3 ms·
Perhaps he should use a license where a company has to pay if they sell more than $N copies of the product, or something along those lines.
by amelius 4y ago
Perhaps he should use a license where a company has to pay if they sell more than $N copies of the product, or something along those lines.
- skykooler 4y agoI suspect in this case clone companies may just "shutdown" and then incorporate a "new" company making exactly the same products with the same branding whenever they get close to $N.
- amelius 4y agoExactly why I said "or something along those lines".
- yumraj 4y agoAnd you’re going to enforce that in China how?
- jrockway 4y agoI guess you get customs to block the imports to other countries. How well this works, I don't know. Probably not well. I am resigned to the fact that there is no intellectual property protection for software, hardware, or trademarks these days. I usually put the Apache 2 license on my projects, but what I am really intending is the "I know you're going to steal this and I can't do anything about it, so have fun" license. (There are licenses like this, but they cause a lot of trouble for organizations that do respect intellectual property. Apache 2 is acceptable to them and basically has the same effect.)
- Chris2048 4y agoYou don't attack the factories, you attack the importers and retailers outside China.
- londons_explore 4y agoOr you use a regular license, but publish the terms openly. Ie. "Anyone who uses this printer design, or one based from it, must pay $3 to us per printer sold. We will give this permission to anyone who asks. For anyone who contributes back to the design of our printers, we will consider reducing this figure to $0"
- cowl 4y agoMost of the cheap "copies" are not copies at all though. They are Iterations on the idea like Prusa was an Iteration itself. Most people when talk about copies talk about products like Creality Ender whihc in fact has so little or nothing of Prusa Designs. The frame is completly different (Extruded Aluminuium profiles vs Single piece cut) the movement guides are completly different (Rollers on V Aluminium profiles vs Rods with bushings, The Board is based on Melzi vs Rambo, The Extruder is different, the sensors are different etc etc. The only thing in common they have is that they are both Simple Cartesian Systems with a fixed Z Bed but this was not something that Prusa Invented. Nothing on these systems (maybe with the exception of the PCB Heated Bed) is an original Prusa Idea. Prusa's Problem is not that they are copying his design, it's that they are Iterating and often improving faster and cheaper than Prusa and these improvements are not given back to the open community, howevere for every "closed" improvement there has been, the community has found open alternatives.
- asddubs 4y agoincidentally the original ender 3 is also open hardware