6 ms·
The anatomy of the Cayman Islands offshore financial center (2016)
- throwaway1777 4y agoClassic schemes like the cayman sandwich are getting broken by bank failures like svb. The cayman division was not fdic insured afaik.
- chollida1 4y ago> Classic schemes like the cayman sandwich are getting broken by bank failures like svb. The cayman division was not fdic insured afaik. This seems wrong to me based on my understanding but i'd be willing to be educated. Based on the fact that everyone got their money back from FDIC in what way have these bank failures caused "Cayman sandwich are getting broken by bank failures like svb" The Cayman's had one purpose for most hedge funds. Move assets off shore so all gains would be tax free. Once you want your money you onshore it again in and pay tax on that total. This allows your money to grow tax free, which means if you're good at it, it grows faster. It's just like a tax free retirement account that lets you deduct your contributes but makes you pay tax on the money you withdraw. As far as for companies using the cayman sandwich, what i've read says everyone got their assets out, no?
- kgwgk 4y ago> Based on the fact that everyone got their money back from FDIC Did they? https://twitter.com/mdudas/status/1641959202078720001 https://twitter.com/mdudas/status/1641959202078720001
- whitemary 4y agoAccording to the shared documents, they will. They just need to file a claim first.
- kgwgk 4y agoWhat documents? (Edit to add: If you meant the letter in that link what it says doesn't sound like "you will definitely get your money back, you just need to file a claim first" at all: "Balances held by customers in accounts at the Cayman Islands Branch at failure are not deposits under the Federal Deposit Insurance Act [...] Your status as a result of the Institution's failure is that of general unsecured creditor.")
- yorwba 4y agoSecond screenshot in the tweet you linked?
- kgwgk 4y agoWhat do you think that "general unsecured creditor" means?
- whitemary 4y agoIt means "to be determined." To be clear, it does not mean their claim will be denied. And if very recent history, politics, presidential speeches are to be believed, it means their claim will be accepted. The first clue about contemporary political economy could tell us that the entire SVB meltdown would be socialized by the US state. See my comments in this thread for my predictions pre-bailout: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35094447 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35094447
- goatsi 4y agoThe key point isn't if a claim is accepted or denied (the people getting the letters almost certainly have standing to be accepted), it's if there is money to pay the claims, and how soon they can get it. Having an unsecured claim isn't "Show up on Monday and the FDIC will hand you a bag of cash", it's "The bankruptcy court and trustees expect the final settlement to be in 3-5 years, with a haircut of 10-30%".
- sokoloff 4y agoAnd if the investments do grow, the governments still get their money, just later (but in greater sums at that time).
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- yieldcrv 4y agoCaymans is just a better jurisdiction. A lot of their financial regulations make sense. It requires complete nationalistic hubris to dismiss that. Its not just a tax blocker. That’s just happenstance because some countries know how to balance their budget. I could think of two dozen other things that Caymans does better than large nations like the US or other financial haven microstates, for business incorporation, capital formation, audits and more. The regulators in Caymans are very meticulous, many are educated in the US at top universities or had careers in the US.
- germinalphrase 4y ago“ I could think of two dozen other things that Caymans does better than large nations like the US or other financial haven microstates, for business incorporation, capital formation, audits and more.” By all means - proceed…
- MichaelZuo 4y agoWell having a law code that’s readable and understandable within a single human lifetime would already be several hundred things done better.
- yieldcrv 4y agoNot sure where to start Its mostly about the master feeder structure, other times about a sandwich, learn about those You have a feeder for domestic tax persons, and a feeder for non-domestic tax persons and domestic tax exempt persons Its usually dumb and pointless to have non-domestic tax persons to use your domestic feeder, because the regulations are poorly thought out and counterproductive and actually serve no purpose. all feeders are partnerships or limited by shares, and send capital to the master entity which does the trading the difficulty is that comparison is not just about the US or insulting any one country, many old world countries have withholding done on investment-in which even US people would find absurd. or the accredited investor requirements are much lower. The attentiveness and accessibility of the regulators is a boon. Dunno where to start but I hope that inspired on the depth of how deep to look. Its a great financial center.
- lordnacho 4y agoAs a hedge fund guy, you stick your money on an island for tax reasons, but it's not always the nefarious reason everyone thinks. It's the tax neutrality that matters. Once an investor takes money back to their own country, they are responsible for the taxes themselves. Rather than a system where for instance you might pay the country of residence and every investor from around the world needs to fill in forms to get their difference back.
- whitemary 4y ago[flagged]
- yt-sdb 4y agoIsn’t this analogy wrong? The question implied is: if shoplifting were legal and if some people shoplifted to feed hungry babies, should we make shoplifting illegal?
- whitemary 4y agoIf it weren't wrong, it would not be an analogy. Most intelligent people will realize that the current state of the law is irrelevant, but if you really can't get past that: If shoplifting were undesirable and if some people shoplifted to feed hungry babies, is shoplifting then desirable?
- yt-sdb 4y agoFrom the guidelines [1]: > Be kind. Don't be snarky. Converse curiously; don't cross-examine. Edit out swipes. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- ClumsyPilot 4y agoRecently I saw that baby formula in our nearby store is now in the plastic box, with a tracker to make sure it's not stolen. Made me really sad. I asked the store employees, and apparently it's a common problem. We have already established, that 'just following orders' is not valid, and there does come a point where the law is so inhumane that you must disobey it. I don't think the line is at 'Hitler is in charge', I think it comes much earlier. For example 'The law' in Britain has castrated Allan Turing for being gay after he won a Nobel prise and helped win the war. Would you follow those orders?
- DelaneyM 4y agoHey, Caymanian here! This is interesting reading, but I feel like it misses the point. I know a lot of people in the finance & professional services here, and I think what's missing from this analysis is how Cayman bends over backwards to make it _easy_ to do business here (especial finance). It's tax neutral but fully transparent to and compliant with UK, US, EU, and Singaporean (as well as many others). This means if you're operating a hedge fund (as an example) with high net worth clients and private investments globally you're generally able to hugely minimize the amount of paperwork to not be double-taxed. It also lets you run financial instruments which might be subject to tax while operating, rather than when earnings are captured and released. And yet, it does that without being on any global watch lists. Financial courts here move _fast_, often ruling and concluding in weeks. And precedents are generally British Common Law (unless improved by Cayman). Starting a company is easy, and fees cover pretty good support. I have a Caymanian company, and when I had a question recently about identification regulations on non-voting shareholders I could call a number and get both a quick answer and great advice from a human being. It's worth noting that Cayman has virtually no Crypto because of the above. We've actually tried, but no significant crypto company has been willing to subject itself to the relatively lightweight regulations. The biggest crypto startup on the island is a crypto regulatory compliance tooling company, which says a lot. Anyhow, I'm not a lawyer or accountant, butt AMA I guess if anyone is curious about my home! :) (It's also an amazing place to live, I love it here. Hard to recommend though because residency is notoriously hard to get if you're eligible through ancestry.)
- vmsp 4y agoThanks for your insight! Can you comment on how easy it is for non-residents to open up a company?
- DelaneyM 4y agoIt's quite easy, the biggest question is whether it's worthwhile. Important: IANAL!!! You can open what's called a "Cayman Islands exempt" company, which can exist here in Cayman jurisdiction but which cannot do business in Cayman (basically don't compete with Caymanians in Cayman). This is generally how holding and investment companies are structured. _However_, this doesn't shield you from either personal taxes or visibility. Cayman is much more transparent than, say, Delaware. And if the book value of investments grows and you're American the IRS will find you quickly (if you have any assets in Caymanian banks they'll report your activity to US authorities regularly, even without a warrant or request.). KYC here is no joke, it took me a month to open a bank account here and I'm a permanent resident with Cayman parents. Since this is HN though, you may be interested in a "fully remote" company with no real home - that works quite well here. You can pay contractors anywhere without holdbacks or forms and let them be responsible for their taxes (be aware of Nexus rules though, it's not foolproof.) You'll generally be responsible for taxes in the countries where you book income from that country, but (consult a lawyer) not always for SaaS. The biggest advantage IMO is that you'll be able to cut your paperwork down enormously because Cayman just doesn't care about the flows of money (so long as it's documented for laundering/tax avoidance reasons). Nothing to file, nothing to pay. Finally, let me plug the good folks at Cayman Enterprise City. https://www.caymanenterprisecity.com/ https://www.caymanenterprisecity.com/. They will set you up to actually have an office and presence here (in a really nice building downtown!), they can give some light legal advice and guidance, and if you have employees anywhere in the world who want to relocate to paradise they can get them a visa in a day or two to move here. So yeah, it's "easy", it's not terribly useful for tax mitigation directly, it's (in my admittedly biased opinion) one of the best places in the world to anchor a truly global startup. If you can share more context I can try to be more helpful? But likely the next step is an actual professional accountant/lawyer.
- motohagiography 4y agoThe reason you can have pensions, savings, or insurance for anything is because the capital pools required to sustain them need to, a) have a return greater than local inflation caused by various domestic policies, and b) be out of reach of being looted by some populist or kleptocrat who wants to pay off their coalition with other peoples money. I realize stable and consistent laws and governace fly in the face of some beliefs, but most criticisms of offshore centres reduces to people seeing a truck full of goods and thinking they can seize and resell the wheels so that others, too, can have wheels. If we didn't have the Caymans, we would need somewhere else. The benefit of the Caymans is they are sparsely populated and literally have one job, whereas if you had custodianship anywhere else, you would be putting the futures of entire nations at risk based on the politics of a banana republic. From a technology perspective, they are like a secret store for authentication tokens. Sure, invent something better, but up-ending the current one without a plan is going wreck literally everything.
- kevin_thibedeau 4y agoThe criticism stems from people extracting disproportionate benefits from a stable society and not paying back their fair share through application of convoluted financial instruments available only to elites. You want to live in Somalia and protect your money in an offshore haven? Great. But do that in a nation that gives you a safe place free of roving bandits and you owe something back.
- pjc50 4y agoThe Caymans are there for tax avoidance: https://www.theguardian.com/business/2020/nov/20/427bn-a-year-lost-to-tax-abuse-by-firms-and-rich-individuals-study-finds https://www.theguardian.com/business/2020/nov/20/427bn-a-yea... I can see the argument that someone from, say, Argentina would benefit from the improved stability, but someone from a Western country is decreasing that country's stability by benefiting from it but refusing to pay for it. I would entirely support the EU making it illegal for EU nationals to do business with Cayman in the same way the US makes it illegal to do business with Cuba.
- medo-bear 4y ago
- elhospitaler 4y ago[flagged]
- therockspush 4y agoThe US is a tax haven mate
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- DelaneyM 4y agoTax haven rules are on the US side, not the Cayman side. FATCA makes Cayman way more transparent than the US itself. Like, what does "stop being a tax haven" even mean? "Start charging a corporate income tax you don't need"?
- dahfizz 4y agoA lot of people who don't know anything about finance think that "offshore bank accounts" is a magical tax loophole. They don't know what "tax haven" really means, they just hear it repeated often.
- thehumanmeat 4y agoIt's described in the paper, but the eurodollar is the incentive behind it all. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eurodollar https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eurodollar
- walterbell 4y agoWhat do you think of Tom Luongo's thesis on dollar/SOFR vs. eurodollar/LIBOR? https://tomluongo.me/2023/03/21/fdic-insurance-credit-suisse-day-fed-killed-europ/ https://tomluongo.me/2023/03/21/fdic-insurance-credit-suisse... & https://www.patreon.com/posts/79871723 https://www.patreon.com/posts/79871723 > On two major fronts, limited insurance for bank deposits and terminally impaired capital structures for European banks, the Fed just positioned the US to be the recipient of major capital inflows as all of the interest rate and credit risk is transferred back to Europe.