6 ms·
> the rich get richer (...) and the poor get poorer It's always the same story. Can't we just make the economy more fair by saying that the wealth gap must at
by amelius 4y ago
> the rich get richer (...) and the poor get poorer
It's always the same story. Can't we just make the economy more fair by saying that the wealth gap must at least be smaller than some value or else the rich will pay (taxes) to make it so?
- satvikpendem 4y agoLots of people say this but very few have a concrete idea of what is needed to accomplish this. What taxes are the rich going to pay? Who among the rich? How does one define "rich?" Et cetera.
- amelius 4y agoWell, it could be simple, but the most important reason that it is not simple is because the rich control the system.
- satvikpendem 4y agoIt really isn't that simple, because again, no one really can say how it is so simple, merely that it is, somehow. Economists also talk about this point often, and they also can't agree, generally speaking, on how to, or even if to, reduce the inequality gap. The best solutions I've seen are land value taxes, inheritance and estate taxes, and taxes on loans backed by stock; and among the worst are unrealized capital gains taxes.
- amelius 4y agoEconomists are part of the problem. When the rich are getting richer and the poor work their asses off and still get poorer, then just about any solution is better and the more decent thing to do than keeping disagreeing about what is the best solution.
- b112 4y agothen just about any solution How can you make such a claim, when you look at the state of many regions/countries in the world?
- amelius 4y ago11.6% of Americans live in poverty.
- robocat 4y agoIs that the World Bank numbers? They think poverty rate was: Sri Lanka 4.1% 2016 Kazakhstan 4.3% 2018 Morocco 4.8% 2013 Belarus 5% 2019 Fuck the World Bank numbers. I’ve been to Sri Lanka and poverty is real over there. Oh, and “According to the U.S. Census Bureau, the official 2017 poverty rate in the U.S. was 12.3%. However, other sources placed it as high as 17.8%. [snip] The 2021 poverty threshold in the United States is $26,246 for a family of four”. So the poverty figures are relative to the wealth of the country? That makes the numbers meaningless to compare (since there is no standard cutoff - just pick a number that gives you a poverty rate of x%).
- robocat 4y agoAn article that discusses this point better: https://fee.org/articles/the-poorest-20-of-americans-are-richer-than-most-nations-of-europe/ https://fee.org/articles/the-poorest-20-of-americans-are-ric...
- badpun 4y ago35 million people in the US live in poverty? That's total nonsense coming from the fictional "poverty line". If we stick to absolutes and define poverty as something as for example "not being able to house, feed, warm, clean or clothe oneself" (so basically - not being able to fill one of the basic human needs, due to insufficent funds) then there's almost no poverty.
- satvikpendem 4y ago
- OnlineGladiator 4y agoThe simplest solution is a wealth tax. Once you reach a certain amount of wealth, you are taxed for it. So for instance you might be taxed 50% of your wealth above $1 billion, annually. You might be taxed 25% of your wealth above $100 million (up to the next cutoff, so a billion in this hypothetical). You might be taxed 10% of your wealth above $10 million but below the next cutoff, and so on. We could even take this further and make it illegal to have too much money. But like all laws, what ultimately matters is enforcement. Currently the IRS doesn't even make much attempt to go after the rich for tax evasion, so writing stricter laws is irrelevant if we don't enforce the laws we already have. I'm not saying this is perfect but it is a simple solution that directly addresses the issue of wealth inequality.
- satvikpendem 4y agoWhat is wealth? How do you define it? How can you tax it? If it's in stocks, what does it mean to tax it? If I own a company worth X billion, does that mean I have to sell my shares to withdraw enough cash to pay my taxes, thereby tanking the value of my own company? If I pay a lot in a downturn but my company does better in a boom, will I get refunded the extra tax I paid? It's not as simple as "make it illegal to have above X amount of money" because it's not really even money at that point, no one has X billion in cash lying around, it's tied to some physical asset. This is just one problem to your statement, there are many others.
- OnlineGladiator 4y agoThis is what the IRS is for. It's one of the only government organizations that actually makes more money than is put into it. So we'd just give them more money and resources to do their job, which would include wealth evaluation. And to answer your "gotcha" question you do get taxed on stocks in this scenario. If you want to nitpick that every solution isn't as simple as fizzbuzz then there's no real point having a discussion. There are plenty of other tax alternatives that are also quite simple, you just seem to be unhappy with anything that isn't perfect.
- 4y ago
- dogcomplex 4y agoAnd pretty-much any of those taxes would help the situation, so long as ultimately they boil down to the rich paying more per year than their profit margins and therefore shrinking inequality (redistributed to the people). This problem isn't complicated because it's intellectually challenging. This problem is complicated because the balance of power is overwhelmingly favorable to the rich, and they have many means to both disrupt the conversation in intellectual circles and to block any political means of making these necessary changes. See economist Richard D. Wolff for extremely simple answers to the above problem. Ultimately it is simply the math of value flows. Current system? Inherently concentrates at the top. Adjust taxes (any of them!!) to reverse that. https://www.youtube.com/user/richarddwolff https://www.youtube.com/user/richarddwolff
- satvikpendem 4y ago> This problem isn't complicated because it's intellectually challenging. This problem is complicated because the balance of power is overwhelmingly favorable to the rich, and they have many means to both disrupt the conversation in intellectual circles and to block any political means of making these necessary changes. It can be both, one does not preclude the other. As I mentioned in my other comments, one can't simply adjust taxes without thinking about higher order effects, and it takes intellectual capacity to even think about what to tax in the first place and how, in order to reduce these effects. > See economist Richard D. Wolff for extremely simple answers to the above problem. Where should I be looking specifically?
- brankoB 4y agoThe best solution is communism. But you won't hear an economist say so ;)
- weatherlite 4y agoMost things aren't so simple and still, it can be done. We got a man on the moon, we split the atom, we built software that can (almost) perform as well as a human being, surely we can tax the rich and corporations more to bring inequality down. If people think taxes are too complicated (which I don't think is the case) so be it - You can simply transfer money to the poorer people, like what happened in Covid but focus on the poor. Every citizen will have a net worth number, everyone will get a sum of money, the less you have the more you get. Now that will be inflationary of course but the burden will go to the rich instead of the poor.
- JeremyNT 4y agoTaxes on real estate are the obvious answer here. Every residential property you own after your first should increase your tax burden substantially, such that you are incentived to sell them rather than hoard them and rent them out.
- satvikpendem 4y agoA Georgist, I see.
- eastbound 4y agoAnd own stock instead, or petroleum or any kind of virtual asset offshore, on which there way more little tax, meanwhile renting a mansion at home that belongs to your own subsidiary? Perfectly doable for the rich, it will raise no tax gains at all. Don’t get me started on “taxing virtual assets beyond the 30th you own”.
- marvin 4y agoLegalize home construction in the places where people want to live. That solves the biggest issue.
- airstrike 4y agoNo, because the rich will then flee to a more rich-friendly economy and you will be left with just the poor
- amelius 4y agoAt least that would make housing more affordable.
- dogcomplex 4y agoYes! But it requires a wealth tax (or equivalent) higher than the rich's profit margins, and requires enforcement in all major jurisdictions. This is effectively impossible due to the sheer amount of power these folks have to prevent it. Simple.
- alexashka 4y ago> Can't we just make the economy more fair by... No. When people say they want fairness, they are being disingenuous. They want a lot of the fair that benefits them and a little bit of the fair that makes their life worse. That's not what fair means. Would you want fair if it made your life a lot worse? The only honest answer is no :) Thus, we have what we have.
- satvikpendem 4y agoOne interesting point regarding this is, ask anyone in the first world whether they want the same fairness as those not in the first world, ie if we added up all of the wages of everyone on the planet and redistributed them equally, the first worlder would be much much poorer than where they started off. Of course, I do support bringing up the average wages in each country overall, which is precisely what capitalism has been doing for the past century of industrialized progress.
- ClumsyPilot 4y ago> if we added up all of the wages of everyone on the planet and redistributed them equally, the first worlder would be much much poorer than where they started off This point of 'most people only want what benefits them' is very shallow. You've set up the question for failure. You limited comparison to income, and to income just among labour class. If you actually setup the question correctly, you might find the results to be different. Are we going to re-destribute capital gains? Most people in developed world earn zero from capital gains. Are we going to re-distribute ownership of assets, shares, and land? Most people in developed world own zero land. Many have net worth of roughly zero. Are we going to re-distribute taxation? Taxes in the first world are paid almost entirely by the middle class. What about right to pollute, currently wealthy individuals have unlimited right to pollute, some take helicopter rides and jets to cut travel time by <1 hour or to avoid traffic. > what capitalism has been doing for the past century Capitalism has been dumping toxic waste from the west in developing nations, like used electronic and plastics. It has brought Opium addiction to China, British American Tabacco is selling to children in South America right now, Nestle has admitted to slavery in Thailand. Western companies have bribed local officials, and hired death squads to kill local union leaders and environmental activists. The leading countries to rise in the last 30 years, China and Singapore, have active, competent and interventionist governments.