7 ms·
Solaris movie review and film summary (1976)
- hulitu 4y ago> Solaris movie review and film summary (1976) Looks like a review written by a 10 year old.
- walterbell 4y agoWho won the Pulitzer Prize a year before this review.
- coldtea 4y agoA pretty low bar. Then again the intended audience is the average movie goer, so the level of analysis is adequate.
- ghaff 4y agoYeah. Without seeing the context of the review, it's hard to say why it seems a bit thin. I'd just note that newspapers and magazines routinely ran capsule reviews of things they considered of lower interest to their audience--which Solaris would presumably have been for Chicago Sun Times readers. Ebert certainly had a serious film critic side but he was mostly pretty mid-brow.
- walterbell 4y ago1976 was during the Cold War, still a decade away from fall of the Berlin Wall. 2003 review had more depth, https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35429240 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35429240
- axus 4y agoI'm very glad I read the story before the movie review, he really loads it up with spoilers! To make the point that the details weren't what he found interesting.
- sparsely 4y agoThere's a lot in Solaris (at least in the 1976 movie and the book). In almost all sci-fi which contains aliens, they're easily comprehend-able by humans - they have motivations we can describe in our own language, a physical form that while strange is likely a mashup of earth creature characteristics (after all that's where our vocabulary comes from). Solaris asks what it might be like if this isn't the case, and where the limits of our comprehension are.
- dreen 4y agoThere is another great story by Lem called Golem XIV about an AI, constructed by the US Military. It is tasked with destroying enemies of the US, to which it says something to the effect of "Why? That makes no sense" and proceeds to give a philosophical lecture, then sort of disappears. Lem was really good at breaking down common scifi tropes and presenting them from a point of view it hasn't been considered, sometimes surprisingly obvious.
- RangerScience 4y agoI think I found it! https://rtraba.files.wordpress.com/2017/01/golem-xiv.pdf https://rtraba.files.wordpress.com/2017/01/golem-xiv.pdf
- te0006 4y agoIt might be of interest that Lem wrote Golem XIV in 1981, more than _40_ years ago.
- scandox 4y agoIt's a persistent theme for Lem I guess. Fiasco and also His Master's Voice both investigate very similar ideas about the limits of comprehension.
- _0w8t 4y agoThis theme is even in the Return from the Stars. There there is a failure to understand human civilization 100 years later.
- mistrial9 4y agosort of a haiku almost, this revue. The real movie takes time to develop the base plot, by indirection and example instead of prose description like this review. The "answers" provided in the review as descriptions are basically accurate, but the viewer has to puzzle it out, and it is never said directly by the movie. This movie has stuck with me for decades. I still refer to it when we get the "Star Trek" irrational exuberance crowd around spending multi-billions on space adventures. Secondly how about those small sats eh? Maybe not every space mission has to be decades long with budgets that match.
- nailer 4y agoThis might be seen as heresy by many but: if you're not a fan of the glacial pace of very old films, you may enjoy Clooney's remake more. This takes nothing away from the original film, which inspired so much of modern scifi. But if you were raised on modern sci fi, Tarkovsky's original is a hard watch. You might feel the same in the nineties listening to Sonic Youth's 80s grunge, or reading Lord of the Rings after you've read the Song of Ice and Fire / Game of Thrones books, or playing System Shock 1 after growing up on Bioshock and Prey.
- type0 4y agoFor long paced old school sci-fi, The Andromeda Strain (1971) is a much better watch. I wouldn't even call Solaris (1976) a proper sci-fi movie, it's a philosophical drama set in sci-fi space milieu.
- drittich 4y agoI think the Clooney film is excellent, and can be enjoyed without knowing anything about Lem's book. And it just might be enough to make you want to dig in to the source material.
- kevin_thibedeau 4y agoWill second. Viola Davis' performance is worth it alone along with a character twist.
- stephc_int13 4y agoI've seen both the original and the remake and enjoyed the remake a lot more. The original was IMHO plagued with useless lengths and a somewhat pretentious/cryptic tone.
- coldtea 4y ago>But if you were raised on modern sci fi, Tarkovsky's original is a hard watch Most good things in art are hard and require some work. If you want the easy version, you're missing a lot. You'd be better served to be listening to Sonic Youth's 80s records instead of me-too grunge during the nineties too.
- AdmiralAsshat 4y agoIncidentally, the Kindle version of Solaris is on sale today for 50% off its normal price: https://www.amazon.com/Solaris-Stanislaw-Lem-ebook/dp/B00Q21MVAI/ https://www.amazon.com/Solaris-Stanislaw-Lem-ebook/dp/B00Q21...
- blacksmith_tb 4y agoWhich is also the newer translation[1]. For quite a while couldn't be sold in the US as book/ebook due to licensing issues, only as an audiobook (which is how I enjoyed it). 1: https://english.lem.pl/works/novels/solaris/196-a-new-translation-of-solaris https://english.lem.pl/works/novels/solaris/196-a-new-transl...
- AdmiralAsshat 4y agoWhich would probably explain as well why only Amazon can sell it. I've been trying to buy only Kobo as of late, but the book literally does not exist (in English) in their library: https://www.kobo.com/us/en/search?query=solaris https://www.kobo.com/us/en/search?query=solaris
- kh_hk 4y agoSomething I felt reading the book that I did not feel with the movie was a bit of horror sci-fi vibes. That alone to me is what makes Solaris one of Lem's top works, on which the crude descriptions add to the suspense and horror.
- zabzonk 4y agothe bit where visitor-Hari punches through a metal door, injuring herself, because she can't stand being separated from Kelvin is quite scary, and was a shock to me when i first saw the fil in the mid 70s. and there are others.
- kh_hk 4y agoFair, I do agree. Both the book and the film are truly masterpieces on their own
- dmix 4y agoI recently watched another lesser known movie based on a Stanisław Lem book (by a Czech director): Icarus XB 1 (1963) https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0122111/ https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0122111/ It also has great set design like Solaris but didnt have such a large budget. I love his style, I should read one of his books. Edit: the full thing is on YouTube https://youtu.be/WwodJW1ikFo https://youtu.be/WwodJW1ikFo
- bvrmn 4y agoAuthor literally gives a plot description. Review itself is a one paragraph. It's not a kind of review one can expect from a movie critic.
- dharmab 4y agoThis review would have needed to fit in a newspaper at the time of publication.
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> would have needed to fit in a newspaper For comparison, Ebert's 2002 review of the remake [1]. [1] https://www.rogerebert.com/reviews/solaris-2002 https://www.rogerebert.com/reviews/solaris-2002
- LoveMortuus 4y agoThe movie was released in the year 1972. The date in the title is for the article.
- AlbertCory 4y agoAs I (dimly) recall, at the Google Cinema Club https://albertcory50.substack.com/p/culture-at-google-part-one-the-movies https://albertcory50.substack.com/p/culture-at-google-part-o... I ran a poll once for the movie people most wanted to see. The leaders were Solaris and The Big Lebowski. It was very close, but I, um, "encouraged" some people on the fence to vote Solaris. Accusations of "election fraud" are misplaced! This is called "getting out the vote."
- pmoriarty 4y agoI'm a huge fan of Tarkovsky. Stalker and Mirror are two of my all-time favorite films, and The Sacrifice is great too, but Solaris was a huge letdown.
- redleggedfrog 4y agoEbert's take focuses on the human aspect of Solaris, but the other aspect of both the movie and the book that is just as appealing to me is our inability to understand the alien ocean itself. All the attempts to anthropomorphize its behavior fail, and in the end Solaris research is abandoned because the ocean is essentially inscrutable to humans. This theme is also covered in another Lem book, "Fiasco." I love the idea of an alien, presented before us, completely available to us to interact with, and we cannot bridge the gap because we and it are so different. It just leaves you with "What is it doing?!" which is such a wonderful contrast to the deep emotional impact that its behavior (creating the doppelgangers) has on humans. Does it know? Is it coincidence? Is it malicious? So many good mysteries.
- goatlover 4y agoThe aliens in the Expanse universe are also very alien and difficult to understand. Which makes their technology and civilization (for the Ring Builders) quite interesting. But yes, the point of the book and even the 2002 movie was that Solaris wasn't human, and yet we keep trying to understand it as it if were a mirror. That seeking out alien life is really just seeking out more versions of humanity. Which was Lem's way of criticizing popular science fiction. Most aliens are either presented as humanoid or monsters from our nightmares. But Solaris is something else entirely. I would say the Arrival aliens are pretty alien as well, even though they do manage to communicate their language to the main character.
- cscheid 4y ago> Does it know? Is it coincidence? Is it malicious? In case you haven't read it yet, you might enjoy Peter Watts's Blindsight.
- xamuel 4y agoSolaris is my favorite Tarkovsky film. Some observations: * When they assist the exhausted Kelvin to his room near the end, his body blocks the light but occasionally his body moves so the light can come through and blind the camera. This parallels the discussion about destroying the visitors with a burst of light. * Burton's extended unexplained car ride is (in my opinion) a nod to the 2001 star-gate. It's quite brilliant how Tarkovsky shows that what Kubrick achieves with exotic special effects can be achieved with everyday footage if we just look from the right angles and play the right soundtrack. * In the old footage they watch near the start of the film, we see stylistic artwork of important figures in the background. These would certainly be informed by Tarkovsky's expertise on Orthodox Iconography (see his "Andrei Rublev"). * Interesting to compare and contrast the visitors with Kubrick's "HAL". The visitors are purely physical and totally unaware of where they are/what's going on. HAL is purely mental and totally omniscient. Both raise all kinds of interesting metaphysical questions about personality and the soul. * The swirling water-plants at the beginning and end of the film are evoked by the paper strips the crew hang up on their ventilators. * Near the beginning, Kelvin stands outside in pouring rain, as if not noticing it, when he could escape it by walking just a few feet. This becomes very meaningful with part of the twist in the ending. * Young Burton talks about how gigantic the child he saw in Solaris's ocean was. Later, when the visitor is frozen from the dry-ice suicide attempt, we briefly catch a glimpse of her face reflected in a concave mirror which makes it seem monstrously gigantic. Right now the entire film is available free on YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LutMHAeCfLU&t=5193s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LutMHAeCfLU&t=5193s (turn on closed captions unless you speak Russian)
- _a_a_a_ 4y agoPerhaps all that counts for you but all I'm getting from it is "stuff happens" and you're picking up patterns which may or may not be there, and if they are then so what. It sounds very typical of 70s films. However I have read Stanislaw Lemand respect him so I'm working up the courage to try and watch it sometime. Trouble is I know I'm going to be bored crapless and wish I hadn't. If anyone can convince me I'm wrong I'd like that.
- xamuel 4y ago
- initramfs 4y agoI am not going to try to compare the 2002 Soderbergh film version, but I like how they both compare the human mind to an a nearly unknowable alien (ocean of clones that appear on the ship) I haven't read or seen the full 1972 version, but does anyone know if this line is in Stanislaw Lem's book? "“We're proud of ourselves. But when you think about it, our enthusiasm's a sham. We don't want other worlds. We want mirrors.” -it is from the 2002 screenplay, but I am curious if it has any analogue in the Polish book or Russian film.
- agarren 4y agoI see the following in the English kindle version - seems like it’s the same in spirit: “We’re humanitarian and noble, we’ve no intention of subjugating other races, we only want to impart our values to them and in return, to appropriate their heritage. We see ourselves as Knights of the Holy Contact. That’s another falsity. We’re not searching for anything except people. We don’t need other worlds. We need mirrors. We don’t know what to do with other worlds. One world is enough, even there we feel stifled. We desire to find our own idealized image; they’re supposed to be globes, civilizations more perfect than ours; in other worlds we expect to find the image of our own primitive past.”
- initramfs 4y agoThank you so much! I've always been curious of that-it's stuck with me.
- Tade0 4y agoIt's a heavily modified version of a quote by one of the characters - Dr. Snaut (Snow).
- initramfs 4y agoThank you!
- baerrie 4y agoSolaris inverts the space epic dynamic of the human mind overcoming space with new technology. Solaris presents the human mind as the ultimate limit to our exploration rather than technology. For this reason, Tarkovsky puts a lot of time in the movie to exploring the main characters existing mental climate so that as viewers we feel the claustrophobia, the scientific problem of understanding the planet Solaris proven moot in comparison to the constricting consequences of our own mental model.
- duxup 4y ago> the human mind as the ultimate limit At least in the American version of Solaris I felt like it asked if what we “know” or remember about a person is real / enough to make a person / how much we can even know…. and by extension what we really know about anything. And regarding the character in the end who chooses to simply live with those memories/ ghosts created by his memory… maybe he isn’t any different than the rest of us.
- baerrie 4y agoMy personal philosophy on truth is that it is simply what remains. In regards to our minds, these are our memories that persist for reasons we often never understand but are profound nonetheless
- tehnub 4y agoNote, he later added it to his Great Movies list and penned a new essay for it: https://www.rogerebert.com/reviews/great-movie-solaris-1972 https://www.rogerebert.com/reviews/great-movie-solaris-1972
- walterbell 4y ago> I saw his 1972 film "Solaris" at the Chicago Film Festival that year. It was my first experience of Tarkovsky, and at first I balked. It was long and slow and the dialogue seemed deliberately dry. But then the overall shape of the film floated into view, there were images of startling beauty, then developments that questioned the fundamental being of the characters themselves, and finally an ending that teasingly suggested that everything in the film needed to be seen in a new light. There was so much to think about afterwards, and so much that remained in my memory. Much deeper essay, thanks for posting.
- raajg 4y agoCoincidentally started reading Solaris 2 weeks ago. About 60% in and really enjoying it. Love stories with novel sci-fi ideas and this one tackles a pretty interesting one. Would appreciate recommendations by the same author or other stories. Other stories that I really liked because I had not thought about those ideas before are: Diaspora (Greg Egan), Permutation City (Greg Egan), Dark Universe (daniel galouye), Three Body Problem series (Cixin Liu)
- cubefox 4y agoI read pretty much all of his books. My favorite is "Wizja Lokalna", I've read the German translation, but there is no English one. Other books of his are available in English though: I like The Cyberiad and The Star Diaries, both quite funny. The former is about the adventures of the two great robot constructors Trurl and Klapaucius, the latter about the journeys of Ijon Tichy, a kind of space Munchausen. Tichy also plays the main role in the the later books The Futurological Congress, Peace on Earth, and "Wizja Lokalna" (which doesn't have a translation, as I said.) All these novels are often quite funny, unlike Solaris. He has also written other great but much more unusual books, such as Memoirs Found in a Bathtub (a Kafkaesque story set inside an underground Pentagon which was cut off from the rest of the world) or A Perfect Vacuum (a collection of reviews of books which do not exist.)
- bloak 4y agoI think there's a (probably US) film that appears to be inspired by "Solaris" but is called something different. Can anyone tell me what it's called because I can't remember and it's annoying me?
- pohl 4y agoJust yesterday I learned something about the translations of this book: Note, there are two translations of Solaris. The bad one is from 1970, which was translated from Polish to French and then from French into English. All physical print versions of Solaris in English use this translation. In 2011, the first direct translation of Solaris into English was published in audiobook and ebook. It's only available digitally, but this is the one you want to read. https://www.reddit.com/r/printSF/comments/12932gh/my_review_of_solaris_by_stanislaw_lem/jelorhi/ https://www.reddit.com/r/printSF/comments/12932gh/my_review_... I wonder if this is why, among all of the Lem books I have devoured, Solaris was one of my least favorites. I'm going to have to give it another shot.
- cubefox 4y agoYou beat me to it by one minute. The problem with bad Solaris translations exists at least also in German.
- cubefox 4y agoIf you enjoyed the movie, I absolutely recommend reading the novel by Lem. It is less mystical and much more analytical/philosophical than the Tarkovsky movie. (And the ending actually makes sense, which I found to be somewhat of a weak point of the Tarkovsky adoption.) But be sure that you read the new English ebook translation by Bill Johnston! The old Kilmartin/Cox translation was a retranslation from a French translation, and it's not good.
- cubefox 4y agoOne interesting problem in the book is only hinted at in the movie. It is basically a form of moral philosophy science fiction. The issue is this: According to traditional Christian morality, God can forgive all sins (salvation). Like the fact that Kelvin was partly responsible for the suicide of his wife. But Kelvin doesn't believe in God, this is an outdated thing from the past. So he is left with secular morality, where the only person who can forgive him is the person he affected. But his wife is dead, she can't forgive him anymore. So Kelvin has to live with his guilt. Except... Solaris seems to offer him something unbelievable, namely a second chance: A recreation of his wife, so that he can reconcile with her. But if she forgives him, what is this worth? Isn't she just a copy, a different person?
- sitkack 4y agoI just had ChatGPT4 recommend this movie as a way to understand alternate forms of intelligence.