8 ms·
Rural children now grow slightly taller than city children in wealthy countries
- anenefan 4y agoI don't subscribe so I only read the first two paragraphs fluffed out to say city kids in US are slightly shorter than country kids. I dare say whomever will rediscover the role sodium phosphate plays in growing bodies when consumption is greatly exceeded -- it is used as a food additive, including some soft drinks. I'm sure many soft drink brands may still use the additive, but at a much reduced rate compared to 70s, 80s and 19990s.
- johng 4y agoIsn’t that a huge ingredient in fertilizer as well?
- escapecharacter 4y agoYeah, in Brawndo too
- anenefan 4y agoNo, it does not form part of commercial fertilizers. Plants though could probably utilize it though. In small amounts it's beneficial to the body, just not in excess.
- hammock 4y agoSo you believe sodium phosphate is good or bad?
- anenefan 4y agoIn excessive amounts it was (1980s) shown to effect skeletal growth detrimentally. The funny thing presently when I search the web is ... I find nothing except a maybe [1] which is sort of sad ... I fear the food industry fingerprints are on poor searches - though I do have somewhere a couple of books from the late 80s that had expounded excess sodium phosphate's role in skeletal formation. When I grew up, in my locale, there was an epidemic of shorter than would be expected children, some clues were there, slowly it seemed most were very thirsty and actively consuming one brand of softdrink ... as much as I liked it, more than a couple of cups caused my gut to grumble and boil for a bit. During the 90s the formulation changed or was fixed, I know it certainly changed as I no longer suffered as I once did if I happened to consume more than a couple cups in a hour. At the time I had no idea of the cause and wasn't until reading conclusions in a pretty grounded book. [1] https://www.health.harvard.edu/staying-healthy/does-carbonated-water-harm-bones https://www.health.harvard.edu/staying-healthy/does-carbonat...
- Vrondi 4y agoSoda consumption is quite high in rural areas in the USA too, though.
- anenefan 4y agoNow someone has posted what the article was based on, with comments saying it was done with little controls for genetics and other factors, my comment may have been premature being the first comment in discussion. Sodium Phosphate though is added to many foods [1] [2] -- it's something to keep in mind. It's possible due to a learning curve, that the rate applied to soft drinks has been reduced in the US as well, but I'm not privy to that sort of information. [1] https://www.healthline.com/health/sodium-phosphate https://www.healthline.com/health/sodium-phosphate [2] https://www.ouh.nhs.uk/patient-guide/leaflets/files/56112Pphosphate.pdf https://www.ouh.nhs.uk/patient-guide/leaflets/files/56112Pph...
- jamesfmilne 4y ago[flagged]
- luxuryballs 4y agoEMF exposure, it’s the new cigarette smoke
- stemlord 4y agoRelative lack of exercise? Are we sure about that?
- Pxtl 4y agoExcept pollution is drastically improving with cleaner engines and the gradual decline of coal power. And fully urban people walk everywhere, the "lack of exercise" in this day and age is more a mark of rural and suburban people who can't get anywhere without a truck.
- Vrondi 4y agoWell, improvements happening now will show up in the next generation, not the current one that has already been growing in the old conditions.
- georgeburdell 4y agoThis has been “country wisdom” for some time in my part of the U.S. Lots of jokes about “farm boys” who are a head taller than their parents, and wondering what they’ve been being fed.
- HWR_14 4y agoBut for most of your time, it primarily being about farm boys been false. Through the end of the 20th century being in the country stunted your growth compared to the city. What is true is that height increases each (modern first-world) generation
- renewiltord 4y agoWait, that means this "country wisdom" has been total bullshit for almost all of the time it existed! https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-023-05772-8/figures/9 https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-023-05772-8/figures/9
- xboxnolifes 4y agoPoster didn't give a start date, how can you assume it's been bullshit for most of it's existence? For all you know poster is 40 years old and is going off of what has been talked about over than last 30.
- 908B64B197 4y agoPercentage of immigrant population? South Americans and Asians are, on average, shorter.
- Zetice 4y agoExcept those groups didn’t just move into cities recently, so even if that were genetically true (it’s not), it wouldn’t explain the change.
- fein 4y agoThe range covered in the article is from 1990 to 2020. The percentage of non white immigration into those areas is frankly staggering compared to the 100+ years prior. So yes, those groups did just move into those cities recently.
- Zetice 4y ago[citation needed]
- fein 4y agoYou are more than capable of using the internet to find time series demographic information of geographic locations.
- Zetice 4y agoSo in other words, you haven't actually done this research and are talking out of your ass? Otherwise it'd be quickly pastable.
- fein 4y agoHas the internet warped your mind to the point that you seriously think people have folders of links on standby to paste to support a point (an obvious point as well)? Find me a big city in the west where white people have even stayed the same in their percentage of population since 1990. I can't find any in the top 100 or so cities in the US on a 30 second search - everything is a decrease.
- noughtme 4y agoThe article weirdly (or unsurprisingly) does not mention diet, but the underlying study does. Immigrants might also be throwing off the average. They tend to grow taller in North America (not just second generation), again, unsurprisingly because of diet.
- ramraj07 4y agoI grew up in India and spent 7 years at UT southwestern where apparently half the students are Indian American and noticed the same, Indian Americans are much taller on average (by several inches), than Indians. I assumed it was diet (red meat was my suspicion) but I’ve come to meet many traditional Indian American families who follow very strict traditional vegetarian diets, so I’m starting to suspect it’s not just gross changes in diet but also changes in the nutritional value of the same food items.
- rippercushions 4y agoSanitation surely plays a part as well. If tap water is filthy (as it is in virtually all of India) and you're constantly getting sick as a result, this will definitely impact growth.
- lotsofpulp 4y agoIf you have the means to travel to the US for college, you have the means to avoid consuming unfiltered tap water.
- bobthepanda 4y agoI would imagine the big thing is air quality. India regularly tops air pollution lists: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_most-polluted_cities_by_particulate_matter_concentration https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_most-polluted_cities.... You can’t totally avoid outside air. Anecdotally I remember hearing of Chinese people moving abroad and having their chronic asthma clear up almost immediately.
- 4y ago
- hammock 4y agoThe actual paper https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-023-05772-8#Sec2 https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-023-05772-8#Sec2 It does not appear they controlled for ethnicity, race or any other measure of genetic stock. Doing so is important in my view. For example, the oft-cited average US male height 5'9 or 5'10", but for white American men it's more like 5'11"
- tomrod 4y agoWhy are global population differences not sufficient? Is there an a priori reason to expect a different distribution of genetic factors in cities versus rural areas that feed city migrations?
- hammock 4y agoAbsolutely. Pick any city of your choice. New York, Los Angeles, London, Joburg, Bangalore, Hong Kong, Lima... Are the ethnic demographics of the city not substantially different from those of its rural surroundings?
- TaylorAlexander 4y agoI thought that due to redlining and white flight, the answer is that yes, there are more white people as a percentage of the total in rural areas compared to cities.
- alwayslikethis 4y agoWhite flight? More like, most immigrants don't move to rural areas to start a farm. White flight is to suburban areas, not to rural areas.
- bobthepanda 4y agoI saw this play out during COVID when some people who entertained the idea of WFH in a rural area had to contend with lack of internet.
- vr46 4y agoDoes this study account for the genetic component?
- sh1mmer 4y agoI didn’t see mention of pollution, but that seems like an obvious one to me if health care and diet gaps have closed.
- Pxtl 4y agoThere are so many possible things that could confound this - wealth, ethnicity (for example most East and South Asian immigrants are coming to cities), I don't envy the statisticians that had to tease this apart.
- ptoo 4y agoUsing the terminology of children turning out slightly "better" in cities in the context of height is slightly distasteful, even though it is societally quite prevalent. Height is an arbitrary physical trait, much like race. Who cares who turns out taller? Discounting malnutrition, there are no health benefits to being taller. There are of course social advantages, but the same can be said for race too. When will we begin addressing heightism in the same respect as other obviously unimportant phenotypic differences?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Vrondi 4y agoMalnutrition is the thing to worry about. Or perhaps toxins. We know that people don't grow to their full possible genetic height due to such things, and it seems natural to wonder if there are any other unrealized effects when they fail to reach their full possible height.
- ptoo 4y agoWhy does it matter if they reach their full possible height, barring health complications? At least 80% of height is genetic so creating a value system based upon something that has no bearing on a person's qualities, aesthetic or psychological, is of no importance. Always substitute race for height and see how the line of argument sounds. The only difference is that one trait is generally culturally acceptable to disparage while the other is not.
- spacephysics 4y agoIt’s these reductionist arguments that lose the forest for the trees. If we see a clear health disparity between two groups who should otherwise have equal outcomes, then it implies there’s possibly something in the environment of one group that’s negatively effecting them. And therefore could possibly have other side effects we’re not privy too. You say height is of no importance, but a majority of women[0][1] would disagree, and men below average height would also disagree. Perhaps our evolutionary signals point to something other than “a social construct” for choosing height in mates. Wild thought. 0 - https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0191886913000020 https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S01918... 1 - https://www.wsj.com/articles/online-dating-investing-match-tinder-bumble-11657890982?mod=lead_feature_below_a_pos1 https://www.wsj.com/articles/online-dating-investing-match-t... (quote of note: “A former Bumble product manager says that a majority of women on the platform tend to set a floor of 6 feet for men, which would limit their candidate pool to about 15% of the population.“)
- m0zzie 4y agoI wonder how much of this can be attributed to poor posture related to device use. Posture correction has been shown to give people back ~1-2 inches in height. Note: I mean real posture correction through exercise and training, not the currrent fad of "devices" that fix your posture for you.
- meghan_rain 4y agoAny links to how to correct posture?
- m0zzie 4y agoHuge disclaimer: I'm not a qualified physiotherapist and not qualified to give advice, I'm just a nerd who had awful posture and did and okay job of correcting it. All I can tell you is what helped me: - Improving my working ergonomics. Specifically, not being hunched over my laptop so often. People talk about great chairs, stand up desks etc, and despite having those things I didn't see much change. I found more of a change by avoiding using my laptop as a laptop unless I was away from my desk. If I'm at my desk, I'm always using an external monitor. - For exercises I did face pulls, rows, and I made chin tucks a thing I just do sporadically throughout my working week. No gym required. - Finally, I discovered I had very tight neck and chest muscles and doing stretching exercises for both was helpful. On the neck and chest stretching I would just suggest taking that kind of thing very slowly, don't overdo it like I did. When I first started with those I ended up in pain because I was overstretching muscles that hadn't been stretched properly in many years (or ever).