8 ms·
Meta is way out of line. There is absolutely no way that the EU is going to allow Meta to break the law at scale without regulators throwing a fit. They might e
by jacquesm 4y ago
Meta is way out of line. There is absolutely no way that the EU is going to allow Meta to break the law at scale without regulators throwing a fit. They might even get to be made into an example of what happens when you repeatedly try to knowingly break the law.
- redeeman 4y ago[flagged]
- jacquesm 4y ago> lol you really think so? lol, yes I really think so. > the EU serves at the pleasure of these megacompanies This is the sort of thing that I'd be happy if it wasn't dumped into HN.
- pessimizer 4y agoIs there some sort of inside information about EU process around Facebook that you want to share here, or is this just generalized bashing of people who have negative outlooks on particular institutions as cynics?
- jacquesm 4y agoTrolls will troll I guess. Let's reverse that: how about you show us how the EU is controlled by Facebook instead? Seriously, the degree and number of dumb comments on HN has been going through the roof lately and I'm getting quite fed up with it. You can have a negative outlook on the EU (assuming you're informed enough to have that outlook in the first place) but to make a blanket claim that (US!) megacompanies control the EU is beyond ridiculous and then to have to defend against even dumber comments like yours in the style of 'when did you stop beating your wife' takes the cake. The person who makes the outrageous claim gets to defend it, not the other way around.
- redeeman 4y agogoogle analytics is illegal in the EU, where is the EU stopping this? privacy shield is dead, where is the EU stopping the illegal data transfer that happens everywhere?
- wkat4242 4y ago> This is the sort of thing that I'd be happy if it wasn't dumped into HN. I agree with you but the OP has a bit of a point when it comes to the Irish privacy regulator. It's not the EU as a whole but the way they can pick the country that most suits them. Ireland gets a substantial portion of its GDP from big tech so they are pretty receptive to their point of view and often Ireland has to be persuaded to give higher fines and to perform investigations in a timely manner. Facebook picked Ireland as their base of operations so the Irish regulators are responsible for the entire EU. It's not just about privacy either. The EU ruled that Apple owed Ireland 1 billion in back taxes they illegally avoided. Ireland fought tooth and nail not to receive this money. Clearly the EU rule that multinationals can choose the privacy and tech regulator to work with for the whole EU by choosing their main host country is helping them to cherry pick those that are most on their side and this is not helping the effectiveness of these laws.
- jacquesm 4y agoThat's a very far cry from the claim that the EU serves at the pleasure of US megacompanies, in fact it documents the opposite: the US megacompanies try everything they can to game the system but end up being fined by the EU in amounts that definitely move the needle. The GDPR is EU law, not country law. Whether member states are able to act effectively with companies playing both ends against the middle is another matter entirely and is exactly why the EU is serving its purpose: it forces the whole to act as a bloc rather than as individual states that you can drive wedges between, of course that won't stop parties from trying. EU anti-trust and EU privacy law has so far served its purpose very well and if they really were in the pocket of big tech I am pretty sure I would have noticed.
- wkat4242 4y agoYes that's why I said I agree with your overall point. But laws such as GDPR are only as good as their enforcement. It would be better if there was a European privacy regulator directly under the EU instead of big tech being able to cherry pick the country that gets to supervise them. But no the EU is not serving the US big tech industry no. I'm just remarking that the system isn't perfect and there doesn't seem to be a whole lot of drive to improve it.
- nicoburns 4y ago> meta knows that they are far far more popular in the population than politicians, and politicians know that if they were to effectively stop facebook, the blowback would be immediate. I'm not convinced that's true. I think most people quite dislike Facebook these days. And I know hardly anyone (of any age demographic) who uses it regularly. Popular opinion on Instagram is less negative but declining. People do still use WhatsApp and Facebook messenger, but I don't think switching would be seen as a big deal if these were banned (just like everyone suddenly installed Zoom in 2020). The only reason they have sticking power is because of network effects.
- tjpnz 4y ago>meta knows that they are far far more popular in the population than politicians, and politicians know that if they were to effectively stop facebook, the blowback would be immediate. If Facebook doesn't want to operate in a region where they're unable to accept payments from local residents that's their business.
- redeeman 4y agowhat do you honestly think would happen? facebook says "we cannot serve the EU because your politicians made it illegal". People would immediately demand facebook be put back, and the politicians would have to comply, or be replaced. They would comply
- tjpnz 4y agoYou are so naive. EU residents aren't stupid and don't particularly like it when foreign companies try to manipulate them, much less ignore the law. Should Facebook choose to pull their services out of the EU the world will keep turning, and people will find alternatives.
- redeeman 4y agothey cheer when someone gets fined, but they clearly value the services way above anything else.
- rendall 4y ago> meta knows that they are far far more popular in the population than politicians Not sure where you live, but in Europe people are generally - with acknowledged caveats and exceptions - but generally speaking behind their governments. Politicians are indeed far more popular than Meta.
- black_puppydog 4y ago> when you repeatedly try to knowingly break the law IANAL but I'd add "blatantly", "brazenly" or some such here. This cannot be in line with things like "it must be as easy to opt out as to opt in" (paraphrasing GDPR) and they know it. IMHO this (like, sadly, many examples before from Meta) could be a perfect occasion to pierce the corporate veil. Whoever signed off on this should never be left in charge of customer data again.