5 ms·
Have they? I would say the subsequent ~10 years of the web have vindicated Flash. HTML5 video hasn't made websites lighter or less annoying - quite the opposite
by lmm 4y ago
Have they? I would say the subsequent ~10 years of the web have vindicated Flash. HTML5 video hasn't made websites lighter or less annoying - quite the opposite (indeed video ads are a worse problem than Flash ads ever were). Meanwhile creativity and innovation on the web have taken a hit. 10+ years on there's still nothing that allows a lone auteur to produce a web experience as easily and effectively as you could with Flash (it seems to be possible to match Flash, a la the NYT's Snow Fall or the previous Madogatari intro, but not at a level that's accessible to an individual creator), and we're all worse off for it.
- rektide 4y agoThis keeps coming up, but it keeps seeming hogwash & backwards. There are dozens & dozens of really really good html/svg animation products that give Flash like capabilities. But there's vastly less interest in this stuff today. Fun/simple/quirky Flash-like stuff isn't nearly as unique or novel, now that we have much more upscale products & experiences. It was a magical time & Flash helped, but we've changed & these rose-colored glasses views on Flash never point out all the myriad of ways it was awful, choppy, poorly integrated, quirky to work with, & otherwise difficult. If you want higher there are hundreds of web-dev targeting game dev systems which can be put to use. Many of these actually do have popularity. In spite of their being good Flash-ish animation toolkits, it doesn't feel like there's a ton of demand or clear winners. It's hard to imagine what we'd want it for today.
- lmm 4y agoI think the demand is there, but you underestimate how much difference the tiny inconveniences make. Like, maybe there's stuff out there that can do the same thing, but the people who are just starting out don't know where it is (hell, I'm an experienced programmer and I don't know where it is) or what to pick up. A lot of those great Flash works were made by literal schoolkids, or more often by young adults who'd got their start as schoolkids and gradually refined their craft, because you could just pick up Flash and start doing things, and kids did. From what I hear maybe Roblox is filling the same niche now, but that's only happened in the last few years, and for all that Flash was notionally proprietary and poorly-integrated with the open web, having it right there in your browser was still a win.
- EamonnMR 4y agoThe loss of the mouse and keyboard as primary input devices is an underrated part of why everything feels worse now compared to the flash era. Web is a very different target now than it was. Also, the flash game ecosystem was intertwined with the animation ecosystem and the advent of streaming full motion video devalued animation skills. Anyway nowdays we have Godot and Unity which are both very nice. But there were definitely lost years where amateur gamedev was less accessable.
- grishka 4y ago> The loss of the mouse and keyboard as primary input devices is an underrated part of why everything feels worse now compared to the flash era. It's okay to say "please visit this from your computer" when someone opens something that requires a keyboard from a phone. > Anyway nowdays we have Godot and Unity which are both very nice. But there were definitely lost years where amateur gamedev was less accessable. The barrier to entry is considerably higher with these things. They require programming from the beginning. The coolest part about Flash was that you could get started without writing a single line of code. Then you could build up your understanding of the thing iteratively. You could build a simple quest-type game with just one line of code that you copy-pasted from somewhere, `goToAndStop(frameNumber)`. And then you go from there — variables, flow control, all that. Flash got a sizable number of people interested in programming. This ease of use is extremely important and it's still unmatched by any purported modern replacements.
- yathaid 4y ago>> It's okay to say "please visit this from your computer" when someone opens something that requires a keyboard from a phone. Unless you have a captive audience, like forced to use enterprise users, this is not a winning strategy for any internet based product. Also, the assumption that everyone will have devices in two form factors is, and I am being charitable here, naive.
- thrashh 4y agoI wouldn’t touch any of those game systems with 10-ft pole. Their user bases are too small to be worth using. They also don’t at all compare to the Flash IDE. Flash was great because it was popular and supported with the weight of a big company that loved its own child. Their love translated to great tooling. Whereas the web is “community-owned” and community/committee-designed things rarely get super cool and fleshed out things like well-integrated for-everyone tooling. Instead, you mostly get self-serving projects that serve the creator’s own need primarily. Usually half-baked. And it’s not interoperable with anything else.
- illiarian 4y ago> There are dozens & dozens of really really good html/svg animation products that give Flash like capabilities. And those are? > now that we have much more upscale products & experiences. And those are?!!
- JoeyJoJoJr 4y agoI was a Flash developer and have searched everywhere for a comparable tool. None exists. Recently I have worked on interfaces for touch screen kiosks, and digital signage. Flash was excellent for these kinds of projects and 10 years later nothing compares.
- stuaxo 4y agoThe authoring tool was a big part of why so much flash stuff got made.
- vlovich123 4y agoAs someone that helped a little bit in bringing Flash to WebOS, it was a battery stuck because there was no HW acceleration. Additionally, the software was very very bad. Used a crapton of memory, was really slow, and horribly insecure. Adobe was caught really off guard by mobile and never prioritized flash. If little else, the modern web is infinitely more secure than the flash player and Adobe would never have prioritized it. We also have ~3 major open source browser engines that independently implement the web compared with one closed source vendor. So structurally things are also infinitely healthier. That the web is a cesspool in turns of content is an orthogonal problem that would have always been the case (but also a flash laden website are up way more RAM and CPU than the equivalent html)
- lmm 4y ago> it was a battery stuck because there was no HW acceleration. Additionally, the software was very very bad. Used a crapton of memory, was really slow, and horribly insecure. Surely lack of hardware acceleration and poor implementation are incidental, not fundamental issues. Just as browsers eventually got their own PDF implementations because Adobe's sucked, I expect the same would have happened for Flash eventually. > We also have ~3 major open source browser engines that independently implement the web compared with one closed source vendor. We have WebKit and Gecko, and the latter barely exists on mobile. I'm not convinced we're a lot better off in practice.
- eyelidlessness 4y agoBlink (Chrome/Chromium-derived browsers) is a fork of WebKit but has diverged for many years. To treat them as the same, you should call them KHTML as that’s their common lineage. But that would be obviously absurd. WebKit and Blink are not the same browser engine.
- dontlaugh 4y agoSure, although Blink and WebKit are still much closer than WebKit and KHTML.
- 4y ago
- kitsunesoba 4y agoFlash games and animations were cool, but it seemed like for every cool thing made with flash there was also a terrible SWF-as-a-website that didn't play nice with browser window resizing and was more frustrating to use than even the worst modern JS-mudball monstrosities. At least content blocker extensions and reader mode can somewhat salvage bad sites… with flash pages you got the whole thing or nothing.
- philsnow 4y agoOddly enough your comment made me think of electron apps vs native apps, because they are usually impenetrable to accessibility APIs so they appear as completely opaque apps with no a11y affordances.
- Earw0rm 4y agoSeems like a solvable problem in the medium term - Electron apps are, in effect, a web page; build an accessible page, the Electron runtime _should_ be able to join the dots same as a full browser does.
- giantrobot 4y agoIt seems like a lot of frameworks used with Electron are the "reinvent every HTML tag as a component with divs" variety. So unless a developer hangs a bunch of event handlers off some widget they don't have default handlers for a lot of accessibility. If they used a real tag they'd get a bunch of free accessibility/functionality but instead they use components.
- kitsunesoba 4y agoTo me that highlights how important it is for UI frameworks of all types to have accessibility affordances not only built in, but as one of the pillars of their designs. That makes it so even apps developed without any regard to accessibility are reasonably accessible by default. This doesn't gel well with the bring-your-own-everything nature of the web, unfortunately. Even if you look just at React there's 50 ways to build the same thing, which I'm sure makes rolling in accessibility that "just works" across all React apps without additional effort from the developer extremely difficult. It's much more practical with UI frameworks that are strongly opinionated with only a single well-supported "happy path" for most things.
- paultopia 4y agoThis brings back memories. 20 years ago, I was managing a band in New Orleans (by an amazing coincidence I'm in New Orleans for a 2 day trip now), and I decided to make them a website. It being 2003, I did the website in flash, and with my zero coding skills at the time ... it still came out pretty awesome. Wish that still existed.
- wink 4y agoTechnically it's not the fault of the videos that web standards now allow easy embedding, it's still the people abusing it to show you video ads. Just saying it's worse than Flash... it's like saying browsers should not show non-animated images because you can have ad banners.
- lmm 4y agoSure, but that was an argument used by anti-flash people at the time. (And if anything it was a lot easier to block flash on some pages than block web video on some pages - indeed I remember some browsers started to be click-to-start-flash by default).
- Pulcinella 4y agoI don’t get the love for Flash on Hacker News. It’s very odd to me to see people say they prefer Adobe’s proprietary format and software to the open web.
- lmm 4y agoI'm all for open source but I don't let that blind me to product quality. Same thing with Discord - yes, I'd definitely prefer an open system, but if this specific proprietary thing has a better UX then we should be honest about that.