sensors, BTW. Yes, I pointed this out to my neighbor. :-)
- drstewart 4y agoI too love my Hyundai™ IONIQ 5™, fellow human.
- drstewart 4y agoIt just serves another flimsy excuse to allow people to rant about Elon Musk. That's it.
- nkotov 4y agoI have a 2023 Model Y without radar sensors and got the parking assist update recently. It's by far one of the most annoying updates I got. Sitting in traffic, it would trigger itself thinking that I'm trying to park. Parking in the garage is now even more annoying with the cameras not being able to accurately figure out how much distance they have instead of reality. I miss the radar sensors. They need to bring them back. My wife's seven year old Infiniti is doing a better job at helping me back into a parking spot than the Tesla does. Insanity.
- kranke155 4y agoTesla seems to be quickly burning its reputation with consumers. Elon seems very good at doing things, but not great at maintaining it. Recently when Karpathy left Tesla and is now at OpenAI, IMO that is good sign that this is no Steve Jobs 2.0, capable of maintaining one the best teams in the world at Apple. Hell at this point, if you look at mature company CEO vs startup, Tim Cook seems better than Elon. Honestly Elon's companies are all suffering from what appears to be his own mismanagement.
- rootusrootus 4y agoFor all I can tell, Elon has steadily continued his descent into mental illness. Or at least that's the character he plays on social media. The best thing that could happen to Tesla at this point is for him to 100% hand over control to someone like Gwynne Shotwell.
- alphabettsy 4y agoMore Howard Hughes than Jobs or Gates?
- kranke155 4y agoDefinitely a bit of Howard Hughes, no? Must’ve been similarly alarming at the time to his close ones, but now we see it happen in public.
- 4y ago
- temp_account_32 4y agoI watched the video, those graphics on the screen seem so glitchy, jumping all over the place every second, like from some bad physics simulation in a video game. Can't believe it's something that is in production and being sold with a "luxury" car.
- dividuum 4y agoThis is really impressively bad (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=o1g1okoQJEE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=o1g1okoQJEE). The glitching alone is enough to not trust this thing one bit, but it's not even able to prevent other predicted cars from clipping into each other, detecting a person right behind the car and so on. What a joke. Combining all the raw camera feeds into a virtual overhead view would be so much more useful that this computed mess.
- HeavyFeather 4y agoSame exact thought. Imagine dropping 50-100k on a car and getting a UI that looks like pre-alpha. I suppose car owners are used to junk UIs, but this feels like a polished turd.
- phailhaus 4y agoThis was what I noticed the first time I rode in a Tesla uber, and I was shocked. While driving down the street, cars would flicker in and out of existence on the screen constantly.
- stefan_ 4y agoIt's funny we got all the people pointing out their great software because not only did the "feature" randomly crash multiple times in that video, the UI is also busy drawing random Tesla semi trucks everywhere. It's embarrassing. I guess we can laugh about it but the real problem is that this is what the "self driving" thinks is the environment.
- Der_Einzige 4y agoHow much has this one idiot, Elon Musk (and his enablers like Kaparthy) done to slow down / stifle the self driving car industry? I claim it's a lot. We are easily 3 years behind where we should be with self-driving vehicles due his refusual to believe that "Sensor Fusion" works or even is a real field of study with lots of smart people who work on it. He is hell bent on taking the things that make cars objectively safer, more aware, and awesome, like radar-based sensors, parking sensors, and heads-up-displays and not only refusing to put them in his cars (or taking them out), but also disparages them and their users on twitter. I am just capital S shocked that this is the behavior of the CEO of a company who is trying to have the aesthetics of being technologically advanced and superior and all that. The sad truth is that my 2017 lexus has a far superior set of sensors on it than a 2023 Tesla. If Tesla didn't have such insanely good powertrains and batteries, no one would buy these tin-cans shitboxes, and they ARE garbage in terms of initial quality/fit-and-finish.
- quonn 4y agoThe question is really if a software update will "fix it down the track". If the auto wipers are an indication, no it won't. On the other hand, the basic vision-based autopilot really _does_ work very well.
- akmarinov 4y agoYou mean the one they said that they'll eventually bring back it working with over 140 km/h and being able to follow at 1 car distance instead of the minimum 2 now? It's been 2 years since they've promised that.
- quonn 4y agoWhether this bothers you really depends on the country. It would both me in Germany where there are still many unlimited roads, but anywhere else? Not sure ... But even then it was limited to 150 before. Not a big difference. And a follow distance of 1 is not safe in any case.
- akmarinov 4y agoStill - they took away the functionality, promised that it' return and there's nothing for 2 years. Anything else is just making excuses for them.
- netsharc 4y agoWow, the video shows how horrible the system is. It shows what the systems see, how can people tolerate it when the display shows all the detected objects dancing around in the UI? At 9:50 it even draws a pickup that the Tesla is about to phantom-crash into, without warning the driver that "Oh I see an object in your way!"
- redox99 4y agoYeah it's incredible they shipped it like that. I bet they planned to ship it with the FSD visualization (which is very impressive), but it got delayed so much that they used that atrocious legacy visualization to meet whatever "deadline" they had.
- jrochkind1 4y agoAutomated parking is a feature available on many cars in the USA now, but I haven't myself driven one yet. Does this feature in other brands typically use ultrasonic sensors, or just computer vision? how is it implemented for other brands?
- Hamuko 4y agoPretty sure they use ultrasonic sensors. This channel actually had an automated parking test with many different EVs, and Tesla's performance was pretty all over the place there too. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nsb2XBAIWyA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nsb2XBAIWyA
- kfarr 4y agoYes basically any car north of 30k usually has little dots in front and back for the ultrasonic sensors. Basically standard for most cars these days. Very cheap, very effective
- mrguyorama 4y agoThey are so cheap they get installed in base models that don't even have the parking assist feature activated, often because they are used for other features like blind spot assist and reverse warning.
- jrochkind1 4y agoThis makes it seem especially weird that Tesla is removing them, right?
- kfarr 4y agoYes agreed. It reminds me of the change a few years ago to remove radar (or was it ultrasonic?) from the FSD hardware to go vision only. Which they seem to be reversing again? https://www.extremetech.com/cars/341409-tesla-may-bring-back-radar-autopilot-hardware-abandon-vision-only-approach https://www.extremetech.com/cars/341409-tesla-may-bring-back...
- m3kw9 4y agoShould be fixed with a software update
- akmarinov 4y agoThere's no fixing the lack of a front camera. It seems that the refresh that's coming up will have front cameras and that model will likely work well enough, but currently people are just getting shafted
- stuaxo 4y agoTypical startup behaviour - realise they can't afford, or don't want to pay for what they offered before, and cut service to a substandard level. Except in this case it's with a car, so injury and death is almost inevitable.
- maxlamb 4y agoTesla is a 20 year old company, I don’t think it can be considered a startup anymore.
- viburnum 4y agoI love how Tesla reviewers always say, "Now to be sure there will be continuous improvement," even as the product quality is decreasing.
- nv22 4y agoI am baffled by the negativity towards Tesla here. I wonder how many people here actually own a Tesla car? It's an amazing car.
- hcnews 4y agoI test drove a Model 3 recently and wasn't impressed at all. I would never buy the car, on its own and with so many news stories like this where they are cutting costs for lower feature set essentially.
- moduspol 4y agoIs this your first time in an EV-related thread on HN? This is mostly par for the course.
- rideontime 4y agoHow old is yours? I.e., does yours still have the hardware they've been removing lately?
- mikestew 4y agoMy neighbor across the street "actually owns" a Tesla car. Bought it just this weekend. And when I talked to him yesterday, he was talking about returning it because it doesn't have parking sensors, which is the topic at hand. But don't just take my word on it, plenty folks who actually own a Tesla are commenting on this very page, and some of them are not flattering toward Tesla.
- kevingadd 4y agoMaybe the negative posts watched the video in the article.
- martin8412 4y agoIt's an econo shitbox sold at premium price with dubious software to increase their margins, with removals decided on a whim by an egomaniac idiot.
- julienreszka 4y agoI wonder what was their defect severity assessment and whether they thought "oh since there's a workaround it's fine we can ditch the sensors"
- moogly 4y agoThat dealer is going to get Elon'd somehow.
- adoxyz 4y agoI have a 2018 Tesla Model 3. It has been the absolute best car I've ever owned. But it will be my last and only Tesla. A Model 3 built today has less features, costs more, and performs worse than my 2018 Model 3. The Autopilot/FSD nonsense has soured me off the Tesla brand. I will admit though, that the competition, even today is lacking compared to my 2018 Model 3, but I'm hoping Rivian pulls through and WV has got some nice stuff coming as well. I'm in no hurry though, I think my current EV can easily last another 5-10 years, so I'm optimistic.
- xiphias2 4y agoInflation is global, so you should also consider the fact that you bought it at the right time. The other companies you mentioned also have to fight with inflation, Tesla is not the only one. As for me I tried a Model 3 once and it didn't feel as comfortable as my 15 year old BMW 3 with beige leather seats, and somehow I expect improved comfort over what I already have.
- yreg 4y ago>A Model 3 built today has less features I have a 2021 TM3 and I don't think it has. - heatpump for one makes a major difference - LFP battery is great (available only in SR+) - powered lift trunk - double pane front windows - wireless charging trays (a simple thing, but very nice) - USB-C ports (and the drive can be mounted in the locked glove box) - Ryzen CPU - matrix headlights (not sure if this is true in US) - outer (pedestrian awareness) speaker - magnetic sun visor clips - depending on location, the build quality is also much better now I'm surely forgetting/not aware about more changes. And that's not counting the many improvements that came in software updates, which of course you now have as well, but they were not in your car when you bought it in 2018. E.g. sentry mode.
- devnullbrain 4y ago>A Model 3 built today has less features, costs more, and performs worse than my 2018 Model 3. Don't you think this was typical of car manufacturers during the chip shortage? Higher prices but lacking simple features.
- 4y ago
- londons_explore 4y agoHeres what really happened: Tesla decided they wanted 'birds eye view', which most of their competitors had. To get that, they needed more cameras and more camera inputs on their autopilot computer. It would be a big redesign of many features of the car. With birds eye view, parking sensors aren't really needed anymore, so they didn't place an order for new sensors. However... The big new birds eye view feature gets delayed by ~ a year, because it depends on new autopilot silicon (HW4). Tesla is now stuck - they don't have the sensors to make the old version, the sensors themselves are EOL by the manufacturer, and the new version isn't ready yet. So - the CEO takes the fall, and announces that this was the plan all along. Software would replace the sensors. That kept people happy for months. But the software team was pulling their hair out - the camera placement on the old HW3 cars was insufficient to see things very near the vehicle needed for parking, so it was never going to work well. And the autopilot software team is being pulled in a lot of directions, and hasn't really met expectations on any targets lately - although perhaps they're trying to achieve the unachievable. Given the original screwup (not having a backup plan for when this big new feature was delayed by a year), I think they made the best of a bad situation. Their approach of 'promise the impossible, and then underdeliver' will hurt the brand, but probably less so than any other approach.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Clamchop 4y agoCan the cars sold without the sensors plausibly be retrofitted later by Tesla service? That would be a good gesture and solution but depends on how completely they removed it I suppose.
- londons_explore 4y agoThe cars without sensors could be retrofitted with sensors, but those sensors are no longer manufactured. You could maybe take some from scrapped cars, or design an entirely new but compatible sensor.
- tristanb 4y agoI love my tesla, but the auto wipers are terrible. They have been terrible for 4 years. They made a similar decision to not use a rain sensor, instead using vision.
- thibran 4y agoThe auto wipers are my main gripe too. But hey, I got an almost perfect car... I love every second in it.
- bilqis 4y agoMaybe AI bros could explain why computer vision still sucks so much?
- AlexandrB 4y agoNot an AI bro, but it's easy to underestimate how good the human vision system is at dealing with novel inputs as well as degraded input quality. When viewed in isolation, our eyes might suck compared to a digital sensor - but the brain does a load of work turning that input into a cohesive and continuous view of the world. And this continues to work when vision is partially obscured by fog, rain, snow, or even injury.
- fatfox 4y agoThe tests using a wheelie bin and…person…seem really basic. How could this pass testing?
- rideontime 4y agoAs with other Tesla features, the public release is the test.
- overthrow 4y agoThe HUD in that video reminds me of cartridge tilting on an N64 to make the models glitch out. https://youtu.be/7DJQb_9CVHc?t=229 https://youtu.be/7DJQb_9CVHc?t=229 Funny in a youtube video, not so much in a $50k car.
- mikestew 4y agoMan, what a coincidence. My neighbor across the street just bought a Tesla this weekend. Having just returned from driving Hyundai IONIQ 5s, I of course scurried over to check it out. He's thinking about returning it. Why? No parking sensors. Seriously, that's the reason he gave, unprompted from me. He seems otherwise happy with the car, but for this sole feature he might take it back. IONIQ 5 has parking sensors, BTW. Yes, I pointed this out to my neighbor. :-)
- barbazoo 4y agoIs the Tesla more difficult to park than other cars for some reason? I'm asking because I've never had parking sensors or that cool "bird's eye view" and thought I was fine.
- Krasnol 4y agoThat's not the point. Parking sensors are pretty much standard in this price range, and have been for quite a while.
- grecy 4y ago> Parking sensors are pretty much standard in this price range, and have been for quite a while And all "smart phones" had keyboards for quite a while before suddenly they were just gone. Just because a feature is standard in an industry, that is not reason alone to mean it should stay.
- Krasnol 4y ago@OPs comment: Keyboard has not been replaced by nothing. OP says he uses nothing. ------------------ @the topic: physical keyboard has not been replaced by some random character generator. The on-display keyboard does at least the same job as the physical one. This new camera thing not only does less, it does it much worse.
- mikestew 4y agoThe use case of my neighbor is apparently backing into his garage. Though also mentioned something about sensing the garage door behind him (to make sure he pulled in far enough?). So I'm not exactly sure why it's important to him, but it's a big feature for him, at least. As for parking, I'd let actual owners comment, but as I was sitting in the front seat, yeah, there's blind spots like a lot of modern cars, but not so much that sensors would be a requirement for me personally. Backup camera would be good enough for my purposes.
- xbmcuser 4y agoMusk in trying to cut costs is going too far in replacing hardware with software. It was the same with Lidar. I don't know why he is okay with car being as good as humans when with sensors like lidar self driving cars can be better than humans.
- CalChris 4y agoHW4 is adding radar back. So it's not impossible that Tesla could bail on this bad decision and add USS back.
- PaulWaldman 4y ago>Tesla is behaving like a company which doesn't realize the competition is catching up fast. Does this really matter when demand for EVs outstrips supply? Can any other OEM deliver close to as many EVs as Tesla? I recently purchased a non-Tesla EV because I appreciate things like having a gauge cluster, but the vehicle was not easy to find.
- JoshTko 4y agoAt least for top two EV manufacturers (Tesla, BYD) manufacturing capacity exceeds demand, hence the large price cuts in Q1.
- mikestew 4y agobut the vehicle was not easy to find As one example, we've been looking at Hyundai Ioniq 5s, and multiple dealers have over 40 on the lot in the Seattle area (Kirkland and Edmunds are two we've checked on). VW that we drove by has a row on their lot. Supply appears to be rapidly catching up.
- NeutralForceUsr 4y agoEverything in Tesla 3 or Y screams COSTS CUTTING.
- JustSomeNobody 4y ago> First it was lumbar adjustment for the front passenger, then it was carpet in the front boot, shortly after the mobile charger disappeared – and now Tesla has removed front and rear parking sensors in the Model 3 and Model Y in a quest to save money and improve profit margins for shareholders. This is why you can't have nice things. There's no way I would buy a new Tesla without these features. Teslas cost too much to not include these. > improve profit margins for shareholders When is this going to stop? I'm sorry, I get that with this audience, I just hurt some of you by asking that. But seriously, this is fucked.
- diebeforei485 4y agoThis is similar to that yoke steering wheel - goes way too far with minimal user benefit. The sensors probably add what, $100 to the manufacturing cost? They could simply charge users $200 more and make everyone happier.
- qgin 4y agoSeems premature to cut costs on a system that doesn’t work yet.
- dauertewigkeit 4y agoIs all this drama part of the experience?
- KingOfCoders 4y agoJust coming back from a 1k km trip with a Model Y LR, generally nice, but on the topic, with heavy rain detection of other cars was real bad.
- ethagknight 4y agoMy wife's 2022 Chevy Suburban excluded both radar-distancing cruise control and also parking sensors. It is very annoying, but Tesla is not the only one that has had to make these compromises. At least Tesla is trying to solve the same problem, Chevy dealership says they will "eventually" be able to retrofit (ha...). They do still have rearview cameras and a front windshield.
- alexchamberlain 4y agoThis is solidly mad. In a car, you have the opportunity for the perfect collaboration of hardware and software - computer vision is great if all you have is a rubbish PC webcam as the lowest common denominator, but when you control the hardware, why on earth would you give up sensors that give you actual depth calculations!?!
- contingencies 4y agoUltrasonic sensors are super common in industry. Modules vary by FOV, distance, update rate, mounting, size, etc. We did a semi-formal comparison of the more popular mainland Chinese units last year. They all have the problem where partial blocks to their FOV (eg. thin post or foliage) or non-perpendicular surfaces generate wildly fluctuating output. Other problem scenarios include dirtied sensor lenses, glass and liquids (feel like reversing through a fish tank?). While these issues are basically inherent to the physics, approaches like sensor arrays, post-processing or visual/inertial sensor fusion, inset mounting and washdown can help to resolve it. The good thing is at the low end they are dirt cheap, in the order of $0.50 or less at volume, with typical nominal ranges of 45 or 60cm, though 4m may be readily achieved in practice. So for an array of three units with dedicated post-processing you may be talking an anticipated final production cost of around $2 per unit. That said, your control plane is still going to need to remain seriously skeptical of output, as something as simple as mud can totally destroy your readings. One may reasonably suspect that Tesla made a strategic decision to move away from ultrasonic owing to the reliability issues pervasive to the technology.
- benmorris 4y agoEntirely predictable train wreck in the making. The vision based transition from the start has been a complete mess for years now. Here is a short summary for those that don't understand. - Mobile Eye dumps Tesla in AP1 days forcing them to develop their own vision based auto pilot aka AP2 https://arstechnica.com/cars/2016/09/tesla-dropped-by-mobileye-for-pushing-the-envelope-in-terms-of-safety/ https://arstechnica.com/cars/2016/09/tesla-dropped-by-mobile... For those that aren't aware it took years for it to work nearly as well as AP1. - Tesla removes rain senor in favor of vision based detection in AP2 cars as well. To this day vision based rain sensing is one of the worst features of the car. It is laughably bad in certain scenarios (night). - Early 2021 Tesla removes radar in favor of vision based cruise control and Traffic aware cruise control. Again, the product was rushed out due to supply shortages in an unfinished state. Still to this day the speed limit and distance settings are not on parity with radar enable cars. Vision based cars still deal with frequent phantom braking (just google it). Surprise surprise this one was so bad radar is coming back in hardware 4. I've AP1,2, and 3 cars now and we were forced to sell our 2021 Y over issue #3 the phantom braking in the vision based system. I've heard it has gotten better but this parking sensor business is just more of the same from Tesla. Another one that is flying under the radar with HW4, Tesla is removing the ambient outdoor temperature sensor. This is right up there with the rain sensor. I can't tell you how many times I've been traveling through a weather system or going up and down elevation it's nice to know the actual temperature, not something fed from an API.
- brokenmachine 4y ago>Tesla is removing the ambient outdoor temperature sensor Another 20c saved, lol. That's truly pathetic. I mean, it's not a cheap car.
- nojvek 4y agoOMG! that was pretty bad. In our Toyota Rav4 it shows camera stitched 360 view. I as a user get to decide with my eyes and brain what is around and my visual cortex does a decent job even in rainy/blurry scenario. It seems Tesla is hiding the raw camera output and letting their vision stack perceive (which is pretty bad compared to human visual cortex). I wonder why they went that route. Even if they augmented an overlay but still showed camera stitched video like https://babydrive.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2020/12/TOYOTA_RAV4_HYBRID_2020_2021_33-1536x1024.jpg https://babydrive.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2020/12/TOYOTA_R..., it'd have still worked. They don't need to re-invent the wheel here. Overlay is a pure software thing, they are doing a disservice to their users.