2 ms·
LOL. He laments how billions are spent for nuclear reactor safety and then uses the casualty numbers based on those billions being spent [1], to calculate the c
by coldtea 4y ago
LOL. He laments how billions are spent for nuclear reactor safety and then uses the casualty numbers based on those billions being spent [1], to calculate the casualty impact of building nuclear factories with more abandon and without such spending (as if the numbers would be the same).
Also hidden in the small print, the assumption that future accidents would be "no worse" that previous ones. Because, you know, that's a given or something.
Not to mention that even the numbers he uses for casualties from prior accidents and later cancers are doctored by governments who had accidents on their watch trying to look good, and by research funded and astroturfed by the nuclear industry to make itself look better.
- rocqua 4y agoNo, he uses numbers from an old regime of rules. Argues those were incredibly safe, and hence the newer stricter rules are unnecessary.
- danw1979 4y agoAlso not to mention that we’d have an additional 26 exclusion zones around blown up nukes. I’d like to see the authors back-of-the-envelope maths for the economic impact of the two or three in the UK alone.
- LorenPechtel 4y agoRadiation releases don't mean exclusion zones. Note that he included Three Mile Island amongst the radiation releases. Where's the exclusion zone?? It's not even a matter of cost, just look at the risks. You're at the fence of the reactor when it happens, you decide to walk away. Let's see how far you get before the risk of the trip exceeds the risk of staying. You come to a street--end of trip. It's more dangerous to cross the street than to stay put. (Admittedly, that's assuming an average crossing of an average street and streets vary. It's a lot safer to cross a 25 mph residential street than a 45 mph main street.)
- bottlepalm 4y agoHe says 'only' 26 more Fukushima/Chernobyl type accidents. Exclusion zones all around the world. Not many people died hopefully, but you can't go back to your home either.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- mpweiher 4y agoActually you can, most of the evacuations were unnecessary and killed significantly more people than the radiation.
- bottlepalm 4y agoI guarantee you after 26 disasters the numbers will catch up.
- mpweiher 4y agoAnd you'd of course be wrong. Because these are ratios... ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
- bottlepalm 4y agoWe know there’s potential for far worse accidents. Build more nuclear plants to find out what the ratio really is. From 2 to 26 disasters you’ll hit some big ones. The NRC itself has said the same - https://www.science.org/content/article/spent-fuel-fire-us-soil-could-dwarf-impact-fukushima https://www.science.org/content/article/spent-fuel-fire-us-s...
- goodpoint 4y ago> Also hidden in the small print, the assumption that future accidents would be "no worse" that previous ones. This is spot on. This is like saying "driving is safe because I never died so far". Besides, it neglected to mention many other problems, including nuclear proliferation, centralization of power etc.
- LorenPechtel 4y agoProliferation? Bogeyman! Power reactors are basically useless for bomb production even if you reprocess the fuel. While it is actually possible to make a bomb from reactor waste it is *much* harder than making it from dedicated plutonium-production reactors. The basic problem is Plutonium isn't all the same. For a bomb you want Pu-239. The desired reaction is U-238 + n -> U-239. Decays (half life 23 minutes) to Np-239, decays (half life 2.36 days) to Pu-239. The undesired reaction is Pu-239 + n -> Pu-240. Not only does Pu-240 not go boom, but it's prone to spontaneous fission, spraying neutrons around. This is a bad thing, making your bomb very prone to being a fizzle. You defeat this by changing the fuel frequently, minimizing the Pu-240 buildup. Nobody has ever used power reactors in a bomb program. While it could be done it couldn't be done without it being apparent to observers.
- joshjob42 4y agoI've ran the numbers and based on the actual run experience of the RBMK it will end it's life as a reactor design having killed less than half as many people per TWh as American coal did in recent years using the 4000 expected dead number estimate from the WHO and EPA numbers for coal. There were some upgrades to the RBMK post Chernobyl but fundamentally simple operational changes would've prevented any further catastrophes. If the worst designed reactor of all time and the only one subject to the only accident in nuclear history to kill a large number of people is significantly safer per unit electricity than coal, it's not crazy to say that all the plants that are radically safer than said reactor design probably are spending too much on safety.