3 ms·
The audit logs can never show who was actually behind the wheel. It will always be possible for someone to claim to be driving, while someone else was actually
by londons_explore 4y ago
The audit logs can never show who was actually behind the wheel.
It will always be possible for someone to claim to be driving, while someone else was actually driving.
The only fix is to have police on the highway randomly pulling over trucks, and checking that the driving license of the actual driver matches who the computer thinks is the driver.
Anyone who is 'accidentally logged in as someone else' gets a warning... And if they are caught again, a lifetime commercial trucking ban.
- londons_explore 4y agoTo catch the majority of truckers who are flouting the rules, you need to spot check each trucker perhaps 10x in a career. There are 3.5 million truckers in the USA, with typical career lengths of perhaps 30 years. So you need to inspect 3200 trucks/day. If an inspector takes 15 minutes to do an inspection (checking name, as well as visual roadworthiness checks), you need 100 inspectors. Or about 2 per state. As soon as word gets out that flouting these rules is career-ending, then the industry will probably mostly regulate itself. Seems pretty easy to solve this problem...
- disgruntledphd2 4y ago> As soon as word gets out that flouting these rules is career-ending, then the industry will probably mostly regulate itself. Seems pretty easy to solve this problem... This has already happened, there's a reason most trucking companies last less than 18 months.
- PragmaticPulp 4y ago> To catch the majority of truckers who are flouting the rules, you need to spot check each trucker perhaps 10x in a career. Or just check 100% of audit logs against payroll/taxes. Ghost drivers would show up as not being paid. The real drivers would have fewer hours logged than they’re getting paid for. No stops required.
- dsfyu404ed 4y agoCash throws a wrench into this.
- pc86 4y agoBitcoin fixes this /s
- 83 4y agoThey already have these inspections, though I don't know that they bother checking ELD stuff. Truck weigh stations are on almost every interstate near state lines where they check trucks coming into the state for compliance with weight/lighting/legal cargo/licensing/etc.
- mistermegabyte 4y agoIf you get inspected at a weigh station, they for sure are looking at that ELD records. Its probably the first thing they do. They don't automatically inspect you, only if you're overweight or if they see other problems such as vehicle safety issues, placards, etc. Once you are in the inspection process its a certainty that your hours will be looked at as well as every little safety and regulatory requirement.
- UncleEntity 4y agoLast time I got pulled in for a level 1 inspection the officer checked my brakes, (presumably) did a visual inspection underneath and just glanced at the summary page of my logs to make sure I had hours. It really depends on how they feel about you how detailed they get.
- mrguyorama 4y agoThe state of maine basically invented those weighing stations yet they only operate like once a month, if that. Crimes as a business is just not policed anymore.
- PragmaticPulp 4y ago> The audit logs can never show who was actually behind the wheel. You would compare the audit logs to the payroll logs. If someone is getting paid for hours that aren’t in the logs, it’s a clear violation. > The only fix is to have police on the highway randomly pulling over trucks, and checking that the driving license of the actual driver matches who the computer thinks is the driver. That wouldn’t even address the problem. The historical logs are being altered, not the current driver. If you pulled them over then the computer would have them shown as the driver. Definitely not that hard. Just audit payroll and driver logs to see if they match. The truck drivers aren’t driving extra hours for free.
- jaywalk 4y agoLong-haul truckers are paid per mile, not per hour.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- disgruntledphd2 4y ago> The only fix is to have police on the highway randomly pulling over trucks, and checking that the driving license of the actual driver matches who the computer thinks is the driver. This is super, super common. Interestingly enough, if your federal scores (FMCSA ratings) drop too low, the police are obliged to stop the truck. Needless to say, this is not conducive to a prosperous future in trucking. More generally, this will keep happening until drivers start getting paid for their time at pickup/dropoff. Right now, the suppliers can basically just ignore the driver for as long as they want, as it doesn't cost them anything. The driver, however, is capped at 10 hours driving or 14 hours total, so they have to lie and pretend to sleep when at a destination. Truckers are basically where instant delivery meets the cold, hard realities of physical existence.
- ok_dad 4y agoCan you imagine if software engineers were only paid for coding, and any other time we used to prepare for that task or deploy the code was unpaid? There would be buildings on fire in SF! For truckers, though, if you're not driving you're not being paid. So dumb.
- dsfyu404ed 4y agoCan you imagine if there was some web forum where upper management types were talking about software developers the way we're talking about truckers in here? Federal licensing, lifetime industry ban for your second bug violation, video monitoring and keycard access, etc, etc. Imagine if the stuff that's being floated in here for truckers was instead being floated for us. It'd be like forcing your average CRUD developer to work in a SCIF. There would be an uproar. I hope nobody wonders why educated white collar professionals historically don't do too well at the hands of the lower classes when regimes change.
- VBprogrammer 4y agoI don't know much about the American trucking industry but it seems like this problem is similar in the UK. Except often times, particularly in the South of England the businesses often don't have room for waiting trucks so expect drivers to turn up exactly on schedule with little leeway before and even less after their scheduled deliver slot. This can result in trucks effectively driving in circles to try to arrive at the correct time. If I was a owner of a trucking company I would be livid at the waste of employee, expensive capital asset (the truck), and fuel. I would definitely be tracking this behaviour from clients and factor that into quotes and contracts.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]