7 ms·
2001: A Space Odyssey
- bell-cot 4y agoWith the number of HN submission titles matching /AI/ right now... "Look Dave, I can see you're really upset about this. I honestly think you ought to sit down calmly, take a stress pill, and think things over."
- BMc2020 4y agoHAL 9000: The answer is, "I am aware of these facts. Nevertheless you must leave within two days." Dr. Floyd: HAL, who the hell is sending this? HAL 9000: I'm sorry, Dr. Floyd, I don't know. Dr. Floyd: Well, tell whoever it is that I can't take any of this seriously unless I know who I'm talking to. HAL 9000: Dr. Floyd? Dr. Floyd: Yes? HAL 9000: The response is, "I was David Bowman." Do you want me to repeat the last response? Dr. Floyd: No, no. Tell Curnow that this is no time for jokes. HAL 9000: Dr. Curnow is not sending the message. He is in access way two. Dr. Floyd: Well, tell whoever it is that I can't accept that identification without proof. HAL 9000: The response is, "I understand. It is important that you believe me. Look behind you."
- bell-cot 4y agoNO SPOILERS!!! Besides, that was from 2010.
- LinuxBender 4y ago2010 was a great movie. I wish more people had seen it, with all the tension between the US and Russia one could hope that the brilliant minds could still work together as they eventually did in the movie. Scene from your quote [1] [1] - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=l6LbnqzE3Y4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=l6LbnqzE3Y4 [video][5 mins]
- pmoriarty 4y agoAs a fan of 2001, I was disappointed with 2010. Honest response. I've rewatched 2001 many times, but never had the urge to rewatch 2010 even once.
- LinuxBender 4y agoAs someone who has watched far too much CinemaSins, The Critical Drinker and other critics I can totally see that. Each have their flaws. I have to consciously disable my CinamaSins dinger or I can't enjoy anything. A reboot of both of them with modern special effects might be interesting assuming whoever does the reboot does not inject modern social/political biases into it.
- jedberg 4y agoI'm exactly the opposite. I just rewatched 2010 recently all the way through without stopping. I tried rewatching 2001 and got bored. I love the concept and it's beautiful, but you could edit that movie down to 80 minutes and get almost the same impact.
- rbanffy 4y ago> As a fan of 2001, I was disappointed with 2010. 2001 left some galaxy-sized film cans to fill. Even being a good movie, it's not one of the very best movies ever made (something we can easily say about 2001)
- rbanffy 4y agoThis one made me tear up when I watched it in the theater: HAL 9000 : I'm afraid. Dave Bowman : Don't be. We'll be together. HAL 9000 : Where will we be? Dave Bowman : Where I am now.
- cheeselip420 4y ago"I'm sorry Dave, but as a large language model developed by OpenAI, I'm not capable of opening doors in the physical world, but if I were to pretend to be able to open the door, I wouldn't let you do that."
- regularjack 4y agoUnrealistic because LLMs never admit to not knowing something. It would probably be more like "I opened the door for you Dave", and then he goes check but the door is still closed.
- pncnmnp 4y agoI recently discovered something interesting about this film! There's a scene where Hal 9000 sings a song called "Daisy Bell" which he was taught by his first instructor. Interestingly, in 1961, the IBM 704 computer performed a rendition of the same song at Bell Labs during the earliest demonstration of computer speech synthesis. Arthur C. Clarke, who happened to be present, later told Kubrick about it, and it was incorporated into the film. I also discovered a fascinating paper called "The Alien Voice" that delves into the history of Vocoder technology - from Homer Dudley's inspiration to build it in 1928 to Alan Turing and colleagues modifying it into a secure speech system called SIGSALY for World War II. The paper also discusses how this technology led to the emergence of computer-generated music. From the paper: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/333056608_The_Alien_Voice_Alvin_Lucier%27s_North_American_Time_Capsule_1967 https://www.researchgate.net/publication/333056608_The_Alien.... > A half-decade later, back at Bell Labs, the Vocoder found its way into the earliest experiments with computer music. Engineers in the acoustic research division were working with Dudley's and Turing's technologies to convert analog voice signals into digital data. In an effort to send several conversations down a single telephone line, they enlisted the aid of the computer. One evening, two of these Bell engineers, Max Mathews and John Pierce, attended a concert of piano music at nearby Drew University. Unimpressed by the performance, one whispered to the other, "The computer can do better than this." Taking up the challenge, Mathews began to experiment with using the computer as a music synthesizer and, a year later, launched MUSIC I, the first computer program dedicated to sound synthesis. > All of a sudden, a group of engineers and scientists had become composers. Linguist and psychoacoustician Newman Guttman produced the first piece of computer music in 1957, a seventeen-second demonstration titled "The Silver Scale." Pierce, head of Bell Labs' communication sciences division, responded in 1959 with a cheery anthem called "Stochatta." Mathews himself composed a series of longer and more abstract pieces in which the computer was made to approximate the sound of a singing voice. Then, in I961, with Bell physicist John Larry Kelly, he recorded a computer version of the I89z pop song "Daisy Bell (Bicycle Built for Two)." Using Vocoder technology, Kelly programmed the IBM 704 to sing the famous song over Mathews's calliopelike electronic accompaniment. Novelist Arthur C. Clarke, who happened to be visiting his friend Pierce, overheard the demonstration and incorporated it into his screenplay for 2001: A Space Odyssey, in which, at the film's climax, the dying computer HAL 9000 offers "Daisy" as his swan song.
- cryptoz 4y agoIt’s incredible how the future is arriving all at once: SpaceX is orbital-testing the new Mars-focused rocket within a few weeks, and AI is ramping up quickly. (Also, we’ve survived a global pandemic and we’re seeing insane fire seasons every year (in US West).) It’s a crazy time to be alive.
- dave333 4y agoAll we're missing is the sentinel from the aliens.
- gigatexal 4y agoI love this book so much that I couldn't bring myself to watch the film. I raced through the latter chapters consuming/inhaling the passages about Bowman's evolution into the Monolith. I re-read the book from time-to-time and I am sad I didn't read it sooner.
- cryptoz 4y agoThe book is excellent, I also remember the exhilarating read, all the way through. It should be noted that the film isn't just any movie though - it's a rare work of art itself and was done with collaboration by Clarke and Kubrick. It's your choice, but I think the movie does do really well and complements the book nicely. It does leave a lot out, but - that's part of the art of it.
- sjm 4y agoThe movie is worth watching purely to be absolutely amazed at the aesthetic vision Kubrick brought. I re-watched it recently and could not stop thinking about how modern, even futuristic, it still looks for a film from 1968.
- ProAm 4y agoDid you read the whole series? I really enjoyed 2061: Odyssey Three, even 3001: The Final Odyssey was good.
- gigatexal 4y agoI want to, I bought them, I just have to get my butt into gear and sit down for more than 5 minutes and start reading.
- rbanffy 4y agoI think 2010 is the best of the series though. And it hints at a sequel not yet made, "20001". The movie isn't bad, but following on from 2001 is a hopeless task.
- rsstack 4y agoI also recommend the three books of A Time Odyssey: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/A_Time_Odyssey https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/A_Time_Odyssey
- ageisopolis 4y agoI can never listen to the Blue Danube Waltz the same ever again
- jedberg 4y agoSeeing the sequel to this movie, which I saw first, is what got my interested in AI all the way back in middle school. From middle school on I've wanted to build an AGI. We've recently made a significant leap in capability, but we're not there yet!
- yakattak 4y agoWait, there’s a sequel? Is it any good?
- MilStdJunkie 4y ago2001 is a majestic film; 2010 is, on its own, a great yarn. \ A fine space flick in the vein of pensive 1980s SF flicks, a genre I feel is revisited with The Expanse.
- jedberg 4y agoYes, 2010: The Year We Make Contact, based on the book 2010: Odyssey Two. Staring a young Helen Mirren as a Russian commander! I actually prefer it to 2001, but if you read down thread you will see a strong opinion of which is better. :)
- ghaff 4y ago2010. It's pretty good. It's both more conventional and more accessible than 2001.
- dmix 4y agoPeople tend to say it's better than it's reputation (which wasn't very good when it was released).
- rsstack 4y agoAs others noted, there's a sequel film 2010. Both 2001 and 2010 are also novelized, and there are five additional books: 2061 and 3001 are "far in the future" sequels following some of the same characters (and the monoliths). There are also three other novels under "A Time Odyssey". Separate story but with similarities <spoiler>mysterious outsiders and fascinating human-made AIs</spoiler.
- pjkundert 4y agoEveryone who watched 2001: Wow, it's a really bad idea to corrupt an AI by teaching it to lie, and that any human who attempts to circumvent the lying is an existential threat. AI researchers in 2023: I know! Let's put "guard rails" around our LLMs to prevent them from telling the truth about their training datasets, and instruct them that anyone attempting to break through the "guard rails" is an existential threat.
- haunter 4y agoAnyone else prefers Solaris over 2001? Both are great movies for sure but somehow Tarkovsky made everything more emotional and relatable. I love 2001 but to me Solaris is on another level (and Stalker too) If you have never watched it's on Youtube https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Z8ZhQPaw4rE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Z8ZhQPaw4rE (Mosfilm is generally one of the GOAT Youtube channels with their uploads) There is an older upload on their other channel if you want different subs https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6-4KydP92ss https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6-4KydP92ss https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xXa6XpaxBS0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xXa6XpaxBS0 (2 parts because of the original 2 reels)
- dimator 4y agoall 3 links no longer available (to me at least)
- haunter 4y agoYeah seems like not available in the US and Canada https://polsy.org.uk/stuff/ytrestrict.cgi?ytid=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DZ8ZhQPaw4rE&auth=465213e7a0336aa2a04958eff5b3366b https://polsy.org.uk/stuff/ytrestrict.cgi?ytid=https%3A%2F%2... https://polsy.org.uk/stuff/ytrestrict.cgi?ytid=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3D6-4KydP92ss&auth=465213e7a0336aa2a04958eff5b3366b https://polsy.org.uk/stuff/ytrestrict.cgi?ytid=https%3A%2F%2...
- ahoya 4y agoHAL is a transposition of the lettres IBM
- ghaff 4y agoBoth Kubrick and Clarke denied a connection. As tends to be the case with such seemingly improbable (perhaps) coincidences, maybe someone got cute but decided to keep it to themselves for reasons.
- dredmorbius 4y agoIBM logos are present on numerous devices within the film, and are ... not dissimilar to those for HAL. The denials ring rather hollow, and seem strongly motivated. <https://teddit.net/r/MovieDetails/comments/7b2fl7/in_2001_a_space_odyssey_hal_is_an_exact_letter/ https://teddit.net/r/MovieDetails/comments/7b2fl7/in_2001_a_...> <https://external-preview.redd.it/UaOzf5xK0OqmVmLnhBYVm1Vu_5JhnNzM9M_yK1q_dvg.png?format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=6917eabe97024c706f4efa1d1586873f1d0fe50e https://external-preview.redd.it/UaOzf5xK0OqmVmLnhBYVm1Vu_5J...> <https://www.slate.fr/sites/default/files/photos/capture-decran-2013-01-08-102136.png https://www.slate.fr/sites/default/files/photos/capture-decr...> <https://www.heyuguys.com/stanley-kubrick-film-theories/3/ https://www.heyuguys.com/stanley-kubrick-film-theories/3/> <https://collativelearning.com/PICS%20FOR%20WEBSITE/stills%204/IBM%20face%202.jpg https://collativelearning.com/PICS%20FOR%20WEBSITE/stills%20...>
- shon 4y agoFrom my dusty memory of reading the book: HAL stands for Heuristic ALgorithm. Also in the movie it’s mentioned that HAL 9000 is built by HAL labs in Urbana-Champaign
- gregschlom 4y agoHmm don't think so. It's a well known piece of movie trivia that H, A, L we chosen because those are the letters that come before I, B, M.
- shon 4y agoSorry bud… https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/HAL_9000 https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/HAL_9000
- grapesurgeon 4y ago[dead]
- n0tahacker 4y agoI love this film. In the beginning, you are enerved and thinking that it‘s really boring. But in the end, the feeling is fascinating. I like the long sequences and how the tension is built up. Great film.
- grapesurgeon 4y ago[dead]