3 ms·
This seems to be an announcement that Prusa is abandoning open-source hardware; they're only going to release the "electronic plans" of MK4 under a license that
by kragen 4y ago
This seems to be an announcement that Prusa is abandoning open-source hardware; they're only going to release the "electronic plans" of MK4 under a license that prohibits "the production of nearly exact 1:1 clones for commercial purposes" and also does not permit the production of "parts that can be considered consumables"¹, which clearly cannot be open source, and they plan to move all their products to such a license.
They also seem to be announcing that they are going to lie about it by falsely claiming that it is open source.
Hopefully this is an April Fool's joke.
______
¹ They say it would permit the production of such parts "after the verification by the licensor", which is to say that it would permit the production of such parts at the licensor's pleasure. This is similar to the situation with copyright, where you can make copies of the work if the copyright owner approves of it, but it is not at all clear that heater blocks and printing plates are subject to copyright.
- treesciencebot 4y agoNow it is kind of funny to think about all the discussions that happened last week when the main advantage of Prusa over Bambu Lab X1C was quoted as them "being open source" and the absolutely crazy pricing was just "supporting/sponsoring Prusa's work since there are many clones thanks to their open source model". The tables turned, or they would have been turned if Prusa did either a huge change in their pricing or brought a completely new printer with features that would actually be worth the price tag.
- pen2l 4y ago> Hopefully this is an April Fool's joke. I'm pretty sure it isn't but it is devilishly clever to drop news like this on a date like this. But as to their decision: It's tough -- obviously we all want to support Reprap movement, Prusa, Ultimaker, etc. and the original innovators in this space of desktop 3d printers, but this is the way things happen, when you've optimized your technique and product the Chinese tend to come and kill you with their high volume low margin approach. Can you really blame them for doing what they're doing? It was probably an existential decision for them.
- kragen 4y agoas they sort of point out, bowyer and (unmentioned) vik olliver are the original innovators in this space of desktop 3d printers, but prusa certainly contributed a lot i don't really blame them for giving up on open-source hardware, even if i wish they wouldn't, but i certainly do blame them for lying about it
- IshKebab 4y agoYeah honestly I think they should just patent their innovations and then be quite liberal about granting patent licenses for reasonable fees (and not going after open source projects). That seems way more achievable legally than a "you can copy it you can't rip it off" license.
- ollien 4y agoThis was published before April 1; it definitely isn't a joke
- jrmg 4y agoHopefully this is an April Fool's joke. This was posted on the Prusa blog on March 29th.